Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect a child to read with a grown up at least a couple of times in the first term of reception?

286 replies

Benibidibici · 01/12/2023 17:17

DC is late aug birthday so only just four on starting school. Happy there and enjoying it etc, settled in fine.

They are never heard read by any adult. Teacher has acknowledged this.

Have found out this week some kids are reading with an adult one on one three or four times a week.

I know they have to focus on the ones who need a bit of help but come the fuck on, how does a little 4 year old feel if they never get that little bit of one on one time with a grown up and others get loads? Its not just about the reading - its about that bit of attention, the teacher or TA learning who they are and how they respond. Surely they can fit in my DC once or twice a term if they can find 3 or 4 times a week for other kids. Dc hates never getting picked to go and read. :(

OP posts:
ThePurpleFairy · 08/12/2023 20:39

Fluffybunniesandkittens · 08/12/2023 16:44

SEN children are not monopolising the teacher's time at the expense of other kids unless it's through bad behaviour in class.
1 to 1 for SEN children happens with other staff members, learning mentors, TAs etc. They are taken out of class, out of assembly, out of PE, whenever the staff are available to fit them in.
Meanwhile the class teacher is giving every other child an education and that education is not affected.
Not having read 1 to 1 to the teacher doesn't mean that the child isn't reading to the teacher/other staff. They may be reading in groups.
Not all children that are so far behind, are behind because not enough effort is made at home. My child had delayed development for medical reasons, had extra help at school through internal SEN, and managed to catch up to national average by year 6, despite being read to/with every night.

So why is there nothing at all written in this child’s reading diary from any school staff? The teacher herself has essentially admitted the ball has been dropped here with OPs child.

I accept that struggling/SEN children may need some additional help in school but it’s not acceptable to just put kids who are on track on the back burner to do it. Children who excel in school also need to be appropriately challenged and stretched.

People suggesting that anybody with a child that doesn’t have SEN should be home educating or paying for private education are quite frankly being ridiculous, and I don’t agree that it’s entitled to expect a child to receive a good standard of education from the school they attend.

Oldermumofone · 08/12/2023 20:14

I still agree with you and I think the majority of teachers on here do too from reading. Interesting that his own teacher really also accepted it isn’t good enough. Parent support is vital in helping them to do well and I will always hear my child read and recognise the benefit where children read at home. However, it is the teacher’s job to be monitoring a child’s reading and good schools are still achieving this despite all the cuts because it should be their priority. It is also their job to ensure all children feel valued in their class and while the picture won’t be the same for every child, never reading while others read daily is not fair - and let’s remember that these children are four and equity is a tricky concept for children far older as well as many adults.

Yummers8 · 08/12/2023 19:52

You’re an adult.
Do YOU read with your child?
If not, then do it!

Kathryn1983 · 08/12/2023 19:46

Segway16 · 08/12/2023 19:15

Agree. I wfh and I am chained to my desk for at least 8-9 hours a day. There is no “popping out” to volunteer. I read with my children in the evenings and at weekends and volunteer in the school roles that I can commit to (school governor out of work hours). We can’t all just drop our full time jobs to volunteer.

This 100%
people assuming wfh means it's somehow easier to nip away I literally have meetings after meetings and already use my flexibility to do school runs and such it's main draw js the lack of commute time etc
it's fine for the op not to volunteer! Anyone suggesting this as the solution is living a sheltered and privileged existence work wise that many can only dream of
would you tell a surgeon to just nip out during an operation to volunteer at school- no so why is ops job any less valuable to her or society somehow because it's done at home!
She sounds entitled and a bit deluded about the normal reading process in reception but her work isn't the issue here really is it 🤦‍♀️

Miracleglaze · 08/12/2023 19:43

Ourlittletalks · 08/12/2023 18:14

Your child is already learning to read? My five year old is in junior infants in Ireland (she goes to an Irish speaking primary school), and so far they’ve learned the phonetics for C A and R. I’m so confused.

It's a different country so the curriculum will be different. That's all it is.
Juniors Infants in English medium schools in Ireland are at the phonics stage too.

Segway16 · 08/12/2023 19:15

Benibidibici · 08/12/2023 19:00

if you wfh occasionally you can spare half an hour to go in and then make up the time over lunch or after bed time etc

I am not allowed to do this with my work. I also already work reduced/flexible hours to cut down on wraparound care needs. I would fucking love to go in and volunteer but I just can't during the school day.

Agree. I wfh and I am chained to my desk for at least 8-9 hours a day. There is no “popping out” to volunteer. I read with my children in the evenings and at weekends and volunteer in the school roles that I can commit to (school governor out of work hours). We can’t all just drop our full time jobs to volunteer.

Benibidibici · 08/12/2023 19:06

it was open to you to delay their start until 5 so that they’d be a bit better able to cope with independence and less teacher input.

I wasn't worried about him and im still not. He's coping fine and is independent. I would describe him as "very able" etc as people on here assume but he's doing fine. Its utterly normal for a child to notice when they never get a turn at something others get almost every day.

OP posts:
Benibidibici · 08/12/2023 19:00

if you wfh occasionally you can spare half an hour to go in and then make up the time over lunch or after bed time etc

I am not allowed to do this with my work. I also already work reduced/flexible hours to cut down on wraparound care needs. I would fucking love to go in and volunteer but I just can't during the school day.

OP posts:
Benibidibici · 08/12/2023 18:43

Kids who are struggling falling further behind and - if not corrected - having their life chances severely affected because little Jonny has to have exactly 1/30th of the teacher's attention

Rtft. I am very clear that i do not expect DS to get 1/30th!

I'd expect 1/500th rather than 1/5000th. While other children get 5/30.

OP posts:
Benibidibici · 08/12/2023 18:40

How often does the OP listen to her child read?

I or DH read with him every day.

OP posts:
Duechristmas · 08/12/2023 18:37

The entitlement here is everything that's wrong with parents at the moment. Your child is doing well, you admit that yourself. Children who come from homes with deprivation you can't even imagine, parental illness, or huge historic disadvantages deserve a step up. Your child probably doesn't even notice whether he's chosen or not. Reading with the teacher isn't a cosy time to connect, it's just reading. If you don't like it, home educate or go private.

Pipistrellus · 08/12/2023 18:36

Ourlittletalks · 08/12/2023 18:14

Your child is already learning to read? My five year old is in junior infants in Ireland (she goes to an Irish speaking primary school), and so far they’ve learned the phonetics for C A and R. I’m so confused.

Can the adults typically read Irish fluently and regularly read to their children in Irish at home? Are children being raised Irish speaking only or bilingual?

Ourlittletalks · 08/12/2023 18:14

Your child is already learning to read? My five year old is in junior infants in Ireland (she goes to an Irish speaking primary school), and so far they’ve learned the phonetics for C A and R. I’m so confused.

Segway16 · 08/12/2023 18:04

Just to add, I agree with OP’s frustration. I would be really annoyed in this situation.

I personally just didn’t like the repugnant comment re children with SEN. My child has an EHCP so there is additional funding for some of the extra assistance required. But yes my child does require more attention because they have significant additional needs.

My neurotypical children still need encouragement and attention at school and home.

Pipistrellus · 08/12/2023 17:12

Reugny · 08/12/2023 14:42

I found plenty of adults who could read before they started school.

I could. My DP could. Some friends of mine could.

We were all born at different times of the year including summer.

My DD could not read before she started school because we deliberately didn't teach her.

I could, self-taught, I taught my sister. DS14 couldn't. DS4 (spring born) could before his birthday, self-taught, I only read to him.

Baba197 · 08/12/2023 17:03

I would be unhappy with this also. My son was heard read at least once a week with the teacher in yr- as we’re all the other children. On
another day he would read with a parent helper sometimes once a week sometimes more if they had lots of helpers. He’s yr 1 now and a good reader so doesn’t always read more that once a week. Are you able to go on to help out at all or another family member? I’d ask to speak to the teacher and express how unhappy you are with the situation. Yes teachers are very busy but each child deserves some time

Rubyphoebetina · 08/12/2023 16:51

What is the school’s explanation?
When my son started reception he was already able to read as a)he was almost 5 and b)he had been in the school nursery where they teach them a year early. However the majority of kids, who had come from other nurseries couldn’t read at all. So in this situation I would expect the ones who could read to be taken off to read and the main teacher to be focusing on teaching phonics to the bulk of the class.

Fluffybunniesandkittens · 08/12/2023 16:44

ThePurpleFairy · 08/12/2023 08:41

Wow I can’t believe the attitude of some people on here - no wonder the school are being so poor if so many people are so accepting of it! How can they possibly know he’s ‘ahead’ if they’ve never once bothered listening to him read?

I would be furious as well OP. Your child deserves some attention to their progress just as much as any - it matters not what level he is at, he deserves encouragement and education from the school too. If a teacher can’t support the learning of all the different levels in their class without simply neglecting those that are ‘doing well’ then they need to improve, simple as. It might be a hard truth but the fact is it’s underperformance and it wouldn’t be acceptable in other lines of work. I’d be advocating for my child too. I pay taxes towards education and would absolutely not accept being told there’s no time at all for my child. Parents with children struggling should be told to be making more of an effort at home if their children are so behind that they are monopolising the teacher’s time. Their progress shouldn’t come at the expense of OPs child's.

SEN children are not monopolising the teacher's time at the expense of other kids unless it's through bad behaviour in class.
1 to 1 for SEN children happens with other staff members, learning mentors, TAs etc. They are taken out of class, out of assembly, out of PE, whenever the staff are available to fit them in.
Meanwhile the class teacher is giving every other child an education and that education is not affected.
Not having read 1 to 1 to the teacher doesn't mean that the child isn't reading to the teacher/other staff. They may be reading in groups.
Not all children that are so far behind, are behind because not enough effort is made at home. My child had delayed development for medical reasons, had extra help at school through internal SEN, and managed to catch up to national average by year 6, despite being read to/with every night.

stichguru · 08/12/2023 16:28

What do you actually KNOW and what is you making wild accusations based on totally wrong information?
"I know there's not much time but if there's enough time for other children 3 and 4 times every week, why does my child deserve SO little of the teacher's attention? He is barely four years old."
If your child is getting so little of the teacher's attention that is bad. However all your comments are solely about how much time your child is reading for, you make NO comment on what else he is being given help with. Do you KNOW that he isn't being given more help than others in maybe something he is weak in? Maybe actually he is being given MORE attention than some other children in an area he struggles with? Before you go ranting maybe just ask the teacher what is happening.

CynicalToad · 08/12/2023 15:29

Ggttl · 08/12/2023 08:37

The aim in schools is for all children to achieve their potential. It is not for all children to reach a standard mediocre level and then leave them to it.

I agree, and I don't think I've said otherwise?

CynicalToad · 08/12/2023 15:22

kitchenideas12 · 08/12/2023 11:01

Sorry @CynicalToad but just no. Why should it be up to the school to get a SEN child up to an average standard, but up to the parents to get an average or above average child up to the top standard? Both of these processes require moving a child on one step. Why should it only be the parents of non-SEN children who are challenged “well are you making time out of your full time job to go into school and volunteer to hear reading?” and not the parents of SEN kids, who receive this as standard? Both children require help to get to the next stage.

Education should be for all families, not just for those with struggling children. I do feel for parents of SEN children, but with the best will in the world this will just be the first of many struggles they face and it shouldn’t always be at the expense of other children or (busy) parents. Otherwise as another person said above, we breed mediocrity - focusing only on the lowest denominator might mean that we can get more people into lower skilled jobs but it will be the absolute death of creativity, innovation and excellence.

Edited

I haven't said the things you think I've said.

Araminta1003 · 08/12/2023 15:05

In our school there was a list of daily readers/early phonics intervention aka kids on FSM, SEN, safeguarding, speech delays etc- those kids were the focus in Reception until they caught up, sometimes by Year 1/2/3/4 etc.
OP are you sure some of the kids getting loads of attention are not on such a list? There may be a lot of kids on the list due to Covid and delays in the NHS especially speech & language.

The second thing I can think of as someone who volunteers a lot in state primary schools is that we have a list of the whole class to get through when I volunteer. Could he have been left on the list by mistake? When we read we stamp the reading journal and I often read with the higher attainers unless the TA hasn’t managed to do the daily reading/phonics with those that need intervention. Pre Covid I did start volunteering in the second half of the first term of Reception. However, that could differ from school to school.

If you want this sorted you have to put it in an email to the teacher and just ask open questions. Things like Dear Ms X I have noticed that nobody has signed my DC’s reading diary. When will an adult start reading with my child regularly and will it be recorded each time etc how many books is my child meant to be given each week? Etc
In a good school the teacher communicates the goal posts clearly in whole class briefings and termly updated and online to these days. My DCs school was very good and because we had other parents join from other schools I know that not all schools are like that. Often it does depend on the cohort though and how involved the parent group are- it is much easier with a group of kids where most the parents are involved and only a few need extra time and help.

Reugny · 08/12/2023 14:42

Bamboobzled · 08/12/2023 00:31

Yeah, sure you did.

I found plenty of adults who could read before they started school.

I could. My DP could. Some friends of mine could.

We were all born at different times of the year including summer.

My DD could not read before she started school because we deliberately didn't teach her.

Kathryn1983 · 08/12/2023 14:23

And I understand the ops frustration - but they sound ridiculously angry and entitled to me and that blurs the ability for us to be empathetic towards them
raise it with the school
if teacher doesn't action your concern escalate it to the head etc etc
you are on the pta so use that to raise concerns about the lack of focus on reading in the early years at the school
maybe the other parents are getting lots of comments in the reading books as their kids are making progress weekly but from a lower standard
if they had to literally learn all their phonic sounds from the teacher they'd get lots of 1-2-1 time but doing just a few sound regognitions etc
have you actually looked at the curriculum for this stage actual reading 1-2-1 of BOOKs is certainly not on it yet!

Kathryn1983 · 08/12/2023 14:00

I'd say if your only just 4 year old can already read (not just still learning letter sounds) they're miles ahead of their peers anyway
most schools spend the first half term getting the class baseline
then they start with phonics sounds etc
then maybe by the second half term they start with some blending in small ability focused groups
I would not expect them to start to do 1-2-1 actual reading (of like a simple cvc book) for at least another term tbh
Our school still has special friends to teach and such
do some 1-2-1 reading at home if you are wanting them to be encouraged
does your daughter feel discouraged?
my only just 4 year old is buzzing over reading and school and other than her base line assessment she's had zero one to one reading time so far!
she could do most of her letter sounds by school start but certainly some she forgot after a summer of us not doing much at home etc

Swipe left for the next trending thread