Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH policing how I talk. AIBu

86 replies

Picturequestion · 02/12/2023 20:22

So I was just chatting to DH about something we have paid someone else to do for us. At great expense. For example a menu for a big event.

We are going through a rocky patch. He is getting therapy to work out why he gets so triggered by certain things which can lead to him getting disproportionally angry and at times very verbally aggressive (name calling for example).

Discussion yesterday and an agreement that neither of us should give the other unsolicited advice or criticise each other. He has asked me to make a reasonable change in how we co parent and I have asked him to continue to work on being less reactive and angry.

So back to the conversation about the ‘menu’.

We were talking through it and the different aspects - what we liked and didn’t like. I said about one bit ‘I feel really ‘meh’ about this bit’. He said - in a slightly irritated tone ‘can I ask that when we discuss these things that you talk more positively.’

i stayed very calm. I’m getting very skilled at that! I said that I was just expressing how I feel about something. He said that I had asked him to change how he talks (I.e. when he’s angry and aggressive) because of how it makes me feel and so he is asking me to change how I talk because it dampens his enthusiasm for the ‘menu’

I very calmly said that I didn’t think it was equivalent and that I need to be able to express myself and my feelings and thoughts. I wasnt being critical of him or aggressive or morose. I was positive about the bulk of the ‘menu’. I was just stating my reaction to a part of the menu.

He was annoyed that I didn’t agree with him and huffed and walked off.

AIBU to think that he doesn’t have the right to ask me not to express my emotional reaction to a part of something that we are paying someone to provide.

Or am I right to stand my ground because I shouldn’t have to monitor what I say just in case it dampens his enthusiasm (it might have easily been that he felt ‘meh’ as well).?

No LTBs please. That’s the next step if he doesn’t stop the aggressive outbursts. Obviously this is a micro event in a much more complex situation but just based on the information here I’d be keen to hear views.

Thanks in advance to anyone that has read and comprehended all of that. I feel quite certain that I am being reasonable but the strength of his annoyance makes it hard to know for sure. Would be great to have different perspectives.

OP posts:
Octavia64 · 03/12/2023 12:03

Hi OP

I think you might benefit from thinking through the situation you are in.

Clearly he is unreasonable. If he is in therapy he might change. However it might give him more tools to be more unreasonable.

You've said that if it wasn't for the DC you would have left already.

Couple of suggestions:in terms of coping until the deadline, treat him like a dangerous tiger who you have no choice but to be around.

Try to get some space of your own in the house or the garden and spend time there or out if the house.
If you have to interact with him, be very calm and try not to provoke at all. You will know what triggers him. You know he's not reasonable so don't bother to treat him like he will be.

Longer term, if as you say he is verbally and emotionally abusive this will be impacting the children. So consider what you can do to support their needs - keeping them away from shouting and arguments and so on by being out etc.

I'm sorry. It's a shit situation.

LittleMissSunshiner · 03/12/2023 11:56

Zaney40 · 02/12/2023 20:50

I'm starting to think that a big chunk of mumsnetters have just broke up from an abusive relationship, they've got time in their hands being newly single and they spend it by replying to every post saying you should definitely not work on anything in your relationship and instead just LTB.

Or... those of us who are free are assisting to liberate the still suffering.

My story - I'm not someone who just broke up from a bad relationship but 25 years ago I did realise that there was something very very wrong - I kept getting in relationships with men who were abusive and violent, sort of macho gangster types. I also didn't want to have sex with them in all honesty. Took a long time and a lot of recovery to realise that I was just quite literally repeating the format of what I'd be brought up in. I also never 'fancied' boys or men as a youngster. That's how bad it was! I'm gay / lesbian. I'm not even bi. But because of dysfunction I was dating violent men. That's how programmed and oblivious I was. It's taken me decades to de-code all this and de-programme myself. Not saying anyone else's story is THAT extreme but life is for living joyfully, not imprisoning and hostage taking one another and using therapists to beat each other into submission.

Picturequestion · 03/12/2023 11:52

YouJustDoYou · 03/12/2023 11:48

Kids pick up on it. I WISH my parents had split earlier, and it was a fucking massive relief, even at 8 years old, when they did. They were far better apart and never together again than they were forcing a marriage that was flogging a dead horse.

Me too but there were very few moments of joy and DV for me. I was shouted at, critics and hit, so I am clear that it’s so so so much different for my DC.

Can I ask what it was you were relieved about please? You don’t have to go into detail but was just verbal arguments or worse? Was it constant or sporadic? If you don’t want to share that’s fine 😊

OP posts:
5128gap · 03/12/2023 11:51

Your husband is making a false comparison between his inappropriate behaviour, raised voice, name calling etc when he is 'negative' and you expressing negativity about anything, in an attempt to show you're 'as bad as each other'.
In the highly unlikely event he doesn't understand the difference (unless he's very stupid, he does, and is doing this deliberately) you need to explain.
"DH, its completely unrealistic for either of us to be positive about everything. Negativity about something isn't the problem. It's how we express it that matters. I was calm and polite and wasn't attacking you personally, so there is no comparison to how you behave"

Picturequestion · 03/12/2023 11:50

LittleMissSunshiner · 03/12/2023 11:43

He's distorting what was requested of him (or both of you) in the therapy session.

This might be a genuine error on his part - maybe he's misunderstood the direction?

However, it could be that he's got what I call 'slippery thinking' and is out to use every opportunity to put you down, gain oneupmanship, and put himself in the victim stance. Possibly as retaliation 'look, you're as bad as me'.

However, let's be clear. Stating you don't feel interested in a menu is not the same as losing your temper and being verbally abusive or frightening to others because you feel 'triggered'. Also, you weren't (I assume) being intentionally disparaging in order to push buttons - some people do that as a form of emotional abuse.

I find it hard to be with people who are persistently disparaging as I realise it's a game and it's one where they're constantly trying to keep me on the back foot. If you are being persistently disparaging as a way of gaining agency over a difficult man, then think about that, but it doesn't sound like it to me. Also, is he doing that to you?

This gives you something to work through in your next therapy session as you can explain this incident to the therapist and discuss as a group - they'll be glad of the 'meat' to work with.

I worry from what you've written that perhaps he doesn't have the intelligence or capacity or humility to take on board criticism and make change. Also you're not his parent or caregiver, you're supposed to be his equal and partner, think about that. As people have said above, life isn't meant to be THIS hard and I agree.

Can I recommend you some really great books - a bit old fashioned now but on the subject of Transactional Analysis - 'I'm OK, You're OK' Thomas and Amy Harris, and TA Today, Ian Stewart, Vann Jones. It's about how we interact and what that triggers in the other. I think you'd get a lot out of them - or maybe there's more modern stuff like youtube videos explaining the theories.

Thanks for that carefully thought out reply.

No. I’m not overly negative or disparaging. Wed talked about what was good. I’d mentioned lots that worked well but I had a strong ‘meh’ reaction to one bit. I was just genuinely and lightly expressing my feeling. I wasn’t even being particularly moany. It was a light conversation.

TA has some helpful things. I’ve talked about it with him. I really try hard to stay in adult mode. He isn’t great at it and is either parent (critical) or child (victim of everyone).

He has the intelligence and the motivation. Humility and insight are harder. Very fragile ego. Very easily becomes defensive over very small things. Even an offer of help - e.g me - ‘you’ve been in the go constantly for a few days, why don’t you leave that and I’ll do it later?’ He got all ‘No! I’ve said I’ll do certain tasks and I intend to do them!!’ - like I’d questioned his ability.

He is working on it

OP posts:
YouJustDoYou · 03/12/2023 11:48

Picturequestion · 02/12/2023 21:15

Thank you all.

It’s good to know I’m not being unreasonable.

It is very hard work at the moment and yes, it shouldn’t be.

My massive dilemma is the DC. He does more of the childcare and domestic stuff so it would be at least a 50/50 spilt. Not sure I can cope with not seeing DC half the time. So going to give it my very best shot but I won’t just sit back and take it.

The therapy is just him. I have my own.
He is exploring why he’s like this and facing some uncomfortable truths.

It’s the best we can do currently but working hard at it. I have a deadline.

Kids pick up on it. I WISH my parents had split earlier, and it was a fucking massive relief, even at 8 years old, when they did. They were far better apart and never together again than they were forcing a marriage that was flogging a dead horse.

LittleMissSunshiner · 03/12/2023 11:45

ChateauDuMont · 03/12/2023 11:19

Neither of you can be yourselves in this relationship and working at keeping up a facade is eventually going to end in massive resentment and probably boil over into one of you murdering the other.

It's never going to work.

LOL say it how it is! hehe made me laugh but also pretty sinister.

If anyone's going to murder anyone, I'd like to point out that statistically speaking it's the male who kills the female so for the sake of accuracy, if we're to believe a person could die then it would be the OP herself.

LittleMissSunshiner · 03/12/2023 11:43

He's distorting what was requested of him (or both of you) in the therapy session.

This might be a genuine error on his part - maybe he's misunderstood the direction?

However, it could be that he's got what I call 'slippery thinking' and is out to use every opportunity to put you down, gain oneupmanship, and put himself in the victim stance. Possibly as retaliation 'look, you're as bad as me'.

However, let's be clear. Stating you don't feel interested in a menu is not the same as losing your temper and being verbally abusive or frightening to others because you feel 'triggered'. Also, you weren't (I assume) being intentionally disparaging in order to push buttons - some people do that as a form of emotional abuse.

I find it hard to be with people who are persistently disparaging as I realise it's a game and it's one where they're constantly trying to keep me on the back foot. If you are being persistently disparaging as a way of gaining agency over a difficult man, then think about that, but it doesn't sound like it to me. Also, is he doing that to you?

This gives you something to work through in your next therapy session as you can explain this incident to the therapist and discuss as a group - they'll be glad of the 'meat' to work with.

I worry from what you've written that perhaps he doesn't have the intelligence or capacity or humility to take on board criticism and make change. Also you're not his parent or caregiver, you're supposed to be his equal and partner, think about that. As people have said above, life isn't meant to be THIS hard and I agree.

Can I recommend you some really great books - a bit old fashioned now but on the subject of Transactional Analysis - 'I'm OK, You're OK' Thomas and Amy Harris, and TA Today, Ian Stewart, Vann Jones. It's about how we interact and what that triggers in the other. I think you'd get a lot out of them - or maybe there's more modern stuff like youtube videos explaining the theories.

Bearbookagainandagain · 03/12/2023 11:34

I'm not sure to be honest, it sounds like he wasn't telling you not to give your opinion, he was asking you to word it differently. So instead of saying you don't like that bit, you could have suggested a way to make it better.
I don't think this would come out of a single comment though, he probably feels like you are generally being negative about the all thing which can be a bit frustrating in the long run.

But I agree with others that nothing should be this hard...

Rocksonabeach · 03/12/2023 11:21

You are reasonable. He isn’t. Sound exhausting, controlling and abusive. I wouldn’t want to do anything with him.

ChateauDuMont · 03/12/2023 11:19

Neither of you can be yourselves in this relationship and working at keeping up a facade is eventually going to end in massive resentment and probably boil over into one of you murdering the other.

It's never going to work.

Uncooperativefingers · 03/12/2023 11:04

AutumnFroglets · 03/12/2023 00:55

Then I'm not sure why you are posting. You refuse to leave and want to work on your marriage but he doesn't want to. He's only finding further ammunition via "therapy" to shoot you down so your self confidence and self esteem crumble away until you are too broken. He doesn't go to improve himself or the marriage.

You are not going mad in your thinking regarding the conversation in your op, it's him playing mind games. But you are mad to think this marriage will ever get better than this.

She is posting because she feels like she is in am impossible situation and it can help to get ideas from other to think things through. In the thick of a situation you can't always see the wood for the trees, especially when the situation is going through a period of change.

Just because she isn't jumping to act on the prevailing LTB options does not mean posting is not worthwhile or helpful. She doesn't need to act on any advice given.

BrassOlive · 03/12/2023 10:56

This is a crystal clear example of one of the reasons why couples counselling and mediation are not recommended when you're in an abusive relationship.

The abusing partner will weaponise the language and process against their victim. I'm not sure where you found this therapist but the moment the pair of you disclosed that he's aggressive towards you, his intimate partner, they should have signposted you to domestic abuse services, not taken your money.

ElevenSeven · 03/12/2023 10:45

I think I’d be way more unhappy without seeing DC everyday. There is a hell of a lot more I’d tolerate to be honest, as long as it didn’t effect them.

There’s no way this isn’t already affecting them. What a miserable household to live in, and a terrible model for their own relationships. Leave.

CurlewKate · 03/12/2023 10:02

Relationships should not be hard work. Sometimes external circumstances make things temporarily difficult of course. But usually you should feel at least contentment with the other person. And under no circumstances should either person have to put up with angry outbursts and name calling as a routine thing. Leave.

Haydenn · 03/12/2023 09:54

What are your work arrangements like? Are you being able to do less because of commute time or because of hours? Are you potentially able to look at compressed hours or a flexible working request?

is there something you can look to do over the next 6 months or so to move yourself into a better position? Given how manipulative he sounds I wonder if that is what he has done in order to trap you.

buckeejit · 03/12/2023 09:43

Rereading your posts, it's clear you're not really interested in your husband's happiness right now. That will have an impact on your interactions & will impact your dc if there's tension in the house.

I think you need to be invested in wanting the marriage to work for each other, not just because you want to see dc daily. I'm pretty sure if the situation were the other way round there would be much talk of what's best for dc rather than what their father wants.

Hope you manage to progress things

boscabosco · 03/12/2023 01:28

You are wrong here in the way you have posed the question. His way of expressing himself is different from your way. You don't want him to do it his way and vice versa. You don't need therapy to figure this out. You don't want any LTB. There is a middle ground to be reached, which you both can do do if you both sit and speak to each other.

AutumnFroglets · 03/12/2023 00:55

Then I'm not sure why you are posting. You refuse to leave and want to work on your marriage but he doesn't want to. He's only finding further ammunition via "therapy" to shoot you down so your self confidence and self esteem crumble away until you are too broken. He doesn't go to improve himself or the marriage.

You are not going mad in your thinking regarding the conversation in your op, it's him playing mind games. But you are mad to think this marriage will ever get better than this.

Picturequestion · 03/12/2023 00:03

Amybelle88 · 02/12/2023 23:56

Fuck that.

Way too much stress and grief. What is it that's worth holding onto so much that this much draining work goes into it?

Like I said, I can’t bear the loss of seeing DC every day. I’d get 50/50 maximum so it’s a massive, heartbreaking loss.

If no DC or if I’d have them 80/20 I’d be gone for sure. But he won’t leave (I’ve asked before) and so I would need to leave and I wouldn’t be able to take DC as he does more childcare than me due to work arrangements. I think I’d be way more unhappy without seeing DC everyday. There is a hell of a lot more I’d tolerate to be honest, as long as it didn’t effect them.

OP posts:
Amybelle88 · 02/12/2023 23:56

Fuck that.

Way too much stress and grief. What is it that's worth holding onto so much that this much draining work goes into it?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/12/2023 22:48

Oh, fuck that for a game of soldiers.

The very fact that you have thoughts and voice is enough for him to despise you for them.

If you said 'That's a wonderful idea', it would be wrong because you were being sarcastic, fake, an idiot for thinking that, and a thousand other things that would make you wrong. And if you said you'd rather boil your own eyes than have goat's cheese tarts for a vegetarian option, you'd be wrong because you're being negative, fake, an idiot and a thousand other things. And if you said nothing, you'd be in the wrong. If you made eye contact it would be wrong. If you smiled - wrong and threatening/attacking. No eye contact - wrong. Not smiling - wrong and threatening/attacking.

You cannot do anything right because that is his narrative to legitimise his treatment of you. Referring to the conversation again will be wrong, but he'll probably bring it back up in a few days as an illustration of how awful/stupid/despicable you are. Bet he also chucks in that you're being abusive and controlling.

He's got nothing but contempt for you.

Fuck. That.

Picturequestion · 02/12/2023 22:36

Holidayhell22 · 02/12/2023 21:31

So does your dh want you to lie?
Would he prefer you to say ‘ Oh yes that part is great.’
Then when it goes tits up he can lay the blame at your door.
I would point this out to him. Ask him if he just wants you to lie.

I will talk to him about it again and ask him this. I think he will see that he was being unreasonable.

OP posts:
Picturequestion · 02/12/2023 22:34

PickAChew · 02/12/2023 22:27

He doesn't want you to express an opinion. His.goal for the therapy, unlike yours, is that you learn to stay in your box.

From what he said he is delving into childhood pain and understanding what triggers him and what this then has him doing. I’ll see. I’m keeping a diary and have a deadline. Leaving comes at a huge cost to me. I will be devastated not to see DC every day. It will break my heart. We are doing ok parenting wise and getting on ok as a family and DC seem to be thriving at the moment. I will also loose out financially now and in the future. He has no pension. He will be awarded half of mine. Grossly unfair for reasons I won’t drive into but if I could have DC more, I wouldn’t care about the money but I can’t face that at the moment.

OP posts:
PickAChew · 02/12/2023 22:27

He doesn't want you to express an opinion. His.goal for the therapy, unlike yours, is that you learn to stay in your box.