Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel RAGE against schools lack of care towards working parents?

654 replies

Stormy900 · 02/12/2023 07:42

I'm so, so angry!!!!
I'm a working parent.
I'm a nurse, so I can't WFH.
Why oh why oh why do primary schools set ALL their plays and productions during school hours when I, and so many other parents I know, are AT WORK!!!!
WHY don't schools factor this in????
My DC has a Christmas performance coming up and it is really important to him and to me that I'm there, it would fill my heart with absolute joy to see him. But school only informed us of the date 10 days ago. I have requested to take annual leave to attend it, but it has been refused by my manager because there are other colleagues on annual leave that day who have already requested, and I've been told my request is too short notice, but I've only recently been informed of the date by school. I'm absolutely heartbroken to not be able to attend. If I'd been given much more notice, I could have attended.
Also, another issue is HOW LITTLE NOTICE schools give parents about dates for events that parents are invited to. Sports day, parents being invited in to see DC's work and class displays, summer shows, Easter performances, class assemblies where my DC have speaking parts, and of course Christmas events. The school tells us no more than 2 weeks in advance maximum. Why?????
In my job, A/L has to be requested SIX WEEKS in advance because of staff rotas.
And don't get me started on children being given award certificates in assembly each week, which parents are invited to watch and the teachers TELL THE CHILDREN THEIR PARENTS ARE INVITED....they invite parents on the afternoon of THE DAY BEFORE THE CERTIFICATE ASSEMBLY!!!!
On Monday, school sent an email to me at 3pm, which I didn't pick up because I was managing a blood transfusion for a critically ill patient, so I picked it up later that day, as I can't access my emails as soon as they come in if I'm working. The invite was for 9am THE NEXT DAY!!!
There was no way I could attend at this level of short notice, as I was due to be at work the next morning, starting at 7am.
My little DD cried and cried. She said she wanted me there more than anything.
I have missed sooooooo many primary school events for my 2 DC because of horrific short notice from school. If I'd had dates in advance I could have attended them all.
WHY do schools do this???
They MUST KNOW what dates they're going to do events on. I simply refuse to believe they don't. They MUST have to plan their school calendar, activities, shows, performances, awards, in advance.
WHY do they assume all parents are eithet stay at home mothers or are in WFH jobs??
I'm SO angry!!!

OP posts:
mantyzer · 03/12/2023 21:13

@AllProperTeaIsTheft yep it is nothing to do with the teachers that multiple daytime events leaves some children upset.
That is what I mean when I say teachers really do not care about the crying and upset kids. Its always not my monkey.

OldPerson · 03/12/2023 21:10

Schools are staffed by real people you can communicate with. And no working parent has enough annual leave to be at every single precious event. Work out what you really want to be there for and communicate with the school. Look at your a/l and any ability to swap shifts and then make choices. Also look at wider family - dad, grandparents, aunts, uncles, childminders - to be there on occasions, when you can't. You sound a bit like you want everyone to run to your rescue and organize their life around you, instead of working out what you can do. The primary focus of a school is to teach and support children - not parents. And if you're a single parent without any family nearby, build a small team around your child, with parents of your child's friends, so your child gets recognized and cheered on by a team. Your child shouldn't be crying. Because the majority of children have working parents who obviously can't be there for everything.

poohsticks30 · 03/12/2023 20:45

Whilst I get it is really hard with late notice your expectations are unreasonable. You would like class teachers, support staff and leadership to spend multiple nights a year(on top of parents evenings) away from their family so you don’t have to miss work. These staff would most likely not be paid to do so while being in the same position of not being able to see their own kids. Educators are there to educate and will always try to support parents where they can but they are people too and shouldn’t have to work masses of overtime for performances/events.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 03/12/2023 20:44

@beforethecoffeegetscold I do not think a lot of teachers do get it. A lot seem to assume there will be another family member who can attend. I got asked about grandparents and Aunts a lot. My in laws were very elderly and could not go anywhere without carers, and even that was extremely difficult. My parents were both working full time and also had to give a fair bit of notice for annual leave. I did not have other people who could just attend something in the middle of the day with 2 weeks notice.
And I think a lot of teachers do not get this because apart from teaching they are used to family who do more middle class jobs that inherently have more flexibility.

It really isn't that teachers 'don't get it'. They invite parents, knowing full well that not all will be able to come. If you complain that you can't come, yes they might make the suggestion that another family member might be able to come. It's just a suggestion, they're being polite and letting you know that relatives other than parents are allowed to attend. Obviously it might not be possible. What else do you want them to do? As has been pointed out, teachers do get it, because they often can't attend their own dc's events. Ultimately it really isn't the school's fault or their problem if you can't attend.

echt · 03/12/2023 20:32

mantyzer · 03/12/2023 19:44

@beforethecoffeegetscold I do not think a lot of teachers do get it. A lot seem to assume there will be another family member who can attend. I got asked about grandparents and Aunts a lot. My in laws were very elderly and could not go anywhere without carers, and even that was extremely difficult. My parents were both working full time and also had to give a fair bit of notice for annual leave. I did not have other people who could just attend something in the middle of the day with 2 weeks notice.
And I think a lot of teachers do not get this because apart from teaching they are used to family who do more middle class jobs that inherently have more flexibility.

This is not the teachers not getting it, they're just being inclusive, making suggestions about other possible family members.

They do not choose to do things at the last moment, that's HT level.

Sherrystrull · 03/12/2023 20:15

So what should schools do @mantyzer?

CaptainMyCaptain · 03/12/2023 20:15

mantyzer · 03/12/2023 19:49

Anyway you will still get the same kids upset throughout the year at no one being able or in some cases willing to attend anything at the school. And teachers will keep on igno0ring or minimising the children's upset to cater to the middle class SAHM who love going up the school regularly.
And I genuinely think no one apart from my kids family cared about their upset.

Do you bother to read any of the posts from teachers explaining why these events happen and that they do care? I'm retired now but I would have been very happy not to do most of these events and, as a single parent myself, I would not have wanted to do evening events instead.

neverbeenskiing · 03/12/2023 20:08

mantyzer · 03/12/2023 18:58

I agree parents expectations are unrealistic. I disagree that having an event every few weeks during school time where parents are invited is okay.
I am not asking for teachers to do more work, I am asking for less. There is no reason except OFSTED to invite parents in for example to look at the work your child has been doing on a particular project - with each child given the job of explaining to their parent what they are doing.

But, like it or not, OFSTED's expectations matter. Schools just can't ignore it even if we fully agree with you that it's pointless box ticking.

Jack80 · 03/12/2023 20:06

I would comment to the school re getting dates in advance for future reference

mantyzer · 03/12/2023 20:05

@Maxus I have never once said all these events should be in the evening. Not once.
But you are right, it is put on because some parents can make it and love them. It is not about what is best for the children. No other practice would be accepted if it routinely left children upset.

beforethecoffeegetscold · 03/12/2023 20:04

mantyzer · 03/12/2023 19:44

@beforethecoffeegetscold I do not think a lot of teachers do get it. A lot seem to assume there will be another family member who can attend. I got asked about grandparents and Aunts a lot. My in laws were very elderly and could not go anywhere without carers, and even that was extremely difficult. My parents were both working full time and also had to give a fair bit of notice for annual leave. I did not have other people who could just attend something in the middle of the day with 2 weeks notice.
And I think a lot of teachers do not get this because apart from teaching they are used to family who do more middle class jobs that inherently have more flexibility.

Yes it's definitely true that a lot of presumptions can be made that all children have Grandparents who can be involved. My parents were in their early twenties when I was born, so even though I was in my thirties when I started my own family, my parents were still nowhere near retirement age and working full time jobs!

Maxus · 03/12/2023 20:02

These things take place during the school day because that's when children and teachers are in school. They organise things to share with parents, why should other parents miss out just because you carnt go. Also who is going to pay the caretaker to lock up late? The cleaners who get the school ready for the next day? The heating bills etc just to keep some parents happy? I'm sure the OP and mantyzer won't we willing to play these extra costs.

mantyzer · 03/12/2023 19:59

@Sherrystrull a teacher not that far above yours has said she gets it because she could never attend, so her DH or mum always had to attend. She does not get it. It is very different if one parent can never attend versus nobody at all ever attending. If My DH and mum could attend I would have been fine.

LeggyLegsEleven · 03/12/2023 19:57

I get schools do it for ‘engagement’ but the thing is I didn’t feel very engaged by the events they did. I think a lot of them contributed to having a poor relationship with school.
The exception was DDs nursery teacher who was utterly amazing at this kind of thing and I still think fondly of her.

Maxus · 03/12/2023 19:53

mantyzer · 03/12/2023 19:49

Anyway you will still get the same kids upset throughout the year at no one being able or in some cases willing to attend anything at the school. And teachers will keep on igno0ring or minimising the children's upset to cater to the middle class SAHM who love going up the school regularly.
And I genuinely think no one apart from my kids family cared about their upset.

Sigh

Sherrystrull · 03/12/2023 19:52

mantyzer · 03/12/2023 19:44

@beforethecoffeegetscold I do not think a lot of teachers do get it. A lot seem to assume there will be another family member who can attend. I got asked about grandparents and Aunts a lot. My in laws were very elderly and could not go anywhere without carers, and even that was extremely difficult. My parents were both working full time and also had to give a fair bit of notice for annual leave. I did not have other people who could just attend something in the middle of the day with 2 weeks notice.
And I think a lot of teachers do not get this because apart from teaching they are used to family who do more middle class jobs that inherently have more flexibility.

That's quite an assumption.

mantyzer · 03/12/2023 19:49

Anyway you will still get the same kids upset throughout the year at no one being able or in some cases willing to attend anything at the school. And teachers will keep on igno0ring or minimising the children's upset to cater to the middle class SAHM who love going up the school regularly.
And I genuinely think no one apart from my kids family cared about their upset.

violetcuriosity · 03/12/2023 19:47

For those wondering why there's so many events for parents- parental engagement is a huge Ofsted drive in recent years. Trust me, teachers aren't doing it to be annoying. The amount of time and effort, on top of the usual work, it takes to organise these things is ridiculous.

mantyzer · 03/12/2023 19:44

@beforethecoffeegetscold I do not think a lot of teachers do get it. A lot seem to assume there will be another family member who can attend. I got asked about grandparents and Aunts a lot. My in laws were very elderly and could not go anywhere without carers, and even that was extremely difficult. My parents were both working full time and also had to give a fair bit of notice for annual leave. I did not have other people who could just attend something in the middle of the day with 2 weeks notice.
And I think a lot of teachers do not get this because apart from teaching they are used to family who do more middle class jobs that inherently have more flexibility.

AllstarFacilier · 03/12/2023 19:43

YABU to feel RAGE towards the school, when you haven’t asked if they’d be able to give you the dates earlier. I’m not sure what you want them to do about a lot of the things you’ve mentioned. If you ask for more notice, then maybe you can request time off for the things. They won’t be able to let you know them all in advance, like the certificates for the week, but things like the school play will be in the calendar. Lots of people work during school hours, but obviously all the things that the kids do will take place during school hours.

violetcuriosity · 03/12/2023 19:39

I mean, I get it's annoying but when else can they do them? Or do you want school staff to work even more hours outside of school time? There's no real answer to this problem.

beforethecoffeegetscold · 03/12/2023 19:34

Scunnered123 · 03/12/2023 18:11

Might be an unpopular view, but I think there are too many events where parents are invited. I often wonder who is supposed to benefit from thrm. It's certainly not the children whose parents can't/don't attend. There are way more invites now than there were when I was at school. I can't help but think it was much fairer to the children then.

I think this is the issue. Schools should have a handful of core events scheduled to take place throughout the year (such as Christmas nativity, sports day, end of year assembly etc). These dates should be given at the start of the year so that parents have ample notice. There is no need to be placing pressure on teachers and parents by hosting celebratory assemblies every single week! However, to say that teachers do not care about working parents is unfair. The vast majority of teachers are working parents themselves who are more than aware of how difficult it is to manage work and school expectations.

JudgeJ · 03/12/2023 19:34

Whenever we do things in the evening we alwaysget complaints - it's too late; they're not coming back out; they have other children to consider; their children have clubs to attend...

Schools can never get it right for some parents, many seem to judge by how it affects them, that their school should organise its events to suit them alone. If schools were to stop all shows and so on they would still be complaining, Maybe all parents should be expected to get involved and they would then see how much hard work goes into that bum-aching, boring hour!

OldChinaJug · 03/12/2023 19:34

I disagree that having an event every few weeks during school time where parents are invited is okay.

I think the reality is probably that most schools are hoping that most parents will he able to attend at least some of the events. So if you can't manage the Christmas show, there are opportunities to attend something else at another time.

Or to arrange for another family member to attend.

Some of the smaller ad hoc things, very few parents actually attend. It's about providing opportunities rather than expecting 100% parental attendance.

Big events like parents workshops or performances are usually arranged months in advance and so advance notice is given. Sometimes we'll have had an outside agency in to do some work with the children (eg art, drama, music) and we sometimes issue a last minute invitation toa 15 min showcase at the end of the day. We know it's last minute and we might only get half a dozen parents attend but, as far as often is concerned, we have included parents in their child's learning 🤷🏻‍♀️

We can't really give more notice for those things for various reasons.

pomers · 03/12/2023 19:30

NoCloudsAllowed · 02/12/2023 07:45

It might help to note that teachers are in the same boat - very hard to get leave mid term to see their own kids' things

I was going to say this. My husband or my mum always had to pick these things up as I could never attend