Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
Arafina · 06/12/2023 13:15

Pomonas · 06/12/2023 12:45

As I said everyone pays for the abuse on the system. Of course there would be people sadly caught in this situation. There are too many people on low income immigrating and putting a burden on the system later on. People and the press are pressuring the government so obviously they would look at ways to reduce the numbers where they can. I find every time they try do something is met with outcries. If not from the press, the UN, activists and social left leaning media and even Mumsnet. Nothing gets done and back to square one.

I personally would not choose the U.K. to live at the moment if I can.

Edited

Who are these "people" that are putting pressure on the government? I keep being told this but I've actually yet to meet anyone that has ever mentioned it apart from my immediate family when it's on the news, most of us are having conversations about things that are personal to us or things like the price of lurpak or pot hole damage, is immigration something that keeps people awake at night if it's not directly affecting their life like it is for those who are awaiting home office decisions

EssexMan55 · 06/12/2023 13:13

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 12:58

I think for me, what baffles me is people “still” think immigrants abuse the system when in FACT… we cannot access the system. What do people not understand about that? There is nothing to abuse.

We pay extra onto the NHS every year. We move into the property our spouse is already living in.

It seems British people always talk about a fair and equitable society, but if a British person marries a non-British person, they are not eligible to participate?

This is somewhat misleading.

The visa says no recourse to public funds, but you can use the NHS which is publically funded. So it's actually no recourse to benefits. Once you get ILR after 5 years you can access benefits for life. The NHS surcharge and NI is similar in cost to the private health insurance I was required to have when I lived in Europe, so its not that different in cost to comparator countries.

So the no access is to specific benefits and only for the first 5 years.

RedRidingGood · 06/12/2023 13:02

@CrashyTime As someone who is here on a Spousal visa, I think you do not understand how hard and expensive it is, even for someone on a 6 figure salary like myself and DH. As my very reputable immigration lawyer told me, the % of sham marriages is very low. People go by media headlines and think it forms a high % of marriages but that isn't the case.
Also for what it's worth the "blame the foreigner" rhetoric from the government is currently being used to mask their failings. Don't fall for it.

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 12:58

Pomonas · 06/12/2023 12:45

As I said everyone pays for the abuse on the system. Of course there would be people sadly caught in this situation. There are too many people on low income immigrating and putting a burden on the system later on. People and the press are pressuring the government so obviously they would look at ways to reduce the numbers where they can. I find every time they try do something is met with outcries. If not from the press, the UN, activists and social left leaning media and even Mumsnet. Nothing gets done and back to square one.

I personally would not choose the U.K. to live at the moment if I can.

Edited

I think for me, what baffles me is people “still” think immigrants abuse the system when in FACT… we cannot access the system. What do people not understand about that? There is nothing to abuse.

We pay extra onto the NHS every year. We move into the property our spouse is already living in.

It seems British people always talk about a fair and equitable society, but if a British person marries a non-British person, they are not eligible to participate?

Pomonas · 06/12/2023 12:45

As I said everyone pays for the abuse on the system. Of course there would be people sadly caught in this situation. There are too many people on low income immigrating and putting a burden on the system later on. People and the press are pressuring the government so obviously they would look at ways to reduce the numbers where they can. I find every time they try do something is met with outcries. If not from the press, the UN, activists and social left leaning media and even Mumsnet. Nothing gets done and back to square one.

I personally would not choose the U.K. to live at the moment if I can.

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 12:39

Seagrassbasket · 06/12/2023 11:48

I think the main problem with discussions like this is that people are unable to take their own emotions out of it. Lots of people talking about their own (admittedly very sad and difficult) situations and lots of people who have very strong feelings either way about immigration in general.

As a person who spent years and lots of money getting residency in a country not the UK, let me give you a newsflash.

The government doesn’t give a shit about your personal feelings or story. The government will do a) what is best for them to get re-elected (and I do think the net migration figures were too high) and b), hopefully, what is best for the country.

On a human level yes I do think it’s sad people can’t bring their spouses over. But you bring your spouse (who has no recourse to public funds for a few years, yes) and then have children and the birth costs a fortune (way beyond the NHS surcharge amount, plus all the healthcare the kids need in their first few years of life) and then the kids are educated (which according to a PP costs 7k a year) and there’s more waste for the bin men and more people driving on the roads that need maintaining and the list goes on and on and on. It’s not just housing benefit and UC.

It’s not unreasonable that the person sponsoring their spouse can contribute to all of that. The government needs to hedge their bets against all the spouses that won’t get a job when they get here.

You do realise that you are basically saying the UK should create a system for British people to only reproduce with someone in the UK if they are British?

Not everyone has kids as soon as they arrive here. In many of the immigration forums (Reddit, ExpatForum etc), a lot of people actually delay having children until they are permanent residents- so five years.

So, even after 5 years of paying excess into the system, would you agree they can reproduce then? Or should Brits with foreign spouses have a child ban placed on them?

CrashyTime · 06/12/2023 12:26

RedRidingGood · 06/12/2023 12:09

@CrashyTime you're missing the point, people that we are talking about here are moving to the UK via marriage. Not all are escaping their country- rolls eyes.

Marriage is the classic way to gain access to a country, why do you think the internet is full of scams where women abroad try to lure men into "relationships"? This thread is over-romanticising the situation, the government are looking at the cold facts, there are too many loopholes and people are pissed off about it, that loses elections for parties that dont fix it. People "escape" countries for many reasons, maybe they just dont like their government or their family or something else about it, but there is a perception among the UK public that people are coming here for more generous benefits with a lower barrier to accessing these benefits (why else would you risk your life in a boat to leave France?)

RedRidingGood · 06/12/2023 12:09

@CrashyTime you're missing the point, people that we are talking about here are moving to the UK via marriage. Not all are escaping their country- rolls eyes.

CrashyTime · 06/12/2023 11:57

User123456713 · 05/12/2023 19:47

I ve worked before in Social Enterprise, i can tell you that many people who are unemployed are also unemployable, variety of reasons, often MH related, some with physical health issues, most have not worked for many years.

They would require a great deal of effort to get to a state where you'd want them looking after your Gran or disabled son.

You'd want them working in a non care role for many months first, with extensive support & who have we got going spare to provide this? they'd need training up too

I really don't think a high motivated person, willing to leave their own country to seek work, can be compared to someone smoking weed & unemployed for years.

Fair points, but remember the primary motivation for many people coming here is to get out of their own country for whatever reason and live in the U.K, it isnt to care for your Gran, although that doesnt mean they can`t care for your Gran it just means she is not their main motivation, on the other hand someone drawn to a social care type career is likely (not always, but likely) to have delivering the best care/support as one of their top priorities? I think the only solution is for care sector wages to rise, but then you get the reverse of people taking the job because there are loads of vacancies and they can get one relatively easily, you will get people who are not really suitable taking the jobs for the higher hourly rate.

Seagrassbasket · 06/12/2023 11:48

I think the main problem with discussions like this is that people are unable to take their own emotions out of it. Lots of people talking about their own (admittedly very sad and difficult) situations and lots of people who have very strong feelings either way about immigration in general.

As a person who spent years and lots of money getting residency in a country not the UK, let me give you a newsflash.

The government doesn’t give a shit about your personal feelings or story. The government will do a) what is best for them to get re-elected (and I do think the net migration figures were too high) and b), hopefully, what is best for the country.

On a human level yes I do think it’s sad people can’t bring their spouses over. But you bring your spouse (who has no recourse to public funds for a few years, yes) and then have children and the birth costs a fortune (way beyond the NHS surcharge amount, plus all the healthcare the kids need in their first few years of life) and then the kids are educated (which according to a PP costs 7k a year) and there’s more waste for the bin men and more people driving on the roads that need maintaining and the list goes on and on and on. It’s not just housing benefit and UC.

It’s not unreasonable that the person sponsoring their spouse can contribute to all of that. The government needs to hedge their bets against all the spouses that won’t get a job when they get here.

literaryloveaffair · 06/12/2023 10:43

Pomonas · 06/12/2023 09:54

I wonder if they looked at faked arranged marriages and all sorts of tricks people come up with to move countries. Unfortunately, everyone pays for as result of the ones playing the system.

To be fair as far as I know £18.000 is peanuts to live in the main cities even if you are single and child free. My salary of many moons ago of £24.000 pre tax would not have allowed me to work and live in London these days if I were renting and obviously owing would have been impossible. If you do not want people going straight to the welfare as soon as they are entitled this raise is fair and more realistic. People saying I do not earn that much and are struggling is precisely what they are trying to avoid. A bit late but I expect they would look everywhere they can cut further low income immigration. We have had a a huge number in the last decade.

Edited

This is a threshold for the whole country not just London.. when we earned a combined 76k I.e. 2 38k salaries we bought a london flat in 2019. And even before my husband got a job exceeding 38k and worked for more than 6 months in same job, we had accumulated savings of 40k which was the majority of our 58k deposit due to living with family. I was on 25k then and he was on 50k (46k plus 4k bonus). We now earn combined 120k age 31 and 33 which I do consider low wage in london (though as a couple we do pay 33k in tax and national insurance) but we also own london property which even the ft says is an inheritocracy and a privilege for few. Is the threshold to buy london property a suitable threshold for a spouse visa.

But back then had there been a 38k threshold, we would have been separated for 3 years. As it took 3 years after graduation for my British husband to have accumulated 6 months work in a 46k paying job as he has a 30k starter job one year, 3 months in a 40k job, hr mistake in a 40k job offer which meant they forgot to issue his offer, plus months of reference checks.. so conclusion he is on 75k now and i am also earning in excess of threshold now but we would have been so screwed if we couldn't follow eu law or had to abide a £38k threshold when we got married at 22 and 24 respectively

Another2Cats · 06/12/2023 10:31

GlasgowGal82 · 04/12/2023 21:19

I don't think many people on this thread realise what a spouses visa is for - it means that if you are a UK citizen you cannot marry someone from abroad and settle with them in the UK unless you earn at least £38K. It think it is too high and will unfairly discriminate against young people early in their careers and public sector workers.

On a personal note, it means that my best friend who is an experienced nurse won't be able to return to live in the UK with her American husband who is an experienced science teacher, despite the fact they could both make a really useful contribution to the UK economy and fill jobs that are hard to recruit to in the public sector. I think it's wrong to calculate it on the basis that the UK citizen needs to be able to support the spouse, because how many relationships these days have only one person working?

@GlasgowGal82 It's a bit more complicated than that. If the foreign spouse is already in the UK on a work visa then the £38k income requirement is a joint requirement between both of them. It's only if the foreign spouse is not already in the UK that it is entirely down to the British spouse.

In the case of your best friend, there is certainly a demand for foreign teachers, especially in London. Here is one recruitment agency that supports foreign teachers in finding jobs in London and pays for their air fares etc to move to the UK:-

https://teach-now.co.uk/international-teacher-recruitment/

For example, I note that they are currently looking for a STEM teacher for KS3-KS5 for a school in Ealing. Salary ranges from £34,500 for a newly qualified (M1) teacher up to £57,000 for an experienced U3.

Once her husband is here on a work visa he can then decide if he wants to stay on a work visa or swap to a spouse visa. Since he is working in the UK both his and your friend's salaries will be taken into account.

International Recruitment - Teach Now

International Recruitment We are recruiting overseas teachers to come and work at schools in the UK. We look after all aspects of relocation from visas to

https://teach-now.co.uk/international-teacher-recruitment

CormorantStrikesBack · 06/12/2023 10:00

@Another2Cats I didn't until yesterday and thank you so much for those details, much appreciated. It looks like that could work. I'd been trying to find out if once his 3 year visa was up would his wage count for a spouse visa so good to know it would.

Pomonas · 06/12/2023 09:54

I wonder if they looked at faked arranged marriages and all sorts of tricks people come up with to move countries. Unfortunately, everyone pays for as result of the ones playing the system.

To be fair as far as I know £18.000 is peanuts to live in the main cities even if you are single and child free. My salary of many moons ago of £24.000 pre tax would not have allowed me to work and live in London these days if I were renting and obviously owing would have been impossible. If you do not want people going straight to the welfare as soon as they are entitled this raise is fair and more realistic. People saying I do not earn that much and are struggling is precisely what they are trying to avoid. A bit late but I expect they would look everywhere they can cut further low income immigration. We have had a a huge number in the last decade.

Another2Cats · 06/12/2023 09:41

CormorantStrikesBack · 04/12/2023 20:28

Well she earns a bit under 30k. They were going to live here or possibly buy a house (she has a deposit saved) and he was going to get a job. I think they assumed they’d have to get married for him to work here. Maybe he can get a work visa first and come over, I don’t know. He works in marketing, he has a degree. Which probably counts for nothing.

@CormorantStrikesBack Are you aware of the Youth Mobility Scheme (YMS) in the UK or the International Experience Canada (IEC) scheme in Canada?

From January a Canadian who is 35 or younger can get a three year work visa to stay in the UK. (It's currently under 30 and two years but it changes in January).

To be eligible he must be 1) Canadian 2) No older than 35 3) Do not have dependent children 4) have £2,530 in his bank account.

There is a £298 fee to apply for a YMS visa. People from many other countries including Australia, New Zealand, Iceland, Hong Kong, Japan, South Korea, Taiwan can also apply.

There are also reciprocal arrangements for young Brits to go and work in those countries. The Canadian scheme, IEC has similar requirements to the YMS except that you are only required to have CAD$2,500 (£1,460) in your bank account.

Details of YMS scheme here:-

https://www.gov.uk/youth-mobility/eligibility

As I understand things, the £38k figure includes income from both partners (see here https://www.gov.uk/uk-family-visa/proof-income)

So, as I understand things, he can come to the UK on a YMS visa for up to three years and get a job here. They can then marry and apply for his visa on the basis of both of their incomes in the UK.

Also, if your DD is saving for a deposit at the moment it may be better to put off buying a house as having cash savings reduces the amount of income you have to show.

For example, under the current requirement for £18.6k income if you have savings of £62,500 then you do not need to have any income at all. The figures change with smaller amounts of savings so, for example, if you have savings of £40,500 then the income requirement is reduced by £9,800 per year.

So, if that continues, then if you have £40k of savings then the income requirement will be reduced from £38k per year to around £28k per year.

Youth Mobility Scheme visa

Apply for a Youth Mobility Scheme visa to live and work in the UK if you’re from a participating country - fees, eligibility, how to apply.

https://www.gov.uk/youth-mobility/eligibility

Morgysmum · 06/12/2023 09:24

That is a lot.
My partner and myself, don't even earn that a year.
He has 2 degrees and works full time, I work part time. It is a struggle.
The sectors that could do with immigrants coming over to help, NHS and Care, don't make that level of wages, nurses start at 22,000 (I think)

SleepDreamThinkHuge · 06/12/2023 09:00

It is a joke. The average person in the UK does not even earn that salary.

Arafina · 06/12/2023 08:52

sashh · 06/12/2023 08:25

@Arafina I believe so, the last article in the local paper was them starting school in the UK.

The local MP was also very supportive.

That's good to know, thank you, hope children of the future are treated with the same humanity although I fear they won't be

sashh · 06/12/2023 08:25

@Arafina I believe so, the last article in the local paper was them starting school in the UK.

The local MP was also very supportive.

Oliotya · 06/12/2023 08:17

SuspiciousSue · 06/12/2023 08:06

How is giving a year to find another job ‘cruel’? I was made redundant in April and found another permanent job within 6 weeks. Whilst I waited for security clearance, I temped for 4 months. There are so many jobs out there, you just have to be prepared to look for them and do them. Some people just don’t want to.

You don't seem to quite understand how the minimum income requirement for visas works. A redundancy, even a very brief period of unemployment, can pull you under the threshold. It's not enough to be employed, earning enough, at the time of application - it has to be sustained for 6-12 months. Allowing for 6 weeks of unemployment, your salary would have to be more like £42,000pa to meet the requirement, demonstrating 12 months of income. There's little room for error.

SuspiciousSue · 06/12/2023 08:06

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:48

This feels even more cruel, if anything. Hey you, failure, lost your job? Very sad, very sad, anyway, we'll kick out your wife in addition to that.

How is giving a year to find another job ‘cruel’? I was made redundant in April and found another permanent job within 6 weeks. Whilst I waited for security clearance, I temped for 4 months. There are so many jobs out there, you just have to be prepared to look for them and do them. Some people just don’t want to.

literaryloveaffair · 06/12/2023 08:06

SuspiciousSue · 06/12/2023 08:03

I think it’s a fair amount. If the person earning has to support another then £38k really isn’t a lot for two people, let alone if you have kids. People shouldn’t come if they don’t like it 🤷‍♀️

My dh didn't earn in excess of 38k until 3 years into our marriage (we came here under eu law as he is british but studied in europe). We are now on combined 120k. Dh on 75k. It's not about whether you can earn 38k now, many people in their 30s and living in a big city can. It's about whether you can at that particular point in time.

BTW when we were on 76k (2 38k salaries) we bought a flat in London in 2019! Which isn't a million years away. Do you feel that only british people who buy london property should be able to settle in the UK with their loved one.

literaryloveaffair · 06/12/2023 08:04

MarvellousMonsters · 06/12/2023 07:00

Anything less than £30k isn't a living wage, why should people work hard and not earn enough to live on? What's the point of working if you can't afford to pay your rent/mortgage, feed, clothe your family and heat your home?

Would you?

The figure set by the govt is an admission that it's the real living wage, and that tells you that the majority of healthcare, hospitality and retail workers are not earning a living wage.

Yes and that's why I feel so down about this figure. I am a londoner and both dh and I earn in excess of this figure. In my own estimation, as an early 30s londoner with a mortgage I should be earning double of the national threshold. Indeed we were both earning double of this threshold back even in 2019.

This means our own personal living wage needs to be 200k and we earn 120k.

SuspiciousSue · 06/12/2023 08:03

I think it’s a fair amount. If the person earning has to support another then £38k really isn’t a lot for two people, let alone if you have kids. People shouldn’t come if they don’t like it 🤷‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread