Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be concerned about DM,s conspiracy theories and radical political views swinging full circle in the last couple of years?

39 replies

Soultree · 02/12/2023 07:12

For the whole of my life my DM has been a fairly left wing liberal, nothing radical but on that side of the political spectrum. She also seemed to have no particularly strong views on issues in the news and media.

In the last few years she has really got into US news. Stuff I know that she has openly told me is that she is a Trump supporter, she believes the vaccine will kill you. She thinks we are all brainwashed and behave like sheep. The global elite are controlling us etc etc.

If she gets onto any of this, I quickly move the subject on and just say each to their own. I don't feel the need to get into a debate and I respect her right to an opinion.

Anyway she sent me a link of a post of something she thought was funny and it had her username. So I went on and this linked me to her profile and I could see all her posts and comments.

I'm honestly amazed in her beliefs, it's much more extreme than I could dream of. Stuff like the fires in Hawaii were created by laser beams, Joe Biden isn't Joe Biden and he wears a mask, Global elite are trafficking children, we are being gassed by planes dropping stuff. So much more but you get the picture.

Could this be dementia or is it just her right to have her own views. In reality she lives in a small town in the UK, she can't do any damage but I feel sad that her retirement seems to have deteriorated into this way of thinking. I can tell she thinks I'm a fool re her Covid beliefs. I'm not strong either way but I did get vaccinated.

Would you keep quiet or mention something? I don't need to say I have seen her posts, things crop up all the time like when she texts me videos of Trump saying he gives excellent advice on how to raise kids! I just laugh it off but maybe I should be challenging her?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Misthios · 29/03/2024 09:25

Could this be dementia or is it just her right to have her own views.

Unlikely to be dementia, more likely that she is just totally lacking in critical thinking abilities and has been sucked into an online community where she is surrounded by similarly unhinged people who are reinforcing her beliefs.

DeeCeeCherry · 29/03/2024 09:20

Some people have too much time on their hands hence fall down the conspiracies rabbit hole. No hobbies, outlet, maybe disappointed in their life and need to present as wordly/knowledgeable/superior. Watch 1 YouTube clip then another, & it just keeps suggesting more and more.

I have a couple of friends like this. I just avoid them. There's no telling them, they've turned into complete bores stuck on 1 subject. No doubt they pity me for being a "sheep". They've never been to USA, never will go, dont do much with their lives yet its all about Trump etc. When I do come across them and they start, I tell them very firmly I'm not interested. I walk away if I have to. You'll have to do that with your Mum.

My Mum's not so extreme in views but she has Sky rolling news on 24/7 and is compelled to talk about the news only. Tedious. I dont allow her to bombard my brain either.

Picturequestion · 29/03/2024 09:05

11oclockrock · 28/03/2024 17:50

I see it as a symptom of mental illness / isolation/ anxiety. I also think people who are vulnerable to these CTs feel like they don't have much control over their own lives in real life and and get a buzz out of feeling they are superior to the "sheep".

My friend doesn’t fit this bill. Full control over her life. Loaded. Great lifestyle. Loads of friends. Lovely warm person. Just has some very entrenched views that have come from going down the rabbit hole. So sad as it’s hard to be her friend because I can’t challenge her but can’t bear to hear all the tosh.

IsawwhatIsaw · 28/03/2024 18:31

We had a friend who became immersed in many conspiracy theories and extremist Men’s Groups. Endless talk of feminazis and vaccines causing death. Became worse when he retired, apparently he was constantly online.

11oclockrock · 28/03/2024 17:50

I see it as a symptom of mental illness / isolation/ anxiety. I also think people who are vulnerable to these CTs feel like they don't have much control over their own lives in real life and and get a buzz out of feeling they are superior to the "sheep".

Italianita · 28/03/2024 17:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

theduchessofspork · 03/12/2023 22:39

Picturequestion · 02/12/2023 09:36

It would be great to have you on an ask me anything thread. My sister has gone down this same path. A friend too. Both intelligent and rationale people with science degrees. It blows my mind how far away from my world view they have gone. One of them is raiding young children. It’s frightening. My sister in particular has become incredibly racist and homophobic.

@Tukmgru yes I’d second an AMA thread, it would really help if this information were better known

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 03/12/2023 22:30

This happened to my best friend of my whole life and she dumped me over it. She's 42 and not stupid.

Soultree · 03/12/2023 22:07

@BMW6 , I could do that with a friend but it's not that simple with your Mother! Especially when it all seems to be newly found beliefs and ideology.

OP posts:
BMW6 · 03/12/2023 21:18

I really don't see any point in challenging her with a view to changing her mind - I think in your shoes I'd say I've seen what she thinks and I wish her good luck but Goodbye.

Soultree · 03/12/2023 21:01

I've sadly found more posts, I've read them all now. She is quite racist and hateful. I'm upset to realise how deeply ingrained it all seems to be. She mentions that she has given up on her relatives who get jabbed and said a few derogatory things about me too.

Guess I will just have to avoid the topics and act like I don't know. Such a shame this has happened. Thanks got all the supportive messages and similar experiences, it's helped to know I'm not on my own!

Has anyone ever confronted their CT and had a good outcome ?!

OP posts:
fishfingersandtoes · 02/12/2023 12:34

My brother is a bit like this. It's due to being isolated (because of a new disability) and his distrust of authority (which is kind of based on experience) plus significant time falling down YouTube algorithms which push borderline content. These algorithms have now been adjusted to avoid this sort of stuff but if you're already subscribed you'll still see it.
I don't get into it with him. I just prioritise our relationship as I think that connection and seeing that there is positivity in life is what he needs. He has gradually got better through getting out more and having a social life and getting involved in local causes. He still doesn't go in for vaccination etc, but he shares fewer mad videos these days.

If I did ever chat with him about stuff I'd say things like, it seems weird that so many people would be conspiring to say the earth is flat, I wonder what they'd get out of it?
Or it would be awful if the world was run by a huge gang of peadophiles and child torturers, but it seems unlikely that I'd be able to stop it happening.

Shadowsindarkplaces · 02/12/2023 09:46

I work with a guy that comes out with all of this stuff, every CT, you name it, he believes it. Most, firmly routed in anti-Semitic belief. He is utterly convinced. Unfortunately, he is the type who has an answer for everything, we would spend far too much time researching to disprove him to even bother
He is shit hot at his job. Otherwise, probably would have been fired long ago.

ConspiracyFeary · 02/12/2023 09:45

Picturequestion · 02/12/2023 09:39

My friend has a doctorate and a science degree. It’s not about education. She’s intelligent and compassionate, yet has been radicalised into some very dubious viewpoints. Some of which have a grain of truth so it’s really hard to dismiss it completely.

My sister has a science degree but has always been prone to take the anti establishment stance.

Im at a loss.

Sorry to hear that. My experience and post relates to my relative and their feeder group

ConspiracyFeary · 02/12/2023 09:42

A lot of people (myself included) have argued the left and the right will become so extreme they will meet and create a circle. They have - look at the Israel/Palestine conflict.

Gender politics reinforces outdated stereotypes.
Disenfranchised communities are seeing the effects of mass uncontrolled migration and, whereas previously they'd be effing and blinding and letting steam off down the pub, they're instead feeding their loop online to a wider audience.

Picturequestion · 02/12/2023 09:39

ConspiracyFeary · 02/12/2023 09:31

You have to walk away and disengage. I have a close relative who has fallen down the same rabbit hole and been there for 2 or 3 years now. You can't influence or change them you can only protect your own space and accept it will change your relationship with them.

I put it down to a mixture of being poorly educated, bored since retirement and anxiety. My family member has always been a bit gullible and easily led, so maybe it's also an element of no strong leadership on society too.

My friend has a doctorate and a science degree. It’s not about education. She’s intelligent and compassionate, yet has been radicalised into some very dubious viewpoints. Some of which have a grain of truth so it’s really hard to dismiss it completely.

My sister has a science degree but has always been prone to take the anti establishment stance.

Im at a loss.

Circularargument · 02/12/2023 09:38

Sorry meant to reply to poster you replied to, @L1ttledrummergirl

Picturequestion · 02/12/2023 09:36

Tukmgru · 02/12/2023 07:21

I work in, amongst other areas, deradicalisation. This is - I’m sorry to say - a textbook case of modern radicalisation through online conspiracy theories. Everything you’ve described there is Q-adjacent and whilst I appreciate it might seem bonkers, trust me, these are pretty mainstream in current conspiracy world.

The isolation is a pretty major factor here. I’ll assume that she spends a lot of time online but has very little in the way of understanding media literacy or how the algorithms work (most digital models reward controversial content, thus conspiracies exploding).

It isn’t dementia - or if she has it, the dementia is incidental.

It can be very very difficult but connection is the answer. There are good resources out there, even just to help you understand. Things like this: https://www.reddit.com/r/QAnonCasualties/s/qzorChICKr

It would be great to have you on an ask me anything thread. My sister has gone down this same path. A friend too. Both intelligent and rationale people with science degrees. It blows my mind how far away from my world view they have gone. One of them is raiding young children. It’s frightening. My sister in particular has become incredibly racist and homophobic.

Circularargument · 02/12/2023 09:35

L1ttledrummergirl · 02/12/2023 09:29

Because he was in a moving vehicle, and had just been shot.

Revisit basic physics.

I don't CARE how Kennedy was killed. It was 60 years ago. Yes, it arguably changed US history in some ways, all similar events do. Yes, maybe his political opponents were behind it. Proving this would make zero difference to today's world.
Mostly what lies behind these theories are nasty views about minorities ime

Draoicht · 02/12/2023 09:34

boamorte · 02/12/2023 09:19

I saw a video on Reddit of the JFK assassination a few days ago

When you take in to account that LHO was behind the car when he shot JFK, why does JFK's head rock firstly towards where LHO was when he was shot the second time?

You can clearly see the shot comes from the opposite direction of where LHO was which rocks his head towards LHO

Not all conspiracy theories are crazy, this one has evidence to disprove the official narrative

JFK wanted to disband the CIA and then gets killed, coincidence?

Tell me you made this post ironically, just to prove the kind of conspiracy-minded underthinking that the OP is worried about in her mother.

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/12/2023 09:34

It’s frightening isn’t it? And thanks to @Tukmgru for the explanation and for the work you do.

I have two friends (sensible, highly educated women in their early 50s) whose views have polarised in an alarming way. Neither of them proper tin foil hat stuff just obsessed focus on a couple of very specific things which have dominated everything they talk about.

In one case it’s all about crystal healing woo with an antivax tinge. Not extreme but worryingly anti science and dogmatic. In another it’s a total obsession with the trans debate (to the point that every conversation is brought around to this topic).

I think a lot of this has to do with the way social media has changed the way debates in the public sphere take place. Everything is so polarised and people get drawn into ever narrowing circles in a self affirming echo chamber.

I do worry that younger generations will grow up without the critical thinking and the ability to absorb alternative perspectives to that of their own tribe.

Sorry to hear your mum had gone through this. It sounds worrying (and highly irritating).

ConspiracyFeary · 02/12/2023 09:31

You have to walk away and disengage. I have a close relative who has fallen down the same rabbit hole and been there for 2 or 3 years now. You can't influence or change them you can only protect your own space and accept it will change your relationship with them.

I put it down to a mixture of being poorly educated, bored since retirement and anxiety. My family member has always been a bit gullible and easily led, so maybe it's also an element of no strong leadership on society too.

L1ttledrummergirl · 02/12/2023 09:29

Because he was in a moving vehicle, and had just been shot.

Revisit basic physics.

Circularargument · 02/12/2023 09:27

boamorte · 02/12/2023 09:19

I saw a video on Reddit of the JFK assassination a few days ago

When you take in to account that LHO was behind the car when he shot JFK, why does JFK's head rock firstly towards where LHO was when he was shot the second time?

You can clearly see the shot comes from the opposite direction of where LHO was which rocks his head towards LHO

Not all conspiracy theories are crazy, this one has evidence to disprove the official narrative

JFK wanted to disband the CIA and then gets killed, coincidence?

No comment🙄

Draoicht · 02/12/2023 09:23

@Tukmgru makes an important point about digital literacy — it’s likely the OP’s mother lacks the ability to critically evaluate online sources, and to understand how algorithms work in terms of showing her more material that reflects and exacerbates her views. I think it’s worth pointing out some of this.

My own mother, almost 80, has a non-internet version of this in that she thinks things that are on the radio or in the newspaper ‘must be true’, with no understanding of bias, political affiliations, PR etc, and unfortunately got hooked on a local shockjock with a racist agenda cloaked under a guise of ‘sturdy common sense and fairness’. I did things like get her to listen to the way the same incident was covered by different stations, and in different papers. Not sure it’s made that much difference…