Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want to keep our dog away from us on Christmas Day?

643 replies

Buddytheboxer · 03/12/2023 18:28

We have a 4 year old Boxer dog who is very much part of our family. We don’t have children yet and both WFH so he is with us all the time. He’s lovely and absolutely no bother, everyone loves him.

We are hosting Christmas Day this year, both sets of parents, my sister and her partner and DH’s brother and his girlfriend.

DH’s brother and gf recently moved back to the UK after living in Australia for the last 10 years so we haven’t seen them in person for a long time, but have FaceTimed and WhatsApped regularly. Earlier today he messaged me (not sure why me and not DH or both of us) and asked if our dog could stay with friends over Christmas, or if we could book him in at a kennels, as his gf is wary of dogs. They are supposed to be staying with us for 3 nights. They have seen our dog loads of times via FaceTime, they address Christmas cards to us and the dog etc and have never mentioned this wariness.

I’m swinging between feeling a bit miffed at the request but also not wanting her to feel nervous or uncomfortable, I like her and was looking forward to seeing them after so long. However there is no way I could send our dog away at Christmas. He’s not ‘just a dog’ we adore him and he is our family.

I haven’t had chance to speak to DH yet as he’s travelling home from a work trip and won’t be home until late. I haven’t replied to the message yet as I really don’t know what to say, it’s a bit of a lose lose situation:

a) If we don’t send our dog away BIL and gf might decide not to come which would be a shame, especially for DH and his parents. It would seem that we are putting our dog before BIL and gf which I guess we would be, but as I said he is our family.

b) If we do find somewhere for him to go (unlikely, as everyone who would normally dog sit on the rare occasions we’ve needed it will be at ours, and he’s never been in kennels so I definitely wouldn’t do that) it doesn’t feel right for him not to be with us over Christmas, it’s unfair on him and us, and a very big ask for anyone to look after a dog over Christmas.

c) If they accept we can’t send him away and still come, I’ll be on tenterhooks the whole time worrying that she is feeling uncomfortable and trying to make sure he stays out of her way (he is not a nuisance dog, he loves a fuss but isn’t ‘in your face’) it won’t be a relaxing time.

I feel like this request has really put a downer on things. AIBU to not want our dog to be sent away to accommodate BIL’s gf’s ‘wariness’?

OP posts:
Pigsinpainauchocolat · 06/12/2023 14:10

@Anisette food and flowers are much easier requests to accommodate than removing a much loved pet with emotions and feelings of its own. Obviously.

Pigsinpainauchocolat · 06/12/2023 14:01

@CouchCat another idiotic reply. No the dog doesn't know it's Christmas Hmm but the OP does and wants her dog where he belongs - in her home!!! The celebrations wouldn't be the same for her without her dog.

Plus it can be deeply distressing to dogs who have never been kennelled to be put in a strange place away from their family without any idea why or when they will return. Many dogs stop eating and lose weight. I wouldn't be able to relax and enjoy a holiday knowing my dog was miserable and stressed somewhere else.

And if you read the OP properly, the DB and gf have now moved back to the U.K. so there will plenty more opportunities to see them anyway.

Pigsinpainauchocolat · 06/12/2023 13:50

HayleyDD73 · 04/12/2023 19:55

Mine, too.

It's interesting that nothing has been said by them before? Why not?

Just tell them that all kennels are full up, some of the doggy-friendly neighbours and friends are away, and the dog has nowhere else to go. Your dog is your family: the BIL and gf have only just applied to move back to the UK from Oz - you owe them no reason, really.

I don't see any reason at all to do the white lie thing about the kennels - or that will set an expectation that they WILL put him into kennels for next year or another occasion.

Much better to just say Buddy stays here, and find a solution - like they have done as OP has updated. Good solution OP! How kind of your parents.

Pigsinpainauchocolat · 06/12/2023 13:40

exaltedwombat · 04/12/2023 18:45

This is hard. But people before dogs. Sorry.

Nope.

A girlfriend she's seen once in 10 years over a beloved dog that brings daily joy? Haha nope. The OP wants her dog home at Christmas, perfectly reasonable and normal.

Pigsinpainauchocolat · 06/12/2023 13:37

Dillydelly · 04/12/2023 18:21

I couldn't imagine putting an animal before family tbh. As much as I like dogs, I don't like them in the house.

Newsflash, you're not the OP and her dog IS part of her home.

Lalalalala555 · 06/12/2023 11:27

You need to have a phone call to really understand the level of the dog fear thing.

I think it's fair youre not wanting to send your dog away, because that costs money and it's your home and it's your feelings.
Equally though you don't know if this woman has had a horrific experience in the past ie been bitten or had someone close to her killed by a dog.

Equally though I think you need to have a chat. You yourself need to figure out what's the maximumly you'd be willing to do to accommodate them and the dog fear.
Ie keeping your dog shut away in another room.

And then tell them you can do that.
Then the ball is in their court if they'd like to stay at your house or if they make other plans.

I think it really needs a phone call to discuss this and not messages. Because you need to say that you find their request too far, but you'd be willing to compromise. And you need to find out exactly what she's scared of so you can accommodate.

Family should come before dogs.
Maybe they can stay with other relatives and then you can put the dog in another room or the car whilst they visit at Christmas.

Personally I can feel for both sides.
Ive been attacked by a dog and had one hanging off my arm. This summer one came at me and drew blood.
It is terrifying.

Equally though, I know how important pets can be to their owners. I had pets growing up and they were like a member of the family. And the home is also their home. Granted they don't know or care about Christmas. But it's also about how you feel. And what is reasonable.

I am scared of dogs, but I wouldn't ask for someone to put their dog in kennels if I was going to stay with them. Id mention I was nervous around dogs, and give suggestions about what would help. Ie making sure they don't bite or jump up. Keeping them away from me.

And then you know if those requests in advance will be met or not. And so you know if the space you're going into is safe.

They need to find a different place to stay if they can't find a way to come to an arrangement with you to segregate the house.

Also though depends if you have a dangerous dog that's bitten people before.

But have a chat with voices about it. That way both sides can show they're being considerate, and also set clear boundaries. Messages are easy to misenterprit. Although it's nice they gave you time to think and process their request.

Pinkiefinger · 06/12/2023 07:43

Can you not keep your doggo to certain rooms where they are not or have him on a lead of all in the same room??

We don't go to in-laws houses anymore as all 4 of them have dogs and our kids have pretty bad allergies so even just seeing them without the things causes reactions we just visit elsewhere or don't at all, it's a hit rude to expect in-laws to send their dogs to a kennel rather than the home they know

SJG7 · 06/12/2023 07:31

It is the dogs home! Very obvious you dislike dogs.

Robbee · 06/12/2023 07:04

SharonMack17 - I agree.
I don't agree though that family, or even any other people should come before any member of your household. The household is your family, your have responsibilities to them all, but especially to those who can't live independently. Your young children can't, your animals can't and they are your 1st priority in all things - you choose to have and take that responsibility.
The old saying is true - you choose your friends but not your family.
While you all live under the same roof growing up you might well be close, but once adult and living independently what responsibility or friendship you have to your siblings depends entirely on the relationship that exists between you as adults.
Not everyone even likes their siblings, approves of their beliefs and way of life or wants to do more than have a passing aquaintanceship with them. That's fine, it's a two way thing - no one can expect favours from some one just because they are related to them, that kind of relationship has to be earned constantly.
As you grow up you become independent of your family - if you want more you have to build an adult relationship not rely on a birth one.
Realistically many many people want to put as much space as possible between themselves and their birth family - that's fine and normal too.
No one is making dogs more important than people by making sure that if you are responsible for a dog's needs they are fully met before considering the needs of someone who's welfare you are not responsible for.
If you choose to take on an animal you are totally responsible for it for its whole life. Children become independent, animals do not - and that applies whether you love them and rely on their company as we might do with dogs, cats and other indoor animals or whether they are the chickens, farm livestock, fish etc that might be providing your income. Their welfare has to come before that of independent adults who can fend for themselves.
As an adult a person has no more call on a sibling to be responsible for their welfare than any other friend or aquaintance - it all depends on how mentally close they are. Many of us prefer our friends to our siblings and rely on and support them far more. Relationships are made in the childhood home - many don't survive once someone leaves that home. And that is fine and normal too
Whether someone likes dogs or not, I really can not understand why anyone can't clearly see that if you take on responsibility for an animal or a person incapable of living independently you will always morally have to put that responsibility first.

SharonMack17 · 06/12/2023 00:22

There's such a split between people who have dogs as part of the family and people who don't understand this and I guess neither group can easily see each other's view point easily. I'm just glad noone is coming to mine this Christmas that is wary of dogs because I have 2, with a litter of pups due the week before Christmas and they're going nowhere! 🤣

Pingu32 · 05/12/2023 22:40

I think moving flowers out is a tad more reasonable than a living sentient being loved very much by OP - what a comparison 🤔

Misty333 · 05/12/2023 22:29

Gensola · 03/12/2023 18:33

I can’t imagine putting a dog over family 😨

You clearly have not had a dog. Otherwise you would know the unconditional love you receive from them. They are just as much a part of the family as everyone else.

Anisette · 05/12/2023 22:05

I'm glad this is resolved, but I rather agree that people come before dogs. The argument that you're not making the dog more important, you're making yourself more important because you want the dog there is just circular - it does mean the dog is more important to you than your husband's brother. This is the way that families break up.

When you say "Family members are very welcome but are also free to choose other accommodation if they don't like my home, which includes my dog" think about that in terms of, say, a family member who is vegetarian: would you say "You are very welcome but you are also free to provide your own food if you don't like mine, which includes meat"? Or if they had a severe allergy to pollen, would you say "You are free to provide your own accommodation if you don't like my home, which includes flowers"?

It's basically giving your BIL the firm message that he comes second to a pet. It's not a message that he is going to forget easily. If you need his help at some time in the future, it would be entirely understandable if he takes the view that your request should be given as much priority as you are giving to him now.

Pigsinpainauchocolat · 05/12/2023 21:47

ProvisionsOnTheDock · 04/12/2023 08:31

It's just a dog and it has no concept of Christmas. Of course it should go into kennels to make a guest feel more comfortable.

But the OP knows it's Christmas and wants her much loved dog with her.

The gf isn't family.

Emgtwinkle · 05/12/2023 21:36

You keep your dog in his home !! They are part of the family. That was really wrong of them to ask you. Just say no sorry that's not possible. Maybe they can stay else where and if they come dinner put a stair gate up so the dog doesn't come near them.

Pigsinpainauchocolat · 05/12/2023 21:32

JacklynBlue · 03/12/2023 19:43

The usual mad Mumsnet responses.

My dog isn't more important than my humans. But I am. So I won't be making arrangements for my dog to go into kennels because I don't want to. Family members are very welcome but are also free to choose other accommodation if they don't like my home, which includes my dog.

Well put! The dog is important to OP so the dog stays.

Pigsinpainauchocolat · 05/12/2023 21:21

WhatInFreshHell · 03/12/2023 19:05

The dog doesn't understand Christmas though? How can you put an animal before a human? It's pure madness!

The dog is a much loved part of her family and lives there, bringing daily joy and love.

The human is a gf they see once a decade.

The dog wins by a country mile.

Ohthatsfabulousdarling · 05/12/2023 19:37

If she's scared of dogs, I'd kind of understand with the temperament of boxers, they think everyone want to be their friend- that she may feel even more wary.
OP if you're nearby me, you'd be more than welcome to drop him off whilst your family visit for xmas dinner- my dog is dog friendly but not particularly happy with humans outside of his own family. Long story!
Weve got a boxer x old English BTW.

Nannyjo1952 · 05/12/2023 19:29

I'd put my dog first everytime......the dogs family and should be treated as such. If visitors don't like the fact that your dog is going to be staying put then tough luck, don't bother visiting

Mothermax81 · 05/12/2023 19:07

Tell them to find alternative accommodation

Mrssnee16 · 05/12/2023 19:07

A dog is for life not just for Christmas ( or to be sent away for Christmas) it's awful for it to even be suggested

Amumof287 · 05/12/2023 18:55

You don’t know why she’s wary so some suggestions of telling her to “get f*cked” are pretty insensitive. Maybe she accepted the invitation thinking she would cope and over time it’s worried her more. Obviously
you can’t send your dog away but I would reassure her you will put the dog away whilst you’re eating etc and if she feels uneasy it will be fine to create some distance between her and the dog. It’s better if know she’s uncomfortable so you don’t let the dog jump up her etc

GrannyHelen1 · 05/12/2023 16:56

I always book an airB&B for family members who find my dog a challenge, so that they can retreat at night and any time if they find her too much. Works very well, and keeps my stress levels down - spending the whole holiday period worrying about if the dog is making a njuisance of herself, however harmlessly, is no fun for anyone.

Catxxxxxxxxxx · 05/12/2023 15:18

Gensola · 03/12/2023 18:33

I can’t imagine putting a dog over family

The dog IS part of their family. I hope to God you dont have dogs and never do

Robbee · 05/12/2023 14:00

Just no. Being wary of dogs is not the same as being allergic when you might have to make alternative arrangements as to where you meet your relatives (if you're genuinely allergic you can't go in a dog's home even if the dog is not present)
If she's just wary, and your dog is well behaved and you can guarantee will avoid her if not encouraged by her, then just tell her she can take it or leave it and give the name and address of somewhere they can book into.
Putting the dog in another room if it normally has the freedom of the house will upset the dog, and might well cause problems (noise, door scratching, even chewing).
If she's only wary now's a good idea to learn that dogs are ok and won't cause her problems. Just keep the dog back or in another room while you let them in the house - if she's sitting down in the room when the dog enters it'll probably completely ignore her unless she interacts (or shrieks, screams, waves her arms around etc that would cause problems - she'll have to know she's only welcome if she promises to behave calmly in the dog's presence))

Swipe left for the next trending thread