Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex and his wedding

605 replies

tukker · 01/12/2023 09:42

My ex is getting married next year and DD is meant to be a bridesmaid. Dd is nearly 18 and we live in Europe. Dd has a boyfriend and wants him to go to this wedding too but exh and gf aren't so keen.
Firstly they expected me to pay for flights, I said no. Then they said they would pay for DD but not her bf..
The wedding is in July so plenty of time. Dd had an argument with her dad about it all a couple of weeks ago. Exh gf has now accused dd of ruining the wedding as there's now an extra guest and she says the plans can't be changed.
Dd just wants to support her dad she doesn't really like the gf or her family.
The gf has now text dd this morning with an ultimatum about whether she really wants to be a bridesmaid or not and they will pay for some of the flight but they will have to pay for their own food for 2 days! , and she needs to let her know ASAP! I'm really trying to stop myself texting Exh because it will be a sh!tstorm if I do, but why hasn't he rang and spoke to DD?!
It's his DD and yes it's inconvenient that she wants to take her bf but so what?! Surely you accommodate that?! Or am I being unreasonable??

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 02/12/2023 23:47

Loopylemon2 · 02/12/2023 23:44

She's an adult, which means you compromise in life, so if her dad said no to the boyfriend, she accommodates that and not throw a tantrum.

It's a few days, pretty sure she would manage. And quite honestly if she can't, then yeah, don't go and pretty sure they won't miss her sulking. But it doesn't need to be made out because her DF is some flake for not forking out on a stranger.

The OP chose to move overseas with DD.

So

Why should her ex have to cover additional costs because of her decisions made to suit her lifestyle. That's fucking ridiculous.

Ps. The world doesn't need to evolve around one person and refusing to pay for a boyfriend doesn't mean she's not important to them, just means the boyfriend isn't important to them lol

Edited

She doesn't have to accommodate anything.

If she doesn't want to go without her boyfriend, she doesn't have to.

If her dad wants her there, he needs to do whatever is necessary to enable her to attend. He can't force her to attend against her will/budgetary constraints.

The point about maintenance is mainly relevant in the sense that he's saved so much money by not paying towards his daughter's upkeep that he should be able to stretch to this.

Loopylemon2 · 02/12/2023 23:44

MargotBamborough · 02/12/2023 23:33

What is she supposed to be accommodating exactly?

She doesn't want to go to the wedding without her boyfriend because she knows she'll have a shit time. She can't afford to pay all the costs of attending herself, because she's 18. She also can't be forced to attend, because she's 18. And the OP obviously shouldn't be paying for her daughter (with or without the boyfriend) to attend her ex husband's wedding to another woman, because that would be fucking ridiculous.

So.

Does he want his daughter at his wedding or not?

If he does, it's on him to facilitate her attendance.

PS - yes, if I were getting married I would consider the groom's daughter to be one of the most important guests and of course she should be allowed to bring her boyfriend if she wants to. "Stranger" or not. Because it would be important to me for her to attend and for her to have a good time.

Edited

She's an adult, which means you compromise in life, so if her dad said no to the boyfriend, she accommodates that and not throw a tantrum.

It's a few days, pretty sure she would manage. And quite honestly if she can't, then yeah, don't go and pretty sure they won't miss her sulking. But it doesn't need to be made out because her DF is some flake for not forking out on a stranger.

The OP chose to move overseas with DD.

So

Why should her ex have to cover additional costs because of her decisions made to suit her lifestyle. That's fucking ridiculous.

Ps. The world doesn't need to evolve around one person and refusing to pay for a boyfriend doesn't mean she's not important to them, just means the boyfriend isn't important to them lol

Badgrief · 02/12/2023 23:38

Can't you put in a claim for him to pay appropriate maintenance for your daughter? Then you could use this towards paying some of the costs for bf to go too.

MargotBamborough · 02/12/2023 23:33

Loopylemon2 · 02/12/2023 23:29

So everyone needs to accommodate the DD, but she’s not to be accommodating?

Also, in all seriousness would you be okay with your limited budget (cause clearly they’re not millionaires) and your hard earned money or that of your family’s paying for a stranger to be at your family wedding? DD is not the brides child, so you’re spending her money/budget.

In addition, when me and my DH paid for our wedding I can assure you it was completely about what we wanted and chose. It was all about us 😁

What is she supposed to be accommodating exactly?

She doesn't want to go to the wedding without her boyfriend because she knows she'll have a shit time. She can't afford to pay all the costs of attending herself, because she's 18. She also can't be forced to attend, because she's 18. And the OP obviously shouldn't be paying for her daughter (with or without the boyfriend) to attend her ex husband's wedding to another woman, because that would be fucking ridiculous.

So.

Does he want his daughter at his wedding or not?

If he does, it's on him to facilitate her attendance.

PS - yes, if I were getting married I would consider the groom's daughter to be one of the most important guests and of course she should be allowed to bring her boyfriend if she wants to. "Stranger" or not. Because it would be important to me for her to attend and for her to have a good time.

sandyhappypeople · 02/12/2023 23:33

The thing that stands out to me is why would she even want to be bridesmaid for someone ‘she doesn’t like’ ? If she just wanted to support her dad as you claim, she could have turned down being a bridesmaid and just be a guest? It sounds like ex and girlfriend wanted her to be involved in the wedding.

they are perfectly within their rights to say no to accommodating and paying for a boyfriend who may or may not be around next year, and I can see why the girlfriend is reluctant to have her as bridesmaid anymore after all this kick off and drama, from what I can see they were paying for DD to go, the problems have only arisen when she’s demanding to bring her boyfriend and for them to pay for that?

you sound like you’re actually stoking this fire with your own opinions of your ex and his girlfriend, rather than being the voice of reason as you claim you are, ultimately they are never going to have a close relationship anymore when they live in separate countries, it’s not either’s fault, I doubt your daughter has time for her dad with all the new stuff she’s going on, and he’s got his family there, so it’s unfair to JUST blame your ex for the lack of a relationship between them, it was you that moved her away from them, but you are flat out refusing to accept that as a contributing factor in them not being as close anymore.

Loopylemon2 · 02/12/2023 23:29

MargotBamborough · 02/12/2023 23:14

It's not all about the bride's family, regardless of who is paying.

It's about two families joining together.

If being able to bring her boyfriend is important to the daughter, not accommodating that is very short sighted. Her father should put his foot down, not let his partner call the shots (if that is what is happening).

They can be difficult and unwelcoming towards his daughter if they want, but any consequences will be on them.

Contrary to popular belief, your wedding is not actually all about you.

So everyone needs to accommodate the DD, but she’s not to be accommodating?

Also, in all seriousness would you be okay with your limited budget (cause clearly they’re not millionaires) and your hard earned money or that of your family’s paying for a stranger to be at your family wedding? DD is not the brides child, so you’re spending her money/budget.

In addition, when me and my DH paid for our wedding I can assure you it was completely about what we wanted and chose. It was all about us 😁

ScoobyT · 02/12/2023 23:15

I would stay out of it and let your daughter fight her own battle - difficult I know. Your ex should definitely be paying for her flight but to be fair I don’t think he is required to pay for the boyfriends.

MargotBamborough · 02/12/2023 23:14

Loopylemon2 · 02/12/2023 23:02

The thing is, you are (as we all are) making assumptions.

The bride’s family could have made a large contribution to the wedding budget, if so why should that be used on stranger. They could be on restricted numbers (venues have capacities), so if they have had to not invite people as a result, why should they facilitate a stranger instead. Ultimately, they shouldn’t feel obligated to invite anyone they don’t want to.

The DD should be adult enough to also maintain a relationship with her DF. She asked, they said no, that’s life, it’s their event. If because of that she now refuses to attend, which is her choice, it absolutely doesn’t fall on her DF if they have a bad relationship.

It's not all about the bride's family, regardless of who is paying.

It's about two families joining together.

If being able to bring her boyfriend is important to the daughter, not accommodating that is very short sighted. Her father should put his foot down, not let his partner call the shots (if that is what is happening).

They can be difficult and unwelcoming towards his daughter if they want, but any consequences will be on them.

Contrary to popular belief, your wedding is not actually all about you.

ThisHouseWillBeTheDeathOfMe · 02/12/2023 23:12

Scruffington · 02/12/2023 23:09

Ssssh I'm still reading through the thread where your dad thinks your husband in untrutworthy.

It was probably past my bed time...

Scruffington · 02/12/2023 23:09

ThisHouseWillBeTheDeathOfMe · 02/12/2023 23:08

Oooooh you can jump on that instead of irrelevant maintenance now eh Grin. It's actually in common use, but if you want, use "tantrum" instead.

Honestly, it's cool. I see on virtually a daily basis you tell people it's past their bedtime, or call them "shit", or accuse them of being drunk.

If you need to do that, its ok.

Ssssh I'm still reading through the thread where your dad thinks your husband in untrutworthy.

ThisHouseWillBeTheDeathOfMe · 02/12/2023 23:08

Scruffington · 02/12/2023 23:02

'have paddys'?

we don't use that term in 2023.

Oooooh you can jump on that instead of irrelevant maintenance now eh Grin. It's actually in common use, but if you want, use "tantrum" instead.

Honestly, it's cool. I see on virtually a daily basis you tell people it's past their bedtime, or call them "shit", or accuse them of being drunk.

If you need to do that, its ok.

Loopylemon2 · 02/12/2023 23:06

Over40Overdating · 02/12/2023 22:59

I see the penis apologists are out in force limboing under a bar set in hell to defend the ex.

If I’ve got it right, OP and her DD are awful, entitled, poor ex bashing harridans because they don’t want to shell out or get a job to pay for the DD to go to the wedding where she’s not particularly wanted, where some support on a difficult day would be welcome, to facilitate a relationship with a disinterested father and hostile new partner and if she doesn’t go she’ll regret it because she’ll be missing out on…what exactly?

And as always on these threads, some nice misogynistic name throwing being flung at a young woman to defend a lazy, feckless father and his new wife.

If paying more than £100 and 2 nights b&b for 2 is too much for Dear Dad to have his daughter comfortable at his wedding, maybe, just maybe, the DD is not the entitled one.

Don’t know if you intended it, but this just smacks of someone who is bitter.

Loopylemon2 · 02/12/2023 23:02

MargotBamborough · 02/12/2023 22:29

The wedding is 7 months away, it's not as if it's next weekend and she's suddenly asked to bring a plus one.

I confirmed final numbers with my venue on the Wednesday before my Saturday wedding.

We don't know what other family members will be there and whether the OP's daughter gets on well with them or not. The point is she would like to bring her boyfriend to make what will probably be a not very enjoyable occasion a bit less crap for her, and if her dad is at all interested in having a good relationship with his adult daughter he should facilitate that.

The thing is, you are (as we all are) making assumptions.

The bride’s family could have made a large contribution to the wedding budget, if so why should that be used on stranger. They could be on restricted numbers (venues have capacities), so if they have had to not invite people as a result, why should they facilitate a stranger instead. Ultimately, they shouldn’t feel obligated to invite anyone they don’t want to.

The DD should be adult enough to also maintain a relationship with her DF. She asked, they said no, that’s life, it’s their event. If because of that she now refuses to attend, which is her choice, it absolutely doesn’t fall on her DF if they have a bad relationship.

Scruffington · 02/12/2023 23:02

ThisHouseWillBeTheDeathOfMe · 02/12/2023 23:01

It's ok. You can't discuss, have paddys, and call people petulant/shit/toddlers.

Usually when you can't answer their pretty standard observation that undermines your opinion.

I see that now.

It's cool.

'have paddys'?

we don't use that term in 2023.

ThisHouseWillBeTheDeathOfMe · 02/12/2023 23:01

Scruffington · 02/12/2023 22:59

That's funny I was just reading your thread.

You were a bit irritable on that one too!

It's ok. You can't discuss, have paddys, and call people petulant/shit/toddlers.

Usually when you can't answer their pretty standard observation that undermines your opinion.

I see that now.

It's cool.

Scruffington · 02/12/2023 22:59

ThisHouseWillBeTheDeathOfMe · 02/12/2023 22:58

Ahhhhh... Just seen how you conduct yourself on other threads...

That's funny I was just reading your thread.

You were a bit irritable on that one too!

Over40Overdating · 02/12/2023 22:59

I see the penis apologists are out in force limboing under a bar set in hell to defend the ex.

If I’ve got it right, OP and her DD are awful, entitled, poor ex bashing harridans because they don’t want to shell out or get a job to pay for the DD to go to the wedding where she’s not particularly wanted, where some support on a difficult day would be welcome, to facilitate a relationship with a disinterested father and hostile new partner and if she doesn’t go she’ll regret it because she’ll be missing out on…what exactly?

And as always on these threads, some nice misogynistic name throwing being flung at a young woman to defend a lazy, feckless father and his new wife.

If paying more than £100 and 2 nights b&b for 2 is too much for Dear Dad to have his daughter comfortable at his wedding, maybe, just maybe, the DD is not the entitled one.

ThisHouseWillBeTheDeathOfMe · 02/12/2023 22:58

Scruffington · 02/12/2023 22:53

you're over tired now and getting irritable.

off you toddle.

Ahhhhh... Just seen how you conduct yourself on other threads...

Scruffington · 02/12/2023 22:53

ThisHouseWillBeTheDeathOfMe · 02/12/2023 22:51

Sign me up. Your ability to determine maintenance, whilst having none of the relevant information to ascertain that, and to bypass the actual issues in hand, is second to none.

you're over tired now and getting irritable.

off you toddle.

ThisHouseWillBeTheDeathOfMe · 02/12/2023 22:51

Scruffington · 02/12/2023 22:42

Oh yeah, for a simple fee I'll have you sorted.

Sign me up. Your ability to determine maintenance, whilst having none of the relevant information to ascertain that, and to bypass the actual issues in hand, is second to none.

Scruffington · 02/12/2023 22:42

ThisHouseWillBeTheDeathOfMe · 02/12/2023 22:39

But when he does, and I emigrate with all the children, I'll know exactly where to come for maintenance adviceWink

Oh yeah, for a simple fee I'll have you sorted.

ThisHouseWillBeTheDeathOfMe · 02/12/2023 22:39

Scruffington · 02/12/2023 22:34

Don't be silly. I'm sure your husband would never leave you.

But when he does, and I emigrate with all the children, I'll know exactly where to come for maintenance adviceWink

MargotBamborough · 02/12/2023 22:38

Cherrysoup · 02/12/2023 22:34

My venue wasn’t very big and I don’t think they did many weddings: we had to confirm numbers early on. One thing I was fussy about was not having strangers there. I know the bf has met the dad/gf, but he hasn’t been given an invitation and I don’t think it’s fair for the dd to try to push that issue at someone’s wedding.

I agree with pp, the dd should block the gf and deal only with her df.

Edited

Look, you're entitled to make whatever rules you want about your own wedding.

And other people are entitled to say "fuck that" and not go.

So if I knew that someone didn't want to come to my wedding without her boyfriend, and I wanted her to come to my wedding, I'd invite the boyfriend even if I would prefer not to have anyone I didn't know at my wedding.

Ultimately you can say "my wedding, my rules" but you cannot then cry and moan and feel hard done by if your rules damage your relationship with people who are important to you.

Ivymom · 02/12/2023 22:36

OP, X is going to do what he wants and you won’t be able to do anything about it, so debating whether it is right or wrong here is pointless. From your posts, it doesn’t seem like X was the most involved father for the first 7 years after the divorce, so expecting anything different now is kind of pointless. My following advice is colored from the experience of being the child of divorced parents who both went on to make new families with new spouses.

First, I think you should apologize to your DD for any negative opinions you have expressed about X. Explain that his behavior towards her upset you, but you shouldn’t have expressed anything other than you love her and are there to support her. Vent to your friends, therapist, online, but never to DD. When DD complains about X, say something like “I’m sorry you are hurting. How can I help you?”. Saying negative things about X to DD is going to hurt DD.

Next, encourage DD to discuss this situation with X and try to work it out with him. At this point, DD should stop texting with GF and have a private phone conversation with her father. I would recommend she make notes about what she wants to say, why she doesn’t want to go without BF and what she wants from X in relation to their relationship. If DD struggles to articulate this, it would probably be helpful to get her a family counselor to work this out or even mediate the conversation with X.

You haven’t elaborated on DD’s relationship with her paternal family, but if there is anyone she has a good relationship with, I would encourage her to find a way to keep regular contact with them. It isn’t your job to facilitate contact with X’s family, but if there isn’t anything negative or toxic in their behavior towards DD, it will benefit her to have those relationships, especially because it seems like X replaced her with his “new family with GF”.

My personal opinion is that X should pay for DD and a guest to attend his wedding. He created a situation where DD feels like she needs someone she’s comfortable with when visiting his family. He created the distance in his relationship with his child and failed to facilitate her becoming closer to his partner and future children. The first step in fixing this would be to show willingness to accommodate DD, and of course telling off GF. I have a feeling you are of the same opinion, but under no circumstances should you share that with DD.

napy · 02/12/2023 22:36

Bringing her BF at a wedding at 17... As a native European that's pretty weird!! Your ex should talk to his/your daughter and tell her so. And if he hasn't the guts to do it then he should accomodate and pay for both. He shouldn't let his fiancee to talk to his daughter. What a spineless man!