Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect a child to read with a grown up at least a couple of times in the first term of reception?

286 replies

Benibidibici · 01/12/2023 17:17

DC is late aug birthday so only just four on starting school. Happy there and enjoying it etc, settled in fine.

They are never heard read by any adult. Teacher has acknowledged this.

Have found out this week some kids are reading with an adult one on one three or four times a week.

I know they have to focus on the ones who need a bit of help but come the fuck on, how does a little 4 year old feel if they never get that little bit of one on one time with a grown up and others get loads? Its not just about the reading - its about that bit of attention, the teacher or TA learning who they are and how they respond. Surely they can fit in my DC once or twice a term if they can find 3 or 4 times a week for other kids. Dc hates never getting picked to go and read. :(

OP posts:
Lokisbiggestfan · 08/12/2023 00:46

OP just remember you are your child’s biggest advocate. So if you feel he needs one on one reading with an adult at school then bring it up to the school right away. Then in a week so 2 if it still hasn’t happened talk with them again. They need to know you are an involved parent and you care what’s going on with your son. Please advocate for your dc because nobody else will like a mom/dad will.

Bamboobzled · 08/12/2023 00:31

GladioliandSweetPeas · 01/12/2023 23:28

I could read very well before I even started Reception and I too was late August born so only just 4 in Reception. DC could also read before Reception?

Yeah, sure you did.

Bamboobzled · 08/12/2023 00:10

I can't relate to what you are saying as my eldest is 9 and middle child is 6 (and just started school in August). My youngest is 3.5 and in his first year of nursery. He is no where near reading but counts very well and recognises some letters... Schooling must be vastly different across the UK, as I don't recognise any of that as normal for first year of school.

Catxxxxxxxxxx · 07/12/2023 23:42

You havent got a clue about the "split of attention" just because theyre not being listened to for reading doesn't mean theyre not getting attention in other areas. Be grateful that your child is not behind in reading and get a grip. And even if everything youre saying is true then if your child has their emotional needs met at home then it will make no difference. Teachers should give the most time to the ones who need it most. If your child is not neglected at home then they are lucky cos many are and they need the extra support in school.

kitchenideas12 · 07/12/2023 23:22

Um…just no. In a class of 30, are 25 children supposed to be neglected just in order that the 5 with SEN come up to an average standard? Taking that approach will produce a generation of averagely able people and no outliers.

Anyway, that’s just not how life works. We don’t spend every penny of the country’s money on healthcare even though l that would save more lives. We choose to spend on music and art and sport and things of beauty and flourishing; things that enhance life and don’t just save lives (which would be the lowest common denominator). Likewise in education we shouldn’t just focus on the really struggling children at school - we need to balance the needs of all children in order that we promote excellence. For the SEN kids, that balance will involve bringing them up to a lower standard, and for others it will involve pushing them to a higher standard. Both are important.

This is why there really needs to be more differentiation in schools - it’s so unfair to all children for teachers to be forced into a ‘one size fits all’ solution. Because ultimately it doesn’t fit all, so teachers are constantly forced to adapt it and flex to such an extreme degree that they essentially fail half the kids.

SophieinParis · 07/12/2023 22:54

Omg! I’m shocked.
At my children’s school, every child from reception up to end of year 3 reads one on one to an adult EVERY DAY! After that just a couple of times a week.
I think less than that is pretty poor. It’s school, learning to read is one of the main objectives!

Mostlyoblivious · 07/12/2023 22:34

It’s sad as the focus in classrooms is often on those that need more focus whilst those more gifted can be neglected as they can get on with things.

CynicalToad · 07/12/2023 21:55

Benibidibici · 01/12/2023 17:50

Fine clearly lots of people disagree. Imho there should never be such an imbalanced split of attention. Id understand if my DC was heard twice and term and others twice a week. But some children four times a week and others never?

Its fucking unfair on little children.

Do you know what else is fucking unfair? Kids who are struggling falling further behind and - if not corrected - having their life chances severely affected because little Jonny has to have exactly 1/30th of the teacher's attention.

Our school takes a "keep up not catch up" approach in KS1 and that means some children get extra help every day and some children don't need so much support.

The school may also be using some of their notional SEN budget towards these extra interventions and some children could be getting funding through an EHCP.

Of course raise any concerns you have if you think your child is going under the radar of the teachers but if they're doing well then please let those children who need it most get that extra bit of support.

TheFlyHalfsMum · 07/12/2023 21:37

I think this is poor from the school. My able readers have been read at least weekly 🤷🏻‍♀️

kitchenideas12 · 07/12/2023 21:37

I’m fully with you OP - I think this is pretty horrific and there should be no obligation on you to be a reading volunteer just so your obviously able child gets a very baseline degree of 1-2-1 attention!

I’m afraid this is where the British state system falls down massively. There are so many SEN issues, so much need to bring the least able up, that the focus is on lowest denominator standards, rather than pushing and supporting the more able to really soar. I totally understand why, given the lack of resources, but I do think that the best teachers are the ones who have the imagination and experience to give children just the right tasks and attention to push them each further. These are seen in both the state and independent sector. I have sympathy for parents of SEN children, but that doesn’t stop it being frustrating that non-SEN children are just expected to get on with it (and the number of SEN children in a class seems to rise every year, it’s so challenging for everyone - them, the teachers, the other children). The best schools seem to have dedicated SEN areas where all pupils’ needs are properly met.

Rycbar · 07/12/2023 21:32

Boomboom22 · 01/12/2023 17:31

I don't think they can actually read at Reception. I have older ones who I remember vividly the pain of 45 mins a night to read 3 letter word per page. I have a 4 Yr old now and they send home books to read to them and are doing letter formation and recognition. I doubt many are ready to read books aloud yet tbh.

I have one child in my class who isn’t reading books. Reception classes send books that are decodable based on the phonics they’ve learnt. So children can read in reception, they just can’t read words with sounds they haven’t learnt yet. Some children wont be at that stage yet as they can’t blend or struggle to retain the sounds. OP’s daughter is probably doing fine in phonics and therefore doesn’t need to be caught up with reading. Just because she isn’t reading doesn’t mean she is t getting quality interaction. Some of the most important learning that happens in early years is interaction with adults in provision.

Bertiesmum3 · 07/12/2023 21:00

Benibidibici · 01/12/2023 17:23

I know there's not much time but if there's enough time for other children 3 and 4 times every week, why does my child deserve SO little of the teacher's attention? He is barely four years old.

If you feel that strongly about it keep him home or go into school and sit with him whilst he reads!

Segway16 · 07/12/2023 20:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Children with special needs - and this will come as a shock it seems - have special needs. My child needs extra help because they have special needs. They can’t fucking speak. They can’t communicate. But yeah it’s super unfair that means it takes some time away from little Johnny and his “need” for some extra attention cause of his parents’ inflated sense of entitlement. Hideous comment.

pizzafordinneragain · 07/12/2023 20:29

Just to clarify, the other parents have td you that yours is the only child in the class not getting 3-4 one-on-one sessions? How many are they getting? If it’s two but some are getting three, it’s no big deal.

Tamuchly · 07/12/2023 20:22

As part of a nurture package, I read with three children on a 1-1 basis every morning in Reception last year (TA). They weren’t behind but they were at risk and building relationships with staff through reading (my colleague was doing the same thing with another three children) which meant we could notice when things weren’t right and that the children had trusted adults to talk to. I’ve also read with a child every day to assess his mood (ADHD) and factor that into the learning over the day eg simpler on a ‘busy’ day and more complex if he was more able to cope. Currently further up the school reading every day with 2 under-achieving children who are sadly well behind their peers. I’ve only read with about 7 of their class, despite my best efforts, I think the teacher is on a similar number and so is the other TA which leaves a handful of amazing readers that don’t get to read each week. It makes me very sad.

As a parent, I think it’s pretty poor they aren’t getting round to reading with your child at least once a fortnight but, unfortunately, I can see how it can happen.

Icopewhenihope · 07/12/2023 19:48

Your Mum is ‘horrified’? I’d to see what she would think if something of any consequence happened! Ridiculous.

Flamingbow · 07/12/2023 19:34

Benibidibici · 06/12/2023 17:54

Oh and my mum's a ks1 teacher and is horrified by it.

Horrified is a bit hyperbolic.

It's still the first term, it's a lot of work to try and get all children to a base line in phonics in order to be able to build on it in lessons going forward. I'm sure when the dust settles the 1 on 1 reading will become more balanced, but in the interim lots of praise, stickers etc at home when you write in their diary and why not ask the teacher if they can show them it every morning or whatever; it'll take a few seconds but might give him the valuation from an adult he's missing. Lots of children who aren't as ahead with phonics find reading really challenging and don't enjoy 1 to 1 reading, it's quite a privileged view really to assume all children enjoy that time. I'd be pleased that my child at this time didn't require it, and that they werent struggling and that I had the resources to hear them read at home.

AnneValentine · 07/12/2023 19:23

Benibidibici · 01/12/2023 17:31

Hes more able. The teacher has told me he is ahead in phonics.

I understand he won't get as much time as others for this reason.

However i hadnt realised just gow much teacher time others were getting until I heard a large group of parents praising the school for managing to hear them read so often and i was the only with a DC who is never heard read.

Its not about the readimg. Its about the fact that these kids are FOUR. They have emotional needs, its not fair for them never ever to have even a single turn having adult attention.

If he’s ahead it’s unnecessary. I’m not sure why you think the only quality time kids get in school is 1:1 reading. For many kids that’s the worst part of the day!

Cavamalparcequejesuisfatiguee · 07/12/2023 18:09

I’m at teacher and at my school we’re expecting to hear every child in Y5/6 read once per fortnight. Those with additional needs or other issues are more often, some daily. In reception I’d say at least once a week. This is the most important time.

K4tM · 07/12/2023 18:01

I’m assuming you listen to your own child read? There you go. They have an adult that listens to them read. When my children were small I read with them and I volunteered to listen to readers in their school (I was working 3 days/week). Some children get no help at home, or English isn’t spoken in the home or they have SEN like cerebral palsy. These children take precedence in school because they are furthest behind their peers and already have fewer chances in life.

StaunchMomma · 07/12/2023 17:48

Hes more able. The teacher has told me he is ahead in phonics.

But you still want him to get 'equal attention' to those who are struggling.

You're in for a rude awakening over the next decade or so!!

StaunchMomma · 07/12/2023 17:45

Penguin34 · 06/12/2023 19:04

My dd goes to a prep (reception, started in sept) and reads with a teacher, assistant, or reading buddy every day. She's given a new book every day and we do it at home (v simple 'he took a big sack of corn to the mill' etc)
A new phonic a day that they work on and have to bring items in with that digraph or trigraph.
She's very happy there.
Lots of my clients children go to state school and they get one book a week which the parents read every night and and they are read with once a week at school.
They are very happy there.

As long as you're doing it at home with them they'll all catch up to the same level.

You're literally paying for that privilege!

I'm sure you're aware that state schools are a tad different 🙄

StaunchMomma · 07/12/2023 17:42

Education is not about 1-1 time or 'attention' for all, it's about standards, levels and help where needed.

Reception year is HUGE in terms of foundations - getting the kids ready for Year 1, knowing the school will be judged by Year 2 SATS, means that although the year can feel quite 'fluffy and fun' from home, especially as there is a transitional 'play' element still, things are very much business in terms of outcome.

Your child will be heard reading by an adult at some point as they will need to be levelled. If they're not getting that weekly, it's because their reading is generally considered to be good enough to not have to input additional time/resources which are, pretty much across the board, thin on the ground.

If you feel so strongly about this then I agree with PPs - volunteer some of your own time to help the school facilitate it.

I would also point out, although it may well get me flamed, that all kids that age should be getting 1-1 reading time at home with a parent or guardian, preferably daily, to encourage vital skills. Schools cannot do that for us.

Casperroonie · 07/12/2023 17:33

Why don't you ask the teacher?

Penguin34 · 06/12/2023 19:04

My dd goes to a prep (reception, started in sept) and reads with a teacher, assistant, or reading buddy every day. She's given a new book every day and we do it at home (v simple 'he took a big sack of corn to the mill' etc)
A new phonic a day that they work on and have to bring items in with that digraph or trigraph.
She's very happy there.
Lots of my clients children go to state school and they get one book a week which the parents read every night and and they are read with once a week at school.
They are very happy there.

As long as you're doing it at home with them they'll all catch up to the same level.