Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
22
murasaki · 18/12/2023 23:05

I think there's an argument for people already here but having to renew visas not to have to hit this threshold.

SoNotRainbowRhythms · 15/12/2023 16:49

WhenLoveIsDone · 10/12/2023 15:48

So... you are pleased your government has let the cost of living get so out of control that people need to take extra shifts in care homes on top of their normal jobs?

As has been said about 1000 times on this thread, foreign spouses have zero recourse to public funds and we aren't doing anything with your benefits system apart from bolstering it with our NI payments.

Not to mention the NHS surcharge, paid when applying and renewing visas, which Is quite extortionate and set to rise again!

izimbra · 15/12/2023 13:56

Oliotya · 14/12/2023 16:54

https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/652602

Petition is finally live for anyone wishing to sign.

I think not only does this increased requirement breach the human rights of British children to a family life if they have a foreign parent, it also discriminates against British women and mothers as they're less likely to be able to meet the income requirement to bring in their spouse than men who are British citizens. It should be challenged specifically on those grounds.

Zamzamzamdeedah · 11/12/2023 06:16

exexpat · 10/12/2023 22:37

I think some checks on people arriving in the UK purely in order to get married is fair enough (proving it is a genuine relationship is a little intrusive but not that hard), but when you have people who have been married for years but living in another country, or who already have children together, I think refusing them the right to live together in the home country of one of the partners is a violation of human rights.

It will be challenged like the HO approval to marry was

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 10/12/2023 23:26

A lot of British people met and married eu citizens at a point in time when we had the right to live and work freely within the eu with an understanding that they could easily live in either persons country and move between them as they wished. This has now been taken away due to brexit making it very difficult for lots of British citizens to return with their families. This is incredibly unfair. Yea the government gave a window of a couple of years to allow you to move back with your eu but that was very short to suddenly make that decision and move and came during Covid when it was extra difficult.

exexpat · 10/12/2023 22:37

I think some checks on people arriving in the UK purely in order to get married is fair enough (proving it is a genuine relationship is a little intrusive but not that hard), but when you have people who have been married for years but living in another country, or who already have children together, I think refusing them the right to live together in the home country of one of the partners is a violation of human rights.

user1477391263 · 10/12/2023 22:10

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 09/12/2023 22:12

Not even share the parenting but lose the right to live in the same country as her children as she would need permission to take them abroad.

If we want to make the dodgiest type of marriage harder, there are all sorts of low hanging fruit we could tackle instead, like requiring foreign spouses to be at least 24, speak the language to a certain level, have a degree or appropriate post-school vocational training in something, and so on. Denmark does this and I think it works well and is felt by most people to be fair and reasonable.

Moving to another country to live as the foreign spouse (I am actually in this position, outside the UK) is a big step. You should be old enough to know your own mind and have some work and language skills so that you don’t becoming isolated and dependent. Even for those who are 100% not bothered about immigration issues, 18yo cousins from villages in Pakistan being brought in as wives is not great for them or for society.

izimbra · 10/12/2023 20:30

"The "Not enough houses!" meme is the biggest con going."

England has fewer empty homes as a proportion of housing stock than any other developed country, and you'd know this if you did any research at all. It's the reason why our housing prices are so high - because housing supply is kept artificially low in order to raise the prices of homes.

To give you an idea - in the UK 0.9% of home are long term unoccupied. The figure for France is nearly 8%, Germany 8.1%, Netherlands 4%.

https://www.tomforth.co.uk/emptyhomesforgood/#:~:text=Across%20England%2C%200.9%25%20of%20homes,for%20Greater%20Paris%20is%206.5%25.

We need to build homes, vast numbers of them. And we need to build many, many more social homes for rent.

The government knows this but it suits them to keep planning laws as restrictive as they are to suit the preferences of home owners, who are their core voters. A surprising number of MPs are also landlords and it suits them to keep the rental market in its current profoundly dysfunctional state.

The Conservatives also know it can use anger over immigration as an electoral tool - trashing public services, failing to address the housing needs of the country, this is all grist to the mill for this terrible, inept government.

Empty homes for good.

England has fewer empty homes than any other developed country. If we had more we'd be better housed, better off, and happier.'

https://www.tomforth.co.uk/emptyhomesforgood#:~:text=Across%20England%2C%200.9%25%20of%20homes,for%20Greater%20Paris%20is%206.5%25.

WhenLoveIsDone · 10/12/2023 15:48

So... you are pleased your government has let the cost of living get so out of control that people need to take extra shifts in care homes on top of their normal jobs?

As has been said about 1000 times on this thread, foreign spouses have zero recourse to public funds and we aren't doing anything with your benefits system apart from bolstering it with our NI payments.

CrashyTime · 10/12/2023 15:18

izimbra · 10/12/2023 11:15

"Anyone earning less than £38k, migrant or not, is being supported by net contributor taxpayers. Basically we are importing vast swathes of people on low wages and then paying for them. It’s just bonkers."

That's the attitude of someone who genuinely thinks a care worker, parent, teacher or agricultural worker makes zero contribution to this country - whatever you do is 'worthless' if it doesn't turn a net profit when set against the cost of your healthcare or your use of public services. What's the phrase? Someone who 'knows the price of everything but the value of nothing'.

This is a great demonstration of a basic lack of humanity in our public discourse over immigration. Imagine saying this to a child to explain why it's morally reasonable to ban their parent from living and working in the UK. :-(

Yes, that sounds emotive and believable, but the problem is that there are plenty of people here already who need to get off the benefits and do something, many people already working are probably doing part-time shifts at the care home to pay their mortgage by now. The PTB (and the care industry) know this, when people dont have access to the cheap debt anymore they will have to take the jobs that they previously wouldnt take because they were pretending to be a "celebrity" on the plastic, it is great cover for a pretence of "tackling" immigration near an election.

CrashyTime · 10/12/2023 15:11

CatherinedeBourgh · 10/12/2023 14:44

"Anyone earning less than £38k, migrant or not, is being supported by net contributor taxpayers. Basically we are importing vast swathes of people on low wages and then paying for them. It’s just bonkers."

But everyone at some point in their life is earning less than £38k. This doesn't mean that over their life as a whole they will not be a net contributor, so even on its own terms (i.e. disregarding non monetary value of contributions) this policy is flawed if the purpose is to only let in people who will be (or be married to, to be precise), net contributors.

If that was the basis on which you were taking decisions, you should be looking at the expected lifetime earnings of the couple, not the current income of one half of it.

It's just yet more soundbitey nonsense from the Tories pandering to an uneducated and bigoted audience.

"uneducated and bigoted audience"

LOL, obviously they have learned from the Remain mistakes then, where they thought that people they considered uneducated and bigoted (because they disagreed with them) didn`t count.

CrashyTime · 10/12/2023 15:07

User123456713 · 09/12/2023 19:43

@greengreengrass25 Migrants aren't eligible for council/social housing, as they a) not been here for long enough and b) in the case of most workers, will have a "no recourse to public funds" on the visa.

UK has a housing crisis because we don't build enough houses and what we do build is too expensive, even the so called "affordable ones" they are just a few % cheaper than open market.

"UK has a housing crisis because we don't build enough houses"

No, UK has a housing crisis because we allowed property prices to become unaffordable by giving people too much cheap mortgage debt to play with, many of those people are now waking up to the reality of how much that debt is going to cost them, there are a quarter of a million empty houses in England alone according to the media? and mortgage applications and sales have plummeted recently but all those people no longer applying/buying still live somewhere. The "Not enough houses!" meme is the biggest con going.

CatherinedeBourgh · 10/12/2023 14:44

"Anyone earning less than £38k, migrant or not, is being supported by net contributor taxpayers. Basically we are importing vast swathes of people on low wages and then paying for them. It’s just bonkers."

But everyone at some point in their life is earning less than £38k. This doesn't mean that over their life as a whole they will not be a net contributor, so even on its own terms (i.e. disregarding non monetary value of contributions) this policy is flawed if the purpose is to only let in people who will be (or be married to, to be precise), net contributors.

If that was the basis on which you were taking decisions, you should be looking at the expected lifetime earnings of the couple, not the current income of one half of it.

It's just yet more soundbitey nonsense from the Tories pandering to an uneducated and bigoted audience.

izimbra · 10/12/2023 14:43

HolidayAddict23 · 10/12/2023 13:51

Sure we’ll just let everyone in that wants to be here without the means to support themselves!!! Lol

This is what you see when someone has no valid arguments against an inhumane policy. If you make an argument that it's cruel, and particularly unfair to women to double the minimum income requirements for British citizens to live with their spouses in the UK, the response from HolidayAddict23 is 'you think we should just have open borders!'

Can't you debate like an adult?

Oliotya · 10/12/2023 13:55

HolidayAddict23 · 10/12/2023 13:51

Sure we’ll just let everyone in that wants to be here without the means to support themselves!!! Lol

No recourse to public funds. They already have to support themselves.

HolidayAddict23 · 10/12/2023 13:51

Sure we’ll just let everyone in that wants to be here without the means to support themselves!!! Lol

WhenLoveIsDone · 10/12/2023 13:38

HolidayAddict23 · 10/12/2023 09:37

Very fair

Very fair, to exile your own citizens in the tens of thousands if they want to live with their partners?

Sure, what does your country need lab technicians, teachers, nurses, supermarket staff etc etc for?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-67630258?fbclid=IwAR1dJO4uZZ2mL0eX8n_XlViiid_EGdjBk4XcUsFf1Pld7cFxceDB-rJ05fA

Furkan and Ruby in Turkey

Couples 'devastated' by migration visa rule changes

New rules will make it harder for British citizens to live in the UK with a foreign partner.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-67630258?fbclid=IwAR1dJO4uZZ2mL0eX8n_XlViiid_EGdjBk4XcUsFf1Pld7cFxceDB-rJ05fA

izimbra · 10/12/2023 11:15

"Anyone earning less than £38k, migrant or not, is being supported by net contributor taxpayers. Basically we are importing vast swathes of people on low wages and then paying for them. It’s just bonkers."

That's the attitude of someone who genuinely thinks a care worker, parent, teacher or agricultural worker makes zero contribution to this country - whatever you do is 'worthless' if it doesn't turn a net profit when set against the cost of your healthcare or your use of public services. What's the phrase? Someone who 'knows the price of everything but the value of nothing'.

This is a great demonstration of a basic lack of humanity in our public discourse over immigration. Imagine saying this to a child to explain why it's morally reasonable to ban their parent from living and working in the UK. :-(

HolidayAddict23 · 10/12/2023 09:37

Very fair

WhenLoveIsDone · 10/12/2023 09:24

I live in an immigrant town where the majority, unlike me, are not white.

There is real poverty here.

I was chatting to a taxi driver who did not meet the 18.5k official income requirement for his wife to be here legally on a spouse visa.

So they put her on the 10 year path, which prohibits her from working legally.

All these foolish rules do is force people into the black economy.

I bet they're all high-fiving each other in the Home Office though.

User123456713 · 10/12/2023 07:19

Papyrophile · 09/12/2023 22:15

The majority of the UKs 68m pop. have zero interaction with the migrants crossing the channel, its racism, pure and simple

I don't think that's true. I live in a 97% white area of the UK, and the POC who have come here seem to like it too. Even the young lads who wore doo-rags a few years ago seem to have given them up. But we don't have migrant hostels housing 200 angry young men making demands. Out here, we make a living to get by, nobody is getting filthy rich. Modestly successful is the goal.

I stand by that (by interaction i mean a bit more than someone sitting 5 rows up on the local bus)
Any so called foreigners i or anyone else i know has meet, are long standing UK citizens, not from SE Asia or Zimbabwe, student areas are just that, always have had a % of overseas, the local hospital has more migrant workers but then again, how many actually spend time getting to know them? for most they wont and what % of the pop. are in hospital at anyone time and are you going to ask what their visa status is?

I ve no idea what POC is, let along Doo-rags.

This kind of subtle racism is so pervasive in SE Cornwall, and it's why my DH and sons (who are visibly "outsiders") don't visit my parents very often.

Same with Brexit, Cornwall, despite having little EU migration but having benefited from EU 1 funding, voted for Brexit, mainly because "we are being flooded with migrants"

How has that worked out then?

Oliotya · 10/12/2023 06:28

Papyrophile · 09/12/2023 22:15

The majority of the UKs 68m pop. have zero interaction with the migrants crossing the channel, its racism, pure and simple

I don't think that's true. I live in a 97% white area of the UK, and the POC who have come here seem to like it too. Even the young lads who wore doo-rags a few years ago seem to have given them up. But we don't have migrant hostels housing 200 angry young men making demands. Out here, we make a living to get by, nobody is getting filthy rich. Modestly successful is the goal.

POC" is not synonymous with migrant.
Giving up "doo-rags" is not a marker of success or integration.
"Same cannot be said about the taxi company" - I mean I think we all know what you're insinuating, so just come out and say it. And use a different taxi company if they're so shit.
This kind of subtle racism is so pervasive in SE Cornwall, and it's why my DH and sons (who are visibly "outsiders") don't visit my parents very often.

kiwiaddict · 09/12/2023 23:54

lkwhjis · 04/12/2023 20:24

It’s smoke and mirrors. Of course they have recourse to public funds. If they are bringing children with them, how is their schooling paid for?

Anyone earning less than £38k, migrant or not, is being supported by net contributor taxpayers. Basically we are importing vast swathes of people on low wages and then paying for them. It’s just bonkers.

Hold on, who's "they"?

I am one of the people being potentially restricted from bringing my husband to the UK (we have no plans to return actually as his job here is great right how but potentially).

Now, I AM English, born and raised, and if I decide to return to the UK with my children they'll get their education regardless of whether my husband comes or not.

I'm not "imported" - I have every much a right to live in the UK as you.

The only difference this law makes is if I decided to return to teaching secondary school science, I won't earn enough to bring my husband - who is a skilled worker but slightly below that threshold too

That's a British born and raised teacher, her British children AND her skilled husband (who wouldn't be allowed to claim UC etc anyway) all suddenly bared from the country