Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect a child to read with a grown up at least a couple of times in the first term of reception?

286 replies

Benibidibici · 01/12/2023 17:17

DC is late aug birthday so only just four on starting school. Happy there and enjoying it etc, settled in fine.

They are never heard read by any adult. Teacher has acknowledged this.

Have found out this week some kids are reading with an adult one on one three or four times a week.

I know they have to focus on the ones who need a bit of help but come the fuck on, how does a little 4 year old feel if they never get that little bit of one on one time with a grown up and others get loads? Its not just about the reading - its about that bit of attention, the teacher or TA learning who they are and how they respond. Surely they can fit in my DC once or twice a term if they can find 3 or 4 times a week for other kids. Dc hates never getting picked to go and read. :(

OP posts:
Araminta1003 · 08/12/2023 12:02

My DCs were ahead in reading when they started and the teacher read with them about 1-2 per term to assess their reading levels and move them up a band. Sometimes they were stuck for ages on a band because of lack of teacher time but school were pretty good to respond if I put a note in the diary when the DC got to really fed up.

The TAs would check the reading diary 2-3 times a week and those kids whose parents did not read with them, got far more attention and interventions because they needed it. The dyslexic children also got far more time and interventions because the Government’s expectation is primarily to get all kids to a certain standard.
The parents with kids who are ahead - it is still better to keep giving your child that 1 to 1. My DC only ever got upset over intervention kids getting more Dojos to encourage them. My DC were set some harder work but expected to get on with it themselves. If this upset them- the girls especially would tell me - and we would help at home/let the teacher know occasionally. Dojos were rewarded for a particular child struggling and overcoming primarily. We had to make sure our own DC understood this. We had to largely challenge outside school although once or twice in 7 years of primary school they did get a teacher who had high expectations of all the kids, including those who are ahead. It is important to understand the system and support accordingly. A child with educated parents who make time is still at a huge advantage!

wishingiwas20something · 08/12/2023 11:50

Benibidibici · 02/12/2023 16:21

It sounds like the other parents know because their children's reading diaries are regularly written in by the person they read to. And OP's child's reading diary is blank except for OP's own entries.

This- the other parents had pages and pages of entries in their childrens journals from teacher/ta/parent volunteers, with 2 or 3 different booms sent each week. My sons just has what i write. The only thing written at school is the title of the one book he's given each week.

Nb i wouldn't say he's "advanced" but i figure he's doing fine - for a 4 year old! Recognising the letters, blending short words etc.

This doesn’t make sense to me… Our school sets 1-2 books per week (depending on how kid does), these travel backwards and forwards each day with teacher and parent comments: great blending, struggled with high frequency words etc. Why don’t you call head of reception (if there is one) and ask them for a meeting and take the book along to show them? If your child is advanced they should be receiving multiple books per week as they are confidently reading them/progressing - are you being issued new books when you note they are completed?

goody2shooz · 08/12/2023 11:05

@Benibidibici cant believe all the people on here giving the op stick because she can’t volunteer in the school, who are saying she’s a ‘demanding parent’, ‘THAT parent’ etc. Omg - her child hasn’t been heard reading ONCE in a term, and other kids get three times a week - on what planet is that reasonable? As an ex teacher I’d say she has every right to complain. Teacher or TA has to get round every single child, and nothing written in their book is disgraceful. I detest the idea of an overlooked child.

kitchenideas12 · 08/12/2023 11:01

Sorry @CynicalToad but just no. Why should it be up to the school to get a SEN child up to an average standard, but up to the parents to get an average or above average child up to the top standard? Both of these processes require moving a child on one step. Why should it only be the parents of non-SEN children who are challenged “well are you making time out of your full time job to go into school and volunteer to hear reading?” and not the parents of SEN kids, who receive this as standard? Both children require help to get to the next stage.

Education should be for all families, not just for those with struggling children. I do feel for parents of SEN children, but with the best will in the world this will just be the first of many struggles they face and it shouldn’t always be at the expense of other children or (busy) parents. Otherwise as another person said above, we breed mediocrity - focusing only on the lowest denominator might mean that we can get more people into lower skilled jobs but it will be the absolute death of creativity, innovation and excellence.

Tiredmamaof1 · 08/12/2023 10:09

I agree that your son should be heard reading more, but at the same time this is not about attention. Its about children learning to read and the ones that struggle more will be seen more. I would speak to the teacher and ask that he have that reading time at least once a fortnight. Just so that they can monitor his progress properly.

Mazuslongtoenail · 08/12/2023 09:09

I don’t think it’s unreasonable at all. How do they know DC doesn’t need to read more if they don’t hear him?

Our school hears all children twice a week. 1/2 of the class read a couple of pages to teacher or TA while the other one supervisors an activity. Those that need more practice read daily with a group of year 6s who volunteer.

Allthingsdecember · 08/12/2023 08:54

Ideally they should be hearing every child read. If that’s honestly not possible, I’d expect them to concentrate on the children experiencing difficulties, not those who are reading at an expected age.

One of my DC has SEN and I’d be furious if he wasn’t given the appropriate support that he needs in order to keep up with his peers. Especially if this was done just to save another child from feeling left out. Surely the teacher (and you) can explain that some children need extra support? Bare in mind that some of these children may be entitled to extra funding that help the school pay for a TA.

ThePurpleFairy · 08/12/2023 08:41

Wow I can’t believe the attitude of some people on here - no wonder the school are being so poor if so many people are so accepting of it! How can they possibly know he’s ‘ahead’ if they’ve never once bothered listening to him read?

I would be furious as well OP. Your child deserves some attention to their progress just as much as any - it matters not what level he is at, he deserves encouragement and education from the school too. If a teacher can’t support the learning of all the different levels in their class without simply neglecting those that are ‘doing well’ then they need to improve, simple as. It might be a hard truth but the fact is it’s underperformance and it wouldn’t be acceptable in other lines of work. I’d be advocating for my child too. I pay taxes towards education and would absolutely not accept being told there’s no time at all for my child. Parents with children struggling should be told to be making more of an effort at home if their children are so behind that they are monopolising the teacher’s time. Their progress shouldn’t come at the expense of OPs child's.

saffy2 · 08/12/2023 08:38

Surely they are heard regularly by an adult at home.

Ggttl · 08/12/2023 08:37

CynicalToad · 07/12/2023 21:55

Do you know what else is fucking unfair? Kids who are struggling falling further behind and - if not corrected - having their life chances severely affected because little Jonny has to have exactly 1/30th of the teacher's attention.

Our school takes a "keep up not catch up" approach in KS1 and that means some children get extra help every day and some children don't need so much support.

The school may also be using some of their notional SEN budget towards these extra interventions and some children could be getting funding through an EHCP.

Of course raise any concerns you have if you think your child is going under the radar of the teachers but if they're doing well then please let those children who need it most get that extra bit of support.

The aim in schools is for all children to achieve their potential. It is not for all children to reach a standard mediocre level and then leave them to it.

wishingiwas20something · 08/12/2023 08:30

At independent school they read with each child everyday. They expect parents to read with their children everyday in return. How often does the OP listen to her child read?

Phoenixfire1988 · 08/12/2023 08:12

Benibidibici · 01/12/2023 17:50

Fine clearly lots of people disagree. Imho there should never be such an imbalanced split of attention. Id understand if my DC was heard twice and term and others twice a week. But some children four times a week and others never?

Its fucking unfair on little children.

Your child won't be the only one stop being so precious about it I bet the other parents aren't sat having a paddy because their little darling isn't getting special 1:1 time with the teacher

Soozy58 · 08/12/2023 08:06

Firstly, are you actually sure your child is never heard reading? In my experience what a 4yr old tells you about school can be very different from what actually happens. Secondly an opinion on mumsnet is not going to solve the problem, you need to make an appointment to see the teacher or alternatively parents evenings are the place to bring things like this up and usually a parents evening for reception is quite early on in the academic year.

oakleaffy · 08/12/2023 07:24

My son has a late July Birthday and started school at age 4.
In retrospect I wish I'd held him back a year.

He was almost a year younger than some of the other children, which makes a big difference to size and maturity when they are so young.

StopLickingTheDog · 08/12/2023 07:21

"The school may also be using some of their notional SEN budget towards these extra interventions and some children could be getting funding through an EHCP."

This is very true. My son is in reception and they read with an adult twice a week, or daily if not meeting their expected level. My son isn't behind but reads with an adult daily because he has a 1:1 LSA and isn't able to go to the daily assembly so reads with her then.

What he actually needs, is a specialist school but despite all professionals saying that, I'm having to go to court to get the LA to actually provide that.

oakleaffy · 08/12/2023 07:19

SWSO · 01/12/2023 18:01

I used to do this , very rewarding. I also managed to spot which kids needed glasses .

I used to volunteer at son's school, too.

My friend knows a 'Pets as Therapy Dog' Whippet who goes into schools and ''Listens'' to the children reading. {Pets as Therapy dogs are assessed and follow strict guidelines of hygiene and good manners as well as quiet behaviour}

The children don't feel worried reading to a quiet dog, and she loves being read to.

Muthaofcats · 08/12/2023 07:11

Lots of working parents still volunteer. It’s incredibly hard to juggle and some jobs (clinical, retail etc) this would be impossible, but if you wfh occasionally you can spare half an hour to go in and then make up the time over lunch or after bed time etc. that’s what many do so that they still get to go in occasionally.

ohdamnitjanet · 08/12/2023 07:03

Whether it’s fair or not, I can’t imagine when my son was 4 he’d have any idea he wasn’t getting one on one attention. He would be much more focused on his little mates than whether or not the teacher listening to him read. I’m sure most infants wouldn’t give a shit.

Muthaofcats · 08/12/2023 07:00

many kids in reception can already read so will be taken to different reading groups to practise.

can your child read books yet? If they’re still working on phonics and can’t join the words together to read them independently yet then maybe this is why?

It’s Just a harsh reality that at school they’re not going to get 1:1 care; it’s school, it’s 30:1 and if lucky an extra TA or SEN support staff. That’s just how it is. You can’t compare based on what other kids are getting as maybe they have different needs or ability you aren’t aware of. You could always ask the teacher how it works when you next have parents evening (if not before?)

if you were worried about your child being so young in the year (and I would have been too), then it was open to you to delay their start until 5 so that they’d be a bit better able to cope with independence and less teacher input. Did you apply for that and have it rejected or just not look into it? I agree it really is so young to start school and get so much less support, there is a big developmental difference compared with those born in the early autumn.

are you reading at home with your child? They should be hearing you read stories to them every night. That’s the best thing you can do to help them.

SmellyNelliey · 08/12/2023 06:47

At my children's school they read once a week to teach/TA with a book change.
Then my children read to me morning and after school everyday and once a day on weekends.
My DD is 4 and in reception and can read 📚
My DD who is 7 struggles alot.
My DD who is 9 is actually reading Harry Potter books.
Every child is different and teacher just don't have enough time unfortunately.

Libra24 · 08/12/2023 06:41

I'm actually going to agree with OP here. Children are sponges and they pick up on everything. And of course never being selected to do activities that others are will feel like a negative thing.

With more able children it is important not to have them feel like they demotivated to be excelling because they miss out on other things.
And I know that from personal experience. I missed out on games and play sessions because I could read early. I got sent to advanced classes because I was ahead of my peers
And I hated it.
OP I would raise with the school as an issue.
You need to be willing to hear them out but nothing wrong with saying you're concerned and would like to understand how they are supporting your child's needs.

Popcorn23 · 08/12/2023 04:34

Every child should be able to read to an adult regularly but maybe the school has staffing issues? The ones that do get chosen to read may have specific needs.

Schools do encourage parents to listen to their child reading at home regularly. This might be a good option.

CynicalToad · 08/12/2023 01:08

SophieinParis · 08/12/2023 00:50

As a teacher I disagree. That approach breeds mediocrity. I want my brighter children challenged to become the best they can be and my average children supported to be lifted out of the average bracket and into excellence. And the struggling children I want to ensure understand the required framework and are able to keep up and not fall behind.

Pretty sure I didn't say that children shouldn't be stretched to achieve their full potential. I merely pointed out that access to education isn't a timeshare scheme and the fact that some children get more one-to-one reading time isn't necessarily to the detriment of others.

Foxymoxy68 · 08/12/2023 00:50

Recently retired deputy head. All children in all classes were heard read at least once a week by an adult (teacher or TA) with the lowest achieving 20%/pupil premium children being heard more often. This was really difficult at times but was made a priority.
A teacher cannot comment on a child's progress in reading if he/she is not listening to them read regularly.

SophieinParis · 08/12/2023 00:50

CynicalToad · 07/12/2023 21:55

Do you know what else is fucking unfair? Kids who are struggling falling further behind and - if not corrected - having their life chances severely affected because little Jonny has to have exactly 1/30th of the teacher's attention.

Our school takes a "keep up not catch up" approach in KS1 and that means some children get extra help every day and some children don't need so much support.

The school may also be using some of their notional SEN budget towards these extra interventions and some children could be getting funding through an EHCP.

Of course raise any concerns you have if you think your child is going under the radar of the teachers but if they're doing well then please let those children who need it most get that extra bit of support.

As a teacher I disagree. That approach breeds mediocrity. I want my brighter children challenged to become the best they can be and my average children supported to be lifted out of the average bracket and into excellence. And the struggling children I want to ensure understand the required framework and are able to keep up and not fall behind.