Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I a nagging and horrible Mum?

35 replies

LanaL · 03/12/2023 12:12

Not a major thing and I’m pretty sure I’m not being unreasonable but having mum guilt!

DS is 9. Myself and his father are separated , he lives with me primarily but spends 3 nights per week with his Dad. This isn’t a custody arrangement , it’s just what was decided between us, I don’t have the best relationship with his Dad but he loves our DS and is a good father . The only issue I do have is that when DS is at his dads he is spoilt rotten by him and his partner ( now , I’m sure your first thought will be that it’s jealousy … a small part , maybe. I have other children , I’m by no means poor and DS doesn’t want for anything but I work full time in quite an intense job -
meaning I have less time to things with him than his Dad , partner and Dads family do when he’s there . I also do have some financial issues , we’re getting out of them now but it’s been a tough year so I have t been able to give as much financially as Dad can) I’m also different - I have rules , I will treat my children but I won’t just buy them whatever they want just because they want it etc. Its the total opposite at his Dads - he has a bedtime but if he wants to stay up later he can, he has every console , every toy he wants , if he wants something he gets it. If I say no to something , Dad says yes and gets it. I have told Dad about DS having a screaming tantrum over wanting something when he was younger, I would never give in to a tantrum . Dad went straight out and bought the toy that was a result of the tantrum. This has happened more than once.

Thats a very long story I realise - but, it’s relevant as I feel as though my DS prefers being with his Dad due to all this and I now feel guilt about parenting him as I feel like the nagging mom , but I also know I can’t give in and spoil him like his dad . He’s not a “spoiled” child in terms of his personality . He is the most sweet, kind, loving boy. He doesn’t brag about what he has at Dads, he’s so grateful for everything and I take credit for that because I feel like I have kept him grounded. But, sometimes I see tiny flickers of things .. he’s began to cry to try and get his own way, and he’s became slightly argumentative.. this isn’t really in a disrespectful way but in a way that shows he has argued like that and got his own way before …. it’s very similar to his dad - his dad was spoiled by his mom and dad , and he still is like this in adulthood and I have witnessed his dad cry and argue like this , but to a bigger extent , for eg when we split as he didn’t want the split.

So - this may seem minor - but DS has an obsession with collecting inanimate objects ( sticks , leaves , balloons , stones ) he wants to keep them all. I don’t allow it. It’s messy - he has a small bedroom and I don’t want it filled with these things . Certain things I’ll allow but not abything that is “ rubbish” and should be in the bin or outside . I don’t think that’s unreasonable but at Dads he can do this . He will regulary say “ but dad lets me …” . I planned a nice festive day today ( putting the decorations up , watching Xmas movies with hot chocolate ) . DS is now in his bedroom in a grump , crying his eyes out because he found a tiny , deflated balloon behind the sofa and I said it had to go in the bin . He said it’s only tiny, why does it matter if he keeps it, dad would let him , I’m mean as I know how much he loves this balloon ( that was from a Halloween party a month ago and has clearly been behind the sofa ever since ) , I never let him do anything fun etc. Now I’m sat here feeling like I’m making this house a house he doesn’t want to be at because of my rules . I know it’s silly but I have the rule - we don’t keep rubbish in the house and like I say I am strict with my rules but I don’t think they’re unfair and I don’t want to give in to things to compete with Dad and if I allow him to just do whatever he wants then he will just become spoiled ? Dad will never set boundaries or rules so it’s all on me to do it , to help my DS to be respectful, but then it leaves me as the strict , boring mom!

AIBU ?

OP posts:
LadyGwendoline · 03/12/2023 12:33

My son had a “stick box”, a cardboard box full of sticks collected on walks and the occasional elastic band he’d found from the postman dropping them, he definitely understood we kept only what fit in that box. His father allows everything and anything, his place is a tip and the food eaten there is junk food…my children are now adults and have good relationships with me, close, but not with their father.

I suggest you consider if any of your rules are strict for strict’s sake, and try not to worry too much about the difference in household life. Your son loves you. Go and have a big hug and enjoy the rest of the day together.

LanaL · 03/12/2023 12:30

I do , he does have some in his room , but I have to have a limit otherwise he would fill his room with it all x

OP posts:
LanaL · 03/12/2023 12:29

Dishwashersaurous · 03/12/2023 12:17

Sometimes you need to pick your battles.

For.some reason he wants these things. Why can't he have a small basket in his room which he can fill with crap? It's his room.

If he's crying, he's upset.

Go and apologise.

Poor kid must be so confused living a split life anyway, and then to have completely different rules makes it even more confusing.

Going forward see if you can agree basic rules like bedtime with your ex.

It's not fair on him to have to continually adjust to different expectations, it must be exhausting for him. He's only nine.

Maybe I should have added this , he does have some . I don’t say no to everything . He actually has about 8 balloons in his bedroom right now and was told that was enough. He has a few stones and sticks in a little pot. So it’s not like I just say no completely . As a rule I don’t like it but I don’t see the need to keep tiny deflated balloons … we had an issue recently because a balloon burst and I wouldn’t let him keep the little bits .

I always apologise to my children if I have upset them , I believe strongly in that. I gave him a cuddle and explained why he could t keep it , I told him I loved him etc . He is crying because I won’t give in and let him keep it , right now that’s the only thing that will stop him crying - going back on my word and letting him keep it and I know if I do then he will in future , cry like this to get me to change my mind over things .

Hes lived this ‘split’ life since he was very young , it’s all he knows and he’s a very well adjusted child . He does not know of any issues between me and dad as we have never let him know , we do things together etc x

OP posts:
AnneLovesGilbert · 03/12/2023 12:27

Or his dad realises he’s 9 and he’s a lovely sweet boy as OP says, and enjoys buying gifts and is less strict about bedtimes. He has nearly 50/50 care, he’s not a Disney dad swooping in EOW to intentionally make OP’s life harder.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 03/12/2023 12:27

Sorry but I think you do seem mean making him put the balloon in the bin, what harm would it do to let him keep it? If you don’t want him to have too much stuff then it’s reasonable to set a limit like only a having 20 pieces in his collection so that once it’s full he has to choose one to discard for every new thing he wants to keep, but to have a blanket rule that he can’t collect the things he’s interested in seems unnecessarily controlling and mean considering it’s a harmless hobby. Just because something seems like rubbish to you doesn’t mean it can’t be meaningful to him, one man’s trash is another man’s treasure and all that. Pick your battles and stop being mean and controlling over minor unimportant stuff or don’t be surprised when he goes to move in with his dad in a few years.

isthewashingdryyet · 03/12/2023 12:23

So, his dad is setting him up to be a hoarder and a man who tantrums when he can’t get his own way ?

I like your logic better, rubbish and nature belong outside

AnneLovesGilbert · 03/12/2023 12:23

I wouldn’t die on the hill of a tiny scratty old balloon he wants to keep for a bit. Make both of your lives easier and choose different battles.

I know it’s your rule but why do you have it and when you’re 80 will you be pleased you stuck to it and showed you wouldn’t be messed around, or will you look back fondly on his habit of collecting stuff and wish you’d chilled out?

LanaL · 03/12/2023 12:21

Just to add - as it may be suggested

  • there are 100% no additional needs .
  • there is no jealousy about what Dad can do - aside from maybe me having a bit of jealousy about having to be the one to be strict . Financially, even if I did have the money like Dad does to buy DS everything he wanted , I wouldn’t.
  • No jealousy over his dad and his partner - I am very happily married , I ended the relationship, I have never been in love with him, the relationship was very short and we split when DS was a few months old so it’s been a very long time.
  • I have no negativity towards his dads partner or parents . I have always got on well with both his mom and dad and they adore my DS. His dads partner has never treated my son with anything other than love and care , it’s not her who spoils him and I certainly don’t think she’s competitive and trying to outdo me etc , she’s very sweet.
OP posts:
myphoneisbroken · 03/12/2023 12:18

If these objects mean so much to your DS, why not let him have them in his room? So long as they are not rotting or smelly, what does it matter? I think especially as children get older you have to be a bit more flexible and let them have their quirks.

Dishwashersaurous · 03/12/2023 12:17

Sometimes you need to pick your battles.

For.some reason he wants these things. Why can't he have a small basket in his room which he can fill with crap? It's his room.

If he's crying, he's upset.

Go and apologise.

Poor kid must be so confused living a split life anyway, and then to have completely different rules makes it even more confusing.

Going forward see if you can agree basic rules like bedtime with your ex.

It's not fair on him to have to continually adjust to different expectations, it must be exhausting for him. He's only nine.