Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandad's Pride is being read on milkshake on channel 5 - not acceptable! AIBU

513 replies

grandadspride · 01/12/2023 09:13

Milkshake story den.

Why are we reading books about pride, gender and drag to pre-school children.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:53

Nonoatchristmas · 01/12/2023 11:49

If you don’t validate my beliefs then are you phobic to my existence? Or can you determine when someone should be absolutely validated without question and when you can tell them ‘that’s nice dear but I don’t agree with your personal expressions’. Hope you’re not being hypocritical now…

Did you write that to yourself?
As I said, enjoy your day, there's more to life than randoms in MN and I am sure we might agree on plenty of other topics.

Nonoatchristmas · 01/12/2023 11:49

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:46

You've made points you feel are valid.

If you don’t validate my beliefs then are you phobic to my existence? Or can you determine when someone should be absolutely validated without question and when you can tell them ‘that’s nice dear but I don’t agree with your personal expressions’. Hope you’re not being hypocritical now…

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:47

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 01/12/2023 11:40

And if a fully paid up trans women are women MNer popped up on the thread, called YOU a transphobe, and reported YOUR post for doing a transphobia, then what?

You'd correct your thinking and cheerlead them all in? Or argue your point about having limitations and responsibilities for female only spaces?

You have your line in the sand, which is what you would probably consider a moderate standpoint. The OP has hers, that sex is immutable and gender identity does not trump it. Neither point is transphobic. But if you insist on calling her a transphobe, then so are you.

I'd accept that MN get the final say on anything we say here, even though I'd try to explain my view respectfully.

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:46

Nonoatchristmas · 01/12/2023 11:40

Oh dear have I made some valid points in my last post that you have no comeback for? Absolutely no problem, have a good day yourself 😊

You've made points you feel are valid.

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:45

HeliumChestedTrollop · 01/12/2023 11:36

Sex is not defined by your sexual organs, it is determined by your DNA and chromosomes

I have had a hysterectomy, that does not make me not a woman, I have no ovaries but I will still be female until I die

I was simply referring to the presence of external sexual organs as an identifier, apologies if you felt what I wrote was cruel - of course you are still a woman, regardless of ovaries (and I hope the hysterectomy was beneficial to you).

Of course our DNA is central to all of our characteristics (visible and hidden) - I will never cease to be amazed by DNA, and don't think any of us fully comprehend how much there still is to learn!

Helleofabore · 01/12/2023 11:43

ArthurbellaScott · 01/12/2023 11:15

Some illustrations had elements removed for UK publication, iirc.

There was a 'furry' pawprint tattoo, and - was it the 'Love is love' slogan?

The 'love is love' slogan was blatant.

Nonoatchristmas · 01/12/2023 11:40

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:39

@Nonoatchristmas I am going to leave you with your opinions, because, you are entitled to have them.

With that I wish you a pleasant weekend.

Oh dear have I made some valid points in my last post that you have no comeback for? Absolutely no problem, have a good day yourself 😊

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 01/12/2023 11:40

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:28

Correct, some people might.

And if a fully paid up trans women are women MNer popped up on the thread, called YOU a transphobe, and reported YOUR post for doing a transphobia, then what?

You'd correct your thinking and cheerlead them all in? Or argue your point about having limitations and responsibilities for female only spaces?

You have your line in the sand, which is what you would probably consider a moderate standpoint. The OP has hers, that sex is immutable and gender identity does not trump it. Neither point is transphobic. But if you insist on calling her a transphobe, then so are you.

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:39

@Nonoatchristmas I am going to leave you with your opinions, because, you are entitled to have them.

With that I wish you a pleasant weekend.

Helleofabore · 01/12/2023 11:38

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 01/12/2023 11:04

Slightly offtopic but ... Mammalian reproductive biology is pretty much binary and no, you can't change sex.

Large gametes, small gametes. No-one can produce both. Bodies start genetically different and develop physically along two different pathways, with two different reproductive systems and genitalia and also other physical effects such as size and musculature. Very rarely a pathway gets blocked, or a non functioning vestige of the other reproductive system grows in place.

Monkeying around with healthy people's sex hormones and with surgery messes up their reproductive organs and makes them non-existent or non-functional. It messes up people's physical health too. But it doesn't change people's sex. It doesn't change their genotype, and it only changes a few cosmetic aspects of their sexed phenotype. It doesn't create an overall body structure like the opposite sex, hardly even visually and certainly not functionally. No-one gets a functioning reproductive system of the other sex. The chances of even getting a halfway usable set of genitalia are not that brilliant, never mind genitalia that are functionally anything like those of the other sex.

Wishful thinking changes none of that. You can't change sex. If you think you can then you have been massively mis-sold. Sorry!

There will always be that poster who declares that the cases of chimerism are proof that sex is not known by scientists and medical specialists though. It is really is enlightening to see the argument 'but science just doesn't know' being brought out. Despite the fact that there is nothing but theory to back up their claims. All the science so far has reinforced what humans have known forever. That humans are sexually dimorphic and sex is immutable, and some humans have ambiguous genital and sex organ arrangements but it still doesn't mean that those humans cannot be categorised as one sex or the other.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 01/12/2023 11:38

The discussion about mental health problems and people believing their bodies are wrong is fascinating.
But it shouldn't detract from the subject of the thread - that even the youngest of children are being targeted with age inappropriate texts and images - including the fetish and paedophilic associations already referenced.
The challenge is for society to remove these people from influencing children. It feels almost impossible with all the useful idiots in the media abandoning safeguarding children in favour of fawning all over some very dubious influences.

HeliumChestedTrollop · 01/12/2023 11:36

Sex is not defined by your sexual organs, it is determined by your DNA and chromosomes

I have had a hysterectomy, that does not make me not a woman, I have no ovaries but I will still be female until I die

TheKeatingFive · 01/12/2023 11:33

Some people experience their body as being 'incorrect'

And they should get psychological help for that, because we cannot escape the reality of our bodies. And we do no one any favours by lying to them about that.

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:33

HiddenLegoOuch · 01/12/2023 11:25

Nope - biology covers it.

The biological reality is that human cannot change sex. Regardless of any other developments and advancements in a growing field - this is an immutable fact.

Biology, as a word, isn't an adequate explanation.

Also, I am not arguing that we can change sex (as already stated) but there is no denying that some people feel their physical body does not represent how they actually feel/identify - we don't know why this is the case.

grandadspride · 01/12/2023 11:32

@sollenwir it's body dysmorphia.

OP posts:
Nonoatchristmas · 01/12/2023 11:32

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:19

Sex is basically defined by what sexual organs you have, basically male or female, and a few people with conditions where it's unclear/they have been encouraged down one route. Sexual organs can be changed to look like other sexual organs, but they won't actually function as those.

Gender is more complex, in that it takes into account what you identify with - I am pretty sure the complexities of what makes most females feel female and most males feel male isn't completely understood, and thus what would make one feel the opposite gender isn't that well understood either.

It's a complex area but undoubtedly people who do feel 'trapped' in the wrong body exist and go through immense heartache coming to terms with it - all I also is that what accept people for who they feel they are.

Of course that comes with responsibilities and limitations (such as the debate around access to female spaces being limited).

I will say, again, that I do find the images in the book inappropriate - they are too sexual regardless of which body they are on!

Sex is basically defined by what sexual organs you have, basically male or female, and a few people with conditions where it's unclear/they have been encouraged down one route. Sexual organs can be changed to look like other sexual organs, but they won't actually function as those.

Oh nearly there but not quite right. Your biological sex can be observed by your organs but it goes much deeper than that. It’s why women can have blood tests when pregnant to determine the sex of the foetus. Intersex in humans still make you either male or female (if you have the Y chromosome you are male), though it’s true that underdeveloped organs can be an observation issue.

Gender is more complex, in that it takes into account what you identify with - I am pretty sure the complexities of what makes most females feel female and most males feel male isn't completely understood, and thus what would make one feel the opposite gender isn't that well understood either.

This is the crux of the issue - there is no such thing as ‘feeling’ male or female. Only the sociological impacts that are placed on us from birth. Pink and blue, dolls and muck, kind and sweet or rough and tumble. It’s all stereotypes that have built up to the point of ‘if you don’t fit into it, you must be a different gender. These literal visions of being the correct type of girl/boy mixed in with how some people take things very literally (remember how I mentioned how a huge majority of young trans people are autistic?) added in the new age of internet where people can encourage these stereotypes as gender affirming - it’s been a perfect maelstrom.

It's a complex area but undoubtedly people who do feel 'trapped' in the wrong body exist and go through immense heartache coming to terms with it - all I also is that what accept people for who they feel they are.

There is no such thing as a ‘wrong body’, especially when lucky enough to be born healthy. Yes mental health issues are absolutely awful, and no more so than for young people who are autistic or have suffered severe trauma in childhood. It is proven that they often have an absolutely awful time going through puberty and changing bodies. Transgenderism is an escape (especially for girls) but it’s not an actual fix for the MH issues that are never acknowledged with neurodivergence.

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:31

TheKeatingFive · 01/12/2023 11:29

Your brain, feelings and emotions are as much a part of you as what organs you happen to have though

They are part of your body, yes. Are you saying they are 'sexed'?

No, I am saying they are how we experience the body we are in. Some people experience their body as being 'incorrect' - we don't really know why that happens, or what may have caused this incorrect relationship/feeling.

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:29

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 01/12/2023 11:28

Course not 😂

Course not what?
True things - the posts have been deleted, I have no desire to repeat transphobia.
Not hard to understand.

TheKeatingFive · 01/12/2023 11:29

Your brain, feelings and emotions are as much a part of you as what organs you happen to have though

They are part of your body, yes. Are you saying they are 'sexed'?

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:28

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 01/12/2023 11:27

Of course that comes with responsibilities and limitations (such as the debate around access to female spaces being limited).

Some people would call THAT transphobia.

If you have limitations for those that want to be seen and treated as female (so men) and they aren't given full and unfettered access to every female space going, they would say you are gatekeeping and denying their womanhood. 🤷‍♀️

Correct, some people might.

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 01/12/2023 11:28

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:21

@MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking the posts have been deleted. I have no wish to repeat what OP said.

Course not 😂

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 01/12/2023 11:27

Of course that comes with responsibilities and limitations (such as the debate around access to female spaces being limited).

Some people would call THAT transphobia.

If you have limitations for those that want to be seen and treated as female (so men) and they aren't given full and unfettered access to every female space going, they would say you are gatekeeping and denying their womanhood. 🤷‍♀️

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:26

TheKeatingFive · 01/12/2023 11:25

It's a complex area but undoubtedly people who do feel 'trapped' in the wrong body exist and go through immense heartache coming to terms with it - all I also is that what accept people for who they feel they are.

But it's a totally nonsense concept. You ARE your body. There is no such thing as the 'wrong' one.

No one should be compelled to lie to address what is being experienced, which is a complex mental and social problem.

People should get all the help and support they need - naturally. But that should not involve any suggestion that what people 'feel' they are should be indulged.

Any more than if they 'feel' they are Jesus Christ, a dog, Spider-Man, African American. Truth is key.

Your brain, feelings and emotions are as much a part of you as what organs you happen to have though.

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:26

HiddenLegoOuch · 01/12/2023 11:23

But… but… you said previously that you didn’t know what was said in the deleted posts, but it must have been really, really transphobic.

I know what OP's posts said and I know what I reported.
I said other posts had been deleted too and I didn't report those.

I didn't say I didn't know what was in OP's posts.

TheKeatingFive · 01/12/2023 11:25

It's a complex area but undoubtedly people who do feel 'trapped' in the wrong body exist and go through immense heartache coming to terms with it - all I also is that what accept people for who they feel they are.

But it's a totally nonsense concept. You ARE your body. There is no such thing as the 'wrong' one.

No one should be compelled to lie to address what is being experienced, which is a complex mental and social problem.

People should get all the help and support they need - naturally. But that should not involve any suggestion that what people 'feel' they are should be indulged.

Any more than if they 'feel' they are Jesus Christ, a dog, Spider-Man, African American. Truth is key.