Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get down because other DC's are so high achieving.

62 replies

Greyskyrain · 04/12/2023 13:56

Just that really. My DC is doing GCSES this year and will achieve mediocre results at best.
Everyone seems to have such high achieving children, both in real life and on mumsnet. Mums boasting about their genius DC has become the norm where I live.

Does anyone else feel this way?

OP posts:
Smugandproud · 05/12/2023 07:40

DD’s best friend is very academic and has worked hard and does well in life. She was a positive influence on dd who worked hard too to try and keep up. Dd could never have had a similar career to bf but was encouraged by bf to study what she is good at.
Bf’s dm did and still does boast about her dd, however she’s a lovely person on the whole. And she’s always been lovely to and about dd.

Whilst academic dc still have to study they are very fortunate to have a gift which is a pure accident of birth.
My db is very highly intelligent and a scientist who has presented papers at conferences. However his emotional intelligence is low and his ex wife bullied him throughout their marriage. He rarely rings or visits our elderly parents and seems to struggle with relationships.
I’d much sooner be me.

HowNice23 · 05/12/2023 07:24

I hear you OP. I got pissed off at people agonizing about their kids only getting a 6 or 7 instead of 9s whilst my son was going to be lucky to get a four. He got 7 fours and a six and is now at college doing an entry level city and guilds in engineering and couldn't be happier or more motivated (unlike when he was at school). And with a real career path. And A Levels? The school offered him Music and IT A Levels only... Well that would have been a fairly useless mix for him as he had no interest in either and he didn't want to spend another day there anyway.

They'll be ok OP. But yes it's pissing annoying x

MyDogCalledMax · 05/12/2023 07:20

My cousins are 10 years younger than me and were very academically gifted at school.
My aunt would brag about this to anyone and everyone however they are now in their early 20s and neither of them have a permanent job. They cannot hold anything down and their social skills are zero.
I honestly believe my aunt put so much focus on their academics that now they are out of that part of life, they just cannot cope with the real world.

Ahwhatthehell · 05/12/2023 07:17

Be sure to drive home to your kids that being successful in life doesn’t necessarily follow high exam grades, being top dog at something or earning gazillions.

Tell them that success is about personal contentment. Everyone struggles with something at sometime.

I think it’s also important to try and be happy for the all ‘A’ grade kids - because, like others have said, there is often an anxiety pay off to it. Come off social media, op, if it’s making you feel inadequate.

I bet your kids are average and wonderful.

EarringsandLipstick · 05/12/2023 07:07

As someone who works in third level education, long term, the students that do best are often the solid, conscientious hard working ones, who are often average at secondary school but come into their own when they study at third level, at depth.

Even where students don't go to university, the attributes about working meaningfully & in a measured way will serve them well in work and life.

Many (of course not all) high-flyers struggle when they meet an unexpected obstacle in further studies or work.

Your DS is doing great - and will be fine!

Angrycat2768 · 05/12/2023 06:53

Notsurewhatnext · 04/12/2023 16:13

so you have a child who is doing average in their GCSEs and that is getting you down? Seriously, you need help.

Mine has severe learning difficulties and will need lifelong 24/7 care so my view might be clouded. But it is hard to get my head around with what other parents find disappointing! I hope your child has at least some other redeeming qualities (kind, caring funny etc). I don't understand why you would reduce your child to an academic achievement? bonkers, your poor DC :(

I think its more the worry that they will be competing for jobs with this plethora of apparently 'genius' kids who get 9's across the board, when we are then told that unless they are getting 7-9 in GCSE they will struggle with A Levels and not get into University. I know that is not true but it is still a worry if you have a child who is not getting 9's and is going to get average GCSES. I know of young people who got excellent GCSE grades ( one all 9's who then had a breakdown) but dropped out of university or A Levels and changed direction. Its not the be all and end all, but it does seem sometimes that because the people who boast are the only ones who publicise their DC's 9's across the board that your kid is going to be the only one not, when obviously that is not true.

Ihadenough22 · 04/12/2023 19:13

I think that some parents are trying to live their lives through their kid's. They push their kids into certain courses because they did not go to university themselves. Then they boast that their child got X GCSE, got so many a levels and are on y course.
Unless their children are naturally good in school, work hard and stay on top of the work load in university they won't get through university exams. I currently know 2 bright kids on hard university course and they said their work load is high and they can't afford to get lazy or leave things to do at the last minute otherwise they won't pass assignments or exams.

The parents that are telling you now about the great results may not be doing the same in the next few years. When you hear the bragging now just ask them after the A levels how their child did or ask what university they are going to.

A lot of parents will keep quite about their child if they are not good in school. You won't here either if they are the class clown or the school bully. Ask kids in their class and you find out what the child is really like.

I have also known several kids that would not have looked great on paper or have been regarded as average and yet they have ended up as very successful adults.
I know one lady who now has a degree and master's and a very senior role where she works.
She has done better than her friends who had better a level results and marks when they all started out. She was always good with people but she worked hard. She took on extra training and courses and was recognised for all the work she put in.

Ihadenough22 · 04/12/2023 19:13

I think that some parents are trying to live their lives through their kid's. They push their kids into certain courses because they did not go to university themselves. Then they boast that their child got X GCSE, got so many a levels and are on y course.
Unless their children are naturally good in school, work hard and stay on top of the work load in university they won't get through university exams. I currently know 2 bright kids on hard university course and they said their work load is high and they can't afford to get lazy or leave things to do at the last minute otherwise they won't pass assignments or exams.

The parents that are telling you now about the great results may not be doing the same in the next few years. When you hear the bragging now just ask them after the A levels how their child did or ask what university they are going to.

A lot of parents will keep quite about their child if they are not good in school. You won't here either if they are the class clown or the school bully. Ask kids in their class and you find out what the child is really like.

I have also known several kids that would not have looked great on paper or have been regarded as average and yet they have ended up as very successful adults.
I know one lady who now has a degree and master's and a very senior role where she works.
She has done better than her friends who had better a level results and marks when they all started out. She was always good with people but she worked hard. She took on extra training and courses and was recognised for all the work she put in.

Hickry · 04/12/2023 16:22

Count your blessings op.
An average, healthy kid who will get GCSE grades isn't something to feel aggrieved about. Quite the opposite.

weleasewoderick23 · 04/12/2023 16:19

funnylugs · 04/12/2023 14:30

No matter how proud any parent can be when their children achieve those glittering qualifications, they will never be as happy as me when my son, finally and hopefully, masters his anxiety sufficiently to leave the house and work for a day.

I'm going through that too. My ds didn't even sit his GCSE's because of anxiety.
Flowers

Notsurewhatnext · 04/12/2023 16:13

so you have a child who is doing average in their GCSEs and that is getting you down? Seriously, you need help.

Mine has severe learning difficulties and will need lifelong 24/7 care so my view might be clouded. But it is hard to get my head around with what other parents find disappointing! I hope your child has at least some other redeeming qualities (kind, caring funny etc). I don't understand why you would reduce your child to an academic achievement? bonkers, your poor DC :(

JaninaDuszejko · 04/12/2023 16:05

There's a lot more 'all 9s' children about if you listen to gossip than there are in real life, less than 2000 children got all 9s last year, so about 1 in every second school.

Changedmymind99 · 04/12/2023 15:54

Here is my opinion on academic capability of kids.

medicore is ideal. Not the best at any subject. It then doesn’t give them a “i’m better than you attitude”. It keeps them vaguely interested in doing ok, but accept that they don’t need to be “the best”. Academic brilliance is a memory game, not a test of how well you’ll survive in the real world.

Parents who boast are unlikeable idiots and trying to make themselves feel better. Ignore such twats. It’s embarrassing for them.

Any kids (now adults) in my class who were the bright sparks have all done very mediocrely average in life, nothing special or exceptional. Me who was perfectly average have far surpassed all expectations and career achievements. It’s fun to catch up sometimes cause honestly jaws have dropped.

Average in school is not a bad thing at all. Ensure you don’t peak too soon and then never meet your own expectations.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 04/12/2023 15:48

There seem to be a few posts on this thread that are basically saying, ‘my child did really well but I don’t boast.’
Surely that’s double boasting, about your high achieving child AND your own lack of boastfulness? 🤔

stillplentyofjunkinthetrunk · 04/12/2023 15:38

have you ever played top trumps?

The person asking the question chooses the point to compare and there are 8 or so categories. So you pick the one at which you think you card is strongest...

So little Timmy...

is exceptionally organised
just got piano grade 6
is now volunteering with a local charity
works as a babysitter saving up money for uni
is predicted an 8 in such and such subject
now has a lovely girlfriend
has such a lot of friends]is learning how to cook
& goes to the gym 3 times a week

blah blah blah whatever - NO

Everybodies little "Timmy" has some things they're doing pretty good at and other areas where they are at least intermittently useless. Parents are picking out the thing that makes their kid seem good.

If you dare to privately admit weakness and you might be pleasantly surprised at how many parents join you sharing their concerns and worries.

Weddingpuzzle · 04/12/2023 15:33

Thanks @ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea I honestly think you could have the highest amounts of cash, brains, looks and even luck but none of them are worth anything if you don't have the underpinning mental and physical health and well being. I desperately want that for my DC and it's the worst part of parenting when they don't have it.

BeethovenNinth · 04/12/2023 15:31

I have a child who can’t attend school. I have learnt to protect myself by never comparing. Life is a long game!!

Newgirls · 04/12/2023 15:29

Isn’t the average eg normal grade for gcse a 5? So plenty of kids getting 5,4,3 etc. That makes your kid entirely normal.

The news etc doesn’t help when it’s all ‘record number of A*’

the highest earning people in my family are self made rather than ‘academic’. Everyone has plenty to offer whatever exams they pass.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 04/12/2023 15:13

Weddingpuzzle · 04/12/2023 14:11

It is really frustrating because I have found it isn't really an indicator of 'being the best at life'. DS1 is exceptional at music (has a sponsorship to a music university) but has terrible mental health issues, they are the biggest battle in his life. DD is absolutely brilliant at a particular sport and quite academic but is really struggling hormonally with puberty. DS2 is probably the brightest of them all but doesn't apply it, he is doing his GCSE's this year and will be 'lucky' to get into 6th form but he is generally happy with his lot and honestly, I think that will be the case throughout his life. I'd rather have all three like DS2 if I am honest. What you achieve at school shouldn't be the indicator or measure of a good life lived or define you. I feel your sadness OP.

I absolutely agree with what you say here. I am much happier that my DC has stable mental health, good friendships and a well balanced attitude to life than if they had been particularly high achieving but weren't the things mentioned above.

I think that MN does tend to attract people who are highly educated themselves and more likely to push their own DC.

Friends' children have been very mixed.

Give0fecks · 04/12/2023 15:04

Honestly - I know it’s cliche but please just focus on whether your child is happy.

I was extremely bright - literally got some of the top results in the whole country. Felt I had to pursue a ‘high flying career’ because I was pushed into it by my parents and became a surgeon. I fucking hated it. Hate it hate it hate. Suffered burn out and now on a prolonged career break so basically a SAHM.

my kids are only very young but I know see the value in just having happy healthy children.

skyeisthelimit · 04/12/2023 15:02

No and you shouldn't either. Celebrate your child and help them find the college course that is right for them, or apprenticeship. My DD will be lucky to get 4's and 5's in her GCSE's. She is struggling in English. That also drags down her results in other areas, ie teacher told her she would have got a 6 for her acting but writing drags it down to a 4.

But I don't compare her to others and don't give a shit what others say/think. I don't have time for pushy parents and bragging parents, but luckily I don't know anyone like that.

The school get great results but are only interested in the high achievers.

She will be taking a btech in Acting (has conditional offer dependent on results and audtion). Her skills lie in other areas, which are more creative.

Spinet · 04/12/2023 14:55

Stop it.

What is great about your kid? What is their personality like? What's the funniest story about them? What's the kindest thing they've ever done? What makes them laugh?

Kids are just human beings and like the rest of us we are not the sum of our achievements. Even those high achieving kids have more interesting and loveable things about them than the fact they're on the netball team and get straight 9s, zzzzz

murasaki · 04/12/2023 14:52

My parents really tried hard to not compare us. Not sure it entirely worked, but they did try. I'm the eldest, so had set the bar in that sense. I remember calling sis from uni to see how she'd done, and while it wasn't great, as she was, to be fair, a dosser who should really have stayed at school rather than been given the freedom of sixth form college, apparently my gran had ripped shreds off her for her results. So I phoned gran and tore shreds off her too, which sis appreciated. Sis has an MBA now and out earns me, and barely spoke to gran for the last years of her life. Way to ruin relationships .

Pandapoppss · 04/12/2023 14:36

I actually did not boast about DS results, he is the child of a Professor and an academic librarian who we tutored at home to some extent with a bit of a Chinese upbringing as I’m mixed race had the odds stacked in his favour. No tiger parenting but much stricter than his white friends parents.

Angrycat2768 · 04/12/2023 14:35

I think it is the parents of 'high achievers' boasting. My DS is also working his socks off for his GCSE's but he is going to have to work really hard to get the grades for 6th form. He is also lovely, is interested in lots of things, is a good speaker and is very polite and sociable. It is frustrating that all those other qualities don't seem to matter when it comes to the GCSE's. I don't care if he gets 7's. I just want him to do his best and hopefully it will be enough for him not to have to do maths again and to get into another course. I agree it is really disheartening when people say 7's are too low to do A Levels, when a 7 is an old A. They don't know what they are talking about to a large extent. Once kids get over the hump of GCSE's which are awful and an exercise in memory retrieval in a lot of cases, no one really cares about anything apart from over grade 4 in English and maths. Once they do higher level qualifications English and Maths are the only ones that count. Kids mature, they change their minds about what they want to do, they thrive doing subjects they enjoy rather than struggling on with subjects they aren't interested in. All sorts of things happen after GCSES.

Swipe left for the next trending thread