Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
literaryloveaffair · 06/12/2023 08:01

Its also not about earning 38k. Sure you can earn 38k in your 30s or even double or triple that in your 40s. It's about earning 38k in the UK at the time you meet and marry your spouse. My British dh is on 75k but we married when he was 24, he wasn't earning that then!

Arafina · 06/12/2023 07:38

sashh · 06/12/2023 05:42

It indirectly discriminates against women who often don't earn that much or may be working part time.

I worked with someone for a short time who had lived in Japan teaching English, got married there, had two children, and then wanted to come 'home', she had no problem bringing herself and children in to the country but her job didn't pay enough to bring her husband in to the country even though he was well qualified and they had been married 15 years.

It's not just spouses this effects.

Where my dad lives there was a man, a British citizen who had been married to a South African wife and had two children, she unfortunately died, her parents were in a care home so not able to take on their grandchildren.

But he didn't earn enough to bring his children in to the country. Even though he had parents and siblings prepared to help in any way.

In the end he brought them in to the country for a 'holiday' so illegally. He played dare with the government, ie would they dare deport two primary school children?

Hope this man got to keep his children here, all those heartless people on here may be regretting their words when it affects someone close to them, the most annoying thing is that it will never affect those that makes the rules as they don't live in the same financial world as the vast majority of us and/or they have friends in high places

Vettrianofan · 06/12/2023 07:33

WhenLoveIsDone · 06/12/2023 07:25

So, please tell me just how easy it is to move here. Sometimes I wish my partner wasn't British because it would be nice to move somewhere I actually feel welcome.

Right. The feeling that my kids don't matter, the government is hell-bent on deporting one of their (hard-working but whatever) parents...

Of course if we don't meet the criteria for right to remain when the spouse visa expires next year, then we will presumably be put on the ten year path- without the right to work, so ForeignParent will no longer be able to work freelance legally. And if they do deport ForeignParenr, BritishParent will have to give up their job and take benefits for the first time in their life to raise the kids (one with special needs).

I haven't slept since the latest announcement. We gave up so much to try to keep this family together- including enduring nearly a year's separation enforced by the Home Office- and they move the goalposts yet again.

We don't even have any visa considerations, and are actually looking at moving out of this country (UK). It's absolutely gone to the dogs, it's getting worse and we are currently looking at DH getting work in one of the Nordic countries who are much more family friendly and want people to succeed in life, not sink.

WhenLoveIsDone · 06/12/2023 07:25

So, please tell me just how easy it is to move here. Sometimes I wish my partner wasn't British because it would be nice to move somewhere I actually feel welcome.

Right. The feeling that my kids don't matter, the government is hell-bent on deporting one of their (hard-working but whatever) parents...

Of course if we don't meet the criteria for right to remain when the spouse visa expires next year, then we will presumably be put on the ten year path- without the right to work, so ForeignParent will no longer be able to work freelance legally. And if they do deport ForeignParenr, BritishParent will have to give up their job and take benefits for the first time in their life to raise the kids (one with special needs).

I haven't slept since the latest announcement. We gave up so much to try to keep this family together- including enduring nearly a year's separation enforced by the Home Office- and they move the goalposts yet again.

MarvellousMonsters · 06/12/2023 07:00

lkwhjis · 04/12/2023 19:46

It’s high. As long as we have jobs that the lazy 5 million brits on out of work benefits don’t want to do.

Anything less than £30k isn't a living wage, why should people work hard and not earn enough to live on? What's the point of working if you can't afford to pay your rent/mortgage, feed, clothe your family and heat your home?

Would you?

The figure set by the govt is an admission that it's the real living wage, and that tells you that the majority of healthcare, hospitality and retail workers are not earning a living wage.

sashh · 06/12/2023 05:42

It indirectly discriminates against women who often don't earn that much or may be working part time.

I worked with someone for a short time who had lived in Japan teaching English, got married there, had two children, and then wanted to come 'home', she had no problem bringing herself and children in to the country but her job didn't pay enough to bring her husband in to the country even though he was well qualified and they had been married 15 years.

It's not just spouses this effects.

Where my dad lives there was a man, a British citizen who had been married to a South African wife and had two children, she unfortunately died, her parents were in a care home so not able to take on their grandchildren.

But he didn't earn enough to bring his children in to the country. Even though he had parents and siblings prepared to help in any way.

In the end he brought them in to the country for a 'holiday' so illegally. He played dare with the government, ie would they dare deport two primary school children?

SoNotRainbowRhythms · 06/12/2023 04:28

My first point is that if it is so impossible to live on any amount under 38,000 then no working family should have to live on less than that!

I think it's absolutely disgusting.

It seems some people think this only affects "foreign" people.

It means that majority of British young people will not be able to stay in the UK if they wish to marry someone from overseas, and this includes if they meet someone from a European country. Due to only one income being considered at first, they will likely never then have a chance to return

If you have DC who could potentially one day meet and fall in love with someone from overseas then you need to be against this.

And yes... Couples can live in the spouses country but surely that should be a choice, not forced out.

Isabellivi · 06/12/2023 01:28

I think it’s fair to the economic future of the nation, for sure. If things are not fair in someone else’s country that is the problem of those countries, particularly the fact that very small % of people hold wealth in most those countries (former Soviet Union, Asia, Latin America). Bankrupting the developed nations that provide public health services, education, etc is not a solution. Actually it will make globalpoverty worse, but yes the top 1% benefit from the cheap labor. It’s the working and shrinking middle class subsidizing it! The social justice propaganda is paid for by the top 1%.

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 01:21

JoBrandsCleaner · 06/12/2023 00:38

I think the whole system needs an overhaul to be honest. It should be an automatic refusal if it’s a ridiculous situation of a fit young lad has amazingly fell head over heels in love with ie, Joyce, a widow from St Helens, who happens to be old enough to be his mother. Or (and this is just in my own Asian in-laws) a special needs young man who in the past 5 years has ended up with 2 wives when he just about knows what day it is. There’s more problems in the system than making sure someone can support who they bring here for whatever reason.

And what about people who are in genuine relationships? Who had the audacity to fall in love with a British citizen?

Do you have any idea what we have to go through to be approved for a visa?

We must hand over our text messages, photographs, bank statements, pay slips, employment contracts, housing deeds, signed declarations, bills, postal mail, and legal documents to prove we can be housed. Then, we must be fingerprinted and photographed by UKVI and pass a rigorous citizenship tests that I doubt a majority of Brits could pass themselves. All costing around £10k+ for the average application.

We are banned from accessing any type of benefit while simultaneously contributing more than British citizens (% wise) thanks to the £1k extra every year in NHS fees.

We can only leave the country for specific time periods and must explain any absences in our application. We are not eligible for many, many things during our 5 year application process due to our immigration status, from mortgage lenders to credit cards and sometimes even rental properties.

So, please tell me just how easy it is to move here. Sometimes I wish my partner wasn't British because it would be nice to move somewhere I actually feel welcome.

JoBrandsCleaner · 06/12/2023 00:38

I think the whole system needs an overhaul to be honest. It should be an automatic refusal if it’s a ridiculous situation of a fit young lad has amazingly fell head over heels in love with ie, Joyce, a widow from St Helens, who happens to be old enough to be his mother. Or (and this is just in my own Asian in-laws) a special needs young man who in the past 5 years has ended up with 2 wives when he just about knows what day it is. There’s more problems in the system than making sure someone can support who they bring here for whatever reason.

JassyRadlett · 05/12/2023 22:01

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 21:49

Darling, I am not here to help with your research. The point is simple: the system has to be fair and equal to all and you do that with standard tick boxing exercises than forensic analysis. That's for would be terro-rists to keep the country safe!

Evaluation on individual circumstances would lead to more and never ending appeals as people will pick anything and everything to appeal against, like teh asylum seekers do as they are subject to much more wide international protections for obvious reasons. Right now, the playing field is similar and appeal judges know what test to use to all appeal applications as it is the same for everyone.

Sweetie, you made a claim that the visa system was funded . I asked for receipts, you were unable to provide apart from "check the news" and some vague stuff that seems to apply to the asylum rather than visa system. It's your research that's failed here.

On the basis of the evidence you've been able to provide for that claim, I think we can pop it in the "bollocks" bin unless you've anything substantive you're able to share.

On the rest of it - not relevant to anything I said - its a bit of a scathing indictment of the failures of the over-centralised British state when other countries manage more nuanced visa systems with eg regional visas, but I don't disagree that it's warranted.

bombastix · 05/12/2023 21:55

@wordler / unfortunately I don't think the Home Office would be tempted. They have their fingers burnt a lot by people who make financial declarations but those cannot be used, for example, the income disappears or the individual refuses to pay. The UK citizen is by then back in the UK and cannot be deported (rightly) and the spouse will have an Article 8 claim. So this is not much of guarantee.

A spouse in the position you describe I think is already non access to benefits, but even if it were otherwise, the Home Office would struggle to enforce this which is why they choose bigger fees upfront for all visas.

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 21:49

JassyRadlett · 05/12/2023 21:42

Isn't that referring to the processing of asylum claims (where the huge delays are causing other costs to the Blessed Taxpayer) rather than visa processing, which is (more than) user-funded?

The "one decision a week" is something I've only been able to find in relation to asylum claim processing.

Darling, I am not here to help with your research. The point is simple: the system has to be fair and equal to all and you do that with standard tick boxing exercises than forensic analysis. That's for would be terro-rists to keep the country safe!

Evaluation on individual circumstances would lead to more and never ending appeals as people will pick anything and everything to appeal against, like teh asylum seekers do as they are subject to much more wide international protections for obvious reasons. Right now, the playing field is similar and appeal judges know what test to use to all appeal applications as it is the same for everyone.

CuteOrangeElephant · 05/12/2023 21:44

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 21:09

There will be countless families like ours who met and married EU citizens (and had families) when there was freedom of movement.

This point I have sympathy with. Welcome to the world and life of all people in UK who are not British citizens. HO keeps upping fees etc etc and changing laws in a second. But I bet you didn't even know any of this before! Well, now you know! None is immune from the f!kery of the UK gov love.

That is my situation also and we chose to leave the UK because I just don't trust the Home office and the UK government quite frankly.

Now the UK has lost a software engineer and an agricultural specialist, both occupations with a shortage. It's incredibly short-sighted.

wordler · 05/12/2023 21:44

bombastix · 05/12/2023 21:36

I don't think they will ever engage with third party sponsors - lots of problems with families attempting to make up businesses or other income to gain entry to the UK in the past. People get desperate and do all sorts, gifting money, or showing "assets" to gain entry.

It is very burdensome to check all this stuff and leads to appeals. The Home Office already has experience of trying and failing to manage bank statements or trying to check if sponsors do have money and don't do this any longer.

By third-party sponsor, I simply mean a UK citizen other than the spouse who makes the financial threshold and will sign a contract to reimburse the government if the foreign spouse ends up resorting to public funds before they get their permanent residency or citizenship.

So in my case, my Dad would happily do that for us if we needed it.

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 21:42

bombastix · 05/12/2023 21:36

I don't think they will ever engage with third party sponsors - lots of problems with families attempting to make up businesses or other income to gain entry to the UK in the past. People get desperate and do all sorts, gifting money, or showing "assets" to gain entry.

It is very burdensome to check all this stuff and leads to appeals. The Home Office already has experience of trying and failing to manage bank statements or trying to check if sponsors do have money and don't do this any longer.

Agreed.

HO reserves that scrutiny to would be terro-rists to keep teh citizens living in teh UK safe- that's even more a priority than citizens who left years ago- sorry. HO is not only there for spouse's applications you know! They have many mandates each of which requires money, so a lot to balance there.

Do you guys even know what our terror threat level teh country is in right now?

JassyRadlett · 05/12/2023 21:42

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 21:37

I will, when I find it. I think it was Labour highlighting why teh system is not working i.e broken ( and instead of addressing the infrastructure shortage and manpower issues, the conservative UK gov punish the people in that system). Anyway labour was urging gov to spend more taxpayers' money so that caseworkers who currently make ONE decision a week, each, can make more decisions each week. Look out for Lab manifesto on immigration- I am sure they will pledge this in there as well.

Isn't that referring to the processing of asylum claims (where the huge delays are causing other costs to the Blessed Taxpayer) rather than visa processing, which is (more than) user-funded?

The "one decision a week" is something I've only been able to find in relation to asylum claim processing.

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 21:38

wordler · 05/12/2023 21:28

Offering the option of a third-party sponsor wouldn't be a huge burden administratively.

It works in the US system - the US also takes into account family size of the US citizens so if you have dependents the financial threshold gets larger which actually makes more sense too because the UK system only increases the threshold for non UK kids. So a family of 5 UK citizens needs to prove the same financial support as a couple without kids.

I'm not trying to get people to feel sorry for me - by the time we want to move I'm sure we will be able to work something out and we've lived apart before for months in emergencies so I know we can cope.

We spent the whole first year of our marriage apart because the US system while financially fairer was/is very very slow because of the sheer numbers of applicants.

But this is a horrible situation for many British families - some stuck in countries they want/need to leave and some stuck living without one of the parents for years.

I do take your earlier post point about there being many terrible elements to the immigration system for non-British applicants too. But this situation is the one I know the most about so trying to counter some of the 'well it's just tough shit' posters.

This was a gracious response. I wish you well.

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 21:37

JassyRadlett · 05/12/2023 21:28

Can you share one of the stories you're talking about? I've had a (fairly brief) search but can't see anything on this.

I will, when I find it. I think it was Labour highlighting why teh system is not working i.e broken ( and instead of addressing the infrastructure shortage and manpower issues, the conservative UK gov punish the people in that system). Anyway labour was urging gov to spend more taxpayers' money so that caseworkers who currently make ONE decision a week, each, can make more decisions each week. Look out for Lab manifesto on immigration- I am sure they will pledge this in there as well.

bombastix · 05/12/2023 21:36

I don't think they will ever engage with third party sponsors - lots of problems with families attempting to make up businesses or other income to gain entry to the UK in the past. People get desperate and do all sorts, gifting money, or showing "assets" to gain entry.

It is very burdensome to check all this stuff and leads to appeals. The Home Office already has experience of trying and failing to manage bank statements or trying to check if sponsors do have money and don't do this any longer.

Skodacool · 05/12/2023 21:35

willstarttomorrow · 04/12/2023 19:56

Not fair in any way at all but this is about trying to win votes. It is also not fair to invite people to take jobs we cannot fill from the home grown workforce but to then say but 'not your partner and children- that is just taking the piss incomer' (paraphrasing slightly there) is crazy . My 101 year old nan was in a lovely care home which was then staffed by EU workers, mostly from Poland. After Brexit, my mother who needs nursing care and has very advanced dementia is in an amazing nursing home staffed by nurses from the Philippines and also care staff.

My SIL is from the Philippines and whilst it is very usual for women to leave their children with grandparents and send money home, the current proposal is cruel. It just stinks of a colonial mindset in that they are bloody lucky to be here. The only thing which probably remains on our side in the UK when recruiting talent from overseas is that English is the universal language.

Hit the nail on the head!

JassyRadlett · 05/12/2023 21:28

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 21:22

Yet, gov keeps being urged to speed up the processing which includes proposal for yet more tax payers' money to teh HO. Check teh news

Can you share one of the stories you're talking about? I've had a (fairly brief) search but can't see anything on this.

wordler · 05/12/2023 21:28

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 21:16

I have tried not to answer you directly. However, you do realise it costs taxpayers billions to process HO applications ( and other applications like at DWP ) that the gov had to find something standard that caseworkers at HO can quickly check if it ticks the main boxes to say yes or no and, therefore cannot carefully look at your individual circumstances as that may come with a 10 year wait for processing? So we all have to accept the reality. But then I think you left teh UK many years ago (20?)? Everything has gone down in teh UK, hence this attitude to immigration and therefore to people which may include you.

Sorry for your situation.

Edited

Offering the option of a third-party sponsor wouldn't be a huge burden administratively.

It works in the US system - the US also takes into account family size of the US citizens so if you have dependents the financial threshold gets larger which actually makes more sense too because the UK system only increases the threshold for non UK kids. So a family of 5 UK citizens needs to prove the same financial support as a couple without kids.

I'm not trying to get people to feel sorry for me - by the time we want to move I'm sure we will be able to work something out and we've lived apart before for months in emergencies so I know we can cope.

We spent the whole first year of our marriage apart because the US system while financially fairer was/is very very slow because of the sheer numbers of applicants.

But this is a horrible situation for many British families - some stuck in countries they want/need to leave and some stuck living without one of the parents for years.

I do take your earlier post point about there being many terrible elements to the immigration system for non-British applicants too. But this situation is the one I know the most about so trying to counter some of the 'well it's just tough shit' posters.

skipandwhistle · 05/12/2023 21:27

It's far too high. And the assumptions in this thread are that it's all about foreign types bringing in foreign type spouses to take advantage of UK benefits etc etc.
But both my (white middle-class white British) children have married citizens of other countries. As young people, they are not yet earning that kind of money to be able to bring their spouses here to live with them.
The end result is that my son - an early-career barrister - has moved to Australia, and my daughter - a conservatoire trained professional musician - has moved to the US. The UK has lost two educated young professionals - who could have spent a lifetime contributing to the economy - by making it too hard for them to create a family life here.

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 21:22

Yet, gov keeps being urged to speed up the processing which includes proposal for yet more tax payers' money to teh HO. Check teh news

Swipe left for the next trending thread