Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel RAGE against schools lack of care towards working parents?

654 replies

Stormy900 · 02/12/2023 07:42

I'm so, so angry!!!!
I'm a working parent.
I'm a nurse, so I can't WFH.
Why oh why oh why do primary schools set ALL their plays and productions during school hours when I, and so many other parents I know, are AT WORK!!!!
WHY don't schools factor this in????
My DC has a Christmas performance coming up and it is really important to him and to me that I'm there, it would fill my heart with absolute joy to see him. But school only informed us of the date 10 days ago. I have requested to take annual leave to attend it, but it has been refused by my manager because there are other colleagues on annual leave that day who have already requested, and I've been told my request is too short notice, but I've only recently been informed of the date by school. I'm absolutely heartbroken to not be able to attend. If I'd been given much more notice, I could have attended.
Also, another issue is HOW LITTLE NOTICE schools give parents about dates for events that parents are invited to. Sports day, parents being invited in to see DC's work and class displays, summer shows, Easter performances, class assemblies where my DC have speaking parts, and of course Christmas events. The school tells us no more than 2 weeks in advance maximum. Why?????
In my job, A/L has to be requested SIX WEEKS in advance because of staff rotas.
And don't get me started on children being given award certificates in assembly each week, which parents are invited to watch and the teachers TELL THE CHILDREN THEIR PARENTS ARE INVITED....they invite parents on the afternoon of THE DAY BEFORE THE CERTIFICATE ASSEMBLY!!!!
On Monday, school sent an email to me at 3pm, which I didn't pick up because I was managing a blood transfusion for a critically ill patient, so I picked it up later that day, as I can't access my emails as soon as they come in if I'm working. The invite was for 9am THE NEXT DAY!!!
There was no way I could attend at this level of short notice, as I was due to be at work the next morning, starting at 7am.
My little DD cried and cried. She said she wanted me there more than anything.
I have missed sooooooo many primary school events for my 2 DC because of horrific short notice from school. If I'd had dates in advance I could have attended them all.
WHY do schools do this???
They MUST KNOW what dates they're going to do events on. I simply refuse to believe they don't. They MUST have to plan their school calendar, activities, shows, performances, awards, in advance.
WHY do they assume all parents are eithet stay at home mothers or are in WFH jobs??
I'm SO angry!!!

OP posts:
Spendonsend · 02/12/2023 08:52

I agree with you about the notice.

I also think there should be 2 dates ideally to give parents an option and it also means lots of children wont have a parent in any given performance.

I dont agree about evenings. Lots of parents dont bring their child back, some people work evenings (i do), others have babies to put to bed. Some primary children have early bedtiimes themselves so they are over tired and useless..

Basically there isnt a time that works for everyone so they might as well pick one that works for the teachers and when the children legally are supposed to be there.

Runaway1 · 02/12/2023 08:49

The events need to be in school time for all
the reasons given before, but YWNBU to feedback to your school the need for a calendar with event dates given far in advance. This is standard practice in many schools, and it’s helpful for staff planning too.

BeavisMcTavish · 02/12/2023 08:48

You’re right to feel personally disappointed because of your situation - it drives me mad too as it’s the same for me albeit I do have more flexibility than you by the sounds of it.

But you’re also being massively unreasonable! you’re suggesting they ought to give you 6 weeks advance notice of your child getting an award - totally takes the entire point FOR YOUR CHILD of celebrating The Moment.

its also insane to suggest they happen ‘out of hours’… when is that exactly? Out of YOUR hours and therefore In the Work hours of someone else?

wishingiwas20something · 02/12/2023 08:47

The issue schools have is whatever date/time they pick will not suit someone, regardless of the notice they give. Schools don’t do productions on evenings/weekends as teachers and other staff aren’t contracted to work weekends (it also costs extra to heat/power the school) . Our school does the fair during the week (running on from the school day) because working parents can’t volunteer their time, so things have to happen during the school day. The PTA should get advance notice of key productions (nativity, christmas carol performance etc), or reach out to the school in early November - if that’s how your booking annual leave works?

HideTheCroissants · 02/12/2023 08:46

Can your school afford to pay the staff overtime to have these events outside of school hours? I know we can’t.
We did try and out of hours play one year but several key cast members weren’t brought back to school so it spoiled it for the other children and the parents.
As school staff we don’t get to see our children in school events either. It’s honestly not the end of the world.

Dibblydoodahdah · 02/12/2023 08:46

PerspiringElizabeth · 02/12/2023 07:45

School faculty is full of working parents too.

Perhaps they don’t want the kids to have to be at school any longer than the school day/come back into school in the evenings.

Agree it’s shit but it’s always been this way.

No it’s not always been this way because we had evening performances of the Christmas play back when I was in primary school 40 YEARS AGO.

bloodyhellKen22 · 02/12/2023 08:45

Curious but would you work past the time you normally stop work and do lots of unpaid hours? So why should a teacher?

👆 this

throughgrittedteeth · 02/12/2023 08:45

OP I'm sorry you've missed out on so much, it's so hard being a working parent and not even having the opportunity to balance things well. My only suggestion would be to speak to the school and ask them to be more mindful of the notice they give for fixed events. I'm not sure there's anything they can do for the last minute things though. Flowers

RockaLock · 02/12/2023 08:45

I agree that for school performances, more notice could be given to enable parents to request leave.

But YABU to complain about things being during the school day unless you are going to pay the overtime for the teachers, caretakers etc to work during the evening.

berksandbeyond · 02/12/2023 08:44

You can ask them to give more notice, I agree that would be good.
but YABU to expect teachers to be in school at 6/7pm (where are their own kids then?) to facilitate you attending things. And if you’re a nurse how would 6pm help you, surely nurses are a great example of not working a 9-5?

FancyFanny · 02/12/2023 08:44

My school tried evening performances of school plays- half the children didn't get to be in it then because the parents wouldn't bring their children back for it.

bellac11 · 02/12/2023 08:44

I havent read the whole thread, but it truly astounds me that the world of business, schools, health care whatever is set up with a view that people dont work.

It beggars belief really

Spacecowboys · 02/12/2023 08:44

I have found that it can be a bit mixed. Some events such as plays, sports day etc the dates are on the school newsletter well in advance, at the beginning of term. Others are short notice. Do you work shifts? I swap my shifts with colleagues to enable me to go to short notice events. Now and again I miss something which is frustrating but just life. The only parents I know who attend absolutely everything don’t work. Secondary school isn’t as good as primary for giving notice.

Onceuponaheartache · 02/12/2023 08:44

Sorry but as a nurse you should understand all the unpaid hours you do, teachers are the same except on far lower pay than nurses in most cases.

Would you be willing to pay £20-30 per ti ket to see it in an evening to cover staff, insurance, heating the school, electricity etc? Because that is the realistic alternative.

gotomomo · 02/12/2023 08:43

Teachers never get to attend their own children's events - many others too, yes it's frustrating but these things are always done in the school day because many families can't or won't outside of school time.

My exh saw no Christmas performances, never went to parents evening etc. there were always very few dads. Quite a lot of grandparents because parents couldn't attend. The school recorded Christmas productions and sold for £5 to raise funds

bluesky45 · 02/12/2023 08:43

Yes, we find the lack of notice difficult. I'm a supply teacher so I just take the day off but husband takes the full last week of term off because we know the events are likely to be in that week but we don't know which days until it's too late for him to take leave. So annoying to have to take a full week of leave to watch a Nativity play.

switswoo81 · 02/12/2023 08:43

Yes parents should be told dates well in advance for major events.
However poor communication between school and parents can often be the way it is received not delivered. Is parents just don't read messages
For eg a couple of weeks ago we were bringing senior classes to a sports event. An email the week before and a text/app notification the evening before as well as children being told was sent to ask children to not bring a snack in a small separate bag they could carry to the venue as there would not be space for schoolbag in the seats.
About 40% of children brought the correct bag .

But no to the evening performances.

Mumsanetta · 02/12/2023 08:43

FUPAgirl · 02/12/2023 08:40

This seems quite strange - surely your DC has been rehearsing, they didn't mention a play to you before now? If so, couldn't you have asked the school for info? Did you check the website?

Have you asked colleagues to swap? Did you ask if you can work from home or make the hours up in some way or swap to a different day? Take a half day off?

Your post seems strange - did you read the OP? She’s a nurse so can’t wfh and can’t take annual leave as it has to be booked 6 weeks in advance …

jemenfous37 · 02/12/2023 08:42

@Stormy900 The trouble is, you cannot please all of the parents all of the time. Some work shifts, some work only evenings/ weekends, some do 9-5 with communting time, some wfh
Then every employer has a different approach to taking time off; 2 weeks notice, 2 hours notice, several people off at same time, only one off atcsame time

Do you see how impossible it is for every school to meet every parent's needs?

Not saying it isn't a shit situation, but it was like this when I was at school. Neither parent attended school stuff because of work aand lack of transport. I think if it was possible to address this issue, all schools would have done it ny now

Bloodyhellmate · 02/12/2023 08:42

YANBU that is very short notice. Not all schools are like that. Ours gives quite a lot of notice especially for xmas performance. Really unfair for you.

Rocknrollstar · 02/12/2023 08:42

I was a teacher and couldn’t attend anything during the day for my two children. My mother sometimes went in my place. However, I explained to the children how much they had benefitted from me starting work and all the things that we could do as a family as a result of my working. As a teacher, we experimented with afternoon and evening parents’ evenings and found that in general the same number of people attended and mostly the same people. Teachers don’t get paid extra if they have to work in the evenings.

Mumsanetta · 02/12/2023 08:42

@Rosebel i think the answer is simply give more notice so parents can arrange annual leave if needed.

My DD’s school has the whole year calendar available from September. None of this last minute surprise announcements bullshit.

niclw · 02/12/2023 08:41

Gameofmoans81 · 02/12/2023 07:47

You are totally right! I’m a teacher and can’t just take days off whenever I want them. I miss everything my daughter does at school, it’s really sad.
theres also a huge divide between the working and stay at home parents it seems. (So few seem to work!) Going to Breakfast and after school club mean I never get the school gate chat/play date invites and I can’t join in or help with any of the pta events. My friends in the city where more parents work seem to have much more after school and weekend things on at their schools so they can actually go

This is exactly how I feel about things too. I'm a teacher too and basically get ignored by the other parents because dc is in wrap around care morning and afternoon five days a week. It was tough enough with him starting school when children already had friends from nursery but he didn't as he attend nursery near my work. I'm lucky that my headteacher is very good about family time so I have time off for dc's nativity. I volunteered as a parent helper at the ks1 disco a few weeks back but again got ignored by the other parents. It makes me feel like a rubbish mum but it shouldn't be like this!

Lucytheloose · 02/12/2023 08:40

Your children know you work, so surely they understand why you can't get to these events?

FUPAgirl · 02/12/2023 08:40

This seems quite strange - surely your DC has been rehearsing, they didn't mention a play to you before now? If so, couldn't you have asked the school for info? Did you check the website?

Have you asked colleagues to swap? Did you ask if you can work from home or make the hours up in some way or swap to a different day? Take a half day off?