Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset with my friend - he is upset with me for not having a smear test

315 replies

pussinboots61 · 03/12/2023 00:17

This is a sensitive subject but here goes. I have never had a smear test. I do have reasons but I can't cope with the thoughts of it. I am now 62, been married twice, I haven't been sexually active for some time now.

I will go for other tests but refuse smears. I have a very close male friend who is more like family to me. I worked with him until he retired two weeks ago but we still keep in touch and meet up. I do rely on him a lot and he is very supportive.

The other night we were messaging each other and he just told me randomly about a doctor he had been listening to on the radio talking about smear tests. It was just a general chat and I just commented that I've never had one. He asked me why I am not concerned about my own body and why I won't go for a test and I just told him its something I have always feared.

Then he just went off on one about it, said I should look after myself but not only that, he said I had upset him very much. The conversation went very sparse after that and when I went to bed and messaged him goodnight he just said I had upset him in a big way.

The next day he continued to be off hand with me and when I asked him why he felt I had upset him he went on about how I don't care what happens to me and was on the verge of unfriending me the night before. I was stunned by this. I can understand him being concerned and maybe trying to persuade me to have a test but to want to fall out with me over it was baffling.

I ended up ringing him and then he told me that his Dad died from throat cancer, he had been a heavy smoker from a young age and at one time his GP had offered to give him tests to check if he was going develop cancer but he refused. He said it is now a sore point for him if anyone refuses to have tests. He said he will try and help me get over my fear of smear tests but wants me to have one because he doesn't want me to be in any danger.

I met my friend today for lunch and things were fine but I am still very hurt and upset by this. He wants me to tell him the reason why I am so scared but I don't want to talk about it. I have told him about other friends of mine who won't have certain tests, one of them won't have any test of any kind, she won't even do a urine sample for the doctor because she fears so much what they might find but he said that is them and I can't go on how other people are.

Is he right in being this way or am I overthinking it? I do suffer from depression and I was getting on a more even keel with some new medication I am on but this is setting me back again. I know he is concerned about me but this is just over the top.

OP posts:
FreshWinterMorning · 04/12/2023 13:20

NeedToChangeName · 04/12/2023 13:17

I do not believe any medical screening is misogynistic or anything to do with'the patriarchy'. I have always had these sort of tests done by a woman who was respectful and caring

@CallieQ like you, I've only ever been treated with respect and kindness

But, I do think that if men had to tolerate smear tests, then better ways of testing would have been found by now eg blood test / urine sample

Exactly this. Women are treated as inferior to men, and always have been.

RedToothBrush · 04/12/2023 13:20

CallieQ · 04/12/2023 11:15

Women can make their own decisions and do not need to be coerced by you or anyone else.

I'm not coercing anyone luv I'm suggesting that cancer screening is a good idea and I'm entitled to that opinion

You can do that by presenting the facts and letting women make a choice without the emotional blackmail or guilt tripping. Treat women as adults rather than trying to peer pressure. If the benefits stand up on their own, their no reason to engage in abusive and coercive messaging.

FreshWinterMorning · 04/12/2023 13:19

@CallieQ why are you not accepting that some women don't want to have a cervical smear? What's it to you? Why are you so insistent every woman should have them, and they are 'wrong' if they don't? As has been said, there are benefits to smears yes, but there are also risks.

Same with breast cancer screening, there are risks with that. I have been offered breast cancer screening several times since my mid 40s, and have refused it every time ... I will never have it, and I shan't be explaining why.

Blablah1234 · 04/12/2023 13:18

As long as you're aware that the HPV virus cannot be totally cleared from anyone's system therefore a negative test at one point doesn't mean the virus will not be active in the future if you're immune system is weakened for any reason. The smear test also is an opportunity for your cervix to be visualised by a nurse or GP in case you have any obvious abnormality.

NeedToChangeName · 04/12/2023 13:17

I do not believe any medical screening is misogynistic or anything to do with'the patriarchy'. I have always had these sort of tests done by a woman who was respectful and caring

@CallieQ like you, I've only ever been treated with respect and kindness

But, I do think that if men had to tolerate smear tests, then better ways of testing would have been found by now eg blood test / urine sample

FreshWinterMorning · 04/12/2023 13:16

IrresponsiblyCertainAboutSexualDimorphism · 04/12/2023 12:10

I’m not your “luv”.

You’re entitled to your opinion, but not your own facts. Screening is not “a good idea” for everyone. There are benefits, and also risks.

This. ^ I have had cervical smears every 3 years since my mid 20s. I have not had once since 50-51, and I don't intend to have any more. (Now mid-late 50s.) I have not told anyone - not my DH, my best friend, or my adult DDs, because as this thread is illustrating, people judge you for it, and stick their beak - and their unwanted opinion in.

I never want another smear, and it is my right to refuse. My body - MY rules!

CallieQ · 04/12/2023 13:15

DropDeadFreida · 04/12/2023 13:08

@CallieQ the person you initially responded to is me. And the medical establishment is an inherently misogynistic one: there are countless papers, books and research that back this up.

And my point about patriarchy was focused on the fact that due to the incredibly high levels of sexual assault and harassment women go through as a sex class, any procedure in and around the genitals can be traumatic for women.

@DropDeadFreida

Well you implied that men do not have to go through invasive medical procedures which is not true. You can say it's all misogynistic if you like I don't agree. I personally think that cancer screening is set up to catch cancer early and therefore save lives , there really isn't anything else to say

FreshWinterMorning · 04/12/2023 13:13

WOW! He sounds bizarrely controlling and manipulative. I would be the one doing the unfriending if I were you @pussinboots61 He sounds batshit.

I also don't get though, why you would discuss this with anyone, let alone a male friend. How bizarre!

DropDeadFreida · 04/12/2023 13:08

@CallieQ the person you initially responded to is me. And the medical establishment is an inherently misogynistic one: there are countless papers, books and research that back this up.

And my point about patriarchy was focused on the fact that due to the incredibly high levels of sexual assault and harassment women go through as a sex class, any procedure in and around the genitals can be traumatic for women.

CallieQ · 04/12/2023 13:03

And going back to women, and specifically cervical screening, due to, you know, patriarchy and all, there are many, many women who unfortunately associate any act around their genitalia with pain, violence and trauma. So for a lot of women a cervical screening is not a 'simple' medical procedure. It can feel like a violation.

I do not believe any medical screening is misogynistic or anything to do with'the patriarchy'. I have always had these sort of tests done by a woman who was respectful and caring

CallieQ · 04/12/2023 13:00

DropDeadFreida · 04/12/2023 11:31

@CallieQ what does your DP's examination have to do with cervical screening? By that same token people have open heart surgery so I guess your DP can't complain if he finds a digital rectum exam painful? It would be great if just once the focus could be on the topic at hand rather than all this whataboutery.

But if we are going there, a DRE (which is what your DP had) does not involve the doctor using a tool to widen your DP's back passage, and then scraping the walls of your DP's back passage with another tool.

And going back to women, and specifically cervical screening, due to, you know, patriarchy and all, there are many, many women who unfortunately associate any act around their genitalia with pain, violence and trauma. So for a lot of women a cervical screening is not a 'simple' medical procedure. It can feel like a violation.

@DropDeadFreida

If you read my post properly I was responding to someone who implied that men do not have to go through invasive tests.

MiracleMumm · 04/12/2023 12:55

He is being over bearing, but if you have DC then it might be worth facing your fear…I recently met a lady who had incurable breast cancer (bracca). Her recently deceased elderly mother had always refused to get checked. As a result, this lady and her three siblings had all found out too late. It was a death sentence for all four of them. Go get a smear. The health professionals are all women, and excellent at putting patients at ease.

Hbh17 · 04/12/2023 12:47

There are lots of reasons why someone would choose not to have any type of screening, but the rest of us absolutely do NOT need to know. Yet again, a poster trying to imply pressure on complete strangers!

Hbh17 · 04/12/2023 12:36

Individuals have free choice 're all their personal health matters. I'm sure I've made decisions that would horrify my friends, if they knew. But it doesn't matter, because it has absolutely nothing to do with anyone else. Just do/don't do whatever you like and politely change the subject if he raises it again.

IrresponsiblyCertainAboutSexualDimorphism · 04/12/2023 12:10

CallieQ · 04/12/2023 11:15

Women can make their own decisions and do not need to be coerced by you or anyone else.

I'm not coercing anyone luv I'm suggesting that cancer screening is a good idea and I'm entitled to that opinion

I’m not your “luv”.

You’re entitled to your opinion, but not your own facts. Screening is not “a good idea” for everyone. There are benefits, and also risks.

ManateeFair · 04/12/2023 11:36

It's absolutely none of his business. Yes, it's good to have regular smear tests, but if you don't want to or don't feel you can manage it, then that is entirely up to you and he needs to back off and leave you alone.

Also, I believe they stop offering smears at 65 anyway, because it's highly unlikely that a woman will develop cervical cancer after that age. He needs to bog off.

DropDeadFreida · 04/12/2023 11:31

@CallieQ what does your DP's examination have to do with cervical screening? By that same token people have open heart surgery so I guess your DP can't complain if he finds a digital rectum exam painful? It would be great if just once the focus could be on the topic at hand rather than all this whataboutery.

But if we are going there, a DRE (which is what your DP had) does not involve the doctor using a tool to widen your DP's back passage, and then scraping the walls of your DP's back passage with another tool.

And going back to women, and specifically cervical screening, due to, you know, patriarchy and all, there are many, many women who unfortunately associate any act around their genitalia with pain, violence and trauma. So for a lot of women a cervical screening is not a 'simple' medical procedure. It can feel like a violation.

LovelyBranches · 04/12/2023 11:25

My mother had cervical cancer before I was born. I probably wouldn’t be here if it wasn’t for a smear test.

My mother’s sister and aunt died of cervical cancer. Well….we think it was cervical cancer in the case of my aunt-she never went for smears and by the time the cancer had taken over it was too late and it was guessed that it was primarily cervical cancer.

My aunt refused to even be told she was dying, she refused any medical information and didn’t want to know anything. Other members of my family are the same-refusing to know anything about their own health.

I can understand your friends frustration, after all it would be him that was left to mourn you and your poor choices. But, these are still your choices.

I think your friend has offered you kindness and support and he doesn’t want to lose you. His fear and trauma may have been talking when he said he had thought about defriending you, but he was wrong to say that (but not wrong to think it-it’s painful to watch someone you love suffer).

I would try and understand why he thinks medical checks are important, but respectfully assert that it’s your body and your choice.

CallieQ · 04/12/2023 11:25

Yes well said, for pointing out the misogyny at the very core of the service design

You really think it's misogynistic to set up a screening service that aims to save women's lives

Catsmere · 04/12/2023 11:21

@DropDeadFreida well said.

CallieQ · 04/12/2023 11:19

Alongside this, maybe if the invasive nature of the procedure (as with a lot of women’s medical procedures) was acknowledged and some attempt was made to make the process more comfortable for women (I’ve seen men being given general anaesthetic for tattoos and women are expected to go through smears, coil fittings etc with just a grit of the teeth) then maybe more women would also be tested. As it is, this is another way in which the medical establishment continues to let us down. I will not ‘just lie back and do it’ thank you, I have a right to refuse.

My male DP recently had a finger up the behind to check for prostate cancer, how's that for invasive? A medical check or examination is what it is, absolutely nothing to do with being invasive because you are a woman or being told to lie back and take it

Elphame · 04/12/2023 11:17

It really is none of his business. Ask him if he's had his prostate checked? If not why not?

FWIW I gave up with my smears once they degraded them to an HPV test. They won't catch an early cervical cancer in me so I will just continue to pay attention to what is happening in my own body rather than rely on screening.

CallieQ · 04/12/2023 11:15

Women can make their own decisions and do not need to be coerced by you or anyone else.

I'm not coercing anyone luv I'm suggesting that cancer screening is a good idea and I'm entitled to that opinion

Tatumm · 04/12/2023 11:09

DropDeadFreida · 04/12/2023 11:06

What really bothers me is the narrative behind all this. Why can’t women be given the information in a matter of fact way and then left to make an informed choice? Why all the scare tactics when it comes to cancer screening for women? Why the hysterics in advertising etc? Why are we always treated like this?

Alongside this, maybe if the invasive nature of the procedure (as with a lot of women’s medical procedures) was acknowledged and some attempt was made to make the process more comfortable for women (I’ve seen men being given general anaesthetic for tattoos and women are expected to go through smears, coil fittings etc with just a grit of the teeth) then maybe more women would also be tested. As it is, this is another way in which the medical establishment continues to let us down. I will not ‘just lie back and do it’ thank you, I have a right to refuse.

According to statistics a third of women do not take up the offer of a smear. Maybe it’s time to look at why that is rather than just going on about how important it is to have a smear? Yes, it is important, but if women are not engaging then we need to look at why.

And I will go back to my original point. I did go for a smear, and my sample was not actually screened for cancerous cells as I am HPV negative. So I followed the ‘rules’ and did what was expected, and the outcome for me was that they still did not bother to actually test my cells for cancer. So am I likely to go for another smear? No.

Yes well said, for pointing out the misogyny at the very core of the service design

DropDeadFreida · 04/12/2023 11:06

What really bothers me is the narrative behind all this. Why can’t women be given the information in a matter of fact way and then left to make an informed choice? Why all the scare tactics when it comes to cancer screening for women? Why the hysterics in advertising etc? Why are we always treated like this?

Alongside this, maybe if the invasive nature of the procedure (as with a lot of women’s medical procedures) was acknowledged and some attempt was made to make the process more comfortable for women (I’ve seen men being given general anaesthetic for tattoos and women are expected to go through smears, coil fittings etc with just a grit of the teeth) then maybe more women would also be tested. As it is, this is another way in which the medical establishment continues to let us down. I will not ‘just lie back and do it’ thank you, I have a right to refuse.

According to statistics a third of women do not take up the offer of a smear. Maybe it’s time to look at why that is rather than just going on about how important it is to have a smear? Yes, it is important, but if women are not engaging then we need to look at why.

And I will go back to my original point. I did go for a smear, and my sample was not actually screened for cancerous cells as I am HPV negative. So I followed the ‘rules’ and did what was expected, and the outcome for me was that they still did not bother to actually test my cells for cancer. So am I likely to go for another smear? No.