Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I shouldn’t have to use my car insurance for this?

91 replies

Mar124 · 03/12/2023 12:10

In my work place carpark, a large tree limb fell on my car damaging it badly. I was in the car when it happened. The car is now financially written off, and I’ve had no car for two weeks. This is because I was told my employer’s insurance would cover it. I was since told, they will not cover it now and I’ve to use my own insurance. I’ve never had to touch insurance in my life and now face losing my no claims bonus higher premium etc. for something completely not my fault. AIBU to not want to use my own insurance, when I was told it was being sorted by my employer?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
enchantedsquirrelwood · 09/12/2023 13:01

Mar124 · 07/12/2023 20:24

Employer’s insurance covering all costs now as tree was shown to be in very bad health.

That's a good outcome OP!

Sadly your premiums will still go up but at least you won't lose any NCD.

Beautiful3 · 08/12/2023 23:01

Great update op.

Mar124 · 07/12/2023 20:24

Employer’s insurance covering all costs now as tree was shown to be in very bad health.

OP posts:
autienotnaughty · 04/12/2023 03:56

Do you protect your no claims.? If you did it shouldn't impact your No claims as you can claim so many times with out losing it.

You have to go through your insurance company (unless your boss pays you up front)

Hopefully the claim will be a non fault claim which shouldn't impact on your renewal too drastically. But do shop around.

Also do you get a hire car in your policy?

JoanOfAllTrades · 04/12/2023 02:14

@Mar124

Also, do not discuss this with anyone at your workplace because anything you say could be prejudicial as, let’s face it, you’re probably not starting conversations with “without prejudice” at the beginning!

PeshwariGran · 04/12/2023 02:13

Car insurance isn’t just for things that are your fault.

You claim through them, and they’ll try to recover costs from the third party if they can.

JoanOfAllTrades · 04/12/2023 02:11

Mar124 · 03/12/2023 13:28

@Angelou79 Thank you. Is that not only
if there is liability there, or would
it cover regardless? And if I go through mine, and they recover costs from theirs, does that mean I don’t lose my no claims?

Even if they are liable, you still have to make a claim on your own insurance first.

This is how insurance works. You make the claim, your insurance company will then contact the landowner (your employer) to get the insurance company details for them, and then the insurance companies sort it out between them.

There is no way that you can do this without involving your insurance company unless you take the employer to court. And even then, if you can’t afford to do that, then your car insurance would have to be used to cover the costs.

Make the claim so that you can at least get either a rental vehicle or paid out so you can buy another car.

OrangeFluff · 03/12/2023 20:10

I work in car insurance. Yes you would claim from your insurance. It would be a fault claim unless your insurer can prove your employer is responsible (unlikely) as it means your insurer will be paying the costs.

If you have your NCD protected you won’t lose it but also won’t gain another year. If it’s not protected then most insurers have a step back system (my company does 2 years) so if you have 6 years NCD now, upon renewal you would go down to 4 years.

If you are very lucky and your employer is liable and their insurance pays, it would be non fault and you wouldn’t lose any NCD.

CornishGem1975 · 03/12/2023 19:26

This happened at my work. A tree from the neighbouring property fell onto one of our employee's cars. He had to tell his insurance but the next door neighbour was liable for the costs because it was proven that the tree was rotten and they were negligible. I'd be looking into that angle and if that is the case, you should be able to keep your no claims as well.

StarlightLime · 03/12/2023 17:56

Mar124 · 03/12/2023 12:28

@Wingedharpy I’ve to buy a new car now!! My car is a financial write off due to the extent of the damage.

But it isn't your employer's fault 🤷🏻‍♀️

enchantedsquirrelwood · 03/12/2023 17:52

OP the whole point of insurance is for incidents like this.

I know it's annoying and expensive to lose your no claims, but that's the way life is.

Imagine how much it would cost you if you had to replace the car (fully) from your own funds (I know the insurance company probably won't cough up the actual value of the car).

People have got silly about insurance though. It's all about saving the no claims bonus, rather than actually claiming for damage that the insurance covers.

GasDrivenNun · 03/12/2023 17:48

Munchyseeds2 · 03/12/2023 12:37

They will try and offer the lowest amount possible for the car, especially if it was more than a few years old
If you think it's worth more, it will be up to you to prove it to them by finding cars of similar age, mileage, condition on the market and showing them

I did this and founds loads of examples of similar cars but the insurance company just didn't want to know and wouldn't budge.

UsingChangeofName · 03/12/2023 16:46

It's a bummer, but this is exactly what we pay for any sort of insurance for. To be able to claim from, in the event of needing to replace (or sometimes repair) that which is damaged. Same with home insurance, or any other kind of insurance.

I'm no lawyer, but would only think the employer could be liable if you, or your insurers could prove they could have predicted that the tree was about to fall and had done nothing about it.
From all your other threads about this, you said it happened in very high winds in one of the named storms. I'm guessing it wasn't predicted by anyone.

It is one of those times in life that you reflect how lucky you are that you weren't physically hurt, and how lucky you were that you had fully comp on your insurance, and you move on with life. It is frustrating your NCD gets reduced, but that's the way insurance works.

tachycardigan · 03/12/2023 15:54

Wouldn’t this be classed as an act of God and therefore not your employer’s responsibility but your insurer’s? I think most car parks are park at your own risk.

notmorezoom · 03/12/2023 15:10

Of course you claim on your car insurance - that's what it is for!

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 03/12/2023 15:09

msbevvy · 03/12/2023 15:06

A huge tree at the bottom of my Mum's garden came down in a storm and damaged the roof of the neighbouring church.
Mum was worried that she would be liable for it but the vicar said that was not the case as it was 'an act of God'

Well he should know.......

msbevvy · 03/12/2023 15:06

A huge tree at the bottom of my Mum's garden came down in a storm and damaged the roof of the neighbouring church.
Mum was worried that she would be liable for it but the vicar said that was not the case as it was 'an act of God'

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 03/12/2023 14:53

you did park under the tree though.

witchypaws · 03/12/2023 14:37

It's shit but, it happens

I got a years free insurance when I bought a new car, only I didn't check if no claims were protected (they weren't)
A passerby punched my brand new car, causing over £1000 worth of damage. Lost my no claims and my premiums went up
He had to pay me £100, which he did at £5pm...

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 03/12/2023 14:31

Mar124 · 03/12/2023 13:28

@Angelou79 Thank you. Is that not only
if there is liability there, or would
it cover regardless? And if I go through mine, and they recover costs from theirs, does that mean I don’t lose my no claims?

As @Angelou79 must know if they actually work in insurance it will only coer the employer if they are legally liable. I notice you are studiously ignoring contributors who actually know what they are talking about.
I sympathise that it's not great, but it does make sense if you think about it - there are very few things where the simple fact of owning something makes one liable for anything that happens in connection with it.

Balloonhearts · 03/12/2023 14:29

Look into it before you accept a write off. My car was written off for over 3k when repair only cost 1500. I accepted the write off, bought the car back off them, got it repaired and was still £800 up.

Doubleespresso33 · 03/12/2023 14:09

Mar124 · 03/12/2023 13:28

@Angelou79 Thank you. Is that not only
if there is liability there, or would
it cover regardless? And if I go through mine, and they recover costs from theirs, does that mean I don’t lose my no claims?

It will go down on your insurance and you will lose your no claims if it isn’t protected - it’s what insurance is for and your work isn’t liable xx

Doubleespresso33 · 03/12/2023 14:08

Angelou79 · 03/12/2023 13:26

I work in Insurance if your company owns the building & land then their third party property liability will cover it for you however you will need to claim via your insurance first

This isn’t true - it isn’t a case that a ceiling was badly mended and caused an injury to an employee/customer. It was a tree which isn’t their liability as it’s classed as an “act of god”. It’s out of their control. it’s not their fault or an action of negligence that led to that happening. It will go down on the OPS insurance

Doubleespresso33 · 03/12/2023 13:59

Wingedharpy · 03/12/2023 12:20

Who owns the tree?

It’s classed in insurance as an “act of god” so to speak when they look at the proximate cause. Her work place isn’t liable as the tree branch didn’t fall as a result of them trying to cut it down for example. So the OP would need to claim it on her own insurance

Aprilx · 03/12/2023 13:56

Mar124 · 03/12/2023 12:21

@Floralnomad You don’t understand the impact of losing your no claims bonus and higher premiums for something that isn’t your fault in any shape or form? Right so!

If your car was stolen it would not be your fault either, your insurance would still need to pay and your no claims would still (probably) be impacted. It is just bad luck.

Your employer was kind enough to investigate whether their policy covered this. Personally I would not have expected it (based in 20 years of working in insurance), it was not their fault a tree blew over. It was an accident and this is what you have insurance for.

Swipe left for the next trending thread