Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No food

218 replies

cherrychapstickk · 01/12/2023 18:07

hello,

As the title says really.

My 2 and 3 year old have been taken out for the afternoon by their aunt and uncle.

They ended up having them for around 4 and a half hours, I expected around 2 but they said they got carried away.

Once they'd left 3 year old burst into tears saying she was hungry (they normally have dinner at around 5) and it turns out (i checked with auntie) they've not eaten with them at all.

Had I known they were going to be 4 hours I'd of packed some food but as I didn't know and they got carried away, am I unreasonable for thinking its quite harsh not to offer your young nieces any food?

I cannot imagine having any of their children, especially at such a young age, for that duration of time and covering dinner time and not offering anything to eat whatsoever.

OP posts:
Wrongsideofpennines · 01/12/2023 20:52

My almost 3 year old would be fine with this gap. We often eat tea when dad is home so gone 6pm. If they were really hungry they would ask for food.

At that age children may also tell you they've not eaten when they definitely have. Time is a tricky concept for them so make sure they really hadn't eaten before you complain to their aunt and uncle.

dogvcat · 01/12/2023 20:50

Don’t know why so many were pilling on you @cherrychapstickk, I don’t think you were being unreasonable to expect them to have had a snack.

I have a 4 year old dgd. If I had her out for the afternoon she would be asking for something to eat by the time we had been out for 2 hours, never mind 4 / 5 hours.

In fact I did have her out to see Santa a few days ago. We went out at 12.30pm and ended up in a cafe by 2pm for drink and cake. Then she was hungry again by 4pm, so went to Greggs, for something to eat. I also had her for (a little later than usual) dinner, along with her parents, which she ate as well.

She normally has a mid morning and an afternoon snack, as well as her usual meals, which I think a lot of small children, including yours seem to do. Glad it’s all been cleared up now and was just an oversight.

Calliopespa · 01/12/2023 20:46

ImustLearn2Cook · 01/12/2023 20:38

Morning tea (which is between breakfast and lunch) and afternoon tea (which is between lunch and dinner) is not what any rational person would consider stuffing your children with snacks all day long. And yes they absolutely do need to be offered morning tea or afternoon tea.

And morning/afternoon tea is not some recent modern new trend. Nor is the cause of obesity. That you can blame on junk food.

FWIW social workers when investigating a family do check the fridge and cupboards to not only make sure that there is adequate food for meals but they also check for adequate snack foods too. So, yes not providing for snacks is considered neglect.

Afternoon tea was invented by the Duchess of Bedford because at that time her social circle didn’t eat until 8 or 9 pm. Some children might get peckish and a snack won’t kill them or even give them diabetes if sensibly chosen; but it’s hardly neglect if healthily fed children can make it from one square meal to the next.

ImustLearn2Cook · 01/12/2023 20:46

We are talking about 2 -3 year olds here. It is based on their age and stage of development, their biology. They do need to be fed more frequently than 3 main meals a day. And their portion sizes are often smaller at this age and stage of development based on their biology.

Penaeus · 01/12/2023 20:46

FWIW social workers when investigating a family do check the fridge and cupboards to not only make sure that there is adequate food for meals but they also check for adequate snack foods too. So, yes not providing for snacks is considered neglect

Rather than continuing to dig this hole for yourself, you'd be better admitting that parents who don't let their children snack all day are not necessarily "neglectful".

If children are constantly deprived of food, or if food is used as a means of coercion, or if children are only ever given Pop Tarts and Pot Noodles, then something is wrong. But if a family has a well-stocked fridge and cupboards, provides three nutritional meals and plenty to drink every day, with 'extras' if a child has been doing something particularly energetic or has to wait a particularly long time for their normal dinner (for example), you cannot possibly even begin to think that this family is neglectful.

There are plenty of astonishingly neglectful parents who let their children snack. There are plenty of astonishingly good parents who don't.
There are also plenty of astonishingly good parents who do let their children snack, and plenty of astonishingly neglectful parents who don't.

I hope you don't seriously think that "neglect" = "lack of access to snacks".

StarlightLime · 01/12/2023 20:45

ImustLearn2Cook · 01/12/2023 20:38

Morning tea (which is between breakfast and lunch) and afternoon tea (which is between lunch and dinner) is not what any rational person would consider stuffing your children with snacks all day long. And yes they absolutely do need to be offered morning tea or afternoon tea.

And morning/afternoon tea is not some recent modern new trend. Nor is the cause of obesity. That you can blame on junk food.

FWIW social workers when investigating a family do check the fridge and cupboards to not only make sure that there is adequate food for meals but they also check for adequate snack foods too. So, yes not providing for snacks is considered neglect.

What is "snack" food as opposed to "meal" food? And can social services really tell the difference?! (How did you find out?)
This is getting weirder and weirder.

StarlightLime · 01/12/2023 20:43

Morning tea... That's a new one on me. Did any of your children emerge from toddlerhood normal sized, @ImustLearn2Cook ?

bellac11 · 01/12/2023 20:40

I do check fridge and cupboards for food.

Not snacking (as long as the child is being fed adequately) is not neglect!!!

ImustLearn2Cook · 01/12/2023 20:38

Morning tea (which is between breakfast and lunch) and afternoon tea (which is between lunch and dinner) is not what any rational person would consider stuffing your children with snacks all day long. And yes they absolutely do need to be offered morning tea or afternoon tea.

And morning/afternoon tea is not some recent modern new trend. Nor is the cause of obesity. That you can blame on junk food.

FWIW social workers when investigating a family do check the fridge and cupboards to not only make sure that there is adequate food for meals but they also check for adequate snack foods too. So, yes not providing for snacks is considered neglect.

Daisies12 · 01/12/2023 20:35

I wouldn’t think anything of that, they had lunch before they left and back for dinner? It’s not healthy how much kids (or anyone) expect to snack nowadays

Pinkpinkpink15 · 01/12/2023 20:33

@cherrychapstickk it's hardly surprising your elderly, childless relatives didn't feed your 4 children for a fortnight. It's your fault for not feeding them the entire week beforehand. Expecting childcare is unreasonable!!

OR

Glad you've sorted it.

im not entering the 'to snack or not to snack debate'. I have a drink waiting for me!!

but I'll just say I'm surprised they didn't come home too full for dinner from a Christmas market!!

Penaeus · 01/12/2023 20:32

bellac11 · 01/12/2023 20:32

More angry than normal fuming and stamped out on the keyboard usually on facebook

Along with 'discusted'

😂

Calliopespa · 01/12/2023 20:32

ImustLearn2Cook · 01/12/2023 20:12

Preschoolers stomachs are too small to get all their nutritional requirements from only 3 meals a day. That is why they need at least 2 healthy snacks between meals such as fruit. And yes I do think it’s neglect to deny children their basic needs.

Do you think if they didn’t have the snacks they might be more inclined to take sufficient nutrition on board at mealtimes? Also mealtimes should be nutrient dense to enable this.

bellac11 · 01/12/2023 20:32

Calliopespa · 01/12/2023 20:30

What’s fumming?

More angry than normal fuming and stamped out on the keyboard usually on facebook

Along with 'discusted'

Penaeus · 01/12/2023 20:31

Rather than being neglect to not feed a child with constant snacks I would suggest it's neglect to stuff a child with snacks all day

I would agree with this, not least because nobody is bothering to find out what is actually going on with them.

Bit of a whinge? Here, have a snack.

Tired? Here, have another snack.

Bored? Oh, have another one.

Want to go home? Fine, but let's have a snack first.

Devilsmommy · 01/12/2023 20:30

cherrychapstickk · 01/12/2023 18:50

no snacks, I said no food not no meals.

I wasn't expecting meals, was just a bit surprised they'd had nothing in 4.5/5 hours, especially as they'd been walking around the markets/lights for a while.

I dunno, I don't think they've done it deliberately but just seems a bit of a while for such young kids to go with nothing and not something I'd do but it looks like I'm in the minority there which is fine :)

No you are absolutely right. My little one has snacks between his meals so never goes over 2 hours without something. Little tummies need smaller portions but more often. I completely see why you're pissed off

Calliopespa · 01/12/2023 20:30

Penaeus · 01/12/2023 19:54

I think you mean "fumming".

Honestly, MN spelling has gone down the drain.

What’s fumming?

Penaeus · 01/12/2023 20:30

i would always get kids a snack if in my company and ask them if they are hungry

I can guarantee that at least one of my DC would have been "absolutely starving" if an adult had offered them a snack which was appealing enough.

I forgot to mention "opportunism" in my list of "why children say they are hungry".

Atethehalloweenchocs · 01/12/2023 20:28

I think if you don’t have kids, then you’d possibly assume that they would ask if they were hungry? And adults usually wouldn’t consider 1.45 - 5.45 to be over any meal times.

This! When I was a young auntie, I was always surprised at how often I had to feed the little blighters when I took them out - far more often than I would have thought of eating.

JudgeJ · 01/12/2023 20:25

Generations of children weren't drip-fed all day. Society is experiencing an obesity crisis, with a dose of Type 2 diabetes for good measure. But people still insist that children need to be brought up with the idea that you spend the day "snacking".

I've been surprised that parents collecting their child from school would have a mini-picnic for their child, surely they would be having their evening meal shortly after getting home.
Rather than being neglect to not feed a child with constant snacks I would suggest it's neglect to stuff a child with snacks all day.

Moonshine5 · 01/12/2023 20:25

Only on Mumsnet is it considered normal to make very young children wait 5 hours between meals (with no refreshments). 😂
It's not.
Are these the parents that wash their bed sheets daily and eek a chicken out to feed their family for a week.

Calliopespa · 01/12/2023 20:24

Penaeus · 01/12/2023 20:10

I am shocked at pp claiming that they would not have fed their 2 and 3 year old children any snacks in between meals. That is neglect

Of all the offensive, ridiculous tripe I've read on here over the past 20 years, this is right up there with the worst.

Generations of children weren't drip-fed all day. Society is experiencing an obesity crisis, with a dose of Type 2 diabetes for good measure. But people still insist that children need to be brought up with the idea that you spend the day "snacking".

What a pile of complete and utter crap.

To be a bit more polite, I think you will find that "child neglect" is something very different.

Yes our paediatrician was not a fan of snacks as it was harder to regulate the balance. Good square meals with carbs, protein, veg and fruit to follow. Ours did have milk in between sometimes but snacks were only for timetable disrupted emergencies ( and on plane, train or long car trips as much as anything to keep them occupied). Children today are often fed constant snacks for that latter reason, and that is much closer to child neglect. They aren’t babies.

bellac11 · 01/12/2023 20:23

ImustLearn2Cook · 01/12/2023 20:04

@cherrychapstickk I am shocked at pp claiming that they would not have fed their 2 and 3 year old children any snacks in between meals. That is neglect. Children that age absolutely do need to eat at least breakfast, morning tea, lunch, afternoon tea and dinner. And they absolutely should not be expected to go for 4.5 to 5 hours without food. They should be offered food at least 3 hourly.

If they are genuine parents and they genuinely didn’t feed their young children any food at all between meal times then they are neglectful parents and I would not listen to anything that they have to say about your situation.

Their auntie and uncle were completely irresponsible and neglectful. Next time they ask to take the kids say no. Then make it very clear why you saying no. Your children are not inconsequential and deserve to be treated better than that.

Any other normal decent person would have bought them something to eat. Especially as it was their decision to have your kids for that length of time.

Neglect!

Lol

Thewondererhasreturned · 01/12/2023 20:22

I'm surprised they didn't offer the kids something to eat im sure looking at Christmas lights etc they passed food shops i would always get kids a snack if in my company and ask them if they are hungry. I wouldn't expect a 3 year old to tell me my 3 year old doesn't ask and needs prompting a lot. I dont think it was done with bad intent if she doesn't have kids she probably didn't think but definitely she should have offered or at least had snacks with her for them

JudgeJ · 01/12/2023 20:21

Should they have probably at least given snacks? Yes.

Depending on the age of the adults, 'snacking' didn't used to be a thing, I recall being astounded at the 'snack drawer'!

Swipe left for the next trending thread