Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandad's Pride is being read on milkshake on channel 5 - not acceptable! AIBU

513 replies

grandadspride · 01/12/2023 09:13

Milkshake story den.

Why are we reading books about pride, gender and drag to pre-school children.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
HiddenLegoOuch · 03/12/2023 12:21

Universalsnail · 03/12/2023 09:36

Because the "evidence" he is a creep that has done that is speculation, putting two and two together, assuming things to fit the "he's a creep" narrative, and not actual evidence. I am not going to get into a panic and ban my child from reading a book or sending angry messages to a TV channel that has a positive message based on such speculation when even if the absolute worst is true, there will be no impact on my child because only the illustrator, some other peados and people obsessed with gender politics on the internet seem to know about, and that is even if it is true, because a lot of the comments here a putting stuff together like a mumsnet version of a you tube conspiracy video. I think the discourse around this is far more damaging then a drawing of a map labelled a map and some heart sunglasses in an illustration.

As for the "fetish gear' drawing. If I am honest I just don't have a problem with either of those pictures. It's a man fully covered wearing clothes. If I took my kid to a pride parade they would see actual men dressed like that. If I took them to a festival they would see grown women dressed like that be it more glittery. It's not a drawing with someone on a gimp suit or a ball gag or wearing a strap on. Honestly I think that image is a none issue and children see far worse watching music videos.

”It’s not a drawing with someone in a gimp suit or a ball gag or wearing a strap on”

No, those drawings are not there - because they have happened in REAL LIFE in front of children. Where people who are meant to be safeguarding children are too scared/woke/allied to say how utterly inappropriate and sexualised it is.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/man-gimp-suit-shakespeares-globe-children-b2380638.html

Man in gimp suit allowed to watch Shakespeare’s Globe play with children in audience

Theatregoer watches The Comedy of Errors dressed in full latex fetish suit and mask

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/man-gimp-suit-shakespeares-globe-children-b2380638.html

StephanieSuperpowers · 03/12/2023 11:59

ArthurbellaScott · 03/12/2023 11:52

Beautiful. Openness, tolerance. Children have so much to learn from adults in sexwear. Like about how it's fine when adults do sexually explicit stuff around children. So much education.

ArthurbellaScott · 03/12/2023 11:52

Kids at Pride.

https://twitter.com/lorgair/status/1647456869638868992

Grandad's Pride is being read on milkshake on channel 5 - not acceptable! AIBU
Grandad's Pride is being read on milkshake on channel 5 - not acceptable! AIBU
StephanieSuperpowers · 03/12/2023 11:47

Thank goodness there's an opportunity for children to interact with the fetish community. They have so much to gain from it.

ArthurbellaScott · 03/12/2023 11:34

Would it be okay for a man in fetish gear like that depicted in the book to read this book to children?

Would it be okay for children to wear that outfit on World Book Day, where children dress as book characters?

Would it be okay for a school to take children to an event where men are wearing fetish gear?

Helleofabore · 03/12/2023 11:17

There is a significant issue when adults cannot recognise the process of normalising fetish within society. And when each sexual boundary has been lowered, the next one to be lowered is more extreme. All sexual boundaries being lowered are harmful.

If a toddler doesn’t understand that seeing people in their kink wear is ok, for example, if a toddler is patting a man in a rubber dog costume at an event, why is that ok? At what age does this action become not ok? If this book was for 6-7 year olds, would it still be ok to see people in BDSM gear?

Where is the boundary? Or is it that some people (generally) simply cannot recognise that children accept the messages that people they trust give them and when it is then built upon by seeing another similar message being read to them or being accepted on their behalf it becomes normalised?

heathspeedwell · 03/12/2023 11:13

It's pretty frightening to see some people on here being so naive about paedophiles. And this almost conscious decision to turn a blind eye is precisely how so many of them get away with what they do.

nothingcomestonothing · 03/12/2023 11:05

Whybobbins · 03/12/2023 10:50

‘Would you say that if Nightmare on Elm Street was being shown on the Milkshake slot? ‘

😅😅😅😅 I’d say that’s not going to happen, and probably not something you should worried about?
and then I would say - turn the tv off, maybe read a book instead? Or pick another channel?

Well a few years ago I wouldn't have thought a book with men in fetish wear being on the little kids' slot on TV was something I needed to worry about, but here we are.

Why do you think it's ok for pictures of men in fetish wear to be shown to small children?

Canonlythinkofthisone · 03/12/2023 11:05

Whybobbins · 03/12/2023 10:50

‘Would you say that if Nightmare on Elm Street was being shown on the Milkshake slot? ‘

😅😅😅😅 I’d say that’s not going to happen, and probably not something you should worried about?
and then I would say - turn the tv off, maybe read a book instead? Or pick another channel?

Why is it not going to happen?

Because its inappropriate for children obvs.

Duh

Whybobbins · 03/12/2023 10:50

‘Would you say that if Nightmare on Elm Street was being shown on the Milkshake slot? ‘

😅😅😅😅 I’d say that’s not going to happen, and probably not something you should worried about?
and then I would say - turn the tv off, maybe read a book instead? Or pick another channel?

nothingcomestonothing · 03/12/2023 10:46

Can I check my bingo card? So far on this thread we've had:

Right wing ✅
Bigots ✅
Homophobes ✅
Paranoid ✅
Pearl clutching/out of touch with modern life ✅
Don't look if you're so offended ✅
And now Section 28 ✅

The ways in which some posters try to shame and silence women concerned about child safeguarding are depressingly predictable.

So again I'll ask, why do under fives need to see illustrations of men in fetish wear?

DonnaBanana · 03/12/2023 10:30

I blame the Tories and section 28 for this if you grew up when I did you will remember the Tories passed a law banning schools from mentioning homosexuality in a positive way at all so our social education didn’t even mention the existence of it. All this stuff now is an over correction to the ills of the 90s.

ArthurbellaScott · 03/12/2023 10:28

Circularargument · 03/12/2023 10:13

@Universalsnail

Thank you, and I'm sorry thatl you felt you had to share your story with the ignorant and prejudiced around here.

It's the anti gay playback from the 80s all over again, with "Women's Rights" standing in for "The Family" as the sacred cow that needs Protection from The Unnatural Others.

What 'Unnatural Others' do you mean? Nobody has used these terms except you.

To suggest that this makes anyone 'anti gay' is absolutely horrible homophobia. The vast majority of LGB people are in favour of women's rights and child protection.

LuvSmallDogs · 03/12/2023 10:26

I've never seen straight couples in kiddies' picture books portrayed in sexy lingerie or fetish wear - if I ever do, I will not be exposing my children to that book and would understand why other parents are upset by it.

Helleofabore · 03/12/2023 10:22

Lowering children’s sexual boundaries happens in different ways. There is not just one way otherwise safeguarding children would be easier and more straightforward.

However, No one needs to share their personal trauma to defend their position or for any reason. I hope you have plenty of support universal.

ArthurbellaScott · 03/12/2023 10:20

I'm so deeply sorry to hear that, Universalsnail. It's a horrendous betrayal and a crime and it makes me so angry to hear about it. I hope that you have had support in coming to terms with it.

The issue here is not that anyone expects their children are at risk from this illustrator. That would, as you say, be absurd.

The issue is that there are groups of people who are invested in eroding, undermining and chipping away at societal boundaries. They may also be victims themselves, sometimes they may not be fully aware of the implications of what they are involved in excusing. They may genuinely think that they are just promoting tolerance and acceptance of 'varied' sexualities, or that society just doesn't understand their intentions.

Predators connect with each other, signal to each other and are collectively involved in trying to undermine societal boundaries and barriers. This is fairly uncontroversial. Look into PIE or NAMBLA.

Teaching children about the existence of gay people is fine, and has been done many times before in other books with no issues.

Teaching very young children about the history of LGBT activism is, I would say, too advanced, in the way that we don't teach four year olds about feminism or civil rights - it's just far too advanced for them to grasp. All teaching should be age appropriate, and trauma informed. Slightly older children can learn about activism and politics, perhaps upper primary age, although to be honest, I still think this is quite young to be learning about, say, the history of legislative evolution in regards to sexuality. Sexuality and politics is just not on the radar of pre pubescent children. They can't grasp sexuality or sex drive. Love, yes. Families, yes. Sex? It's alien to them, or should be.

Teaching people about BDSM, or fetish, or kink, or 'pansexuality', or 'Lolita', or MAPS, is another matter entirely. That's crossed the line very clearly into very, very dodgy territory.

When we get to the point where a picture book for four year olds with pictures of old men in bondage gear is chosen as book of the year, wins awards, and is lauded and read on TV?

We're in serious shit. As a society, we have been groomed. Our boundaries are shot to pieces.

GreenAppleCrumble · 03/12/2023 10:13

Universalsnail · 03/12/2023 09:46

Yes I am familiar with how grooming works. I was groomed as a child by an actual friend of the family. He didn't send secret very coded messages in an illustration to children he will never meet. He pretended to love us and taught us to keep secrets from our parents, let us do things we shouldn't have been able to do, bought us treats, made us feel like he was important and trusted him. That's actual grooming and all of your children are at a significantly higher risk of that from people you know and trust them they are at risk of some random illustrator that may or may not have put some extremely secretive peado nods in his illustration.

Literally noone is looking at those tiny pictures in that illustration and having peadophilla normalised to them. The vast majority of people are not sat on Mumsnet or Twitter talking about this subject and arnt even aware that peados call themselves MAPS online.

None of this is worth shielding children from being taught about the existence of gay and trans people and this story is a nice story about acceptance and diversity.

Okey dokey.

Circularargument · 03/12/2023 10:13

@Universalsnail

Thank you, and I'm sorry thatl you felt you had to share your story with the ignorant and prejudiced around here.

It's the anti gay playback from the 80s all over again, with "Women's Rights" standing in for "The Family" as the sacred cow that needs Protection from The Unnatural Others.

Universalsnail · 03/12/2023 09:46

StephanieSuperpowers · 02/12/2023 22:09

You're familiar with how grooming works, right?

Yes I am familiar with how grooming works. I was groomed as a child by an actual friend of the family. He didn't send secret very coded messages in an illustration to children he will never meet. He pretended to love us and taught us to keep secrets from our parents, let us do things we shouldn't have been able to do, bought us treats, made us feel like he was important and trusted him. That's actual grooming and all of your children are at a significantly higher risk of that from people you know and trust them they are at risk of some random illustrator that may or may not have put some extremely secretive peado nods in his illustration.

Literally noone is looking at those tiny pictures in that illustration and having peadophilla normalised to them. The vast majority of people are not sat on Mumsnet or Twitter talking about this subject and arnt even aware that peados call themselves MAPS online.

None of this is worth shielding children from being taught about the existence of gay and trans people and this story is a nice story about acceptance and diversity.

Universalsnail · 03/12/2023 09:36

GreenAppleCrumble · 02/12/2023 21:28

Ok. Let’s say that’s true, just as you’ve said it. Why are you so comfortable with some ‘creep’ getting his words and his pictures waved in front of your pre-schooler, while he enjoys the thrill of dropping his perverted hints right into your home? Is that really fine?

But it’s not just as you said, is it? Kids look at the pictures. Kids see pictures of men in fetish-wear. If that doesn’t normalise something, I’m not sure what does.No, ‘paedophilia’ is not being normalised by this book, because toddlers don’t know what sex is, let alone paedophilia. But it’s more subtle than that. As you well know.

Because the "evidence" he is a creep that has done that is speculation, putting two and two together, assuming things to fit the "he's a creep" narrative, and not actual evidence. I am not going to get into a panic and ban my child from reading a book or sending angry messages to a TV channel that has a positive message based on such speculation when even if the absolute worst is true, there will be no impact on my child because only the illustrator, some other peados and people obsessed with gender politics on the internet seem to know about, and that is even if it is true, because a lot of the comments here a putting stuff together like a mumsnet version of a you tube conspiracy video. I think the discourse around this is far more damaging then a drawing of a map labelled a map and some heart sunglasses in an illustration.

As for the "fetish gear' drawing. If I am honest I just don't have a problem with either of those pictures. It's a man fully covered wearing clothes. If I took my kid to a pride parade they would see actual men dressed like that. If I took them to a festival they would see grown women dressed like that be it more glittery. It's not a drawing with someone on a gimp suit or a ball gag or wearing a strap on. Honestly I think that image is a none issue and children see far worse watching music videos.

Helleofabore · 03/12/2023 08:05

Well gosh! If a parent cannot read a book that the illustrator has added questionable symbolism in without recognising the symbols, or thinking it is ok once they find out, that is just ok. Isn’t it? Because when the parent next sees those symbols grouped they will still think nothing of it as they have seen it in an award winning and much lauded toddler’s book. It must be ok. Everyone else thought the book was so good they gave the illustrator huge acclaim. And the next book that illustrator produces maybe for the older age group will have similar hidden symbols and feature fetishes again, it is just the bigots who think it is wrong. Because all the community gave the illustrator awards and stuff.

It not just the children being groomed, is it? We are seeing it here on this thread.

Apparently it is perfectly fine to expose children to fetishes and to paedophilic symbolism because they are too young. ‘Just chill the fuck out peeps, it is nothing!’

Yeah. Grooming doesn’t just happen to children. Adults with lowered sexual boundaries exist too. That is, of course, how children end up with lowered sexual boundaries. Because they have been taught or had it modelled by adults usually. And so the cycle continues.

ArthurbellaScott · 02/12/2023 22:59

'even if it is full of weird peado symbolism that is going to have zero influence over children.
Maybe the illustrator is secretly some creep who has snuck in some little peado nod in his work, I mean it's a pretty serious accusation, but even if that's the case, but the book itself is about Gay acceptance and diversity. Absolutely no child is reading this book and having peadophilla normalised to them. We don't need to get into a moral panic about children being taught about homosexuality and gender because it was read on milkshake like the OP is currently doing'

Well, there you go. Just when you think nobody could ever rationalise grooming children ...

StephanieSuperpowers · 02/12/2023 22:09

Universalsnail · 02/12/2023 21:14

I read it yes. Which is why I made that point about even if it is full of weird peado symbolism that is going to have zero influence over children.
Maybe the illustrator is secretly some creep who has snuck in some little peado nod in his work, I mean it's a pretty serious accusation, but even if that's the case, but the book itself is about Gay acceptance and diversity. Absolutely no child is reading this book and having peadophilla normalised to them. We don't need to get into a moral panic about children being taught about homosexuality and gender because it was read on milkshake like the OP is currently doing.

You're familiar with how grooming works, right?