Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbours banging wall at night

267 replies

beebumble552 · 02/12/2023 09:14

Just looking for opinions on this, I don’t think we are in the wrong but I’m struggling to understand why neighbours are acting this way.

My 16 month old is going through a bad sleep regression and teething. It means 2am and we are awake with lots of tears. I go straight in and try to calm things down but it can take a while at the minute so it might go on for about 30 minutes and worst case scenario an hour on and off.

im trying everything I can to settle them but now my neighbours have started banging the wall, I presume to let us know they have been woken. Which I understand is frustrating but I’m not sure what they are wanting to achieve.

are they just horrible people, should I say something? They haven’t liked us since we moved in due to Diy during the day in the first month we moved however not during unsociable hours.

aibu to be annoyed or are they?

OP posts:
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 02/12/2023 13:29

Womencanlift · 02/12/2023 10:24

Do not give them ear plugs as a “gift”, that is just a passive aggressive move

I agree. If someone did that to me when I was tired and grumpy anyway I'd be telling them to shove their ear plugs!

Puddypuds · 02/12/2023 13:29

Awful neighbours! When ours were having long term issues with their little boy I saw our neighbour and asked if she was doing ok. He was screaming through the night. Her first reaction was to apologise but I let her know that I was absolutely not complaining. Just checking they were all ok as he was about two. Turns out he has a serious medical condition which caused pain particularly at night.
Your neighbours don't sound great but maybe broaching it with them might make them a bit more tolerant.

CustardySergeant · 02/12/2023 13:18

It may be one of their teenagers doing the banging.

TheHouseElf · 02/12/2023 13:16

Is there anyway you can re-arrange your bedrooms so child's bed/cot isn't against your party wall - if it currently is? Think it would be best for neighbour relations if you went and talked to them, or at least dropped off a note, to apologise and explain about the noise disturbance.

This situation will pass, but while its there, maybe best to take your little one downstairs and try and lessen the disturbance on your neighbours.

SurelySmartie · 02/12/2023 13:00

This isn’t a unique situation.

Nothing you can say will make them understand,

They probably do understand having children of their own and yes babies crying is normal. But your neighbours have the right to an undisturbed night’s sleep. This may be impacting not just on the quality of their life but their abilities to do their jobs. It could be driving them to distraction and impacting on their health. Regardless of whether a baby is a ‘non verbal human’.

There probably are other options to try (downstairs, same room) but these are more of an inconvenience for op and partner…

vivainsomnia · 02/12/2023 12:55

They knock because they are so frustrated. Can't you understand that. 1/2 h to 1 hour crying is very long. Why is your baby at 16 months old crying like that? Is he poorly.

And yes, you shouldn't expect them to cope with your inconvenience. Your priority should be to stop your baby crying and ensure the least impact on your neighbour. It's your issue, not theirs.

Mummymummy89 · 02/12/2023 12:54

LaurieStrode · 02/12/2023 12:40

She should not adapt her parenting to the needs of another adult.

This sums up the whole problem with today's parents. No one matters beyond their household.

I agree.

The op hasn't gone into detail about how she soothes her child beyond just "going in". Whatever she is/isn't doing, taking 30mins to soothe at that age is quite long: even my perennially-sleepless dd wouldn't scream for that long at that age. It's beyond the colic age.

Is op using calpol to soothe the teething pain? Co sleeping? Breastfeeding? Teething powder?

Her current strategy is ineffectual and the neighbours know this and have got fed up.

LaurieStrode · 02/12/2023 12:47

Justaquickthankyoumessage · 02/12/2023 11:17

Don't give them gifts or mess up your night by taking your toddler downstairs in the night. How does that help you settle them?

If they want to live somewhere without neighbour noise then they need to buy a detached house. If they can't afford to then they need to suck up hearing neighbour noise. It's a crying baby, not an all night raver.

They don't even have the decency to knock during the day and talk to you, they just bang on the wall, it's aggressive and shouldn't be encouraged. "They must be exhausted"?? They're not the ones actually getting up with a toddler. OP is the exhausted one who should show compassion to their neighbours despite their neighbours not showing compassion to them? No.

But that goes both ways. What if they decide to create a loud disturbance on their side, maybe around midnight. Loud sex, a shouty game, loud "argument" night after night. Waking the baby.

Wonder how many would empathize.

They've endured 16 months and only complained recently. I think they're pretty kind overall.

Lochness1975 · 02/12/2023 12:45

My last house was hell with a baby. Trying to get up and drive anything up to 4 hours for work after zero sleep, then work all day was so difficult, I used to feel sick as I was so tired. It then went to toddler screeching and crying at night. I eventually moved. I now get a full nights sleep with peaceful neighbours.

For the record I do have children, but we’d take our downstairs if they woke crying, so that neighbours weren’t disturbed.

Chipsatsunset · 02/12/2023 12:44

Having the baby hand over the chocolates is pretty manipulative. It doesn't solve the sleep deprivation issues.

but nothing is going to solve the sleep deprivation. Chocolates are a small acknowledgement that it’s not fun for them to have to put up with. And ok, OP can hand them to neighbour themselves.

LaurieStrode · 02/12/2023 12:40

She should not adapt her parenting to the needs of another adult.

This sums up the whole problem with today's parents. No one matters beyond their household.

LaurieStrode · 02/12/2023 12:38

Well said, @NoTouch

Having the baby hand over the chocolates is pretty manipulative. It doesn't solve the sleep deprivation issues.

Chipsatsunset · 02/12/2023 12:34

I would tackle it head on by going round and sympathising about their disturbed sleep. It’s hard enough being woken up and kept awake by our own babies, who we love. Another persons baby crying, however normal and just a phase, isn’t pleasant to have to cope with.

i would take your little one with you (being able to put a face to the howling can help them see your baby as a little person, rather than just a screeching noise). I would tell them you know they must be so tired and fed up, but that you are doing absolutely everything you can to settle your little one as quickly as you can. If you can bring yourself to give your toddler a little box of chocolates to hand to them, it would be a hard person who wouldn’t feel a little bit better about the situation. This is no nobody’s fault, but empathy and recognition that this can’t be fun for them, can make a huge difference.

NoTouch · 02/12/2023 12:32

HaddawayAndShite · 02/12/2023 12:16

Until they act like the adults they supposedly are, I would be doing sweet fuck all. If there is a problem they can come and speak to you like grown ups and you work out an amicable solution or agreement together. You don’t bang on a wall like an absolute caveman and expect to get results.

Pot kettle black? NDNs bang on the wall for the first time out of pure frustration, as this is the 2nd/3rd night of being woken by ongoing crying and not being able to do anything else when in bed at 2am. They hope it lets the OP know they are being disturbed and the OP takes action the next night. The OP doesn't and they bang again to let OP know they are being disturbed again, or because they think the OP didn't hear the first time as nothing changed, again its 2am so nothing else they can do and hoping the OP is considerate and takes action.

Why on earth do they also need to speak to the OP, the OP heard, the OP knows they are repeatedly disturbing their NDNs for significant periods of time in the middle of the night but chooses to do nothing about it. That isn't very grown up either. The OPs household is the one that is causing the problem and should be the grown up dealing with it.

Greenfinch7 · 02/12/2023 12:32

The neighbours might not realise that you are trying to comfort the baby and might think you are just ignoring the crying. I would tel them you are trying...

(Just as an aside, I know that many people don't agree with this, but our 3 all slept with us and breastfed at night when they woke and they never cried for more than a moment, except under extraordinary circumstances.)

GuitarGeorgina · 02/12/2023 12:18

Chances are that they’re not horrible people just very tired ones at the end of their tether with broken sleep. Nobody is at their most rational or forgiving if disturbed in the night.

i think the idea of an apologetic and friendly note with an offer to chat over a cup of tea is an excellent one.

and don’t suggest they get earplugs! They can work that out for themselves and it will probably piss them off. And it is true that not not everyone can wear them (I can’t).

HaddawayAndShite · 02/12/2023 12:16

Until they act like the adults they supposedly are, I would be doing sweet fuck all. If there is a problem they can come and speak to you like grown ups and you work out an amicable solution or agreement together. You don’t bang on a wall like an absolute caveman and expect to get results.

waytooearlyforthis · 02/12/2023 12:12

The OP should absolutely NOT use a dummy if she doesn’t want to. She should not adapt her parenting to the needs of another adult. When you were a baby, how did you express your needs? Verbally? No. By crying. It’s a fact of human development that we need to express our needs by crying. It’s evolution and survival and can not nor should not be suppressed. The adults with fully developed brains should learn to regulate themselves, adapt and use their fully developed frontal cortex to do some rationale thinking. Not aggressively attack parents for doing …. Parenting!!!

Really ridiculous comment the next door neighbours don't have to pander to the parents decisions to have children. The neighbours may have particular needs that means they need more sleep e.g epilepsy. The world does not revolve around children I think some adults forget that there needs to be compromise all round and if it's been going on for a while and the neighbours have only just started complaining I think they've done their fair share of putting up with it

Reallybadidea · 02/12/2023 12:12

I think you should speak to them, apologise and reassure them that you're doing everything you can to stop her crying in the night. There's not much more you can practically do really. I sympathise with them hugely, but some level of disturbance is inevitable when you live in a house with an adjoining wall. You can't get through life without being inconvenienced by other people in some way, most people are trying their best I think.

LittleMissSunshiner · 02/12/2023 12:03

I would write a note and say sorry the baby's crying at night he's only little but the banging isn't helping and makes it worse.

If you'd like to come round for a chat and think of solutions then please come for a cuppa tea.

Personally, when I live in places with party walls that transmit neighbour noise easily I get a) fed up of hearing them and b) paranoid they can hear my every move. Usually I use that wall for the wardrobe or a bookshelf to block sound.

I've got a friend being badly bothered by noise and also wonder if a simple and effective 'fix' is to mount some kind of plasterboard or fire proof MDF with a layer of dense foam or polystyrene or something behind it.

mummyh2016 · 02/12/2023 11:55

How long has it been going on for? I know you've mentioned this week has been worse but has it been going on for weeks/months? You need to take baby downstairs to minimise the noise. Yes it inconveniences you but it's your baby, not your neighbours. A couple of nights yes you can put up with it. But if it's been for weeks/months they have been putting up with it if the banging has only just started. Of course it's not the right way to deal with it, and they are being unreasonable to bang. You're angry. If they'd knocked onto complain about it though would you be angry or feeling guilty? It would've been nicer for them to knock of course but depending on how your response was when they complained about the DIY noise they may not have been that keen to.

User123456713 · 02/12/2023 11:54

Sorry if this has been mentioned before but why don't you just move the cot etc into your room?
Or move the pair of you downstairs for a while?

Seems the obvious thing to do until this stage is over.

Or would that wake your partner and he wants an undisturbed night.... mmmm.

Picturequestion · 02/12/2023 11:48

margotrose · 02/12/2023 11:30

She may not be doing anything wrong but the noise is still causing a problem for her neighbours so she needs to do as much as possible to prevent that.

She’s comforting the baby. That’s all she needs to do.

Onlinetherapist · 02/12/2023 11:45

I feel sorry for my adjoining neighbours (even though they are absolutely horrible people). My baby had silent reflux and screamed 24/7 only sleeping for between 5-45 minutes at a time. This went on for months. He was never left alone to cry, I paced with him day and night, but he screamed anyway. My neighbours never once complained (they just complained about everything else!)

m00rfarm · 02/12/2023 11:39

I have just realised from reading posts that Picturequestion is not capable of "rationale" thought, as she only comes from one perspective. Everyone else who has sympathy for the neighbours, ALSO has sympathy for the mother and toddler. Not Picturequestion. So I am now discounting her responses to this post.