Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not sending my estranged daughter a birthday card?

216 replies

MumNoMore · 03/12/2023 21:45

My 25yr old daughter and I reconnected 4 years ago after she chose to cut contact at 13 after her father’s and my divorce. I couldn’t have custody due to severe physical and chronic illness but it broke my heart.

I thought we had rebuilt a very good relationship with regular contact, until January when she suddenly cut me off again with no explanation or response to my messages and calls, that left me very confused and distressed since only the week before she told me how much she loved me.

She did send me a printed card from moonpig on my birthday, with a gift she knew I could not use (bath stuff..no bath) but no personal contact.
She posted across social media how much better she felt having made the decision to just focus on herself, and not have to think about anyone else.

That confused me (I’m on the spectrum) as I had always made the point of never complaining to her or asking for any help, ever, as I did not want to burden her with my health difficulties and depression which she did know about.

Its her birthday on Tuesday, and as much as I try to do the right thing, I cannot bring myself to send her even a card as I am still so very hurt and angry.

I have lived life with ‘you either love and care about me and are in my life, or you don’t and you aren’t” which means I have no contact at all with any family and never will, once a door is closed, it’s closed for good.

All the opinions seem to be to send one anyway as a good (even if unwanted) mother, to keep the door open in case she changes her mind and wants a relationship again. For me, that can never happen as I can’t forgive or trust her and risk my mental health being destroyed again.

It broke me to near suicide, and cannot spend the rest of my life anticipating for months and waiting to see if she sends a Xmas, Mother’s Day or birthday card again, reopening wounds of distress when she doesn’t respond to thank you messages I look for in the following days and weeks.

Is it selfish of me to be so protective of my unstable mental health that is already so challenged with being bedbound, depressed and alone, or does the fact she is my daughter trump all that as a priority I should put first and acknowledge as a mother?

Any opinions or advice is welcome, but you don’t have to tell me how crap I am at relationships, I am only too aware my autism makes me think and act differently that seems right to me, which is why I am reaching out.

OP posts:
ExpressionSession · 04/12/2023 09:39

Anoisagusaris · 04/12/2023 09:33

I was estranged from my late father, my choice. The last thing I wanted was a card from him. If you love her, respect her decision.

I am estranged too and I don’t want cards but the OPs DD has sent her a card so I think she is in a different place to mine or yours.

I suspect the DD can only have a very light touch relationship due to the past and ongoing trauma the relationship causes for her.

SandyWaves · 04/12/2023 09:37

Singsonggsu · 03/12/2023 22:06

It sounds like your daughter is upset and confused too. A 13 year old won’t be able to make a deeply conscious decision about access with their parent. You are the adult and your DD is the child in this relationship even though she is technically an adult herself now.
It seems that you will always have ‘will she/wont she’ contact me anxiety around anniversaries etc with her. You can keep contact open through sending her cards etc which is what I would absolutely suggest. She may reply, she may not.
You can control what contact you make with her and how you react to her contact (or lack of) with you. But of course you cannot control what she does. Send the card. You will regret it if you don’t.

Good advice

Anoisagusaris · 04/12/2023 09:33

I was estranged from my late father, my choice. The last thing I wanted was a card from him. If you love her, respect her decision.

ArthurbellaScott · 04/12/2023 09:32

Send a card; do not expect anything in return. The differential in a parent/child relationship is not equal, nor is it reciprocal.

Your mental health and wellbeing cannot be dependent on someone else's responses. That is unfair on both you and her.

You need to be what you call 'selfish', in that you need to attend to your mental health - not by demanding someone else act a certain way, but by attending to your own inner world and needs. That's not an easy task but it's your task.

It sounds like you really need some support and help. If you're in England or Wales, you can self refer through the NHS. There are many things to try - medication, meditation, counselling, therapy, exercise (yes even when bedbound), spirituality/religion, creativity, nutrition, etc. Keep trying. Just keep going. Expect setbacks and dead ends and occasional failures as part of the process. Your life is your life's task.

Once you feel on a stronger footing yourself then perhaps you will be better able to offer your daughter the steady, reassuring presence she needs.

It's not easy, OP. Life can be very difficult and there is much we can't control. But we can control our responses to situations, we can learn to frame things differently, we can learn to both accept what we can't change, and work at the things we can change to improve them. Sending you my best. Flowers

mrboombasticwhy · 04/12/2023 09:30

Send one

mindutopia · 04/12/2023 09:29

She sent you a card and present, so I’d say she is open to the sort of relationship where you keep in touch with cards. So I would send her a card unless she has explicitly asked you not to.

I have no relationship with my mum and have explicitly asked her never to contact me again. I see cards as harassment at this point. But she hasn’t asked you never to contact her again. Interestingly, my mum also has no relationship with any of her family and her partner is largely the same (his dc and grandchildren are NC). In these sorts of situations, there is a common denominator and it isn’t the children and grandchildren. 🙄

That said, you’ve made this all about you and what you need and your pain, and said very little about what your dd has been put through having a parent who couldn’t care for them and hasn’t been present in her life due to mental illness and other issues. I can understand why she would focus on the people in her life who have been there for her, for reasons similar to why you have cut off your family. These cycles repeat themselves until someone is brave enough to take a stand and put a stop to them.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 04/12/2023 09:29

I'm estranged from my mother, in large part because I spent much of my childhood having to be her mother, because of her mental health problems and addiction.

She has never sent me a word since. That is (irrationally, I know) sometimes difficult for me, because it's clear that she's estranged me right back. But I prefer it that way to her sending cards or whatever and reminding me of what I worked so hard to escape.

There's no easy answer here, but people do not estrange themselves from their parents for no reason. I'd be inclined to say don't send the card, but in doing so you may reinforce in her mind that once people are cut off from you, that's it.

JenniferJupiterVenusandMars · 04/12/2023 09:27

AshtonAshley · 04/12/2023 08:04

Send a card. Be the bigger person. Be more mature. Poor child sounds quite damaged by her teen years.

I would send one too.
It’s very telling when you say I have lived life with ‘you either love and care about me and are in my life, or you don’t and you aren’t” which means I have no contact at all with any family and never will, once a door is closed, it’s closed for good
That really sounds brutal.
I would be interested to hear your DD’s side of the story, I imagine she’s been through some very traumatic and difficult experiences since her early childhood.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 04/12/2023 09:26

I’m incredibly low contact with my parents.
I send them birthday presents and cards

I get a card occasionally

it fucking hurts.

my psychiatrist said not to send them anything. But I have to do the “right” thing for my own peace.

send the card, your the grown up, her feelings will be the 13 year old. You know all those complicated feeling am you have about her not sending you something. She will feel them too, you can ease that for your daughter, even if she doesn’t for you.

Pr1mr0se · 04/12/2023 09:25

Send her a card. Don't over think it. If she sends one to you then great. Keep sending the cards to keep communication open.

There maybe many reasons why she can't or won't send a card back or be in touch but you do your thing. Remember even though she's 25 you are the parent in this relationship, she is the child.

Send her a card for Christmas too if you want too.

Alondra · 04/12/2023 09:19

pizzaHeart · 04/12/2023 08:57

I don’t think it works like this, you’ve reached 25 and you understand ASD now, it’s more complicated than that. And you can understand but dealing with it might be too much for you.

That's not what I said. Her daughter has probably been dealing with her moms "oddness" for a long time. But the difference between being a child and adult is having the cognitive resources and emotional experience to recognise her mother isn't just odd, unable to communicate effectively or being emotionally in sync. Her mother has a disability that impacts how she perceives her own world and impacts all people around her.

People on the spectrum are the most genuine, sincere and loyal people I've ever met. It's not easy dealing with them, their disability needs to be understood for families to have a good relationship. It takes time but it begins with the people around them, their parents, their children, their spouse really understanding the spectrum, caring for them and how to communicate effectively.

Clytherow · 04/12/2023 09:11

Sausage1989 · 04/12/2023 06:41

You sounds very me me me. I'm pretty sure at 13 (a child!!!) It wasn't her fault that she cut contact with you..how does a child even cut contact with a parent..as a parent you just don't let that happen, surely?!?!?

Sometimes there isn't a choice. I know children whose parents divorced who were told a pack of lies by their other parent (of either sex) which then affected their relationship for many years. If a teenager doesn't want to talk to you there is a limit to what you can do to force them to.

FiveShelties · 04/12/2023 09:08

I would send her a card. The regrets I have in life are about the things I have not done and cannot change.

ExpressionSession · 04/12/2023 09:08

I completely disagree with you that it's the OP's problem. She can't change who she is and her black and white thinking. Her daughter is 25, an adult and, I understand, neurotypical. She is not a kid and should be able to understand, by now, how the spectrum affects her loved ones.

I think we will have to agree to disagree on that one. My father’s ASD did not just affect him it affected all of us children too. We adored him and made allowances left, right and centre for him as you should with people you love but his behaviour deeply affected my childhood and my childhood development. The story of our estrangement is for another thread.

As parents we work on black and white thinking with my DD all the time. We have taken her to an excellent therapist and she has developed much better skills in this area. The OP could open herself up to that experience too, as an adult she has that choice, but she gets safety and certainty out of choosing to extricate herself from difficult unmanageable relationships.

Clytherow · 04/12/2023 09:07

Why do people always automatically assume that if an adult child cuts contact with their parent it's always the parent's fault?

And no, I am not in this situation in either direction so not projecting.

I get that you do get damaging, narc parents but damaging, narc adult children also exist.

Wherearemykeysagain · 04/12/2023 09:04

PS if it helps from an autistic point of view… the absolute rule for parents to their child is unconditional love. Your daughter doesn’t have to earn it and can’t lose it for poor behaviour. That’s what she needs from you. If you haven’t given her that then she will feel aggrieved with you because you have broken a key parent code. She will be nursing some very deep wounds that may never fully heal. All you can do now is be consistent in your unconditional love.

Zonder · 04/12/2023 09:02

Alondra · 04/12/2023 08:47

I agree. Most people on the thread have no idea about being on the spectrum and how to tailor their responses to an autistic person.

I completely disagree with you that it's the OP's problem. She can't change who she is and her black and white thinking. Her daughter is 25, an adult and, I understand, neurotypical. She is not a kid and should be able to understand, by now, how the spectrum affects her loved ones.

She can't change who she is but she can learn to change her behaviour. It would be crazy to think that just because someone has autism they can't learn how to improve things socially.

waterrat · 04/12/2023 09:00

Hi Op my daughter is austistic so I understand you may struggle to understand why you should reach out to someone who has upset you

Would it help to remember that in a parent / child relationship - the care from parent to child is unconditional - that is the role of a parent. You continue to give, to support to offer love - even if the child is dfificult.

When it comes to your feelings - they come second to your role as parent.

Your daughter was a young child when she cut contact with you - that is not something you should be holding against her at all. 13 year olds do not have the same developed mind as an adult - she will have been hurting iwth a child's level of understanding.

CiaraLiara · 04/12/2023 08:59

Those of you saying the daughter is an adult now, do bear in mind that the trauma she has gone through as a child would have delayed her development, and she probably has a lot of ground to cover. Both mother and daughter need counselling separately and together.

Wherearemykeysagain · 04/12/2023 08:59

I can’t pretend to understand the ins and outs of your relationship. But my child will always have an open door, however hard that may be. It’s part of being a mum. You forgive first and you forgive longest and hardest. This is your child.

Chocolatepeanutbuttercupsandicecream · 04/12/2023 08:57

I have a fractured relationship with my similar age daughter (long story, and someone else’s thread isn’t the place to share it). I always send a card and a small gift (money, gift voucher, chocolates type thing). Sometimes it is acknowledged or not, but I do it because she’s my child, I love her, and it’s the right thing to do. Of course it hurts, but counselling has helped, I take responsibility for my past actions, and I accept that I have no control over hers, only my own in the present. I really hope you can heal OP, but it needs to be for your own self, not with expectations on her.

pizzaHeart · 04/12/2023 08:57

Alondra · 04/12/2023 08:47

I agree. Most people on the thread have no idea about being on the spectrum and how to tailor their responses to an autistic person.

I completely disagree with you that it's the OP's problem. She can't change who she is and her black and white thinking. Her daughter is 25, an adult and, I understand, neurotypical. She is not a kid and should be able to understand, by now, how the spectrum affects her loved ones.

I don’t think it works like this, you’ve reached 25 and you understand ASD now, it’s more complicated than that. And you can understand but dealing with it might be too much for you.

zurala · 04/12/2023 08:56

tenbob · 03/12/2023 21:52

“I have lived life with ‘you either love and care about me and are in my life, or you don’t and you aren’t” which means I have no contact at all with any family and never will, once a door is closed, it’s closed for good.”

This jumped out at me.

If you are a full ‘my way or the highway’ person, it’s easy to see how she got to the point of having to cut contact with you.

I guess it’s up to you to decide whether you continue to live by a frankly awful set of rules, and spend the rest of your days with the consequences, or get some help to foster a healthier mindset that allows enough flexibility to allow for some sort of relationship in the future.

OP I'm also autistic and I agree with this reply. I know we tend to be very black and white about things but if you can try and find the shades of grey life will be easier. I recommend counselling, it's really great and helpful.

I would send the card, because cutting yourself off from everyone isn't healthy or helpful for you. Surely all your family can't be so awful? But also, sending a card keeps your options open.

But please get therapy for your mental health. You deserve to be well.

CiaraLiara · 04/12/2023 08:55

Send a card.

Bernardmanning · 04/12/2023 08:54

Unfortunately I don't think that you can be the mother that your daughter needs. She wants someone who reassures and nurtures her. It sounds like your relationship put too much pressure on her. Perhaps she worried about you or seeing you vulnerable with poor mental health impacted her health. I grew up with a vulnerable parent and it did feel like a burden upon my shoulders.

What concerns me is your approach to dealing with relationships. You think that your cutting off people approach serves you well, but it actually doesn't. I have a sister who uses the same approach and it has unfortunately contributed to the decline of her mental and physical health. She has become very isolated. She has never learned to resolve issues. She has put up huge flimsy defences. It's not helped her mental health at all. Life is not black and white, but many shades of shifting grey that change as often as the clouds in the sky. Sometimes, for whatever reason, relationships are better than others. They can shift and change patterns.

I think that you should send her a card. Don't put too much pressure on her. Keep it happy and breezy so that she doesn't feel guilty or bad to receive it. If you cut her off, then you will always deny yourself that happiness of building a relationship again in the future. That won't do your mental health any good either. Instead, send it and a nice gift. Send her a Christmas card. Wish her well. Tell her something positive and upbeat about your life, even if not entirely true, so that she doesn't worry about you. Don't expect a response. And seek help for your mental health issues and a lot of support instead, including how to deal with relationships in a better and less black and white way. I think that you should seek CBT to help with this as your distorted thinking is impacting your relationship with others and causing you distress.