Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want DSIL's cat locked in room away from DC

438 replies

onesleepyma · 03/12/2023 21:16

My DSIL has no kids but she does have a cat, who is her absolute world. Because the cat is a rescue he can't be locked in a room due to his previous trauma (I think?) so always needs to be roaming free in the house. The cat also, from the times I've visited, seems quite reluctant to be touched, can hiss if you come too near. Quite an unfriendly cat. Also a very fluffy cat.

For Xmas we are all going to my ILs house, me, my 2 DC, DH, DSIL and the cat. My kids are 11 months and 2.5. DC1 isn't always going to listen to instructions like "don't touch the cat" or "don't come near the cat" and DC2 is newly walking, leans on furniture when walking so there's a HIGH chance that one of the DCs will be hissed at or worse scratched by this cat. The only way to avoid it is to be 24/7 watching, not sit down for a minute for me and DH. DSIL says leaving him at home isnt an option because " the cat to her is what my DC are to me" (her words). locking him in a room, even for just xmas dinner so i can eat, is "cruel". The parents wont address it because DSIL is sad that shes single and this kitten is making her happy so they dont want to disturb that.

we are there for 2 full days, 3 nights. DH wont address it for similar reasons that PIL wont.

OP posts:
kairi1 · 06/12/2023 00:13

lochmaree · 05/12/2023 23:18

"her feelings are just as strong"

I disagree, I dont think someone can have the same level of feeling for their pet cat as parents do for their child/ren. I also don't think it's necessary to try and force a comparison, a cat is a cat and a child is a child and we should honour each and the relationships with each as incomparable things.

SIL has herself said she considers her feelings equivalent. We idealise our relationship with children but there is no reason why a person can’t have that level of attachment to an animal and I know many people who experience this. OP is not obliged to spend their Christmas in an environment they feel uncomfortable in, and they should absolutely do what feels best for them, but creating a hierarchy between their feelings and that of the SIL disrespects the family she has created with her cat.

allmyliesaretrue · 05/12/2023 23:24

I feel sorry for the cat tbh. They don't like to be taken away from their familiar environment. SIL is unreasonable for doing that to the cat. I took my kitties many years ago to vist 'granny and grandad' once and it did not go well!!!! No kids involved.

My cats weren't used to young children then either but when my cousin's DH approached one of them, and she wasn't happy, she smacked but retracted her claws.

You're just going to have to manage the interaction to avoid arguments. There's two of you, two PILs and two children - should be manageable. I think though the cat will avoid you all. Hissing at your kids won't do them any harm, and even a scratch doesn't tend to be life-threatening. I'd be inclined to contain your children in a high chair and in a playpen over dinner so that everyone gets to eat in peace.

For the future - maybe get your own cat so your children learn how to handle one and be gentle with it. It's so good for kids to have a pet, teaches them empathy.

lochmaree · 05/12/2023 23:18

"her feelings are just as strong"

I disagree, I dont think someone can have the same level of feeling for their pet cat as parents do for their child/ren. I also don't think it's necessary to try and force a comparison, a cat is a cat and a child is a child and we should honour each and the relationships with each as incomparable things.

AdultLounge · 05/12/2023 23:12

Sorry my opinion has changed! It's not your SIL's house? She's batshit crazy and needs to leave her cat at home.

AdultLounge · 05/12/2023 23:10

AlltheFs · 03/12/2023 21:26

Your kids won’t die from being hissed at or scratched. The cat will likely hide from you all. But you are being absolutely ridiculous to think someone should lock their pet away. Get a bloody grip woman. Your kids need to learn how to behave around animals.

My DD learnt very quickly what is ok and what isn’t.

This!

One scratch from the cat and your kids will learn to stay away.

My dogs stay as far away from my cats as possible! They learnt the hard way!

kairi1 · 05/12/2023 22:14

I have both cats and a child and I think you should respect that this is your SILs family in the way she has chosen to define it. It may not be your idea of family but it is hers and her feelings are just as strong. Plenty of people find children difficult and would rather their parents left them at home but how would you feel if your family told you that you had to leave your children with a babysitter over Christmas?

Forget that this is a cat. What if it were another child that was liable to outbursts and might scratch or bite your children? You couldn’t lock a child in a room so how would you respond then? Perhaps you’d rather not go, or you’d expect the parent to control them or you’d put measures in place. Whatever that answer is, it should be the same here.

NoCloudsAllowed · 05/12/2023 21:35

Doone22 · 04/12/2023 21:42

FfS it's a cat! Just ignore it, they'll get scratches and learn to leave it alone. No one will die.

Cat bites and scratches are quite likely to become infected, they carry a lot of bacteria and it can be nasty. With an 11 month old I wouldn't be blase about it.

However cat is most likely to cower upstairs shitting on your beds to express it's distress while you have a massive argument downstairs once you're two drinks in.

OP's relationship with SIL sounds like a Christmas blow up waiting to happen.

Mamabearandcubs · 05/12/2023 21:33

Would your 2.5 year old not be able to follow instructions of not to go near the cat because it might scratch/bite you. I have a 2.5 yo and I know they would understand this. The 11 month old you will just have to watch and turn them away if she heads towards him, but surely you should be watching 24/7 anyway to make sure doesn’t put things in mouth/ fall etc.

HarrietSchulenberg · 05/12/2023 21:24

There are not many cats that will happily be in a room with toddlers. If the cat is having free range of the house it will take itself off somewhere quiet. If it's not in its own house I'd be more concerned about what your SIL is planning to do about toileting it on the day. Is she parking a litter tray in the kitchen?

Phoenixfire1988 · 05/12/2023 21:01

PersonWithInternalGonads · 04/12/2023 19:58

The cat is going to be terrified of being in a new house, i don't think you'll see much of it.

My dad's got a cat that I've only seen running away at pace from me. He says she 'doesn't like kids' but I'm knocking 50.

Absolutely hilarious 😂

Elfontheshmelf · 05/12/2023 20:58

I haven't read the whole thread but read op's updates.
there's a risk that a window or door will be opened and the cat will run away and get lost. So I'd suggest that she needs to try and keep it in her room for it's own safety in case it tries to run away from your children and winds up outside in an unfamiliar area.

Phoenixfire1988 · 05/12/2023 20:57

The cat will likely hide away and honestly it's a good teaching moment on how to behave around animals I've always had pets and my DC learn very early on how to interact with the pets appropriately and I'd assume at the ages they are you will be watching the kids 24/7 anyway , unless you're one of those nightmare parents that let the kids run wild and assume everyone else will chase after them

SisterBethina · 05/12/2023 20:57

gannett · 04/12/2023 09:09

I remember that thread. Nasty thread it was. There are definitely similarities in how the OP writes.

Ah I see I’m not the only one that picked up on that. The writing is very similar, very cruel. Op was salivating at the prospect of rubbing it in her sil’s face that op has human children while her childless sil only had a cat!

SisterBethina · 05/12/2023 20:48

Are you the same OP who wanted to complain to your sil to stop comparing her experience with her cat to yours with your kids?

The sil who wants kids but can’t have them so treats her cat like it’s part of her family?

milkywinterdisorder · 05/12/2023 20:40

TBH, OP, more than anything it comes across that you’re miffed about having to keep an eye on your kids. When my kids were that age I’d have been more worried about them upsetting the cat with their over-enthusiasm (they LOVE animals) than them being hissed at - I’d be keeping a very close eye on them for that reason and I absolutely wouldn’t resent the cat’s owner for forcing me to watch what my kids were doing when I should be doing that anyway. (And I’m a bit baffled that you think there’s anything for your DH or your PIL to be “addressing” here other than the fact that I can’t imagine the cat will particularly enjoy being in a strange house.)

Steffy85 · 05/12/2023 20:17

It's not the cats home, sil is taking cat to the parent in laws house for Xmas

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 05/12/2023 16:20

Then the cat’s much more likely to be cowering under a bed the whole time.

keye · 05/12/2023 14:59

@NoThanksymm

but totally unreasonable to ask someone to lock up their car in their own home because you won’t be keeping a close enough eye on your kids.

It's even not the cats home

NoThanksymm · 05/12/2023 14:56

cat will probably avoid the kids.

but totally unreasonable to ask someone to lock up their car in their own home because you won’t be keeping a close enough eye on your kids.

OneTC · 05/12/2023 14:51

It's a bloody cat just chill out

Whyamiherenow · 05/12/2023 14:38

It is hard. We have a cat and a 17 month old. Cat is 11. Also a rescue cat. I have a cousin who is scared of cats because they walk strangely (apparently). I too refused to shut the cat away. When I was pregnant. I didn’t know if the cat would be good with the baby or not. As it is. The cat is fine with the baby, not hissing etc. although there have still been small incidents. The odd scratch and bite - to be honest going both ways between the cat and the baby.

They have reached a mutual understanding and respect. The baby knows he can go so far with the cat and no further. Has learned boundaries etc.

We tend to just leave them to sort themselves out. For toddlers the odd bump and scrape is just part of life.

I don’t think it’s unreasonable to leave the cat to roam free and for children to learn boundaries and face consequences. Cats don’t tend to inflict any great injury before anybody thinks I’m advocating injuring children.

CaptainMyCaptain · 05/12/2023 13:51

Our cat used to disappear when our grandchildren came round and the children were told to leave it alone. One day the youngest (about 6) was sitting on the sofa and the cat came and sat on his lap. I told him the cat had decided he was grown up and sensible now and it was a great compliment. Children need to learn to behave around animals. A cat is not likely to attack unless it is provoked. It isn't a question of whether cats or children are more important.

Isometimeswonder · 05/12/2023 12:16

It's a cat not a starving Sabre tooth tiger looking for a meal.
The cat will hide.
And your kids need learn how to be respectful around animals.
And you need to be nicer to your SIL.

cockadoodledandy · 05/12/2023 11:44

YABU. This is a perfect opportunity to teach your children how we behave around animals. We have had animals since before my daughter was born and it’s one of the first things you teach them, to keep everyone safe.

Mumof2girls2121 · 05/12/2023 07:41

Cats tend to hide from toddlers, you’ll probably find he secures himself a warm area hidden away from them!

Swipe left for the next trending thread