Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect a child to read with a grown up at least a couple of times in the first term of reception?

286 replies

Benibidibici · 01/12/2023 17:17

DC is late aug birthday so only just four on starting school. Happy there and enjoying it etc, settled in fine.

They are never heard read by any adult. Teacher has acknowledged this.

Have found out this week some kids are reading with an adult one on one three or four times a week.

I know they have to focus on the ones who need a bit of help but come the fuck on, how does a little 4 year old feel if they never get that little bit of one on one time with a grown up and others get loads? Its not just about the reading - its about that bit of attention, the teacher or TA learning who they are and how they respond. Surely they can fit in my DC once or twice a term if they can find 3 or 4 times a week for other kids. Dc hates never getting picked to go and read. :(

OP posts:
PTSDBarbiegirl · 02/12/2023 09:52

*Decode not decide.

PTSDBarbiegirl · 02/12/2023 09:51

He could be working on phonological awareness and the building blocks of literacy and learning through Play, age 4. If children are going in small groups to read from 'reading books' at age 4 they must be at that stage, can decide and have true comprehension. Lots of 4 or 5 year olds struggle to attend to instruction and staff support them to reach milestones. Teaching literacy is a science. Unfortunately some parents are totally clueless about what 'reading' actually means and involves. Don't you have any communication from class teachers about monitoring progress, setting targets etc?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 02/12/2023 09:40

I don't think parents realise how much financial pressure schools are under. Funding is incredibly tight and resources are unbelievably stretched. The school where I'm a governor has had to massively cut back on TA support because there is simply nothing else left to cut. This means that there are fewer adults in the classroom. We are fortunate because we have an army of capable and educated volunteers who come in to help - not all schools have that.

If resources are stretched, then it makes sense to focus 1:1 support on the kids that need it most, otherwise those kids will be left behind and the consequences may be lifelong. My dd was a very able reader, and simply didn't need the level of support that some of her classmates needed. Rather than being jealous of the extra attention that the other kids got, I was grateful that she didn't need it.

If you're unhappy about the level of input that your dc is getting, I think you should complain to your MP about the state of school funding right now. The government is absolutely failing our children. The vast majority of schools are doing their very best with the limited resource that they have, but they can't magic up resource from nowhere.

AlPacinosHooHaa · 02/12/2023 09:03

Op of course they should.
Schools should be able to do lots of things but unfortunately they can't.
I must say I think it's incredible what they a chive with small dc!
However it should be more well known that they a
Can't do much except broad education and taught in a very specific way.

Confrontayshunme · 02/12/2023 09:00

If I can come at this from a slightly different angle, it may be that reading happens during continuous provision ("learning jobs" or play), and the teacher knows that your son is doing well and has support at home. If his strength is reading, he may have low gross motor skills or lack coordination or social and emotional communication. Taking him out of learning those just to read with him for five minutes is actually a disadvantage to him. Also, he WILL be doing adult 1:1 or small group writing or maths as I don't know a single school where that doesn't happen. If the removal for reading happens during play, I would be surprised if he has even clocked it.

Finteq · 02/12/2023 08:52

My kid in Year one is listened to in class at least 3 times a week.

It is important- how are they supposed to decide on what books to give to the kids if no one actually sits down and listens to them read, and no one is checking their comprehension?

Finteq · 02/12/2023 08:50

YouAreMyCentreWhenISpinAway · 02/12/2023 08:10

When my DC was about 8 I got an email saying my DC needed to go to learning support as he didn’t know his number bonds to 20. I was really shocked as he is a really bright DC who was a great reader.

I took him to an independent maths teacher who assessed him and told me he was actually very good at maths, just clearly hadn’t been taught properly. I then came out that the teacher thought my DC was bright, and could be left to get on with it, and their attention was needed on the other children. I went mad, but there wasn’t a lot I could do. Basically he’d been neglected big time because he was a bright student.

From that day on I lost all faith in schools. I’ve come across good teachers, but they are spread too thin.

I got my DC a maths tutor, and years later my DC is grade 9 GCSE/ grade A admaths, and A* A’level maths student.

NEVER leave your DC’s education to the governments of this country. Send them to school, but do maths and reading at home and take them out and about. YOU are their best teacher.

Edited

Agree.

No point in getting to mocks for GCSEs and being shocked at the predicted grades.

Take an active interest in your kids progress.

This doesn't mean teach them everything yourself. But keep a close eye.

The focus should be math and English.

If they can read and have good comprehension then the rest of the subjects are much easier.

The science subjects are much easier if they have a good grasp of figures.

mikado1 · 02/12/2023 08:50

mikado1 · 02/12/2023 08:06

YANBU

I teach 10yps and listen to them individually, all of them, 3-4 times per week and I have 5 different levels within my class. I prioritise it tbh as imo it is very important and it's fantastic to have that one on one time with them. Three children are heard 5x a week on top of that.

Tried to edit but couldn't. I meant heard individually within a group, 3 pages or more daily. Those heard on top of that (3x5) are 1:1.

Bunnie007 · 02/12/2023 08:31

I’m a Reception teacher. An adult should be reading one to one with your child, I would hope at least weekly. Ask to speak to the class teacher about this and what the school policy is (may also be on the school website) If you’re not happy with her response then ask to speak to the literacy lead or the head teacher and express your concern regarding the lack of ongoing individual assessment (they can do assess reading fluency, comprehension etc in a whole class group) Children all need to be assessed/supported and it isn’t best practise to focus all this support onto those children who are struggling. If they say they don’t have enough time etc that is in my opinion not a good enough answer!
I would keep your discussion very much focused on reading assessment/progress and ‘enquire’ rather than accuse and try and get to the bottom of exactly what is happening in class.
In terms of your child feeling sad about not getting ‘picked’ support them with this to build some resilience (as it is really hard for children in schools and often things won’t seem ‘fair’) I am sure the adults are spending time with them in other ways but I do know children can feel sad not being part of interventions (and obviously hard to say you don’t need it you’re too clever without risking them repeating this)
I hope you get this resolved, it is ok to speak to school and advocate for your child. Good luck

YouAreMyCentreWhenISpinAway · 02/12/2023 08:10

When my DC was about 8 I got an email saying my DC needed to go to learning support as he didn’t know his number bonds to 20. I was really shocked as he is a really bright DC who was a great reader.

I took him to an independent maths teacher who assessed him and told me he was actually very good at maths, just clearly hadn’t been taught properly. I then came out that the teacher thought my DC was bright, and could be left to get on with it, and their attention was needed on the other children. I went mad, but there wasn’t a lot I could do. Basically he’d been neglected big time because he was a bright student.

From that day on I lost all faith in schools. I’ve come across good teachers, but they are spread too thin.

I got my DC a maths tutor, and years later my DC is grade 9 GCSE/ grade A admaths, and A* A’level maths student.

NEVER leave your DC’s education to the governments of this country. Send them to school, but do maths and reading at home and take them out and about. YOU are their best teacher.

mikado1 · 02/12/2023 08:08

If they are heard reading aloud in a group regularly, I'd count that BTW, so if that's happening, no problem.

mikado1 · 02/12/2023 08:06

YANBU

I teach 10yps and listen to them individually, all of them, 3-4 times per week and I have 5 different levels within my class. I prioritise it tbh as imo it is very important and it's fantastic to have that one on one time with them. Three children are heard 5x a week on top of that.

Girlsjustwannahavefundamentalrights · 02/12/2023 08:05

Your kid is ahead of the class, and you read with him at home. He doesn't need special attention from the teacher, i expect they will have heard him read in a group and know he doesn't need additional support.

The other children clearly do need additional support because they're recieving it. Not hearing him read 1:1 doesn't mean the teacher doesn't hear him read at all. At my kids school they read in groups, and take turns. Occasionally they'll read 1:1 if there's a volunteer available. The teacher was fully aware of how they were progressing.

I honestly can't see why you're so upset. Just be pleased your son is doing well. Talk to the teacher but i wouldn't approach it like you have here, as in "woe is he, why are you ignoring my child?". He's got a lot of years left to go at school.

Reugny · 02/12/2023 08:01

GladioliandSweetPeas · 01/12/2023 23:35

@ichundich What? I would be furious if some random none-DBS parent who I've never met was sat with my child reading! Jesus Christ. They could do anything whilst the staff are not looking.
Obviously I'm not implying it's likely but some people out there are capable of anything. It only takes one twisted monster

Parents and others who volunteer in schools are DBS checked.

Reugny · 02/12/2023 07:57

Hankunamatata · 01/12/2023 19:40

None of kids in reception has reading books at our school. The most able get ones in January time of reception.

Wow!

My DD got books a month after starting school.

She started with a weekly library book then a phonics book was added.

Every Friday morning for 30 mins at the start of school a parent/carer is expected to stay to hear their kid read. A lot of dads make this weekly commitment when they aren't involved with the school run otherwise.

Regardless she has had lots of people reading to her since she was a baby. We refused to teach her to read before starting school as a friends kid who is equally intelligent learnt was reading fluently at Christmas.

StopLickingTheDog · 02/12/2023 07:43

@Benibidibici have you actually asked the teacher about it?

BendingSpoons · 02/12/2023 07:38

I can't believe this thread has turned in to criticising OP for working and not hearing her son read at school! (I say that as someone who has been a reading volunteer in the past but was lucky enough to have flexibility to do so. I never read with my own child when in school anyway as they used my time for the children who were either struggling or not heard read at home)

My son is ahead in reading. He has been heard read about 3 times since starting Reception in Sept. Not sure the class teacher has heard him read (maybe once at the start, but she has heard him read signs etc in the classroom) but the TA and cover teachers have. It's a shame your son hasn't had this.

avenue1 · 02/12/2023 07:18

In most reception classes- actually in most year groups in primary, children are heard in groups now. It's called guided reading. They are taken out of the classroom and in group of 3/4 are talked through the book, it's phonetically read to them, then they read it themselves. They are not distracted by each other, often are at different speedS and the teacher moves around and hears them all (although not every word). This is the core way reading is 'heard' in schools now. Some children, those who are struggling, who clearly don't read with a adult at home, or who have problems working in group, may get 121 with an adult at other times. IME this has never affected a non-participating child's self-esteem. This system is time-efficient and aims to leave no child behind at the very beginning of their education.

Does you child bring home a reading book and diary? Do they read in a group with the teacher?

C0ldasIc3 · 02/12/2023 07:06

GladioliandSweetPeas

Why is that nonsense?
PP children are often prioritised. They bring additional funding which helps pay for additional help and their progress is monitored. You don’t need to say why any child is highlighted as being at the top of a reading list but children falling behind or those that have SENS, IEPs, PP and EHCPs will all be focused on.

Sirzy · 02/12/2023 06:55

GladioliandSweetPeas · 01/12/2023 23:35

@ichundich What? I would be furious if some random none-DBS parent who I've never met was sat with my child reading! Jesus Christ. They could do anything whilst the staff are not looking.
Obviously I'm not implying it's likely but some people out there are capable of anything. It only takes one twisted monster

Having a dbs doesn’t automatically make someone “safe” it just means they haven’t been caught!

but a parent volunteer isn’t going to be left alone with a child. They will be in a corner of the classroom surrounded by people.

Spacie · 01/12/2023 23:44

@GladioliandSweetPeas parent volunteers are DBS checked. (I certainly was 20 years ago)

GladioliandSweetPeas · 01/12/2023 23:35

@ichundich What? I would be furious if some random none-DBS parent who I've never met was sat with my child reading! Jesus Christ. They could do anything whilst the staff are not looking.
Obviously I'm not implying it's likely but some people out there are capable of anything. It only takes one twisted monster

GladioliandSweetPeas · 01/12/2023 23:31

Puppupandaway · 01/12/2023 17:39

Could those children be pupil premium? When I was a reading volunteer in a reception class, I had a class list to work through and always had to start with the ones highlighted. Sometimes I wouldn't get through to the other children, but always made sure those highlighted were listened to. The teacher will be under pressure to ensure children who get pupil premium show progress.

Also, just because he isn't being listened to read doesn't mean he does no reading in class or is not being given attention. Is he happy to go to school every day, does he come out chatting about his learning? If so, I wouldn't worry.

Utter nonsense! The children highlighted will be behind in reading! They absolutely cannot 'highlight' children who receive pupil premium ffs

GladioliandSweetPeas · 01/12/2023 23:28

Boomboom22 · 01/12/2023 17:31

I don't think they can actually read at Reception. I have older ones who I remember vividly the pain of 45 mins a night to read 3 letter word per page. I have a 4 Yr old now and they send home books to read to them and are doing letter formation and recognition. I doubt many are ready to read books aloud yet tbh.

I could read very well before I even started Reception and I too was late August born so only just 4 in Reception. DC could also read before Reception?

GladioliandSweetPeas · 01/12/2023 23:26

Just ask my DD (Year 4) how many times she's sat with a teacher or TA and done reading this week and she said in October 🤯