Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not sending my estranged daughter a birthday card?

216 replies

MumNoMore · 03/12/2023 21:45

My 25yr old daughter and I reconnected 4 years ago after she chose to cut contact at 13 after her father’s and my divorce. I couldn’t have custody due to severe physical and chronic illness but it broke my heart.

I thought we had rebuilt a very good relationship with regular contact, until January when she suddenly cut me off again with no explanation or response to my messages and calls, that left me very confused and distressed since only the week before she told me how much she loved me.

She did send me a printed card from moonpig on my birthday, with a gift she knew I could not use (bath stuff..no bath) but no personal contact.
She posted across social media how much better she felt having made the decision to just focus on herself, and not have to think about anyone else.

That confused me (I’m on the spectrum) as I had always made the point of never complaining to her or asking for any help, ever, as I did not want to burden her with my health difficulties and depression which she did know about.

Its her birthday on Tuesday, and as much as I try to do the right thing, I cannot bring myself to send her even a card as I am still so very hurt and angry.

I have lived life with ‘you either love and care about me and are in my life, or you don’t and you aren’t” which means I have no contact at all with any family and never will, once a door is closed, it’s closed for good.

All the opinions seem to be to send one anyway as a good (even if unwanted) mother, to keep the door open in case she changes her mind and wants a relationship again. For me, that can never happen as I can’t forgive or trust her and risk my mental health being destroyed again.

It broke me to near suicide, and cannot spend the rest of my life anticipating for months and waiting to see if she sends a Xmas, Mother’s Day or birthday card again, reopening wounds of distress when she doesn’t respond to thank you messages I look for in the following days and weeks.

Is it selfish of me to be so protective of my unstable mental health that is already so challenged with being bedbound, depressed and alone, or does the fact she is my daughter trump all that as a priority I should put first and acknowledge as a mother?

Any opinions or advice is welcome, but you don’t have to tell me how crap I am at relationships, I am only too aware my autism makes me think and act differently that seems right to me, which is why I am reaching out.

OP posts:
pizzaHeart · 04/12/2023 08:52

Send her the card.
Dont send her gifts, don’t expect reply.

tsmainsqueeze · 04/12/2023 08:48

IcyGleamyPinkyDiamond · 04/12/2023 08:35

You sound quite ruthless with people and lonely as a result. I get the feeling that being chronically ill has built up resentment, and although you think you never ask anything of anyone, you are projecting your upset onto others. This is, of course, your choice. But twice now your daughter has found you so toxic she has had to distance herself. I think you might want to consider therapy if you want to break this cycle. You chose to have a child, and it doesn't sound like your daughter is a bad person at all, just someone who needs to set her own boundaries, which technically is a trait you, as a caring parent, should applaud. Of course it smarts when she does it with you, but rather than wallowing in self pity and being petty over a birthday card, I think it's time to do some soul searching.

I totally agree , the op needs to 'bend' however difficult that may be.

Alondra · 04/12/2023 08:47

ExpressionSession · 04/12/2023 08:30

There is a lot of talk on the thread about the OP seeing this from her child’s point of view. Clearly though the OP lacks this ability, like everything to do with autism inability to see others point of view is on a spectrum, my ASD daughter is excellent at theory of mind but my ASD father has absolutely no insight into other’s thinking.

I suspect that the OP is at my father’s end of the spectrum, speaking personally that was incredibly difficult to deal with as a child, it guarantees a lack of attunement which is obviously imperative for healthy childhood attachment. I adored my father growing up and I admired him beyond belief but his unwillingness to see anyone’s perspective except his own rose to emotionally abusive levels during difficult time in our family and eventually and I had to cut contact completely. He doesn’t get it either. He should have spoken to a therapist but to be honest I’m not sure it would have made a difference due to his rigid thinking.

I wish you well OP but I suspect your difficulties which are clearly breaking your own heart will break your daughter’s heart too.

This is a you problem though. It really is.

I agree. Most people on the thread have no idea about being on the spectrum and how to tailor their responses to an autistic person.

I completely disagree with you that it's the OP's problem. She can't change who she is and her black and white thinking. Her daughter is 25, an adult and, I understand, neurotypical. She is not a kid and should be able to understand, by now, how the spectrum affects her loved ones.

NewFriendlyLadybird · 04/12/2023 08:46

Of course, autism is highly heritable. The black-and-white thinking and may not belong to the OP alone.

Mummy3Plus1 · 04/12/2023 08:46

This won't be an easy opinion to read but based on what you have written I think you are being wholy unreasonable. By having a child you took on that responsibility of putting them before yourself, always. Age in my opinion does not change your obligations to your child. If your DD needs a break from you then you need to respect that, keep the lines of communication open with special occasion cards/gifts and the odd 'hope you're doing okay' messages but nothing over the top. To say you can never forgive your own child for simply needing a break from you is mindboggling.

As you mentioned you are ND, you need to also be accepting that your view on the relationship you shared with her is probably very different to what she has seen. As others have mentioned, you appear to be in great need of counselling and that should help you come to terms with why you are so quick to severe connections but also judge others who do so so heavily.

Good luck. I hope by working on yourself and giving your daughter time you can get to a better place.

gotomomo · 04/12/2023 08:45

If you want any future relationship send a card with a message that you understood she finds the relationship difficult with you but you would love to see her occasionally.

I'm wondering if you were too intense with the relationship too quickly?

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 04/12/2023 08:40

tenbob · 03/12/2023 21:52

“I have lived life with ‘you either love and care about me and are in my life, or you don’t and you aren’t” which means I have no contact at all with any family and never will, once a door is closed, it’s closed for good.”

This jumped out at me.

If you are a full ‘my way or the highway’ person, it’s easy to see how she got to the point of having to cut contact with you.

I guess it’s up to you to decide whether you continue to live by a frankly awful set of rules, and spend the rest of your days with the consequences, or get some help to foster a healthier mindset that allows enough flexibility to allow for some sort of relationship in the future.

Agree with Tenbob.

BungleandGeorge · 04/12/2023 08:40

I would send a card because I’d want to leave the door open for her to come back

IcyGleamyPinkyDiamond · 04/12/2023 08:35

You sound quite ruthless with people and lonely as a result. I get the feeling that being chronically ill has built up resentment, and although you think you never ask anything of anyone, you are projecting your upset onto others. This is, of course, your choice. But twice now your daughter has found you so toxic she has had to distance herself. I think you might want to consider therapy if you want to break this cycle. You chose to have a child, and it doesn't sound like your daughter is a bad person at all, just someone who needs to set her own boundaries, which technically is a trait you, as a caring parent, should applaud. Of course it smarts when she does it with you, but rather than wallowing in self pity and being petty over a birthday card, I think it's time to do some soul searching.

IncompleteSenten · 04/12/2023 08:33

Send her one without any expectations.

See it as a wedge to stop the door slamming shut forever.

If it's too hard then is there anyone in your life who could do it for you? If you were my friend I would do it for you in a heartbeat.

You give them the details and they send her a Moonpig card or something and you ask them to send her birthday and Christmas cards until such time as you ask them to stop.

That way you don't have to keep thinking about it and you haven't let the door get locked shut forever.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 04/12/2023 08:31

I have lived life with ‘you either love and care about me and are in my life, or you don’t and you aren’t” which means I have no contact at all with any family and never will, once a door is closed, it’s closed for good.

That is "black and white" thinking - make a decision, stick with it forever. But the real world is full of change and development. Maybe shutting the door for good feels safer to you because it is prediatable and it means nothing more bad can happen, but it also means that nothing more good can happen either.

You seem to think that she should know that bath salts are no use. But it doesn't sound as if you have been very close to each other so maybe she really doesn't know or remember all the details of your wash routine. And she sent something. Bath salts are a very generic kind of present, a present you send to someone you do not know very well. It is a symbolic present, a present with a message - "I still want some contact".

So instead of slamming doors, can you do reciprocation? You can do the same as her. Send her a card on her birthday. And a generic kind of present as well. Flowers, or nice chocolates. Follow her lead "plus one". So if she sends a card and a prsent, you send a card and present (reciprocation). If she send a thank you message for your present, you send her a thank you message for her next present (reciprocation) If she doesn't send a thank you for your present but she does send you a present on your birthday or birthday, then you can do a "plus one" by sending one thank you message in response to her present.

I wonder if some of your "thank you" messages have been repeated too many times and seemed"too much for her, and that is why she withdrew? Limiting communcation to "reciprocation" or "reciprocation plus one" can be a good strategy. Oh, and when you write a thank you message it is very important not to include any negative comment about her present. So if you couldn't use the bath salts don't say so! You don't have to lie but you don't have to say the whole truth either. Say "they smell lovely" or "such a kind thought" or something. Yes, you might get unwanted bath salts for several years to come, but if that happens there will be other ways to deal with it. The important thing is the link that you make by sending each oher cards and present.

Cards on birthdays and Christmas are fairly neutral "plus ones" that you can pretty much always do, unless she specifically asks/tells you not to.

Good luck!

ExpressionSession · 04/12/2023 08:30

There is a lot of talk on the thread about the OP seeing this from her child’s point of view. Clearly though the OP lacks this ability, like everything to do with autism inability to see others point of view is on a spectrum, my ASD daughter is excellent at theory of mind but my ASD father has absolutely no insight into other’s thinking.

I suspect that the OP is at my father’s end of the spectrum, speaking personally that was incredibly difficult to deal with as a child, it guarantees a lack of attunement which is obviously imperative for healthy childhood attachment. I adored my father growing up and I admired him beyond belief but his unwillingness to see anyone’s perspective except his own rose to emotionally abusive levels during difficult time in our family and eventually and I had to cut contact completely. He doesn’t get it either. He should have spoken to a therapist but to be honest I’m not sure it would have made a difference due to his rigid thinking.

I wish you well OP but I suspect your difficulties which are clearly breaking your own heart will break your daughter’s heart too.

This is a you problem though. It really is.

Alondra · 04/12/2023 08:25

MumNoMore · 03/12/2023 21:45

My 25yr old daughter and I reconnected 4 years ago after she chose to cut contact at 13 after her father’s and my divorce. I couldn’t have custody due to severe physical and chronic illness but it broke my heart.

I thought we had rebuilt a very good relationship with regular contact, until January when she suddenly cut me off again with no explanation or response to my messages and calls, that left me very confused and distressed since only the week before she told me how much she loved me.

She did send me a printed card from moonpig on my birthday, with a gift she knew I could not use (bath stuff..no bath) but no personal contact.
She posted across social media how much better she felt having made the decision to just focus on herself, and not have to think about anyone else.

That confused me (I’m on the spectrum) as I had always made the point of never complaining to her or asking for any help, ever, as I did not want to burden her with my health difficulties and depression which she did know about.

Its her birthday on Tuesday, and as much as I try to do the right thing, I cannot bring myself to send her even a card as I am still so very hurt and angry.

I have lived life with ‘you either love and care about me and are in my life, or you don’t and you aren’t” which means I have no contact at all with any family and never will, once a door is closed, it’s closed for good.

All the opinions seem to be to send one anyway as a good (even if unwanted) mother, to keep the door open in case she changes her mind and wants a relationship again. For me, that can never happen as I can’t forgive or trust her and risk my mental health being destroyed again.

It broke me to near suicide, and cannot spend the rest of my life anticipating for months and waiting to see if she sends a Xmas, Mother’s Day or birthday card again, reopening wounds of distress when she doesn’t respond to thank you messages I look for in the following days and weeks.

Is it selfish of me to be so protective of my unstable mental health that is already so challenged with being bedbound, depressed and alone, or does the fact she is my daughter trump all that as a priority I should put first and acknowledge as a mother?

Any opinions or advice is welcome, but you don’t have to tell me how crap I am at relationships, I am only too aware my autism makes me think and act differently that seems right to me, which is why I am reaching out.

I agree with posters saying "send the card". Sending it with a simple message, "Happy Birthday, I wish you are happy and well. I love you", tells her you are thinking of her without any expectations on your part.

My maternal grandmother had a difficult relationship with 2 of her sons. She always send cards or small gifts on their birthdays/Christmas. When her daughters reminded her how awful they were, her standard phrase was "I have 5 children, like fingers on my hand. I will never cut them off even if they give me pain".

You don't have to accept abuse, disrespect or being bullied by silence. Reminding her you love her, tells her just that. Nothing else.

NewFriendlyLadybird · 04/12/2023 08:23

Hey everyone. The red flags in the OP’s post point to her being depressed. Yes, very ‘me-centric’ because that’s what depression does.
It all sounds much more complicated than can be communicated in a single internet post.
Suddenly cutting someone off without explanation is not a nice thing to do, and parents are allowed to feel hurt and angry when their children do not treat them nicely. Endless sacrifice and sublimation of your own feelings is not good for anyone.
However, OP, she hasn’t told you she is cutting you off, nor, it seems, has she blocked you on social media. She doesn’t sound hostile, just (ironically) feeling the need to be selfish at the moment. I think you should send a Moonpig card nd get some support/ therapy for yourself.

Sallyh87 · 04/12/2023 08:19

I imagine her side of this story would be illuminating.

GetYourBaublesOut · 04/12/2023 08:15

I think your post lacks any insight at all into how your daughter is feeling - which is pretty surprising tbh.

It places the responsibility for parental contact on the shoulders of a 13 year child and then seems to hold that decision against her for the rest of her life.

It does not seem to acknowledge any fault on your part, when life is complicated and often 'both sides' have flaws and made mistakes.

But I also agree with a pp: sending a card may be the worst thing you can do, for her. It may suggest you care when nothing in your OP suggests you do. Rather, you go to pains to explain that you will never allow her to have a relationship with you again.

If she has posted that she is feeling happier without you in her life, then the kindest thing to do (for her) may be to leave her in peace.

BelindaOkra · 04/12/2023 08:12

tenbob · 03/12/2023 21:52

“I have lived life with ‘you either love and care about me and are in my life, or you don’t and you aren’t” which means I have no contact at all with any family and never will, once a door is closed, it’s closed for good.”

This jumped out at me.

If you are a full ‘my way or the highway’ person, it’s easy to see how she got to the point of having to cut contact with you.

I guess it’s up to you to decide whether you continue to live by a frankly awful set of rules, and spend the rest of your days with the consequences, or get some help to foster a healthier mindset that allows enough flexibility to allow for some sort of relationship in the future.

Yes this.

You can change your mindset. Even if it is too late for your relationship with your daughter working on the way you manage relationships gives the opportunity for better future relationships.

Viviennemary · 04/12/2023 08:09

It's hard to advise whether or not to send a card. Its obviouslg your DD is traumatised by her upbringing. I think you need to start seeing this from her point of view and the difficulties of having a mother with your problems. She was a child. Counselling would be a good idea.

tara66 · 04/12/2023 08:06

It really isn't the end of the world to send someone a birthday card and they do not say ''thank you'' . Actually it happens all the time.

awaynboilyurheid · 04/12/2023 08:06

Send a card you are the adult, and go for specialist mental health counselling zero contact with anyone in your family and the all or nothing contact approach you have will not help you in a mother daughter relationship. I am aware very rigid thinking can be an autistic trait but you can learn how to respond better to your daughter.

AshtonAshley · 04/12/2023 08:04

Send a card. Be the bigger person. Be more mature. Poor child sounds quite damaged by her teen years.

converseandjeans · 04/12/2023 08:02

Agree with @BackAgainstWall

You are her mother, you are older and are supposed to be a good role model, not some petty woman she hardly knows up the road.

You seem more concerned about your own feelings than hers. I also find it unusual that she chose to cut contact at 13. Why would she do that?

leachesleachesleachesleachesleaches · 04/12/2023 07:59

Gah, I voted wrong. YABU. Pull yourself together. I am also autistic, but presumably after 13 years of raising a child you are capable of being a parent and putting your child’s needs first when you need to.

fuzzyduck1 · 04/12/2023 07:50

By not sending a card she can use h that of proof that you don’t love her and she was right to cut ties. so it’s probably best to send one.

MargotBamborough · 04/12/2023 07:48

I'm so sorry you're going through this OP, it sounds terrible.

One thing that strikes me about your post is that you and your daughter both sound quite similar.

All this "either you love me and play a proper part in my life or you don't and we will be estranged and have no contact" stuff is quite extreme, and you both appear to be doing it.

There are a lot of people on Mumsnet who will advocate in favour of going no contact with "toxic" parents and, less frequently, "toxic" children, saying that you can't change who people are but you don't have to put up with bad treatment and you can prioritise your own mental health and wellbeing.

I think that's true to a certain extent but I also think that we are all flawed, damaged individuals and for all our faults and mistakes, most of us are really just seeking love and human connection. I think that cutting off family members, particularly our parents or our children, is a very extreme thing to do, because those people can't be replaced. Your daughter will never have another mother, you are the only one she has got, for better or for worse. And you grew and gave birth to her, no one else can replace that part she has played in your life. So for that reason, although I wouldn't say you should never go no contact with a parent or a child, I would only advise doing it in the most extreme circumstances, such as when there has been abuse.

You and your daughter sound like you are both playing the same game, i.e. taking the view that if the other person isn't willing to be the person you want and need them to be, they don't deserve to be in your life at all. I think that's very sad and you will probably both come to regret it.

So in your position I would send her a birthday card, maybe even a present, and continue to leave the door open and offer olive branches here and there, in the hope that one day you can have a better relationship. You can't control what she does, but you can control what you do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread