Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AMA im a perfectionist

30 replies

Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 13:33

This might be the most boring and dull AMA ever but I’ve seen similar before and just thought I’d give it a go!

i’ve been quite an extreme perfectionist since I was a young child and unfortunately still am to this day. Just wondered if anyone had any questions or things they wondered about perfectionism or anything like that?

cheers 🙂

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 15:17

@wishingiwas20something
Sorry, im on my laptop now and for some reason I can't quote your post to reply so just tagging you in this! Hope it works.

I'm really not trying to be obtuse but I dont understand your last sentence at all... I dont think im perfect, where did I say that? perfectionism doesn't mean you think you're perfect- it means you're utterly devastated if you don't achieve whatever unreasonable or unmanageable goal you set yourself.

yeah, that's the entire point- you become obsessed with trying to get perfection but in doing so end up sabotaging yourself and you can't get perfection. With my example about studying for 15+ hours a day- I was obsessed, and I mean obsessed, with getting 100% as I deemed anything less to be failure and awful and worthless etc. And the problem is that sometimes you do achieve 100% which means your brain sort of reiterates to itself that it was correct and it hammers in the idea that perfection is possible. But ultimately it sometimes just isn't, but by that point its so engrained its hard to get out the cycle.

yeah, I studied for 15+ hours a day regularly. But by not taking breaks to do anything else, not letting your brain refresh, not eating proper meals etc its a vicious cycle and you end up doing worse. I frequently collapsed or had breakdowns because I was so terrified of not getting 100% and you end up completely self sabotaging.

I dont know what's worse tbh- achieving whatever unrealistic goal was set and then having your brain think the unhealthy lifestyle is good and so starting a vicious cycle, or not achieving it and being utterly devastated and feeling totally worthless. there's no good outcome tbh

OP posts:
wishingiwas20something · 02/12/2023 15:07

Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 14:35

No- it was lots of different areas of my life I just accidentally used the maths example a few times. I’m not really sure how to answer your question sorry, as I’ve said a few times perfectionism isn’t always just being perfect at absolutely everything. According to what I’ve been told by professionals, it usually manifests in certain areas- for example very successful and talented musicians can be consumed by perfectionism about music and not about sports etc. I’m not sure where you’re getting the personality disorder bit from my posts sorry?

Ok. Which areas of your life are you a perfectionist about? You mention cramming for coursework 15 hours a day, but also that you got a 2:1, are you saying your perfectionism doesn’t reap perfect results - and that makes you anxious? I’m finding it hard to grasp as a concept, because if I thought I was perfect at something (I do not) - would not my results and outcomes be perfect too?

Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 14:35

wishingiwas20something · 02/12/2023 14:25

As others have said your posts do seem a bit slapdash. Is it just maths you’re obsessed with? My view of a perfectionist is someone who applies this level of correctness to all aspects of their life. What you’re describing sounds like OCD and a personality disorder.

No- it was lots of different areas of my life I just accidentally used the maths example a few times. I’m not really sure how to answer your question sorry, as I’ve said a few times perfectionism isn’t always just being perfect at absolutely everything. According to what I’ve been told by professionals, it usually manifests in certain areas- for example very successful and talented musicians can be consumed by perfectionism about music and not about sports etc. I’m not sure where you’re getting the personality disorder bit from my posts sorry?

OP posts:
wishingiwas20something · 02/12/2023 14:25

As others have said your posts do seem a bit slapdash. Is it just maths you’re obsessed with? My view of a perfectionist is someone who applies this level of correctness to all aspects of their life. What you’re describing sounds like OCD and a personality disorder.

Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 14:08

if people don’t believe it they’re absolutely welcome to their opinion and that’s totally fine, but it sort of shows the point of my thread which was that perfectionism isn’t really understood very well as many people think it means you have to perfect at everything and that’s not the case- usually there’s a few areas in life you become obsessed and focused on and you don’t really care if other areas are not perfect

OP posts:
Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 14:07

therealcookiemonster · 02/12/2023 13:56

"perfectionist" doesn't feature on the DSM IV as far as I know and is not a clinical term. Not sure what the mental health professionals meant when they said that meant?

OCD is a known medical condition. have you been diagnosed with this?

I have to say I'm a little confused by your AMA

What is it that confuses you?

yes, I’ve been diagnosed with OCD and anxiety. I was told by a psychiatrist he had never seen quite as strong perfectionism tendencies or something along those lines, and that it’s linked to OCD and childhood trauma etc. I could probably dig out my old letters from up in the attic

OP posts:
Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 14:03

Tiny2018 · 02/12/2023 13:54

I am exactly the same OP. The way my need for perfectionism manifests is having to have my house immaculate, everything in it's place. I also had a terrible childhood, so I really empathise with you.

I wondered if your perfectionism stemmed from a similar place to mine. Sorry you had a bad time growing up. Do you think you will ever change or is this behaviour too ingrained now?

So sorry you’re the same 💐

I don’t think it will ever change, but I live along side it now and don’t let myself get wrapped up in it all. For example, if I were to get 99% now I would tell myself that I tried my best and it’s ok to be disappointed but MOVE ON, and I wouldn’t let myself spiral or get stuck in the cycle of im a failure, I’m worthless, I need to do better next time etc because that’s an awful path to go down x

OP posts:
Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 14:01

nobabiesyet · 02/12/2023 13:41

Does being a perfectionist mean that you are less successful than you would be if you weren't. As I imagine your output might be limited by the need for perfection. Do your friends and family find this trait off putting?

Yeah, absolutely. It’s not as bad now but as a child I would frequently self sabotage by not turning up or avoiding something rather than attending and getting 99% because to me that was awful. As an adult now, I can manage my expectations better but I’m extremely hard on myself at work- I would easily work all lunch and all night if I could just to make sure my work is perfect and I would never leave the office unless I physically forced myself to. It’s definitely better now but was worse as a teenager- i would regularly ghost people because I was studying for up to 15 hours straight so I ignored messages, plans and lost lots of friends which was my own fault, but I was just so obsessed with whatever I was fixated on being perfect

OP posts:
Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 13:56

Waitingfordoggo · 02/12/2023 13:41

Does this cause issues for you? Does it feel like it ever verges into obsessive/compulsive behaviours?

I think I’m a perfectionist and it has caused me to self-sabotage on many occasions- because if I can’t do something perfectly, then why bother?

Also, my perfectionism is selective- I can be really slapdash about some things but ridiculously exacting over small things. It can take me ages to write a shopping list for example, because if it looks messy, I have to start again. Not sure if that is perfectionism or something else though.

Be interesting to hear what forms your perfectionism takes and how it impacts your life.

Yes, you summed it up brilliantly!!

in some areas, I don’t care if I’m perfect or not. But in other areas it’s a horrific obsession. I think it’s related to whatever I was good at as a child, because I had so little to control so they became obsessions and then the connection was just consolidated as I got older.

im NOT like this now thankfully, but as a teenager I was fuelled by anxiety to the extent I nearly ended my life. To me, getting 96% on a maths test meant I had failed, and I was worthless and useless and what the fuck was even the point in being alive? I took an overdose because I was so devastated and angry at myself.

obviously I’m NOT in that bad place now, I’ve since got better thankfully. But the perfectionism tendencies never leave you. I frequently self sabotage without realising it- as a young adult I didn’t turn up for a university test because I felt i wasn’t going to get 100% and it was better not to show up at all. I was heartbroken, genuinely heartbroken at getting a 2:1. I cried all night to the point my face was blistered raw. I have to physically work hard to remind myself that it’s ok not to be perfect otherwise my brain will spiral that it’s awful, I’m a terrible person and so on. I’m definitely better at it now with years of therapy behind me but it’s taken a lot of work

OP posts:
therealcookiemonster · 02/12/2023 13:56

"perfectionist" doesn't feature on the DSM IV as far as I know and is not a clinical term. Not sure what the mental health professionals meant when they said that meant?

OCD is a known medical condition. have you been diagnosed with this?

I have to say I'm a little confused by your AMA

Tiny2018 · 02/12/2023 13:54

I am exactly the same OP. The way my need for perfectionism manifests is having to have my house immaculate, everything in it's place. I also had a terrible childhood, so I really empathise with you.

I wondered if your perfectionism stemmed from a similar place to mine. Sorry you had a bad time growing up. Do you think you will ever change or is this behaviour too ingrained now?

Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 13:50

AlanBrazil · 02/12/2023 13:41

im a perfectionist

No, no you're not.

Like I said, I better tell the therapists, psychologists and psychiatrists who helped me through it that I’m not a perfectionist, because AlanBrazil has said so 🙂

OP posts:
Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 13:49

Veryirritating · 02/12/2023 13:39

i didn’t think a true perfectionist would think that they are a perfectionist.
I was often told by other people I was one but I thought I was chaotic and not good enough

I better tell the therapists, psychologist and psychiatrist they’re all wrong then! It’s anxiety and OCD at the root of it but I was told I have a perfectionist personality type or something like that

OP posts:
Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 13:47

AgnesX · 02/12/2023 13:37

Are you autistic or something like that?
In what way(s) are you a perfectionist and does it come easily? Are you a natural planner?

I don’t know, I’ve never had an assessment and I don’t really show any typical traits but I’m not sure.

I’m definitely driven by anxiety and OCD to be honest. As a child, I could control very little and getting good grades seemed a good way to get approval- I always thought if I did better next time, I would be happier and so on. But it became an obsession. Even as a young adult I was terrified of getting less than 100% in a test- I don’t know why, because by that point I knew nothing bad would happen, but it’s as if the connection in my brain is set in stone that I absolutely had to be perfect at everything

OP posts:
Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 13:43

Tiny2018 · 02/12/2023 13:36

Do you think it's a control issue?

Yeah, it 100% is.

i didn’t appreciate it when I was younger but with hindsight it absolutely is. I had a horrific childhood and the only areas of my life I could control were my weight, my school results and a few other similar things like that. They brought me some small joy and then as I became older became obsessions as it was some control I could have in my life

OP posts:
nobabiesyet · 02/12/2023 13:41

Does being a perfectionist mean that you are less successful than you would be if you weren't. As I imagine your output might be limited by the need for perfection. Do your friends and family find this trait off putting?

Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 13:41

EasterMummie · 02/12/2023 13:35

Come on, you know the first question is going to mention the apostrophe

That’s sort of the thing about perfectionism that not everyone realises- it doesn’t mean you’re a perfectionist in all areas of life. But the things you focus on become hyperfixations. I don’t care if my spelling is poor or my grammar is poor because that’s not really a fixation for me. But in other things I would genuinely have a break down if I made a mistake.

as a teenager I was shit at sports- I didn’t care about being perfect at that. I was last in a race at sports day and wasn’t bothered. But the following week I tried to commit suicide when I got 96% in a maths test.

I think there’s sort of a myth that perfectionists are obsessed with everything being perfect but that’s not usually the case, according to my therapist anyway x

OP posts:
Waitingfordoggo · 02/12/2023 13:41

Does this cause issues for you? Does it feel like it ever verges into obsessive/compulsive behaviours?

I think I’m a perfectionist and it has caused me to self-sabotage on many occasions- because if I can’t do something perfectly, then why bother?

Also, my perfectionism is selective- I can be really slapdash about some things but ridiculously exacting over small things. It can take me ages to write a shopping list for example, because if it looks messy, I have to start again. Not sure if that is perfectionism or something else though.

Be interesting to hear what forms your perfectionism takes and how it impacts your life.

AlanBrazil · 02/12/2023 13:41

im a perfectionist

No, no you're not.

Veryirritating · 02/12/2023 13:39

i didn’t think a true perfectionist would think that they are a perfectionist.
I was often told by other people I was one but I thought I was chaotic and not good enough

Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 13:38

PosteriorPosterity · 02/12/2023 13:36

Wrong board, poor grammar. You might be the world’s worst perfectionist!

I mean, that’s quite nasty considering I’ve already addressed that in my first comment!

OP posts:
MissingMoominMamma · 02/12/2023 13:38

I’m not a perfectionist, but I would have to go back and edit what you’ve typed before pressing post… 😬.

Perfectionisttt · 02/12/2023 13:38

SleepingStandingUp · 02/12/2023 13:34

In what was does it affect your relationships?

it definitely caused problems as a teenager and young adult. I was so obsessed with certain aspects of my life being perfect that I completely lost track of other areas. For example, I lost many friends over the years because I was utterly consumed by studying and completely distanced myself from them. I’ve had to make a conscious effort to maintain relationships because I get so overly consumed by whatever I’m focused on at the time. It also caused problems because it made me accidentally behave like an asshole- eg, me being completely devastated at getting 99% which was genuine upset from me, but in front of friends who got 75% is obviously extremely insensitive and definitely put a lot of people off me, which is my own fault for not realising how insensitive i was being x

OP posts:
debbrianna · 02/12/2023 13:37

What is your definition of a perfectionist?

AgnesX · 02/12/2023 13:37

Are you autistic or something like that?
In what way(s) are you a perfectionist and does it come easily? Are you a natural planner?