Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be raging about this school scheme?

260 replies

Promdiddlyontomtom · 03/12/2023 17:01

Hi, name changed as potentially very outing.

Have found out recently that my daughter's school has introduced a 'Points for Prom' incentive newest low.

The school get good results.

The demographic has some challenges and therefore they have a VERY strict regime and the kids are controlled with strict policies and sanctions (and a little praise- the balance is well out). The kids get detention if they don't get 100% in HW for example.

This is, IMO, the lowest they have gone.

Their newest bright idea- the young people have to earn 'behaviour points' to be in with a chance to get a ticket for their Y11 prom.

Apparently there's not enough spaces for all pupils (they only have spaces for 2/3 of the pupils... so find a bigger venue then!)

This is not an incentive and should not be used as a reward for 'good behaviour'.

Surely this is just a control tactic. A punishment for not toeing the line.

AIBU to think that all teens should get the opportunity to go to the end of school celebration? It draws the line after 12 years of compulsory education, a stressful period of formal exams, and friendships going in different directions (there's no sixth form). It marks the end of an era. Why should they be told they cannot go? Why shouldn't they be able to mark the end of years of education - for some this may have been a struggle all the way through- with their friends. There'll be no closure.

For the record, I've no concerns that my daughter will be excluded. I just think it's an awful idea.

What do you think?

OP posts:
charlotte361 · 03/12/2023 19:39

Pewpewbarneymcgrew · 03/12/2023 19:33

Except we don’t actually know that as op hasn’t been back to confirm how she knows, she simply said ‘apparently’

@barbieofswanlake I dont think you are paying attention, because i said that I do not believe there is not enough space. . The school would have no motive in not wanting all the students to behave well enough to earn a place.

Mmmm19 · 03/12/2023 19:38

That’s just awful. Exclusion should be for only the most serious offences (eg physical harm of student/staff). My kids are in first school and I dread the move to middle and high where they seem to be so strict-maybe it’s necessary for some but so much I hear on here suggests all the fun and joy of school is gone.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 03/12/2023 19:37

I find it weird that there are even ‘venues’ for Y11 proms. It definitely feels like it should be a fancy disco in the school hall (which is what usually happens in American film and tv too).

I’m not really sure why it needs to be a dinner dance type thing with a proper venue.

It's not that it 'needs' to be a dinner dance type thing. It's that the students want that kind of thing. Is there any particular reason you think they shouldn't be allowed to?

Did I read the OP right and the kids get detention if they don’t get 100% on their homework. This is absolutely shocking!!! Surely if a child can’t do their homework this is a failure of the teacher.

I'm pretty sure the OP meant that the students have to do 100% of the homework set, not that they have to score 100%.

Your comment that it's the teacher's fault if a child can't do their homework is very revealing though. Surely it should be very obvious that quite often children do badly on their homework because, in spite of the best efforts of the teacher, the child hasn't paid attention in class or simply can't be arsed to do their homework,or do it properly? There are many other reasons for poor or not-done homework, including MH issues or problems at home. Funnily enough, those aren't the teacher's fault either Hmm

LeggyLegsEleven · 03/12/2023 19:35

I worked for a large MAT and this was common. I know closer to the prom they would ease up on the requirements esp if they had tickets to sell, so you could go if you behaved the 2 weeks before etc.

Hoovermehenry · 03/12/2023 19:34

What a load of shite! Get a bigger venue! You can’t have a prom for 2 thirds of the kids- it’s either for all or not at all

Pewpewbarneymcgrew · 03/12/2023 19:33

barbieofswanlake · 03/12/2023 19:26

here's a thought, why don't you simply act like a parent and support the school?Tell your offspring that all they have to do is keep their nose clean, and they will be going to the ball!

Clearly you weren't paying attention at school @charlotte361

Here's a thought..... Do you usually struggle to understand very simple concepts such as THERE ARE NOT ENOUGH SPACES FOR ALL THE CHILDREN TO GO.

Except we don’t actually know that as op hasn’t been back to confirm how she knows, she simply said ‘apparently’

uninterestingusernamealert · 03/12/2023 19:31

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/12/2023 17:59

The issue here is that there isn't enough tickets for everyone which means that they are setting up some children to fail.

Generally, I don't have an issue with it.

Edited

Agree.

Setting up 1/3 of a year group to fail/be excluded in advance is shit.

Point deductions should be for actual poor behaviour. Not for things outside of the child's control.

But generally I do think it's a privilege not a right and if kids are going to dick around at school and particularly in year 11, from low level disruption which affects everyone to high level serious stuff then they shouldn't be allowed to go.

Why would a DC who has worked bloody hard (and the teachers too - who as much as it probably irritates them working in their free time, I would imagine, are probably happy/proud of the kids who've worked hard and pleased to wish them well) and had their lessons and learning time disrupted by someone being an arse all year, have their celebratory evening potentially spoiled by more of the same behaviour?

Oh and for the people saying hire your own venue in spite of the school - good luck with finding a venue that'll take hundreds of 16 year olds when there's no alcohol sales to boost profits especially if there are no teachers present to supervise it properly!! Most won't bother, too much mess and hassle for not enough money plus risk of underage drinkers on their licensed premises sneaking illicit booze past parent 'supervisors'. Nope:

And suggestions of someone find out who had the biggest house and host it there?!?! HAHAHAHAH! Who in their right mind would host a year 11 end of year party, in their actual home? Rather you than me, not a fucking chance!

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 03/12/2023 19:29

In my first year of teaching, there was a student who absolutely kicked off during a GCSE exam, really disrupted it for other students, really upset a lot of students, and to be honest, probably harmed their grades. Yes, she did have anxiety, and I'm sure it was a reaction to that, but even so, she could have just quietly walked out, rather than doing what she did.

She was told she wasn't to attend prom, which to be honest was partly due to the anger from some of the other students, and there were huge issues on the day of prom, with her mum coming up to school and being really aggressive with staff etc.

As others have said, it can be really tricky to find venues for prom where tickets are affordable, and it's a nice, accessible location for the students (even worse for Y13 when there's always a proportion who can't drink yet legally and all the issues that come with that). Therefore, if you've got a good venue, it's important to keep them on side by making sure there's no vandalism, violence, vaping in toilets etc on the night.

I do agree that if the venue can genuinely only accommodate 2/3 of the students, that's setting some students up to fail, and I would query this. But beyond that, I don't have an issue with the idea in general.

As others have said, you're welcome to try and organise your own alternative event (and see how tricky that is!).

Bournetilly · 03/12/2023 19:28

If people are badly behaved then I think it’s fair enough to say they can’t come but it’s not fair for them to find a venue that will only fit 2/3 of the children because they are not giving them all a fair chance of attending.

barbieofswanlake · 03/12/2023 19:26

here's a thought, why don't you simply act like a parent and support the school?Tell your offspring that all they have to do is keep their nose clean, and they will be going to the ball!

Clearly you weren't paying attention at school @charlotte361

Here's a thought..... Do you usually struggle to understand very simple concepts such as THERE ARE NOT ENOUGH SPACES FOR ALL THE CHILDREN TO GO.

Anisette · 03/12/2023 19:22

These things ultimately become counter-productive. Once a child knows they have lost their prom ticket, they have no incentive to behave and have nothing to lose.

charlotte361 · 03/12/2023 19:20

here's a thought, why don't you simply act like a parent and support the school?Tell your offspring that all they have to do is keep their nose clean, and they will be going to the ball!

Anisette · 03/12/2023 19:19

Pewpewbarneymcgrew · 03/12/2023 19:14

And neither do you, most schools will use common sense

To be honest, when a school has rigid uniform rules and/or rigid discipline systems, it can't claim to be using common sense. Far too many academies do operate policies like that, so sadly a lack of common sense is not unusual.

LolaSmiles · 03/12/2023 19:19

If there's only space for 2/3 of the year then I'd be querying that and asking why they've chosen a venue that will exclude a third of the year group.

The idea of having prom points doesn't bother me unless there's something highly unreasonable in there (eg must have 100% attendance or another threshold that discriminates against those pupils with disabilities).

Most schools I know that have done similar things have points for generally good attendance with mitigations for certain situations, decent behaviour across school, decent attitude/effort scores. It's hardly unreasonable in my opinion for students to turn up to school, work in class, be polite and do some homework and revision.

Pewpewbarneymcgrew · 03/12/2023 19:19

Anisette · 03/12/2023 19:18

No, they still can't break the law.

Who said they were ?

Anisette · 03/12/2023 19:18

Pewpewbarneymcgrew · 03/12/2023 19:07

Who said they were ?
And as it’s not a compulsory event they can exclude who they like

Edited

No, they still can't break the law.

BurbageBrook · 03/12/2023 19:18

YANBU at all. I detest these 'zero tolerance' schools and the way some educators are going with regard to behaviour management at the moment.

SleekButMeek · 03/12/2023 19:17

Well, if this scheme is a thing when my ADHD/ASD DS leaves secondary school, then I can guarantee he won't be going to a prom. He struggles to get 100% in his written work (despite knowing everything and can confidently prove it verbally) because he falls as 'severe' on both the ADHD and ASD scale and writing is just something he cannot focus on. He also cannot comprehend 'home work'. In his mind, home is home and school is school. School is for learning, home is not. Lockdown was an actual nightmare and while me and his DF are not keyworkers, we had to literally beg for him to be allowed to attend school with keyworker kids, because my DS just could not school from home. It caused untold stress for us all.

His educators have also been very obstructive in making any allowances or changes for his condition, it took us 4 yrs of endless battles to get his diagnosis because school wouldn't acknowledge it (he was just lazy/naughty etc) and have refused to back us with an application for an EHCP despite his diagnoses finally being confirmed.

My DS is intelligent, but his condition means he struggles in certain aspects of his school life. Its been really difficult for him and caused him a lot of tears and distress. To think that, in years to come, he could be essentially punished for this and denied the opportunity to finish school with a celebration is just depressing. That'd be more irreparable knocks to his confidence and self esteem.

It's a horrible scheme OP, I'd be vehemently challenging it.

Drfosters · 03/12/2023 19:16

charlotte361 · 03/12/2023 18:57

The same here, but, certainly in this area, now venues will not hire unless teachers are in attendance too ( and this is for very good reason)

The 'only room for 2/3 threat will not be the case, but will double down on the message to students to make them try harder to behave

Sure but parents can be in attendance instead. I have absolutely no idea who was in attendance as our party but I didn’t think it was that raucous tbh but maybe we were quite tame! As far as i was concerned once I had don’t my last a-level I had left the school, can’t imagine having any teacher involvement past that.

Pewpewbarneymcgrew · 03/12/2023 19:14

Anisette · 03/12/2023 19:11

But you don't know how this school defines poor behaviour. If it has an automatic detention for not doing 100% of the homework, no matter what the mitigating circumstances, it may well base the criteria on nonsense like uniform.

And neither do you, most schools will use common sense

katepilar · 03/12/2023 19:13

Just plain wrong.

Anisette · 03/12/2023 19:11

Pewpewbarneymcgrew · 03/12/2023 17:40

As previously said - vaping, truanting and disrespectful behaviour, I never mentioned uniform.
If you think repeatedly telling teachers to ‘fuck off’ should be rewarded with a prom ticket then you crack on
If you can’t behave then tough shit

But you don't know how this school defines poor behaviour. If it has an automatic detention for not doing 100% of the homework, no matter what the mitigating circumstances, it may well base the criteria on nonsense like uniform.

Canisaysomething · 03/12/2023 19:07

So the teens are all pitched against each other for limited prom places? Do they have to then fight to the death for prom king and queen?! It’s like the start of a shitty teen horror movie.

They just need to get a bigger venue, or boycott the whole thing and arrange their own event where everyone is welcome.

Pewpewbarneymcgrew · 03/12/2023 19:07

Anisette · 03/12/2023 19:05

Nope. If a school is going to organise an event like this, it still has to comply with, for example, the Equality Act. The teachers can't just decide to exclude the kids with autism or Tourette's because they're giving up an evening to supervise and want to make their lives easy.

Who said they were ?
And as it’s not a compulsory event they can exclude who they like

Anisette · 03/12/2023 19:05

Ilovelurchers · 03/12/2023 17:07

I presume the teachers organise the prom? And give up their evening unpaid to supervise it? f so they have a right to extend it only to the kids they wish to, who they believe will behave well and not create any problems for them on the night.

You should organise an alternate one with some other parents if you don't like the one they have organised. It would be hard work, but you could then invite whoever you liked.

Nope. If a school is going to organise an event like this, it still has to comply with, for example, the Equality Act. The teachers can't just decide to exclude the kids with autism or Tourette's because they're giving up an evening to supervise and want to make their lives easy.