Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset with my friend - he is upset with me for not having a smear test

315 replies

pussinboots61 · 03/12/2023 00:17

This is a sensitive subject but here goes. I have never had a smear test. I do have reasons but I can't cope with the thoughts of it. I am now 62, been married twice, I haven't been sexually active for some time now.

I will go for other tests but refuse smears. I have a very close male friend who is more like family to me. I worked with him until he retired two weeks ago but we still keep in touch and meet up. I do rely on him a lot and he is very supportive.

The other night we were messaging each other and he just told me randomly about a doctor he had been listening to on the radio talking about smear tests. It was just a general chat and I just commented that I've never had one. He asked me why I am not concerned about my own body and why I won't go for a test and I just told him its something I have always feared.

Then he just went off on one about it, said I should look after myself but not only that, he said I had upset him very much. The conversation went very sparse after that and when I went to bed and messaged him goodnight he just said I had upset him in a big way.

The next day he continued to be off hand with me and when I asked him why he felt I had upset him he went on about how I don't care what happens to me and was on the verge of unfriending me the night before. I was stunned by this. I can understand him being concerned and maybe trying to persuade me to have a test but to want to fall out with me over it was baffling.

I ended up ringing him and then he told me that his Dad died from throat cancer, he had been a heavy smoker from a young age and at one time his GP had offered to give him tests to check if he was going develop cancer but he refused. He said it is now a sore point for him if anyone refuses to have tests. He said he will try and help me get over my fear of smear tests but wants me to have one because he doesn't want me to be in any danger.

I met my friend today for lunch and things were fine but I am still very hurt and upset by this. He wants me to tell him the reason why I am so scared but I don't want to talk about it. I have told him about other friends of mine who won't have certain tests, one of them won't have any test of any kind, she won't even do a urine sample for the doctor because she fears so much what they might find but he said that is them and I can't go on how other people are.

Is he right in being this way or am I overthinking it? I do suffer from depression and I was getting on a more even keel with some new medication I am on but this is setting me back again. I know he is concerned about me but this is just over the top.

OP posts:
DropDeadFreida · 06/12/2023 15:40

Blablah1234 · 06/12/2023 15:23

-Lots of people commenting that smears are not worthwhile as they now don't do cytology if HPV negative
-People saying that as they're no longer sexually active they don't need smears
-People saying after 65 your risk goes down for cervical cancer
-People saying if you have one HPV negative smear you never need another
-People saying it's impossible to cease yourself
-People saying there is no alternative except for a smear at a GP practice

None of these are true

"-Lots of people commenting that smears are not worthwhile as they now don't do cytology if HPV negative"

It's true that they do not do cytology if you are HPV negative. So for women who will remain HPV negative, they are not worthwhile. This is not misinformation.

"-People saying that as they're no longer sexually active they don't need smears"

Sexually active means different things to different people. There are a whole plethora of sexual activities that do not involve activities that increase your risk of contracting HPV.

"-People saying after 65 your risk goes down for cervical cancer"

Why does the screening programme stop at 64 then?

"-People saying if you have one HPV negative smear you never need another"

Goes back to my above point about sex lives and contracting risks.

"-People saying it's impossible to cease yourself"

Are you accusing the people who have had that experience of lying then? Because even in cases where people have managed to do it the process seems onerous.

"-People saying there is no alternative except for a smear at a GP practice"

I don't even know what you mean here.
So where is the misinformation?

IrresponsiblyCertainAboutSexualDimorphism · 06/12/2023 15:34

Blablah1234 · 06/12/2023 15:23

-Lots of people commenting that smears are not worthwhile as they now don't do cytology if HPV negative
-People saying that as they're no longer sexually active they don't need smears
-People saying after 65 your risk goes down for cervical cancer
-People saying if you have one HPV negative smear you never need another
-People saying it's impossible to cease yourself
-People saying there is no alternative except for a smear at a GP practice

None of these are true

They don’t do cytology if HPV negative.

People who are not sexually active are at a lower risk. Obviously. And the risk/benefit decision may be different.

Risk (i.e. likelihood of diagnosis of cervical cancer) does go down after 65. Most new diagnoses are in the 35-44 bracket. screening ends after 55 anyway.

No-one is saying that one negative HPV test means you’ll always be HPV negative. Although the likelihood of testing positive later on if you know you have not been exposed for many many years is relatively low. Risks may not outweigh benefits. And nobody “needs” a smear test. They may of course wish to have one.

In practice, it is very difficult to opt out. You obviously have not opted out, so how on earth would you know?

Nobody is saying the GP is the only option.

Blablah1234 · 06/12/2023 15:23

-Lots of people commenting that smears are not worthwhile as they now don't do cytology if HPV negative
-People saying that as they're no longer sexually active they don't need smears
-People saying after 65 your risk goes down for cervical cancer
-People saying if you have one HPV negative smear you never need another
-People saying it's impossible to cease yourself
-People saying there is no alternative except for a smear at a GP practice

None of these are true

IrresponsiblyCertainAboutSexualDimorphism · 06/12/2023 15:16

Blablah1234 · 06/12/2023 15:08

It's not about thinking you're silly, it's understand able that if you wish to remove yourself from a lifesaving screening programme and therefore increase your risk of a very common cancer they have to make sure you're informed so you don't sue the NHS and say you didn't mean to remove yourself from screening or that you were removed in error. The process (if you follow the instructions) is reasonably simple. Your GP surgery has an obligation to provide you with the best evidence based medical care which means ensuring you're fully aware of the risks of not being screened for cervical cancer and they need to cover their tracks just as they do whenever a patient declines treatment that they need. Your GP can also then discuss with you any barriers stopping you from being screened. Lots of women are happy to have it with anaesthetic or sedation and this can be arranged and your GP would want you to be aware of that rather than removing yourself from screening because you don't want it at the practice. Considering the amount of misinformation on this thread it's very clear that people aren't adequately informed and are spreading misinformation to others which is sad.

Edited

Where’s the misinformation?

RedToothBrush · 06/12/2023 15:11

Melroses · 06/12/2023 14:21

Yes it was ridiculous but it existed which was something.

You can also pick up the form at the GPs and fill it in then they will do the same thing with it. If the GPs have ever heard of it. They will probably tag on things like the old mandatory counselling or something because they don't want to read through the reams either.

I was told by a GP there was no way to remove yourself permanently.

All screening letters should have a web address to opt out printed on them. They don't.

There should not be hoops to jump through.

I find the hoops impossible to navigate.

Blablah1234 · 06/12/2023 15:08

It's not about thinking you're silly, it's understand able that if you wish to remove yourself from a lifesaving screening programme and therefore increase your risk of a very common cancer they have to make sure you're informed so you don't sue the NHS and say you didn't mean to remove yourself from screening or that you were removed in error. The process (if you follow the instructions) is reasonably simple. Your GP surgery has an obligation to provide you with the best evidence based medical care which means ensuring you're fully aware of the risks of not being screened for cervical cancer and they need to cover their tracks just as they do whenever a patient declines treatment that they need. Your GP can also then discuss with you any barriers stopping you from being screened. Lots of women are happy to have it with anaesthetic or sedation and this can be arranged and your GP would want you to be aware of that rather than removing yourself from screening because you don't want it at the practice. Considering the amount of misinformation on this thread it's very clear that people aren't adequately informed and are spreading misinformation to others which is sad.

Melroses · 06/12/2023 14:21

DropDeadFreida · 06/12/2023 10:42

@RedToothBrush and I would argue that having to look through reams of documents and click through five different links to complete the form, find the correct email address and send it off is not easy, it's ridiculous.

Yes it was ridiculous but it existed which was something.

You can also pick up the form at the GPs and fill it in then they will do the same thing with it. If the GPs have ever heard of it. They will probably tag on things like the old mandatory counselling or something because they don't want to read through the reams either.

Melroses · 06/12/2023 14:17

RedToothBrush · 06/12/2023 08:07

Well quite. Not everyone finds it this easy. Because the procedure is designed to be as difficult as possible. You somehow slipped through. This has NOT been my experience.

I did wonder if it was a bit of a loophole - I tried to get it out to as many women as I could at the time. I don't have the links as they are on my old computer.

It seemed a far more civilised way of removing yourself from a programme you never signed up to in the first place.

Not so long ago, the policy seemed to be delegated out to the administrators of the recall software and there was a long list of hurdles, including mandatory counselling from a doctor, to be overcome. None of it complied with the documents being put out by the national screening committee etc.

MartyMcFlysPurpleUnderwear · 06/12/2023 12:33

I am just guessing here but I am going to say no.

DropDeadFreida · 06/12/2023 11:31

Case in point. There are many, many examples of this.

To be upset with my friend - he is upset with me for not having a smear test
DropDeadFreida · 06/12/2023 11:27

@MartyMcFlysPurpleUnderwear I didn't say there was a screening programme, my point is that I wonder if the same tactics used on women by healthcare providers, in advertising, in conversations etc. are employed when discussing the pros/cons of testing for prostate cancer in men.

Do men report feeling harassed, threatened, manipulated etc. in those same settings into agreeing to testing for potential prostate cancer as I hear women report when being spoken to about testing for potential cervical cancer?

MartyMcFlysPurpleUnderwear · 06/12/2023 11:17

DropDeadFreida · 06/12/2023 10:50

It is interesting to see the types of words/phrases that a lot of the posters have been using on this thread (regardless of whether they support screening/have had smears/will have smears etc.)

Harassed
Painful
Traumatic
The fear of cancer being "hammered" into us
Threatening
Bleeding
Abuse
Sexist
Infantilising and so on

Something is clearly going wrong here. I wonder if men feel the same about prostate cancer screening?

There is no prostate cancer screening program in the UK.

DropDeadFreida · 06/12/2023 10:50

It is interesting to see the types of words/phrases that a lot of the posters have been using on this thread (regardless of whether they support screening/have had smears/will have smears etc.)

Harassed
Painful
Traumatic
The fear of cancer being "hammered" into us
Threatening
Bleeding
Abuse
Sexist
Infantilising and so on

Something is clearly going wrong here. I wonder if men feel the same about prostate cancer screening?

DropDeadFreida · 06/12/2023 10:42

@RedToothBrush and I would argue that having to look through reams of documents and click through five different links to complete the form, find the correct email address and send it off is not easy, it's ridiculous.

RedToothBrush · 06/12/2023 08:07

Melroses · 05/12/2023 23:18

I just filled in a form and scanned and e-mailed it to CSAC or something - found it buried in the reams of documents on the gov website, having followed links through about 5 of them. Then they just sent a letter and it was done.

Well quite. Not everyone finds it this easy. Because the procedure is designed to be as difficult as possible. You somehow slipped through. This has NOT been my experience.

HamBone · 06/12/2023 01:20

I don’t know @XenoBitch , ppl can be pretty derogatory about bad teeth!

As for vision, it’s hard to function when you can’t see clearly and/or you start getting headaches due to eye strain. So going for a test in the early stages seems like an obvious step.

Whereas breast or cervical cancer can be quite advanced before the victim even realizes that there’s a problem.

Nagado · 06/12/2023 01:16

pussinboots61 · 05/12/2023 18:49

Just a question - does anyone here have mammograms, I will go for those, its just smear tests I avoid.

I do. I don’t have smears and it’s not my intention to have any in the future unless I’m absolutely forced to, but I’m ok with mammograms.

Edited due to me not reading your updates. It’s quite interesting that he feels you’re not listening to him, but you’re telling him that there are private reasons for your decision but he’s refusing to hear that.

crispcreambun · 06/12/2023 01:00

XenoBitch · 06/12/2023 00:53

But no one gets grief about not seeing a dentist or optician. A woman not getting a smear... it seems to be everyone's business.

Because of the three, only smears are associated explicitly with cancer. And cancer is the big bad scary. It’s hammered into us that all screening, more screening, test for everything = good and morally right. Combine that with most of us knowing people dead from various cancers and emotions run high. Rightly and wrongly.

XenoBitch · 06/12/2023 00:53

crispcreambun · 06/12/2023 00:49

Not a healthcare professional but I would speculate that it’s because the current procedure also allows for a visual inspection of the cervix, along with the vulva and vagina—areas we are unlikely or unable to check ourselves for visual anomalies. Urine testing would be much cheaper and free up lots of resources but removes the ‘professional visual checkup’ benefit.

Like how going to the dentist isn’t just about your teeth and an eye test isn’t just about your vision. They can spot other problems before they get serious or, in some cases, life-threatening.

But no one gets grief about not seeing a dentist or optician. A woman not getting a smear... it seems to be everyone's business.

crispcreambun · 06/12/2023 00:49

Tatumm · 05/12/2023 23:15

Can any healthcare professional with a relevant background explain why this isn’t done?

Not a healthcare professional but I would speculate that it’s because the current procedure also allows for a visual inspection of the cervix, along with the vulva and vagina—areas we are unlikely or unable to check ourselves for visual anomalies. Urine testing would be much cheaper and free up lots of resources but removes the ‘professional visual checkup’ benefit.

Like how going to the dentist isn’t just about your teeth and an eye test isn’t just about your vision. They can spot other problems before they get serious or, in some cases, life-threatening.

Melroses · 05/12/2023 23:18

DropDeadFreida · 05/12/2023 23:00

@Blablah1234 have you looked at the process for requesting withdrawal? So you'd have to go through it with potentially two healthcare professionals and jump through all sorts of hoops.

It reminds me of the nonsense women have to go through if they want their tubes tied. I guess we're so silly they need to MAKE SURE we know what we're doing. I'm surprised they don't ask for written permission from our husbands...

I just filled in a form and scanned and e-mailed it to CSAC or something - found it buried in the reams of documents on the gov website, having followed links through about 5 of them. Then they just sent a letter and it was done.

Tatumm · 05/12/2023 23:15

DropDeadFreida · 05/12/2023 23:05

So the NHS could ask for every woman to provide a urine sample to test for HPV, and then only perform a smear on those women who test positive rather than subjecting thousands upon thousands of women to a procedure that many find painful and traumatic? And this approach would provide them with the same outcome but in a much less invasive way and I dare say the uptake would be higher?

Now I wonder why they don't do that?

Can any healthcare professional with a relevant background explain why this isn’t done?

DropDeadFreida · 05/12/2023 23:05

beanontoast · 05/12/2023 20:41

OP I also find smear tests awful due to previous sexual assault. I think your friend is overstepping and it’s your body your choice. May I make a suggestion though. You can get an at home HPV test now, either a self swab of the vagina or a urine sample. If you do not have HPV, you would be doing the same standard of test as a smear - they have changed in recent years, and your cell sample is now ONLY tested for cancerous cells IF you are HPV positive. If you do at an home HPV test and it comes back negative, this is the same as what the NHS would’ve done - they don’t send HPV negative samples off for the extra cancerous cell testing.

now, if you are HPV negative then happy days - you have done the same test you’d have had on a smear, without the trauma, and your friend can be satisfied. If you are HPV positive then you could consider trying to go for a smear (no judgement if this is too difficult but you would be making a more informed choice about whether to opt not to have one).

If you don’t want to do any of this and sod your friend’s judgement then I support you too. It’s very sad what he’s experienced but it doesn’t give him the right to dictate other people’s healthcare choices.

So the NHS could ask for every woman to provide a urine sample to test for HPV, and then only perform a smear on those women who test positive rather than subjecting thousands upon thousands of women to a procedure that many find painful and traumatic? And this approach would provide them with the same outcome but in a much less invasive way and I dare say the uptake would be higher?

Now I wonder why they don't do that?

DropDeadFreida · 05/12/2023 23:00

@Blablah1234 have you looked at the process for requesting withdrawal? So you'd have to go through it with potentially two healthcare professionals and jump through all sorts of hoops.

It reminds me of the nonsense women have to go through if they want their tubes tied. I guess we're so silly they need to MAKE SURE we know what we're doing. I'm surprised they don't ask for written permission from our husbands...

To be upset with my friend - he is upset with me for not having a smear test
RedToothBrush · 05/12/2023 22:24

I don't need the third fucking degree about this. I have tried repeatedly.

This upsets me. Are you trying to upset me further?

Swipe left for the next trending thread