Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If social contact results in higher longevity, what about introverts?

69 replies

malificent7 · 02/12/2023 12:13

Or those with toxic family?
Watching the blue zones with interest.
I am in awe of those people in the med socialising with generations of family.

I am in introvert with. difficult family. Luckily I have a lovely dh and I do have great colleagues atm. I love me time though.
Am i going to live a shorter life if I don't want to socialise as much and prefer distance from family?
In the past I had toxic friends, does socialising with them shorten life!?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Firefly2009 · 05/12/2023 09:51

Not many people in the western world live a blue zones life.

it’s also missing some info IMO

For example, the fact that us introverts should probably just surround ourselves with cats. Pets are good for your health too, and people suck more.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 05/12/2023 05:58

Gwenhwyfar · 04/12/2023 18:30

You said " too am in my sixties and there has been a very long list of so called good/bad for you things over my lifetime - and yes, what is bad one year suddenly becomes good the next."

Which I took to mean that you don't follow health advice because it can change.

I would have thought it was obvious to anyone with a grain of common sense that I wasn't talking about something as harmful as smoking. However, as we all know, common sense isn't actually very common.

Gwenhwyfar · 04/12/2023 18:30

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 04/12/2023 06:10

Did I mention smoking? There's always someone who has to try and prove how smart they are Hmm

You said " too am in my sixties and there has been a very long list of so called good/bad for you things over my lifetime - and yes, what is bad one year suddenly becomes good the next."

Which I took to mean that you don't follow health advice because it can change.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 04/12/2023 06:10

Gwenhwyfar · 03/12/2023 09:58

Let's just smoke ourselves to death then.
After all it was considered good for you at one point.

Did I mention smoking? There's always someone who has to try and prove how smart they are Hmm

Nofilteritwonthelp · 03/12/2023 17:47

I saw so many people withdraw after lockdown. It aged so many older people. Isolation is not good

eujk · 03/12/2023 17:44

My grandpa is a 92yo introvert from a Mediterranean country. He doesn't have many friends and doesn't talk too much but he still meets his neighbours everyday. He's close to his family, but only those members that he likes.

Socialising in Mediterranean countries just feels so natural and it's not only about meeting family. In fact, a lot of friends and neighbours are as present in your life as family.

mantyzer · 03/12/2023 17:25

The research about the health impact of social isolation is pretty robust.

Thepeopleversuswork · 03/12/2023 11:11

@Ginmonkeyagain

However I find the whole "too peopley" meme a bit disturbing. At its heart it is a basic contempt for people and failure to understand we all need this interconnected society that relies on the labour and co operation of others to live a decent and safe life. The cogs of this "machine" are humans who deserve repect and interaction.

I totally agree. It’s really horrible and I loathe the way people lean into it as some sort of in joke. Stop indulging pathological behaviour.

Ginmonkeyagain · 03/12/2023 10:46

In previous centuries society relied a lot more on in person co operation. You needed to be very very rich or care little for even the most basic comforts or personal security to "go your own way".

Those people who enable you to live a comfortable and safe life are still there but distance and tech means you don't really have to forge co operative relationships with them.

However I find the whole "too peopley" meme a bit disturbing. At its heart it is a basic contempt for people and failure to understand we all need this interconnected society that relies on the labour and co operation of others to live a decent and safe life. The cogs of this "machine" are humans who deserve repect and interaction.

This attituded manisfested itself during covid with people loftily declaring it wasn't too hard to stay indoors to avoid covid and people who didn't clearly weren't serious about protecting themselves. With little apprent thought for those who did need to leave the house to keep the whole show on the road.

Thepeopleversuswork · 03/12/2023 10:34

@Gwenhwyfar

I get your point about social cohesion, but I think you should accept too that putting an onus on socialising does favour some people over others.

I do think the way socialising is promoted in a lot of workplaces at the moment is very unhelpful. "Team building" exercises such as paintballing, team sports and the need to overshare with colleagues. I can totally understand how more withdrawn and less confident people struggle with this. I'm a pretty socially confident person and I find it absolutely cringeworthy and avoid it if I can. Workplaces really need to rethink this approach.

But that doesn't change the fact that some social collaboration is necessary in any community and being an "introvert" (ie not really an introvert) isn't a get out of jail free card that allows you carte blanche to totally disengage from society.

Gwenhwyfar · 03/12/2023 10:27

". Imagine a government run by ministers who “hate people” and refuse to come in to work."

I've worked with a few techies who are like that. Obviously, they come into work, but avoid contact as much as possible and don't communicate that well. However, it's so common among them that I think there's a certain tolerance for it.

I get your point about social cohesion, but I think you should accept too that putting an onus on socialising does favour some people over others.

EmpressaurusOfCats · 03/12/2023 10:22

I like my work team & we sometimes socialise through choice.

Socialising with the wider company is another matter. I’ve made sure I’m free for the team Christmas lunch but I’m sadly double booked for the company Christmas party.

Thepeopleversuswork · 03/12/2023 10:06

@Gwenhwyfar

Its true that a lot of workplaces and schools do things to encourage socialisation. But I don’t see that as being about favouring extroverts. It’s about supporting cohesion within teams, which is really pretty critical for a well functioning organisation.

I think sometimes this goes too far and the kinds “team building” antics some go in for are cheesy and uncomfortable for some people and there are more intelligent ways to do it.

But there’s no getting away from the fact that most companies, bodies and businesses require people to work together to some degree. Imagine a government run by ministers who “hate people” and refuse to come in to work.

You simply can’t allow everyone to opt out of any social interaction on the grounds that they self identify as an “introvert”.

Gwenhwyfar · 03/12/2023 09:58

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 02/12/2023 19:35

Aint that the truth! I too am in my sixties and there has been a very long list of so called good/bad for you things over my lifetime - and yes, what is bad one year suddenly becomes good the next. Those of us with a grain of common sense just carry on with life as usual - and somehow most of us manage to survive.

Let's just smoke ourselves to death then.
After all it was considered good for you at one point.

Gwenhwyfar · 03/12/2023 09:57

"See I take issue with this: this is the prevailing narrative but I just don't buy this story. "

Well, look at schools. In our parents or grandparents' time it was each child behind a solo desk. By the 80s it was all about sitting in groups and sometimes group work and projects. Offices are increasingly becoming open plan. Refusing to participate in team building and socialising is frowned upon, promotions and advantages are often given to the popular (depending on the sector of course).

"I have both introvert and extrovert tendencies."

Most of us probably do.
I personally spent way too much time identifying as an introvert because of this 'energy' thing and then realising I don't have much in common with others who call themselves introverts.

pickledandpuzzled · 02/12/2023 20:45

The ‘outside world’ has become maddeningly overstimulating. In the past it was polite not to inflict yourself noisily on those around you.

Now music, lights, loud conversations, swearing… it’s so, so noisy.

I was outgoing as a youngster. The world has got so loud and intrusive though

I’m happier at home, quietly, now. I don’t go to anywhere busy. The whole ‘it’s too peopley out there’ trope fits me.

The world is heaving! I’m trying to move to the country.

Random30 · 02/12/2023 19:56

malificent7 · 02/12/2023 12:13

Or those with toxic family?
Watching the blue zones with interest.
I am in awe of those people in the med socialising with generations of family.

I am in introvert with. difficult family. Luckily I have a lovely dh and I do have great colleagues atm. I love me time though.
Am i going to live a shorter life if I don't want to socialise as much and prefer distance from family?
In the past I had toxic friends, does socialising with them shorten life!?

I think it’s more subtle than that.

Introverts all things being equal probably do live shorter lives because they have a different quality of friendship compared to others.

Among the introverts I know, none of them would I feel in a position to say “I think you should get that checked out”. Whereas among the friendships, where someone is not worried about whether I need a saucer this is a possibility.

Also, introverted people are less likely to seek help either when they first get sick, or during recuperation. Therefore they have poorer outcomes.

I think quality is important in friendships, toxic friendships (with addicts, and personality disorders) of course they’re going to be life shortening.

Malarandras · 02/12/2023 19:43

Not all introverts are created equal, so to speak. I did one of those personality type tests for work recently and I am nearly 100% introverted, some people that were ‘labelled’ introverted were only 51% introverted. I have very few friends, and a fairly small family. I don’t value friendship that highly and I’m perfectly happy to spend very long periods alone. If someone made me socialise most days I’m more likely to die early, I suspect. The trick is to figure out what works for you as an individual.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 02/12/2023 19:35

Fairyliz · 02/12/2023 19:31

I would take this ‘research’ with a pinch of salt.
I’m in my sixties and over the years I have heard so many things that are supposed to be good/bad for you. The thing is they often change from one to another and then back again.
Im convinced it’s mainly genes that determine how long you will last.

Aint that the truth! I too am in my sixties and there has been a very long list of so called good/bad for you things over my lifetime - and yes, what is bad one year suddenly becomes good the next. Those of us with a grain of common sense just carry on with life as usual - and somehow most of us manage to survive.

Fairyliz · 02/12/2023 19:31

I would take this ‘research’ with a pinch of salt.
I’m in my sixties and over the years I have heard so many things that are supposed to be good/bad for you. The thing is they often change from one to another and then back again.
Im convinced it’s mainly genes that determine how long you will last.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 02/12/2023 19:31

I have no family, other than an exDH, I only work in a casual role now, and I live alone. However, every day I go out walking and at some stage interact with someone on that walk, even if just to say Hi, or I talk to people in shops. I also take an interest in what is happening in my town. I don't have lots of friends locally, but do catch up with people for coffee or lunch. That, to me, is social contact, and I would hate to be without it, but I have never felt it necessary to be constantly with other people. I am far more happy and content than many people and think that is more likely to result in higher longevity than being a social butterfly.

Btw, what makes you think introverts = hermits?

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/12/2023 19:27

Gwenhwyfar · 02/12/2023 19:00

" We'll look back at those in decades to come and see those as a particular low for our society."

You might be right, but I do think it's partly a response to how extroverts have been lauded for the last few decades.

See I take issue with this: this is the prevailing narrative but I just don't buy this story. I think it's a grotesque oversimplification and a mislabelling of what's happening.

Confident people (not necessarily extroverts) have an evolutionary advantage. In the days of hunter gathering and in early human history these were the people who became leaders and told people what to do and over time those traits have tended to be plentiful in people who lead. These are people with authority, but not all of them are extroverts. It's true that extroverts sometimes have a superficial advantage in social situations because this is their natural environment but they are not necessarily leaders or in control. Often they are social butterflies and quite a lot of them are massive people pleasers. They frequently are the people who you notice first in a group but by no means always the ones with the most authority. (A lot of really extrovert people I know are alcoholics, btw).

Introverts (as others have pointed out) can sometimes be shy and uncomfortable but more often they are people with inner confidence who just need time out from social situations to be themselves.

For complex social reasons in recent years (and I'll leave COVID but that was a huge trigger) a disparate group of people who don't feel they fit in have rebranded themselves as "introverts" (largely inaccurately), because they think it makes them sound more interesting/deep. I presume because it makes them feel they now have a "tribe". It's become cool.

And like all tribes, you have to define yourself by finding an "other" (in this case "extroverts" (who usually aren't extroverts either) so they spend a lot of time talking about how they've all been sold down the river by dreaded "extroverts" because society has ganged up on them. I've read thread after thread with people calling themselves "introverts" and by and large they are not: they are people who are shy/anxious/pissed off/grumpy who think being an "introvert" sounds more interesting.

I think most of this is just people with a chip on their shoulder, grasping at straws. Of course the world is easier for the confident: this is hardly news. But the binary distinction between "introverts" and "extroverts" as if there were some conspiracy against quiet and contemplative people seems really paranoid. And it worries me a bit because I hear people on here and IRL talking about their "introversion" in the language of the radicalised. It's fine to be quiet or withdrawn but talking about yourself as if you are some oppressed ethnic group is a bit nuts.

And btw I'm kind of an ambivert. I have both introvert and extrovert tendencies.

Badbadbunny · 02/12/2023 19:07

Dilbertian · 02/12/2023 12:22

An introvert can still enjoy social contact and get all the benefits she needs from it - but social contact on the level that is satisfying for her.

Social contact does not have to be raucous fun and massive chitchat. Even sitting in contented, companionable silence is social contact.

I fully agree! I think there's too much of an assumption that social contact has to be loud, exciting, etc and I think that's what puts a lot of "quieter" people off doing things and going places, and that expectation seems to get worse over time.

All you need to do is look at TV game shows. If you watch the Bullseye from the 80s, most of the contestants are "quiet" yet watch a modern game show and they're all loud, bright, attention seeking types.

Gwenhwyfar · 02/12/2023 19:01

Hbh17 · 02/12/2023 18:24

As an introvert, I'd be happy to kick the bucket at any point and then I never have to worry about other people EVER again. What a great result! Living to be 70 or 80 plus would be my idea of hell, so any time in the next 10 years will be fine.

Introverted or depressed? Your attitude doesn't sound healthy.

Gwenhwyfar · 02/12/2023 19:00

" We'll look back at those in decades to come and see those as a particular low for our society."

You might be right, but I do think it's partly a response to how extroverts have been lauded for the last few decades.