Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not trying for a baby vs not trying to prevent it!

94 replies

MulledWhiney · 01/12/2023 19:34

I feel like I have misunderstood “unplanned pregnancies” my entire life and would love to hear other people’s opinions!

A good friend of mine is pregnant with baby number 2. I’m very happy for her, but this means her due date is the EXACT date we have (very hard fought for and very expensive) Taylor Swift Eras tickets for, so it’s very unlikely she will be able to go. We had spoken before about not getting pregnant at a bad time for the concert, and so when I asked how it happened, she said it wasn’t planned. When I asked further about what happened (we are close enough to talk details), it transpires that although they weren’t actively trying to get pregnant (tracking ovulation etc), they also weren’t actively trying to prevent pregnancy.

In my head, not using ANY form of prevention still trying to get pregnant. “Unplanned” to me always meant you were using birth control but for whatever reason it didn’t work. Now I’m looking back on my entire life and wondering if I’ve got it all mistaken 😂. I read a lot of teenage magazines in the early 2000’s with very strong messages on contraception and I don’t think I’ve been able to let that go!

Am I the odd one out here?? What does everyone else think? What would you define as “unplanned” ?

(I am meaning this to be light-hearted, there are no hard feelings about the friend’s pregnancy, I am still going to the concert 😂 I’m just really curious about how other people define planned and not planned)

OP posts:
Wren43 · 01/12/2023 23:11

Picklewicklepickle · 01/12/2023 21:54

I’m with you OP, unplanned means a contraception failure.

Not using contraception = planned pregnancy.

Absolutely don’t agree, there is a risk to everything, we don’t say people planned to get cancer because they smoke or have a car accident because they drive 🙄 people sometimes assess the risk and sometimes they are just lucky/unlucky and sometimes they had a false understanding of that risk

Burningthroughthesky · 01/12/2023 22:42

She's probably just said it wasn't planned because she knew you'd be annoyed about the concert. It sounds a bit like you interrogated her about how she managed to get pregnant 🤣

It can take years to conceive, you can't put your life on hold for it and not make plans.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 01/12/2023 22:42

Surely the first part of trying for a baby is stopping using contraceptives and having sex regularly. Giving your body enough time to work them out of the system (if hormonal)

If nothing happens after a while the "trying" ramps up with ovulation kits, bbt, charting, apps and such like...?

No contraception is either trying or risking imo, depending on the couple in question. Definitely can't claim unplanned though.

Enjoy TS, maybe baby could have a swifty nickname.😆

MulledWhiney · 01/12/2023 22:27

disappearingfish · 01/12/2023 21:26

So what you're saying is that you have TS tickets you don't want? I'll have them OP!

(Everyone else has totally missed the point of this thread)

Hahaha no I am most definitely going to the concert myself 😂😂😂

I will leave it a bit longer to find the next best Swiftie to go with though. Having had a pregnancy loss myself in the past and knowing all too well how awful that was, I want to wait until this pregnancy is further along before promising the ticket to anyone else!

OP posts:
Mischance · 01/12/2023 22:23

My 2 planned pregnancies were achieved simply by not using contraception. I did not measure anything - I just waited to see what would happen. All this measuring malarkey makes it a bit clinical. Just chuck out the pills and DID!!

MulledWhiney · 01/12/2023 22:23

HiCandles · 01/12/2023 21:16

I share your definition OP. However many, many women don't!
I am a GP and it's crazy the number of times a woman says they aren't using contraception but are sexually active, and I say 'so you're trying for a baby? Are you taking folic acid?' and they look at me in horror or laugh like I've made a joke.
When I explain I'd say about 50% then say it's a would be happy if I was but don't mind too much if I'm not situation, and 50% would be the worst thing in the world situation. The latter group I then really try to encourage contraception but still sometimes it falls on deaf ears.

That’s so interesting! I’m genuinely so interested reading everyone’s responses and as a GP I bet you’ve seen it all!

That’s crazy there are women who are not using contraception and actively don’t want to be pregnant though, I can’t even understand that thought process…

OP posts:
ZiriForGood · 01/12/2023 22:19

It might change with age.
For a young adults and short relationships, I would understand unplanned as contraception failure.

For a bit older stable couple, it makes sense to distinguish between trying and leaving it on the nature.

rainbowtea23 · 01/12/2023 22:09

We took the not trying not preventing approach to TTC when we got married as we were 25 and had time on our side so I wasn’t worried . I thought it would take a while but it took 9 years in the end. I went through periods of tracking on and off but didn’t make a difference in the end.
After DC1 was born we used condoms like we’d done prior to getting married. Like another poster on this thread we didn’t bother one morning when I was 4 months postpartum. Yep. That resulted in DC2. Couldn’t have been more shocked after it took nearly a decade the first time. I know you hear stories of it happening to people but I didn’t think it would happen to me for as many as it happens for I’m sure for more it doesn’t.

CurlewKate · 01/12/2023 22:04

@Naptrappedmummy "I agree 🤷🏼‍♀️ when used correctly (not hard given that just means popping along for an implant/IUD fitting) then it’s over 99% effective."

A properly used condom is similarly effective. I absolutely understand why implants and IUDs are not easily available to all. But condoms are.

Naptrappedmummy · 01/12/2023 21:56

CurlewKate · 01/12/2023 21:52

There should be a vanishingly tiny number of accidental pregnancies. Genuine contraceptive failure is incredibly rare- it does happen, but it's almost always human failure not contraceptive failure. Every baby should be a baby longed for by both parents.

So fight me.

I agree 🤷🏼‍♀️ when used correctly (not hard given that just means popping along for an implant/IUD fitting) then it’s over 99% effective.

IgnoranceNotOk · 01/12/2023 21:56

Ittastesvile · 01/12/2023 21:49

Counts as unplanned for me, definitely. If you are told you are infertile by a medical professional you are definitely not unreasonable to believe them and not use contraception!

👍😂

Although I’d love to become pregnant again so I’ve not been preventing for a couple of years but I think the professionals are probably correct and DS2 was just an incredibly lucky fluke!
If I did manage to get pregnant naturally again, I wouldn’t count it as unplanned though as I know it could be possible and we’d actually quite like another.

couldn’t go through IVF again though.

Wren43 · 01/12/2023 21:55

To me planning involves actively planning/trying for a baby, not necessarily tracking ovulation etc. I think there is room for middle ground between the 2. An unplanned pregnancy does not necessarily mean an unwanted pregnancy e.g. you might have the 2 children you planned for but feel happy either way about a 3rd. i.e. you wouldn’t got and get fertility treatment if it didn’t happen. Maybe there’s also a weigh up between the risks/downsides of using contraceptives and the chance of pregnancy e.g if your 45 or fully breastfeeding a baby not yet on solids your unlikely to conceive anyway. Perhaps also you do want a baby but not just yet ideally, however at the same you don’t want to actively prevent a pregnancy (unless significant reason) as it would then be quite rotten if you subsequently found you had a lot difficulty conceiving

AlmostAJillSandwich · 01/12/2023 21:54

Planned = trying to get pregnant, and deliberately having unprotected sex at the point in your cycle that you know you're ovulating and most fertile.

Unplanned = not actively trying to get pregnant, having unprotected sex throughout the month, possibly avoiding mid cycle when you're ovulating and most fertile, and sometimes using contraception. Or, relying on methods such as withdrawal as your only method of pregnancy prevention, with no actual barrier/pill/LARC.

Accidental = using a reliable method of contraception every time you have sex, but the contraception failing and you fall pregnant.

By my own personal definition, the pregnancy was indeed unplanned.

Picklewicklepickle · 01/12/2023 21:54

I’m with you OP, unplanned means a contraception failure.

Not using contraception = planned pregnancy.

CurlewKate · 01/12/2023 21:52

There should be a vanishingly tiny number of accidental pregnancies. Genuine contraceptive failure is incredibly rare- it does happen, but it's almost always human failure not contraceptive failure. Every baby should be a baby longed for by both parents.

So fight me.

ActDottie · 01/12/2023 21:50

When we started TTC we were like your friend in that we didn’t track ovulation but has unprotected sex as we were just being casual about getting pregnant and not wanting to put pressure on it.

When this didn’t work we started tracking ovulation etc.

If I’d have got pregnant the first time (so before tracking ovulation) I’d still say my pregnancy was planned I think. But I’d also have been surprised I got pregnant because there’s so much that has to align for conception to happen.

Ittastesvile · 01/12/2023 21:49

IgnoranceNotOk · 01/12/2023 21:44

I spent many years preventing pregnancy and then had to have IVF after being told the dr wanted to say there was no chance of us conceiving naturally. So I didn’t go on contraception after DS1 and somehow I got pregnant with DS2 (contrary to all the comments - my tubes did not suddenly know that to do - it was male factor infertility).

So I don’t know what that counts as either. Wasn’t planning it but didn’t prevent it and had been told by many medical professionals they wanted to say they 100% sure we wouldn’t conceive without IVF.

Counts as unplanned for me, definitely. If you are told you are infertile by a medical professional you are definitely not unreasonable to believe them and not use contraception!

Babyboomtastic · 01/12/2023 21:46

I think with readily available contraception (which is awesome, don't get me wrong), the relationship between sex and pregnancy had become a bit lost for some people.

By default sex = chance of pregnancy. That's literally the biological purpose of it. We interfere with the default by preventing, but take the prevention away and we are back to the default.

Egg and sperm don't give a damn whether they meet because you are charting temperatures, just aren't preventing, got carried away or your antibiotics made the pill ineffective.

For me, no contraception = trying for a baby because it meant I reverted to the biological reason for having sex. Charting just increases your chances.

IReallyMissPrince · 01/12/2023 21:44

I’m with you, OP. If you’re not using contraception, you are planning a baby. Either that, or you are deluded, because that’s likely what you’re going to get!

IgnoranceNotOk · 01/12/2023 21:44

I spent many years preventing pregnancy and then had to have IVF after being told the dr wanted to say there was no chance of us conceiving naturally. So I didn’t go on contraception after DS1 and somehow I got pregnant with DS2 (contrary to all the comments - my tubes did not suddenly know that to do - it was male factor infertility).

So I don’t know what that counts as either. Wasn’t planning it but didn’t prevent it and had been told by many medical professionals they wanted to say they 100% sure we wouldn’t conceive without IVF.

Ittastesvile · 01/12/2023 21:44

I agree with you OP.
Imo your friend's baby is not unplanned.
Having tried unsuccessfully to conceive for several years however, I think it's unreasonable to put off conceiving for a concert!

LadyGeorginaSmythe · 01/12/2023 21:41

We were TTC for a year and initially that meant stopping contraception. After no success we tracked periods and then TTC more scientifically for 2 months and conceived. Whilst baby 1 was not very old we used condoms. One night we threw caution to the wind because what were the chances when it took over a year to get baby 1?! Anyway, we definitely were not TTC but we also definitely did not use contraception. Babies 2&3 came along together in a surprise bogof deal.
BTW I think buying tickets/committing to an event aids pregnancy. After that first of no luck for #1 we got tickets for Take That. Of course I then got pregnant with baby due the day of the show!

Needmorelego · 01/12/2023 21:37

Well at least she has a name for the baby.
Taylor can be suitable for a boy or girl 😂

Chuckiee · 01/12/2023 21:37

All my babies were planned. I have never tracked anything. We stopped using contraception. That is trying for a baby.

PlumpShady · 01/12/2023 21:35

I would say that your friends pregnancy was planned. I’d never even heard of temperature taking and other such things to conceive until I started using Mumsnet, most people just stop taking the pill and hope for the best don’t they? The ‘trying’ part is just having sex.

But I think it’s too simplistic to say that if you have unprotected sex you are ‘planning’ to get pregnant. People are idiots and make mistakes sometimes and game the risks, are careless, or even drunk. This doesn’t sound like your pal though. I doubt many people who end up having an abortion after a drunken ONS think their pregnancy was planned.

I’d believe someone who said their pregnancy was unplanned even if they’d had unprotected sex. I’d think them a bit daft but we all make mistakes I guess.