Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want DSIL's cat locked in room away from DC

438 replies

onesleepyma · 03/12/2023 21:16

My DSIL has no kids but she does have a cat, who is her absolute world. Because the cat is a rescue he can't be locked in a room due to his previous trauma (I think?) so always needs to be roaming free in the house. The cat also, from the times I've visited, seems quite reluctant to be touched, can hiss if you come too near. Quite an unfriendly cat. Also a very fluffy cat.

For Xmas we are all going to my ILs house, me, my 2 DC, DH, DSIL and the cat. My kids are 11 months and 2.5. DC1 isn't always going to listen to instructions like "don't touch the cat" or "don't come near the cat" and DC2 is newly walking, leans on furniture when walking so there's a HIGH chance that one of the DCs will be hissed at or worse scratched by this cat. The only way to avoid it is to be 24/7 watching, not sit down for a minute for me and DH. DSIL says leaving him at home isnt an option because " the cat to her is what my DC are to me" (her words). locking him in a room, even for just xmas dinner so i can eat, is "cruel". The parents wont address it because DSIL is sad that shes single and this kitten is making her happy so they dont want to disturb that.

we are there for 2 full days, 3 nights. DH wont address it for similar reasons that PIL wont.

OP posts:
spiderlight · 04/12/2023 17:06

Being carted off to a strange house is going to be massively stressful for a nervous rescue cat. If she cares about its welfare, your SIL would be far better off finding a friend or neighbour to pop in and feed/keep it company at home for the duration.

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 04/12/2023 16:56

If the cat is reluctant to be touched like you say then it will more than likely avoid your DC anyway. Plus keeping an eye on them 24/7 when in a new environment is normal anyway I’d say.

YABU to suggest she locks the cat away just so you can then not have to watch your DC, you are aware of the reasons for this not being an option so yes it would be cruel.

I think you’re overthinking this; the cat will no doubt steer clear of young children so as long as your DC aren’t allowed to chase/corner it then it should be fine to just keep an eye out.

sheeplikessleep · 04/12/2023 16:30

Darknessoldfriend · 04/12/2023 16:26

I’m sorry but you can’t compare a German Shepherd to a cat! A dog could kill a child for a start.

I wasn’t saying exactly the same. Just saying dynamics of pets versus family visiting are the same. I’m also not asking my SIL to get rid of their dog. I’m asking her can we organise a meet up somewhere else for lunch and been honest as to why and even this has massively offended.

ExtraOnions · 04/12/2023 16:28

What’s the bet that the cat dashes through the first open door / window it sees, and you all spend the best part of Christmas Day hunting the streets for it

Darknessoldfriend · 04/12/2023 16:26

sheeplikessleep · 04/12/2023 13:17

Similar situation here but with my SILs 2/3 year old German shepherd who is still mouthing and wouldn’t leave my DSs alone last Christmas. I’ve caused WW3 by asking to meet up for lunch rather than at their home and SIL has taken it very personally.

Im sorry it’s turned sour, but no way was I going to experience what happened last Christmas and just be constantly hounded by an under exercised massive dog who mouths hands and arms still.

I’m sorry but you can’t compare a German Shepherd to a cat! A dog could kill a child for a start.

GreatGardenstuff · 04/12/2023 16:21

SIL should leave the cat at home, it will be much happier in it’s own environment than carted to a strange house with a load of strange people.

I also think you’re over estimating the risk to your DC from the cat. A hiss should be a warning they quickly learn to respect. And it might want to dominate its own territory at home when you visit, but will most likely lurk in your IL’s place with all the noise and folk about.

SwishSwishBisch · 04/12/2023 16:00

onesleepyma · 04/12/2023 15:03

I'm not saying out of sight, I'm saying playing in the same room but without me having to be at arms length from them at all times. Ie I'd be able to eat whilst the baby plays with blocks on the floor

I don’t think you know very much about cats OP 😂
Oh well. Enjoy the pointless argument and bad feeling you’re about to start with your family I guess. Merry Christmas!

sheeplikessleep · 04/12/2023 15:26

DangerousAlchemy · 04/12/2023 15:03

My friend's youngish Rottweiler is like this (still) @sheeplikessleep I find it unsettling when I visit her & I'm a grown woman who used to be a vet nurse 🤣 people forget how small children are & how big some breeds of dog are i think! I also dont want someone's dog jumping all over me & covering me with slobber tbh. Dogs can be so needy it gets on my nerves when they arent trained properly or shut away if they can't behave when guests are over.

Yes and my SIL is now refusing to talk to me after suggesting we go out for lunch and seems to think I have a fear of dogs (I don’t, just their German shepherd and not being able to stop him putting his jaws around my DSs hands and arms 🙈🤷‍♀️). Absolute insanity that I’ve now massively offended her.
Love my cats, but totally appreciate they are our cats and friends / family may feel very different!)

thing47 · 04/12/2023 15:14

Absolutely bonkers carting cats to other people's houses, most of them would hate that. Mine have an electronic cat flap and a controlled food provider, I can safely leave them for a couple of days - the only exception being if we'd had a dry spell and I was worried about their chances of finding water, but that's not usually a concern in England!

I don't wholly agree with those saying the cat will hide, though. Of my current two, one would definitely hide, either on or under a bed, but the other is inherently nosy (I think he has FOMO) and will wind himself in and out of strangers legs, follow them to the toilet, sit on them at the first opportunity and miaow if he doesn't think he is receiving enough attention etc.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 04/12/2023 15:04

They just shouldn’t be moving the cat, having a competition about whether the cat being locked up or the toddler being possibly hissed at is pointless. Keeping cats in single rooms when they’re moved is standard practice, but they should be getting a good sitter and not upending the cat’s life for this. Cats are generally reactively dangerous (ie if a toddler pulls their tail, they will get scratched) whereas dogs can be dangerous even by just being friendly - a 45-kilo pit bull could be the nicest being in the universe and still push a toddler over. If the cat is in its house it won’t be happy to be confined indoors but it’s going to live. It’s hissing to protect both itself and the toddler - in Cat that’s basically “I’m feeling threatened, please go no further” to a human. IMO the cat should be locked up but with all mod cons - favourite toy, loads of food, litter tray, both for the sake of th toddler and cat. Easier for everyone.

onesleepyma · 04/12/2023 15:03

meganorks · 04/12/2023 13:59

YABU. That cat will be getting as far away from your kids as possible! And at that age, you do need to make sure someone has an eye on the kids at all times. It doesn't mean you won't be able to sit down, but they shouldn't be out of sight for more than a minute.

I'm not saying out of sight, I'm saying playing in the same room but without me having to be at arms length from them at all times. Ie I'd be able to eat whilst the baby plays with blocks on the floor

OP posts:
DangerousAlchemy · 04/12/2023 15:03

sheeplikessleep · 04/12/2023 13:17

Similar situation here but with my SILs 2/3 year old German shepherd who is still mouthing and wouldn’t leave my DSs alone last Christmas. I’ve caused WW3 by asking to meet up for lunch rather than at their home and SIL has taken it very personally.

Im sorry it’s turned sour, but no way was I going to experience what happened last Christmas and just be constantly hounded by an under exercised massive dog who mouths hands and arms still.

My friend's youngish Rottweiler is like this (still) @sheeplikessleep I find it unsettling when I visit her & I'm a grown woman who used to be a vet nurse 🤣 people forget how small children are & how big some breeds of dog are i think! I also dont want someone's dog jumping all over me & covering me with slobber tbh. Dogs can be so needy it gets on my nerves when they arent trained properly or shut away if they can't behave when guests are over.

PissOffJeffrey · 04/12/2023 14:58

Totally agree that SIL should not be taking the cat with her. Any cat would feel unsettled & nervy in a strange house with extra people, let alone a cat with past trauma.

SIL needs to leave him at home for the day & either go home herself later that night or get one of the automatic pet feeders which are perfectly fine for a couple of days.

DangerousAlchemy · 04/12/2023 14:56

Pippik · 03/12/2023 21:30

If the cat is not in it's own home I imagine it will feel safer locked in a room anyway. Most rooms are significantly bigger than a cattery "room".
It's a cat, it will survive. Babies and toddlers come first and if it was my cat I would not risk a child being swiped, scratched or bitten.
We have a cat visiting us at Christmas, it will be shut in a room throughout with food and water and a warm bed. That's really all a cat needs.

100% this @Pippik i foster cats & they feel more secure in a smaller room for the first few days while they adjust to a new house. Safer anyway in case a front or back door is left open & the cat escapes or someone opens a steamy kitchen window & the scared cat does a runner. A cat who hisses a lot feels threatened & shouldn't be free-roaming round a strange house during such a busy time anyway. Madness

Ohnoooooooo · 04/12/2023 14:46

I am very big on animal safety around kids but I am sorry I suspect you are annoyed that your hubby's family give so much credit to this cat. One minute you are saying this cat is unfriendly "seems quite reluctant to be touched, can hiss if you come too near" and the next minute you are implying the cat is going to be close to a noisy toddler and you need to be at arm's length. If a cat is unfriendly they are not going to be going near your children. If your children are going near the cat the cat can get away must faster than a toddler. According to you, your 11 month old leans on furniture to walk - not exactly going to catch up with a cat even with the best will in the world. If you are sitting down for lunch I am guessing your kids are sitting down too. A cat hissing at your kids while unpleasant won't harm them - its the risk of them being scratch and I really can't see how a cat you describe as being unfriendly is not going to hiss first before any child gets a chance to risk petting them and being scratched.

Luxell934 · 04/12/2023 14:39

Sonolanona · 03/12/2023 21:48

Dramatic much?
I love cats, and dogs..and yes, toddlers too, so no agenda.
I wouldn't take my nervous rescue cat to someone else's house for Xmas.. it would be torture for my cat. Can't she leave it at home where it's comfortable if it's only for a night or two.. litter tray, enough kibble? I would get a neighbour in to feed if longer than that .

If the poor creature has to come it will hide...it'll be more likely hiding under a bed than stalking your kids. Seriously. Worse case scenario, you don't keep an eye on the man eating beast and it hisses... not really a big deal and the children will soon leave it be.

You are being absolutely ridiculous.

This.

Whilst the best place for the cat is to be left at home in it's safe space, I really don't see the big issue with it being in the house. It won't want to be anywhere near your little darlings. Presumably at least one adult will be watching them at all times anyway?

MissingMoominMamma · 04/12/2023 14:38

CatInCardboardPalace · 04/12/2023 13:39

Yes OP. Just tell your baby not to go near the cat - I'm sure they'll understand 😂.

I don't think the cat is as much of a hazard as you think it is, but I completely disagree with people who think you can never relax with young children. There are degrees of relaxation. I would never let my DC at those ages out of my sight, but there's supervising from the sofa (which you can do in a fairly child-safe house) and intervening when you see danger, and then there's what I call "swimming-pool" levels of supervision - hovering within arm's length of the child the whole time ready to scoop them up, get in between them and danger or bat their hand away in an instant.

I would always supervise my children in someone else's house, but I'm afraid my limit for "swimming-pool" supervision is a couple of hours as it's too exhausting. My in-laws used to live in a house with multiple levels with steep steps in between, hard flagstone floors, stone stairs with slippy carpets and lots of "stuff". When DC were tiny, I used to retreat to our carpeted room with some toys and barricade the door after a while, or take them out somewhere, as that house was just an accident waiting to happen and I'd have to strap the DC into the pushchair to go to the loo.

How do you all manage to keep your kids away from danger if you can’t keep them away from a cat that won’t want to be anywhere near them anyway?

Mynewnameis · 04/12/2023 14:29

Kinder for the cat to stay home. Poor thing

Cordychase · 04/12/2023 14:26

DSIL is being unreasonable, she should put the cat in a cattery or have a neighbour pop in and feed while she is gone. The cat will be far more stressed in someone else's house with unfamiliar sounds and smells. Seems to me she is doing this for herself and not the cat.

Bertielong3 · 04/12/2023 14:15

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Kittynoodle · 04/12/2023 14:14

Of goodness that poor cat!!
it’s a great opportunity to teach kids to be kind and respect animals

fliptopbin · 04/12/2023 14:04

This is really not as much of an issue as you think. Any time I have taken a cat to a new location it has spent the first few days hiding under a bed. You will probably not see grumpy cat at all.

LoobyDop · 04/12/2023 13:59

Just re-read and seen that it’s not the cat’s home. Cats are not like dogs or children, you can’t cart them around visiting with you. Your SiL is mad and not a good cat owner.

meganorks · 04/12/2023 13:59

YABU. That cat will be getting as far away from your kids as possible! And at that age, you do need to make sure someone has an eye on the kids at all times. It doesn't mean you won't be able to sit down, but they shouldn't be out of sight for more than a minute.

LoobyDop · 04/12/2023 13:57

Well, you can’t go, can you. It’s not reasonable to expect that the cat should be confined to one room for three days, it’s not realistic to expect that your small children won’t chase it, and you can’t leave them at home alone for three days. Therefore the cat and the children can’t be in the same house. Just explain that reasonably, and make it clear that you aren’t trying to manipulate anyone or suggest that anyone’s being unreasonable.