Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandad's Pride is being read on milkshake on channel 5 - not acceptable! AIBU

513 replies

grandadspride · 01/12/2023 09:13

Milkshake story den.

Why are we reading books about pride, gender and drag to pre-school children.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
Helleofabore · 01/12/2023 15:33

ArthurbellaScott · 01/12/2023 12:59

Quite right! Get that bondage and BDSM content in front of the toddlers for the sake of free speech!

Yes. Toddlers need to understand that what BDSM gear is all about and what each hidden message about paedophilia (MAP) is too.

I guess some people really don’t like safeguarding at all.

Bobsboob · 01/12/2023 15:17

Caerulea · 01/12/2023 12:19

Isn't it always the argument from bigots that homosexuality in men is just a perversion? Something the gay community had to fight hard against to show they are actually just normal ppl doing normal shit who happen to be same sex attracted. Normal jobs, normal families, normal pets. Just really ordinary normal people, not degenerate fetishists.

I get increasingly annoyed at seeing gay men (especially) be stereotyped BACKWARDS in media & this movement of absolute acceptance without question. It's so regressive & this book plays into that with its artwork.

Yep that was my point. Gay men are no more likely to be fetishists of any type than any other man. Yes, clearly being gay is partly ‘about sex’ because it’s about who you find arousing and attractive, but that’s the same as being straight. No more sex and no less either.

Bobsboob · 01/12/2023 15:06

Soubriquet · 01/12/2023 11:19

So the defence friends have given are

A) celebrities wear less on tv Hmm
B) go to any pride parade and you will find lots of leather bound people. This book is a fantastic way of introducing it to children so they aren’t afraid.

WTF?! No.

No- the book is a fantastic way of breaking down children’s boundaries about bodies, and when, where and with whom it is appropriate for them to be sexualised- which when it concerns children should be never.

You will see all that at pride- which is why I never take my children.

Bobsboob · 01/12/2023 15:02

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 11:03

I don't think anyone said it's transphobic not to find male sexual organs attractive.

Possibly not on this thread- I haven’t read every post. But in the media in general it’s said. Owen Jones in the pink news springs to mind, but there’s plenty if you google.

Munchyseeds2 · 01/12/2023 14:33

When my kids watched milkshake many moons ago it was Brain Cant and Dappledown Farm
I am so glad they are grown!!

No toddler needs to see a book like that ever

Kath85 · 01/12/2023 14:29

So are the pics you have posted from the same story read on milkshake?!

PartOfTheFurniture12 · 01/12/2023 14:28

sollenwir · 01/12/2023 10:49

I don't think anyone is defending any of those images, I do think people are defending the 'right' for LGBTQIA+ people to exist and not be told by others that they believe them not to be real.

I'm bisexual. No-one on this thread has denied my "right to exist". Please do not delude yourself into thinking you are doing any favours for LGBT people with this rhetoric. We will all pay the price with guilt by association when this despicable trans fad blows over and it finally sinks in how many medical atrocities have been committed against vulnerable young people. Meanwhile, the army of virtue signallers such as yourself will get off scot-free and prance off to your next moral crusade, having learnt nothing. You'll probably even pretend you were always against the opinions you currently beat everyone over the head with. Because parroting these short-sighted "progressive" positions has always been about what is good for your own reputation and self-image, not what is actually right and safe for kids, or young people, or gay people, or trans people.

A distressing number of kids going to gender clinics are gay kids who have been convinced that being gender non-conforming or liking people of the same sex somehow makes them not a real man or woman. The definition of trans has been warped and expanded far beyond its original definition to incorporate people for whom it is not remotely suitable, and all the safety stops that would have prevented these individuals from medically transitioning and regretting it have been removed in the name of political correctness. You are so busy spouting slogans, shutting down dissenting opinions as "transphobic" and ignoring the nuances of the trans situation to notice that you are helping to drive the wrong people towards the surgeon's scalpel. As someone who was gender non-conforming, I am relieved to have grown up in an era where transgenderism wasn't being pushed and parents and medical professionals were willing and able to act as the adults in the room to stop me from ruining my life. I am pregnant with my first child. If I had fallen for the gender ideology you seem so keen to push then I could have lost my ability to bear a child or breastfeed, and I would not be thanking you for it. Brainwashing and sterilising young gay people is neither kind nor accepting.

Regarding "educating" people on transgenderism so we aren't "denying the existence of trans people": nope, sorry. Confusing children with contradictory, widely refuted and scientifically unproven concepts is not a step forward for anyone. Gender dysphoria is a poorly understood condition and gender ideology is a regressive and unstable belief system. Its inconsistency means it cannot be taught clearly or responsibly and therefore shouldn't be taught at all, certainly not to impressionable small children with limited reasoning skills. Despite not having had a single class about homosexuality, my generation are very accepting of gay people. There is no need to "get them while they're young" when it comes to complex or age-inappropriate topics like transgenderism.

If you gave me the choice, I would rather my kids had the exact sex education I did - which included absolutely zero discussion of homosexuality - than have them learn about transgenderism and gender identity. Hell, I'd rather they learnt that being same sex attracted was morally wrong or that the earth was flat than learn about gender identity, because at least they'd be at less risk of having their bodies needlessly carved up.

Moreover, trans people constitute 0.1% of the population (at least, they did before the trans wave). If we are to dedicate lessons to transgenderism, it stands to reason that we should also teach children about literally every other demographic that constitutes 0.1% of the population or more, to ensure we aren't "denying the existence" of anyone. Schizophrenics, for instance, make up 1% of the population and suffer terrible public misconceptions about their condition. That's just one of thousands of mental, cultural and physical differences. How can we in good conscience have our children learn reading, writing and arithmetic when they haven't been educated about every single human difference on the planet?

MrsOvertonsWindow · 01/12/2023 14:07

IvorTheEngineDriver · 01/12/2023 12:56

I have never heard of this book and have no intention of looking it up or reading it but on a point of principle I will be damned if I will see it, or anything else, cancelled.

I am from a generation that saw legal battles to end censorship. We do not need to see it reinstated by an unthinking younger generation under a new name.

You say "cancelled". I say "censored".

Edited

Have you read the thread Ivor? You do realise that society has always "censored" what children are allowed access to? Exposing children to porn, allowing them to watch sexual acts let alone encouraging them to participate in sexual acts have always been offences under the Sex Offences Act or breached a range of Safeguarding legislation.
Arguing that toddlers must be exposed to portrayals of adults in fetish gear etc because they're in a book is nonsense.

MaryWhitehouseisCOOL · 01/12/2023 13:54

It's really interesting reading this thread.

If Transwomen want any credibility , they would be as outraged as women as it's an attack on childhood innocence.

As usual it's ALL about them 🙄

slavicflower · 01/12/2023 13:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

TheKeatingFive · 01/12/2023 13:30

I mean, in theory I'm against censorship too.

I just don't know what the market is supposed to be for picture books about Grandpas that include material unsuitable for under 18s.

TheKeatingFive · 01/12/2023 13:01

I have never heard of this book and have no intention of looking it up or reading it but on a point of principle I will be damned if I will see it, or anything else, cancelled.

It's showcasing BDSM and not so veiled references to pedophilia - and it's written for toddlers. You don't think, on the grounds of age appropriateness, there's a problem there?

ArthurbellaScott · 01/12/2023 12:59

IvorTheEngineDriver · 01/12/2023 12:56

I have never heard of this book and have no intention of looking it up or reading it but on a point of principle I will be damned if I will see it, or anything else, cancelled.

I am from a generation that saw legal battles to end censorship. We do not need to see it reinstated by an unthinking younger generation under a new name.

You say "cancelled". I say "censored".

Edited

Quite right! Get that bondage and BDSM content in front of the toddlers for the sake of free speech!

IvorTheEngineDriver · 01/12/2023 12:56

grandadspride · 01/12/2023 09:27

Yes. @GreenIsMyFavoriteColour have a google.

It needs cancelling

I have never heard of this book and have no intention of looking it up or reading it but on a point of principle I will be damned if I will see it, or anything else, cancelled.

I am from a generation that saw legal battles to end censorship. We do not need to see it reinstated by an unthinking younger generation under a new name.

You say "cancelled". I say "censored".

ArthurbellaScott · 01/12/2023 12:52

MrsOvertonsWindow · 01/12/2023 12:24

Great post - as is the one from @Worldgonecrazy. The relentless erosion of boundaries and the toxic impact of "bring your whole self to work etc" and being "authentic" is becoming a cover for abusers.
As this thread demonstrates - if you can allege transphobia and bigotry, you can both derail and silence adults from speaking about safeguarding children.
If you can persuade Mumsnet that a thread like this shouldn't be on a main board but hived off to a feminist one, then ordinary parents lose the opportunity to safeguard their toddlers from a book like this.

Safeguarding children, respecting boundaries and the right to say no is everybody's business. We need to do more challenging of those pushing these safeguarding eroding ideas - even if at times it feels uncomfortable to be called a "phobic" . Thank you OP for this thread.

Hear, hear to all of these points.

Helleofabore · 01/12/2023 12:30

I would suggest that the reason this book has been promoted so heavily as being an excellent resource for children is very much stemming from the same principles as the political movement that is attempting to use ideological premises to make comments about 'gender identity'.

Queer Theory is a great place to start. If you can lower societies boundaries, particularly around children, then you can make the currently unacceptable gradually acceptable. Look at how fucking long it took France to change their laws of consent back up to 16. And all the children harmed along the way. All because a group who considered themselves to be intellectuals and 'progressive' convinced the government in the 1970s to lower the age of consent. It took some 20 or 30 year old man raping a child in a park and declaring that child 'wanted it' in a court of law for them to finally do so though.

The issue becomes problematic when you get some people who police other people's words because they don't agree rather than entering into a discussion. Rather than asking questions and presenting evidence. The distraction tactics are nothing knew though. Once you recognise that some people have outsourced their critical thinking ability to social media influencers and are repeating tropish mantras or mindless phrases, those posters lose all credibility. Particularly if they cannot provide any evidence to defend their weak arguments.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 01/12/2023 12:25

Helleofabore · 01/12/2023 11:38

There will always be that poster who declares that the cases of chimerism are proof that sex is not known by scientists and medical specialists though. It is really is enlightening to see the argument 'but science just doesn't know' being brought out. Despite the fact that there is nothing but theory to back up their claims. All the science so far has reinforced what humans have known forever. That humans are sexually dimorphic and sex is immutable, and some humans have ambiguous genital and sex organ arrangements but it still doesn't mean that those humans cannot be categorised as one sex or the other.

If you don't like what the science says you can always say "but we don't really know".

Of course we do already know quite a lot of different ways that people develop feelings of their bodies being the "incorrect" sex, but the knowledge doesn't fit the narrative around trans so (for the time being) that knowledge isn't being respected or used.

I say "for the time being" because there's a tsunami of evidence building up and it will sweep away the wishful thinking model. Too late for some though. The damage is being done.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 01/12/2023 12:24

nothingcomestonothing · 01/12/2023 12:13

Boundaries have been pushed and pushed and pushed by the do what I say or I'll call you a bigot brigade. And now we're at a point where a kids book celebrating individuality and every type of body forced the author into leaving the industry (Rachel Rooney, My Body is Me) - while a kids book showing fetish gear and dodgy references is read out on childrens tv.

Posting purely to highlight what @MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking pointed out upthread - Rachel Rooney's lovely book encouraging children to love and respect their bodies was vilified and the author hounded. While a book with pictures of men in fetish gear and references to 'minor attracted persons' is read out on kids TV. No one will convince me that this is accidental.

Great post - as is the one from @Worldgonecrazy. The relentless erosion of boundaries and the toxic impact of "bring your whole self to work etc" and being "authentic" is becoming a cover for abusers.
As this thread demonstrates - if you can allege transphobia and bigotry, you can both derail and silence adults from speaking about safeguarding children.
If you can persuade Mumsnet that a thread like this shouldn't be on a main board but hived off to a feminist one, then ordinary parents lose the opportunity to safeguard their toddlers from a book like this.

Safeguarding children, respecting boundaries and the right to say no is everybody's business. We need to do more challenging of those pushing these safeguarding eroding ideas - even if at times it feels uncomfortable to be called a "phobic" . Thank you OP for this thread.

Caerulea · 01/12/2023 12:19

Bobsboob · 01/12/2023 11:07

Also, as my wife just pointed out- most gay men don’t go about in fetish gear, they wear jumpers like everyone else! Why the need to sexualise ‘gay’? Especially in a kids book.

Isn't it always the argument from bigots that homosexuality in men is just a perversion? Something the gay community had to fight hard against to show they are actually just normal ppl doing normal shit who happen to be same sex attracted. Normal jobs, normal families, normal pets. Just really ordinary normal people, not degenerate fetishists.

I get increasingly annoyed at seeing gay men (especially) be stereotyped BACKWARDS in media & this movement of absolute acceptance without question. It's so regressive & this book plays into that with its artwork.

Worldgonecrazy · 01/12/2023 12:13

Why has the trans issue overtaken a threads about a children’s book being used to promote imagery of fetish gear and paedophilia overtones?

The core issue with the book is that the male gay community have had to fight very hard against being tarred as paedophiles, and this book undoes years of work.

The book is actually incredibly HOMOPHOBIC despite its supposed story, yet I’m sure some parents would (wrongly) think that it was promoting kindness and acceptance.

what this thread does highlight is how utterly toxic the linking of the TQ+ with LGB is, and the homophobia of those pushing for trans rights.

nothingcomestonothing · 01/12/2023 12:13

Boundaries have been pushed and pushed and pushed by the do what I say or I'll call you a bigot brigade. And now we're at a point where a kids book celebrating individuality and every type of body forced the author into leaving the industry (Rachel Rooney, My Body is Me) - while a kids book showing fetish gear and dodgy references is read out on childrens tv.

Posting purely to highlight what @MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking pointed out upthread - Rachel Rooney's lovely book encouraging children to love and respect their bodies was vilified and the author hounded. While a book with pictures of men in fetish gear and references to 'minor attracted persons' is read out on kids TV. No one will convince me that this is accidental.

Thehop · 01/12/2023 11:59

This is bloody hideous. It's a fetish book for children.

teaching tolerance of all the colours of relationships does NOT require this imagery.

Helleofabore · 01/12/2023 11:58

"Gender is more complex, in that it takes into account what you identify with. I am pretty sure the complexities of what makes most females feel female and most males feel male isn't completely understood, and thus what would make one feel the opposite gender isn't that well understood either."

Does anyone else feel that there always seems to be something missing in discussions such as this where 'gender' is brought into the discussion and immediate 'gender' is limited to sex based descriptions? While neglecting completely the over 100 other 'genders'. That is transphobia there isn't it? The artificial limitation of the genders. I fully support ALL the genders being included in discussion because it really shows just how only a few genders are the focus these days.

CagneyAndLazy · 01/12/2023 11:57

Fucking appalling that people are defending this shite!

I'm disgusted that children are being exposed to this. Absolutely disgusted.

Swipe left for the next trending thread