Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult children - feeling a bit unloved

361 replies

mindsetchange · 01/12/2023 08:06

Is this just the way it is, for a lot of us Mums of adult children? My kids are mid 20's. They have successful lives. They have good jobs and relationships. I am very grateful for that. But.... I don't feel important to them. Maybe that's how it should be?

If I send a Whatsapp message, it sits unread for days. They don't visit often. There is definitely nothing "wrong" between us, because when I do see them, we have a great time. There have been no fall outs or anything. I think they are probably just enjoying their very full lives and I've been left in the dust, so to speak.

I have a good DH, and a good life. I think I need to somehow stop thinking about them all the time. How does one do that? Can anyone resonate with this? I sometimes see women who seem to be the "Matriarch", but that is definitely not me. I spoiled them rotten (still do), I really went overboard to compensate for me divorcing their Dad (he cheated lots). Bizarrely, he seems to be on a pedestal as well.

OP posts:
honoldbrist · 01/12/2023 10:37

mindsetchange · 01/12/2023 08:35

I don't ring them, but I do send lots of messages. It's not as easy as making a big meal and asking them over. They both live in different towns to me. They are both about 45 minutes away, in opposite directions. Neither drives. It would be a train journey to get here plus a long walk. They work where they live. They socialise where they live every weekend. They have lots of friends and loads going on. There isn't any time left for me. I do get that. I think the thing that's hurting me at the moment is not replying to messages. It just seems a bit neglectful.

Do you go and see them? Send them messages about what is going on in your life? Phone them?

Its your job to keep it going. "Hi darling, I thought i would catch the train over and take you out for lunch / dinner. Does wednesday or saturday suit you better?"

When i was a similar age i lived further away and my parents would just tell me they were coming up to take me out for dinner. It was nice. And they used to phone constantly, even when it was inconvenient. How are you, what are you doing, do you need anything? Annoying at the time but creates an obligation to keep in contact!!! The more you talk to someone the more you onow about their life and then you talk more.

BallaiLuimni · 01/12/2023 10:37

If you're serious about wanting a better relationship with them, stop giving advice. Treat them like an equal, a friend, rather than someone naive who needs your direction.

I guarantee it'll help, if you can manage to do it.

Brefugee · 01/12/2023 10:37

JennyForeigner · 01/12/2023 08:42

My mum could probably have written this a few years ago. We all went off and worked overseas, which is probably easier in terms of understanding not replying and so on.

Then we settled down and bought houses and struggled with the adult stuff and started to think about families of our own. Mum became completely central to our lives again in the most natural way. We wouldn't have a clue what to do without her and thank the god of nannas that we got a great one every day.

At that point 45 minutes distance may feel just about perfect!

so you ignored your mum until she was useful to you? seems harsh

Brefugee · 01/12/2023 10:35

anythinginapinch · 01/12/2023 08:34

Same. I think, they'll get in touch if anything is actually wrong in their lives so no news is good news. I recall finding my DM low on my list in my 20s (mind you, I am a much better, less annoying mum than she was!). The idea of speaking weekly is too much for me. I take mine away for a week in the summer all paid for them and that way I do get a "reset" time with them but I'm lucky I can afford to do that.

No one loves us like a 3 year old tho - the fact is we are less essential to life than we were, for them. And that's a good thing. But painful yes.

i think that's a pretty shitty attitude towards parents though. Maybe my family is a bit weird?
I come from a military family so we were always away from my parents' families. but they wrote to (and when we had a phone called) their parents weekly.
And I have carried that on, so now it's just my mum left, i make doubly sure to make that weekly call. (my siblings are fuckers and don't)

So as a result my mum doesn't get into a panic when i call, but as soon as my siblings do, she knows there is bad news coming (and they're asking for money). That is a shit way to treat your parent, imo.

MrsKeats · 01/12/2023 10:35

I am definitely a matriarch but I think that's common where I live.
My dh barely is in touch with his adult children which I can't understand.

Treewizard88 · 01/12/2023 10:35

Hey OP, I was a bit like this with my mum in my early 20s had lots going on with friends, partner, jobs etc. She suggested we meet once a fortnight for dinner and a drink (wine Wednesdays we called them) and it made us closer we looked forward to them would have a good catch up over dinner and drink occasionally we'd go to the cinema afterwards was a good way to keep close. Could you suggest something like that?

shepherdsangeldelight · 01/12/2023 10:33

do you not think sometimes that young people just need to be told that they’re wrong and just accept the wisdom of older , more experienced people? Surely that’s what OP’s daughter has to do at work for example? She can’t just be told she’s right all the time she isn’t!

Older people are not always wiser than younger people and shouldn't necessarily expect young people to agree to their views. It's different in a work setting, where you have to do what your manager says even if it actually is wrong.

In the spider example, neither OP or DD have any idea at this point whether DD's specific apartment will have spiders. OP's view is no more valid than DD's but by forcing it on DD she is saying "see, I know more than you". I suspect this is also part of a pattern - if she's always giving unsolicited advice, DD's natural response will be to reject it even if it's actually good advice.

Alondra · 01/12/2023 10:33

mindsetchange · 01/12/2023 10:29

Re the spider thing - she is TERRIFIED of spiders. I mean panic attack level. If she is here and there is a spider, me or DH have to get rid of it (humanely). That's the only reason I brought it up. Conversation lasted all of two minutes and it's never been mentioned again. We have had loads of conversations about the move, and I can't honestly think of one other negative thing I've said. We are also currently planning our visit to see them next year.

She will have to cope with spiders and deal with them. She is not a kid, don't treat her like one.

As moms, we are so used to always be one step ahead trying to protect our kids that often we forget, when they are adults, that they are no longer kids and need to deal with their own issues and learn from their own mistakes.

Draconis · 01/12/2023 10:32

45 mins is nothing. That's less than many peoples daily commute.

Invite them over for dinner or lunch or to stay the weekend. Pop over and visit them or meet them for a meal.

Sendhelp101 · 01/12/2023 10:30

I was the same with my mum OP when I first moved out, my mum is amazing but I thought I was too busy or had too much on to bother and my mum worried but knew I'd contact her if I was in trouble or needed anything! Fast forward to my 30's I've been diagnosed with a long term chronic illness and ended up a single parent so rely on my mum heavily and speak to her daily. I think she would rather the former, a healthy independent child who didn't need to rely on their parents at 30 years old 😪

mindsetchange · 01/12/2023 10:29

Re the spider thing - she is TERRIFIED of spiders. I mean panic attack level. If she is here and there is a spider, me or DH have to get rid of it (humanely). That's the only reason I brought it up. Conversation lasted all of two minutes and it's never been mentioned again. We have had loads of conversations about the move, and I can't honestly think of one other negative thing I've said. We are also currently planning our visit to see them next year.

OP posts:
Fernsfernsferns · 01/12/2023 10:28

mindsetchange · 01/12/2023 09:52

Okay, silly example of advice :

DD is moving to a country that has a lot of spiders. She is terrified of them. She will be living in a high rise, and therefore has stated that there will never be any spiders in the apartment, because they will be on a high floor. Someone I know is from there, and he said that spiders most definitely will be in the apartment from time to time. I suggested getting a spider catcher. She said there will be no spiders. The person I know is wrong. Accompanied with eye roll. 😂So we are not talking big bits of life advice here, just little conversations where I feel like I am some comedy act to be dismissed.

Ok but this kind of thing is annoying.

on that can you stay out of it and let her find out herself?

but generally I think part of this is acceptance and then another part is being more confidently pro active in your relationship with them.

i recognise the dynamics you describe, I found my dad easier as a young adult vs my mum who was needy and looking to me for validation (which you are doing, a bit)

for example, at university my dad didn’t call me much (or i him and he didn’t seem to mind). But he would come and see me twice a term. He’d call and say ‘I’m coming to see you in the next week or two. What evening is good for you, I’ll book somewhere nice for dinner?’ Clear, assertive, offered me a nice dinner.

still now he’ll suggest doing something - seeing a film together or an exhibition, or something g he thinks my kids would like, and then make the running to organise and book it if I say yes. Takes it graciously if I say no. My mum has no ideas, and expects me to do all the organising.

and in general she was much needier ‘I never hear from you’ ‘when will I see you’

i know you’ve said they are moving but you could for example say:

’id like to see you, I’ll come over and take you out for a meal. Is dinner or lunch best? Which day?’ And then book somewhere they’d like to eat and show up.

its not their fault you are working ‘seven days a week’ and you don’t need to go to where they live to visit them.

you have to make some running and make reasonably timed suggestions, as you would with other adult friends

maybe their dad now treats them as the adults and equals they are which they find easier? I know I did.

with your DD moving away - once she’s settled you have to take responsibility for planning a trip during which you see her. So organise a holiday for yourself with opportunities to see her in it. Don’t expect to stay with her for weeks and weeks (maybe a few nights spaced out). Maybe invite her to join you at a nice holiday resort in the middle and offer to pay for that. But spend plenty of the trip doing your own thing off exploring, don’t rely on her to host / plan / entertain you.

and then she’ll enjoy it and want you to visit again.

if she’s really going to have her kids there i would plan to get to know if. Scope out airbnbs I could book for extended visits, and eg whether I could work from there to support that.

Pluvia · 01/12/2023 10:27

OP, no time to read the full thread, but it sounds as if you need to build your own busy and fulfilling life — hobbies, socialising, studying, activities, new friends, new interests — and be the one not to instantly respond to WA messages and not always be available. You've launched them successfully so well done. Now focus on the next 30 or 40 or 50 years of your own life. Don't be the boring and predictable mum they can take for granted, have them chasing after you.

laveritable · 01/12/2023 10:27

I'm in the same boat. OP understand that most 20s are all about ME, ME. ME! It is a big wide world they have stepped into, jobs, relationships, homes, etc. I love travelling and belong to a lot of groups and have a lot going on! Enjoy the time you have with them. They would be "back" esp when they start a family!

Alondra · 01/12/2023 10:26

mindsetchange · 01/12/2023 09:52

Okay, silly example of advice :

DD is moving to a country that has a lot of spiders. She is terrified of them. She will be living in a high rise, and therefore has stated that there will never be any spiders in the apartment, because they will be on a high floor. Someone I know is from there, and he said that spiders most definitely will be in the apartment from time to time. I suggested getting a spider catcher. She said there will be no spiders. The person I know is wrong. Accompanied with eye roll. 😂So we are not talking big bits of life advice here, just little conversations where I feel like I am some comedy act to be dismissed.

Look, you are mom. You always keep in touch. You are also very nice without major issues. End result? They are taking you a bit for granted. And I don't say this in a negative way.

I have 3 adult sons. The youngest is 19 and beginning to fly solo. In our household we are the opposite to you, my DH is the one always sending text messages to the kids that are answered a couple of days later to my DH's exasperation. I'm the opposite, I hate phones so I rarely call or text unless I have to. And they call me/ text back very quickly probably because they know I only get in touch when there is an issue. I've said to DH to let them live their lives without needing to be in touch every fucking day. He agrees with me but still send the messages and then gets cranky when they don't answer for a couple of days.

Your kids are in their 20s with full lives. They also don't drive, making it more difficult to pop around if they have a couple of hours to kill. Don't overdo the texting and please, don't feel "unimportant". You are very important. They may not show it in the way you want, but trust me, you ARE.

Ramalangadingdong · 01/12/2023 10:24

Also, thinking about being in my 20s I remember that I just had so much to do - work , dating, trying to have fun. You have to enjoy your 20s free if your parents, don’t you?

When they settle down in their 30s and 40s you will find that they identify with you more - especially if they become parents themselves. For now you should enjoy yourself, op; make new friends. You only need one or two really good friends. Good luck.

Ramalangadingdong · 01/12/2023 10:21

anythinginapinch · 01/12/2023 08:34

Same. I think, they'll get in touch if anything is actually wrong in their lives so no news is good news. I recall finding my DM low on my list in my 20s (mind you, I am a much better, less annoying mum than she was!). The idea of speaking weekly is too much for me. I take mine away for a week in the summer all paid for them and that way I do get a "reset" time with them but I'm lucky I can afford to do that.

No one loves us like a 3 year old tho - the fact is we are less essential to life than we were, for them. And that's a good thing. But painful yes.

i hear what you say.

when my mother died I realised that a big part of our love was my feeling that I could take her for granted - do you know what I mean? I don’t mean that I disrespected her but that I knew she was always there if I needed her. She was with me even if we weren’t together. I still feel that now. And then when she got I’ll I couldn’t do enough for her. My caring for her was a way of saying a big thank you. It was hard but it would have been harder if I hadn’t done it - the ultimate in taking someone for granted.

Do your Dcs have their own dcs, op? If not they may well see you more when they do.

Historybooks · 01/12/2023 10:19

Just phone them every 2 weeks. A missed call is harder to forget.

Offer to visit them. There must be a way to get round the long walk, like have a long walk, or cycle, bus or get a lift. Arrange something between all of you somewhere in the middle like a restaurant. Also depends what you mean by long walk, if its under 3 miles they or u could fo that in the spring.

It's good they have busy lives though. They sound like they're doing well.

Himawarigirl · 01/12/2023 10:19

The advice thing resonates with me so much and is worth being aware of. My mum has been like that as long as I can remember. I absolutely know it comes from a good place of wanting to look after me and that’s what I remind myself of and bite my tongue. But all I hear is criticism, the idea that I’m not capable of sorting out problems myself and also pre-emptive stressing about things I simply don’t think are a big deal and will be very able to deal with as and when they become an issue, which I find exhausting. Over decades it really wears you down. As another pp said, my MIL never does that and I hugely value her advice as and when I ask for it.

bonzaitree · 01/12/2023 10:18

TBF at 25 I was doing my own thing, didn’t really have much involvement with parents or wider family - I was doing my own thing, working on career etc.

Fast forward 10 years and I am super close with family - not just mum and dad but aunts uncles cousins etc.

Your priorities change and you « come back » as it were.

housethatbuiltme · 01/12/2023 10:17

I wouldn't phone them.

I along with many I know have phone anxiety. I use to hate call as I never knew if they where going to be 10 minutes of 2 hours. Phones are also like forums where no one can read body language and people get angry over nothing, it removes a human element (kind of like road rage).

If they are teens, early 20s or new parents they probably are just focusing on their life, they are still learning it all and it takes a lot of time and energy to learn to 'adult'.

Do you accept invitations? I invited my mam out many times she was sick and disabled which did effect a lot of why she said no especially after Covid but she always said no. She talked a lot about 'plans' but never actually wanted to carry them out.

I'm sad I didn't get to do lots of things with my mam towards the end, I offered often from holidays (even found specialist medical hotels) to going for afternoon tea to local beach trips but she never felt up to it.

Deliaskis · 01/12/2023 10:15

LuckySantangelo35 · 01/12/2023 10:08

@Greycottage

do you not think sometimes that young people just need to be told that they’re wrong and just accept the wisdom of older , more experienced people? Surely that’s what OP’s daughter has to do at work for example? She can’t just be told she’s right all the time she isn’t!

Not on something so insignificant as this, it isn't valuable, and if it happens a lot it is just annoying noise. Generally, we learn the best and the most meaningfully from experiencing things ourselves, even if sometimes we make mistakes.

Where there is actual risk or make or break stuff, then yes wisdom and experience from older people can be crucial, but not on something like this. And if we don't give advice too often, and save it for the important stuff, we are more likely to be listened to and respected when we do.

spriots · 01/12/2023 10:15

Something to think about is the ratio of praise to criticism/advice.

There's a lot of research about this in the workplace but I think it's also relevant to personal relationships.

https://www.happybrainscience.com/blog/the-ideal-praise-to-criticism-ratio-at-work-51/

Things like the spider advice might be absolutely fine if your interactions with her are generally positive but if it's the 5th critical thing you have said to her that day, it's different.

My MIL actually says nice things about me and my parenting and my children all the time, it means that when she does give advice I take it more seriously.

My mother very very rarely says anything nice about me. I got a big promotion recently - my dad, my MIL, my FIL all sent me congratulations and supportive messages, my mum said "oh well I don't think it's good for your kids if you work even more"

LuckySantangelo35 · 01/12/2023 10:14

ManateeFair · 01/12/2023 10:10

I'm imagining this conversation from your DD's perspective.

"I'm moving abroad soon to a tropical country. Instead of being pleased for me, my mum keeps looking for tiny things go on about, like the fact that I'm scared of spiders and there might be spiders in my apartment. Moving abroad is a massive deal and there's a lot to organise, and my mum is just looing for reasons that I won't like it, which is really annoying because I'm a grown adult who is capable of sorting these things out for myself. I've tried to shut the spider conversation down because frankly, I've got enough to sort out with my move as it is and the last thing I need to be worrying about is sourcing a fucking spider-catcher right now, but she is so determined to make this an issue that she literally consulted someone she knows who lives there just to prove to me that she's right and is still going on about it. AIBU to think she needs to accept that I'm an adult and that, just because she's my mother, she isn't always right and that she needs to butt out sometimes?"

@ManateeFair

lol if that’s the daughters perspective she sounds very sensitive and highly strung! Being given advice whether you asked for it or not is all part of life and we all just gotta suck it up 🤷‍♀️ no big deal.

HoppingPavlova · 01/12/2023 10:13

DD is moving to a country that has a lot of spiders. She is terrified of them. She will be living in a high rise, and therefore has stated that there will never be any spiders in the apartment, because they will be on a high floor. Someone I know is from there, and he said that spiders most definitely will be in the apartment from time to time. I suggested getting a spider catcher. She said there will be no spiders. The person I know is wrong. Accompanied with eye roll. 😂So we are not talking big bits of life advice here, just little conversations where I feel like I am some comedy act to be dismissed

Thats the problem. They are at an age where they believe they know everything. I’d like to know everything like people they age, how great it would be🤣. Instead of feeling dismissed, just smile and nod, safe in the knowledge that she will likely have to deal with a spider at some point. And she will be fine. And somewhere in the back of her brain it will float about ‘fuck, mum was right’. After at least a decade, all these thoughts coalesce and it finally starts to filter through that mum indeed has some valuable life advice and you will be proactively approached, will take some time though. Meanwhile, just go live your best life.