Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult children - feeling a bit unloved

361 replies

mindsetchange · 01/12/2023 08:06

Is this just the way it is, for a lot of us Mums of adult children? My kids are mid 20's. They have successful lives. They have good jobs and relationships. I am very grateful for that. But.... I don't feel important to them. Maybe that's how it should be?

If I send a Whatsapp message, it sits unread for days. They don't visit often. There is definitely nothing "wrong" between us, because when I do see them, we have a great time. There have been no fall outs or anything. I think they are probably just enjoying their very full lives and I've been left in the dust, so to speak.

I have a good DH, and a good life. I think I need to somehow stop thinking about them all the time. How does one do that? Can anyone resonate with this? I sometimes see women who seem to be the "Matriarch", but that is definitely not me. I spoiled them rotten (still do), I really went overboard to compensate for me divorcing their Dad (he cheated lots). Bizarrely, he seems to be on a pedestal as well.

OP posts:
Fernsfernsferns · 01/12/2023 18:35

@MsRosley

Do you seriously hold this attitude to your own parents? That you owe them nothing?

I think a GOOD adult child / parent relationship is about wanting to spend time together rather than obligation, debt, duty.

and the OP expresses regret that her adult children don’t NEED her

she's also described telling her daughter how she’s wrong (eg about spiders in Australia)

well, successful adult children should not NEED you if you’ve done a good job. And want them to need you is, exactly being needy, and (still) seeking to define yourself as a mother, and perhaps seeking to direct or shape their lives (see the spider thing. The OP’s DD is an adult, she will find that out herself and figure it out, the OP should stay out of it).

my PIL are needy and seek to overly direct their adult children’s lives. Hence both their children have made their lives in the U.K. thousands of miles away from over bearing PIL.

back to a good relationship- it’s about being pro-active - suggesting a activity to do together. And when they are young adults being prepared to make the running in terms of travelling to them, booking the place for lunch, etc.

Mikimoto · 01/12/2023 18:34

SerenityNowInsanityLater · 01/12/2023 12:34

I just wanted to add something my mother told me when I first held my baby DC1. She said to me, "He is his own entity. He's of you but he's not you. You'll name him but he becomes him." That's always stayed with me and helped lift me whenever I feel a bit, "Ah where's my boy who wanders around every street from Camden to Cricklewood but doesn't make his way to his own front door?".

Was your mother Maharishi Mahesh Yogi?

MsRosley · 01/12/2023 18:12

SunSparkle · 01/12/2023 12:14

@MsRosley I really disagree that adult children owe their parents anything. If their parents sacrificed too much of themselves to give you exceptional chances in life, that was a choice they made. You didn't ask for it or demand it - you were a child. It isn't now your responsibility to repay it. And if a parent resents you because of how much of themselves they gave to parenting to you or how many financial resources they overspent, that's not fair either.

You parent your kids because you presumably wanted them and you took on the responsibility to raise a child. But if you martyred yourself, you can't suddenly make your children pay you back for that sacrifice.

I hope I never give my daughter more than I'm happy to give, and I never make her feel responsible for the choices I made in my life for her because if I wasn't happy with them, I shouldn't have made them. She will owe me nothing.

Do you seriously hold this attitude to your own parents? That you owe them nothing?

Goatymum · 01/12/2023 17:59

It’s great they’ve got good relationships and jobs and you’re fulfilled too! Mine are a bit younger, both at uni but come home during term time where my dd un particular is quite ‘clingy’ to me when in!
I find if they’re doing well we get less communication than if they’re struggling- I’d def prefer the former.
What do you do when you see them?

aSpanielintheworks · 01/12/2023 17:55

I've not read all replies but I have two adult children, both went away to Uni & didn't come home & now have successful lives miles and miles away.
Our saving grace and the way we've stayed close is our family Messenger group, not a day goes by without that pinging away about life in general. Photos of the cat doing silly things, memes we've seen on the Internet, news, selfies (them!!), everything.
I never ring for a long chat, everything is done on Messenger and the odd private message if its something they feel not everyone will be interested in.
Short, sharp, regular and often very funny!
It's kept us very close and works for us.

Sceptre86 · 01/12/2023 17:50

My sister is mid 20s and speaks to my mum once a week and visits every few weeks. Mum texts her regularly and when she comes home they spend one on one time together. I'm older by 10 years and I speak to mum every day but I work part time compared to my sisters full time and I have 3 kids who want to speak to their nan daily. I think it is just a stage of life thing. My mum works now and she didn't when we were younger so that gets her out of the house she also does date nights with dad and meet ups with friends to keep her busier. Do you have any hobbies that you could indulge in? I probably wouldn't speak to them about it as I wouldn't want then to get on the defensive but I would keep being loving and supportive and invite them around at least once a month for a family meal.

PercyPigsInBlankets · 01/12/2023 17:43

TiredCatLady · 01/12/2023 13:18

Thank you PercyPigs - I could have written near the same about my parents.

Add in that when I do go to see them, they don’t actually want to do anything except sit in front of the tv. It feels like a waste of 10 hours of driving and precious time off work but they just don’t get it.

Haha yes, the TV. Going out to dinner is a waste of money (and yes I always pay). Going for a walk is pointless. It feels like they just want me there for the sake of it.

Shrammed · 01/12/2023 16:22

mindsetchange · 01/12/2023 14:22

I feel sometimes, that I am seen as "Mum", rather than a real living woman, with thoughts, desires, feelings of my own, if that makes sense.

I know what you mean - though recently got told by problematic family it was my own fault as I had no interest or hobbies.

This upset me as I do but no childcare and limited funds tended to mean we all did them as a family and somehow this then meant they weren't mine anymore and if kids have carried interests on into study or own hobbies it's nothing to do with my/our input. If I did spend time and money on just me that at time was also very wrong - so does feel what ever I did I was in wrong there.

I do think all you can do though is keep communication going keep other aspects of your life going or given them more time attention and maybe odd polite reminder you are human with feelings.

Birch101 · 01/12/2023 16:08

Honestly try not to take it to heart perhaps a different approach.

I would call or message my mum back on the walk home from work, but then I moved and had to start driving so couldn't do that.

If they are taking 3 days to respond is there a pattern e.g. do they respond more during the working week or the weekend, in the mornings or the evenings

Maybe you'd be better of messaging once a week?

My mum once message my sibling and I urgent call me

I left work desk immediately went to kitchen only private space and called her...she was shopping and wanted to know what bottle to get for Christmas... had to sit her down after that 🤣

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 01/12/2023 15:56

@FreshWinterMorning I live 4 hours from my family. My DCs birthday was recently. There was grandparents, cousins, aunts, siblings all in my house regardless of distance, so DC could have a lovely family party.

I've been 4 hours from my family for over a decade. Aside from a couple when I was heavily pregnant/had just given birth I've been at EVERY major family event. And if I couldn't make it with work, I've done something different with them. My family are here every few weeks taking DC on days out and doing things with them. They're on video call every few days because DC ask for them.

30 miles is nothing, it shouldn't stop this if its what you all want.

StardustGiraffe · 01/12/2023 15:54

mindsetchange · 01/12/2023 14:22

I feel sometimes, that I am seen as "Mum", rather than a real living woman, with thoughts, desires, feelings of my own, if that makes sense.

Ah OP, I think this is part and parcel of the role of mum!

For what it's worth, I did see my parents weekly through my 20s but it was more out of a sense of obligation - not that I didn't want to see them (I did) but I felt guilty if I didn't see them really regularly as I felt that they were waiting around for me. It doesn't sound like your life is like that.

However, now I have a baby of my own and I see them so much more, and happily. Not because I need things from them (although they do have her while I work) but because it has opened my eyes to all they've done for me and when I think of my own baby treating me as I've treated them sometimes, I know I would hate it. But genuinely it has taken this life shift for me to see it.

So I do think what you've described is very normal. As you're all so busy, I'd definitely advise setting a date for a family lunch every month or something like that - one Sunday a month you get together, or get together with one of them, and book it in in advance so none of you can be 'too busy'.

girlfriend44 · 01/12/2023 15:17

FreshWinterMorning · 01/12/2023 13:39

I 100% get you @mindsetchange I've got two daughters. (mid to late 20s.) One lives 20 miles away and one lives 30 miles away. I'm in my mid 50s and so is DH ... They have both been to university, they have both got partners - one is married, they have both got successful professional careers, and they both bought a house with their partner within the past 2 years. They have many friends, and very busy lives.

They can easily go three days without any contact. I do send WhatsApp messages - and sometimes they will answer within five minutes sometimes it's 3 or four hours, occasionally it's several days. I do see them on Twitter and Instagram. quite a lot, and they don't respond to me for a couple of days, which I do find a little bit irksome ... I think 'well you have the time to post on here, but not to send me a quick whatsapp message back?' Confused But I know they don't do it deliberately. Something else probably comes up as they are about to message me.

They've both got about 20 friends each. (I'm not kidding you!) From college and school and uni. and very, very full lives. They travel a bit with work, and they go away a lot - abroad on weekend trips, and to London, Edinburgh, Brighton, Bournemouth, Devon, and other places where they have old uni friends, and other people they know. It's can be a bit hard to pin them down for a visit, and we have to plan it several weeks in advance! I gave up phoning them to have a chat, because they never EVER answered.

They visit us about once a month and we visit them once a month in between. So we see them every two weeks if you see what I mean. We go a day trip together. (Me, DH, and the 2 DDs,) to the beach - in the summer, and we will go to see a show another time, and we will go for 2 or 3 meals together during the year. (Their husbands don't come on the day trip, and will come to one of the meals.) Neither of them are planning on having any children anytime soon. Although probably they will one day. The older one says she would like one in about five years.

We go to the oldest DD for Christmas day, for a couple of hours, (because she lives in the middle of me and DH, and our youngest.) Me and DH leave on Christmas day at about 1pm and have the rest of the day/our Christmas meal on our own... They all come to ours for Easter, and spend 2 or 3 ours on Easter Sunday with us.

Upshot is, they really, really, really don't need me (or DH,) and it does sting to be quite honest with you. I know it's natural, and I feel me and DH must have done a good job for them to be so independent and successful. But it makes my heart a little bit sad that they don't need me, for anything...

Not far from me, there's 4 or 5 families who have got between 15 and 20 family members within 15 minutes walk - and they're always popping in for coffees, going for a walk together, going on a day trip together, (two or three times a week for the six weeks during the summer holidays!) Going to the bingo together, having big family BBQs in summer, and all the little cousins play together.

3 of 4 generations of family are all there for each other all the time, and they gather at the gran's - or great gran's for special occasions and have big family parties. I do get so envious of this and long for my daughters to live closer to me and DH, and have a couple of kids each, and have the kids running to my house, to come and see nan and grandad for an hour or so. I would take them to the zoo or the woods or the park and play with them, and bake cakes with them, and have a great time. Grin

I grew up with this situation - living close to about 20 family members and they'd all pile into my nan's house on Christmas Day, and go to the oldest uncle's house on Boxing Day for a great big family get together, about 30 people. Me and my cousins would play together at uncle's house on Boxing day, and me and my friends would play outside on Christmas day with our new bikes/scooters/skateboard etc.

Quite honestly, it was a magical time and it's not like that anymore. But I know our DDs do love me and DH so much - and there's nothing they wouldn't do if we asked them. (And the same for us with them.) They speak to me a few times a week on Whatsapp. and I communicate with them on Twitter and they message me back - and as I said they do visit, and we visit them.... and see them twice a month, and I know they'd be here in a heartbeat if we needed them urgently. And they're only 30 to 40 minutes drive away after all.

But yes, I really, really do wish that they were a lot closer and I do feel a little bit woeful and envious when I see the families in my street that have all their family members within 15 to 20 minutes walk. I long for that ..... Maybe one day.... Maybe when my DDs hit their 30s, and they have kids, they will need me and DH more, but right now they don't need us at all. I remember the wonderful days, when they were tiny, big-eyed infants, and I was the centre of their world. Now I'm just on the edge of it, looking in.

And oh, how I miss the wonderful, magical CHRISTMASSES with them, when they were little. 😄 Going to Santa's grotto, and lots of different Christmas events and places, and driving around looking at all the Christmas lights, and taking them to the big indoor shopping centre in the evening for the late night shopping, a few days before Christmas. Such wonderful days.

Edited

Lots of families don't I've near each other.
Some live in different countries.

Not all children make their parents grandparents.

You need to concentrate on what you have not what you haven't.

To some you already have alot
I think overall health and happiness is more important than whose seeing who and how often.

DarkWingDuck · 01/12/2023 14:46

Congrats on bringing up independent children who now have great lives. I don’t know if this is part of it but I often feel very overwhelmed by WhatsApp messages and all the pressures of modern life, I often leave messages unread from people I love and care for very much. It’s about me and my ability to manage modern life rather than a reflection on our relationship. Could this be the case here?

Maybe let them know that you would like to connect more and see what suits them better- a quick message every now and then, a booked in phone call or a weekend together.

moomoomoo27 · 01/12/2023 14:45

Scruffington · 01/12/2023 13:45

Such a coincidence that you decided distance was required from both your mothers.

They are close friends and have been for decades, parent in very similar ways because they were always trying to outdo each other in a small town. Maybe it's a competition between them, I don't know. Mine is not as abrasive as his, but then I would think that.

Scruffington · 01/12/2023 14:34

If things are genuinely okay between the two of you, and he only lives 45 mins away, I do find it a bit baffling that you’ve only seen your son twice in 2023.

iamrageohtheresakitty · 01/12/2023 14:33

I think booking time in advance with them is the key here - my mother would probably say similar, that I'm too busy to see her, but she doesn't actually organise anything with me. And so of course I'm busy when she happens to be free.
It seems a bit unfair to blame your children for not seeing you enough if you're not actually organising anything.

Do you have a group WhatsApp? It's much easier (and fun) to respond in the family chat than to respond directly to your mum asking "how are you?"

And don't dispense advice - if you don't want to be viewed as "Mum" you need to treat them like adults.

Ilovelifeverymuch · 01/12/2023 14:30

mindsetchange · 01/12/2023 14:22

I feel sometimes, that I am seen as "Mum", rather than a real living woman, with thoughts, desires, feelings of my own, if that makes sense.

.

mindsetchange · 01/12/2023 14:22

I feel sometimes, that I am seen as "Mum", rather than a real living woman, with thoughts, desires, feelings of my own, if that makes sense.

OP posts:
JenniferJuniper80 · 01/12/2023 14:13

Not read the whole thread but..op,

how often do you call your folks

Are ,you too busy

mindsetchange · 01/12/2023 14:13

FreshWinterMorning · 01/12/2023 13:39

I 100% get you @mindsetchange I've got two daughters. (mid to late 20s.) One lives 20 miles away and one lives 30 miles away. I'm in my mid 50s and so is DH ... They have both been to university, they have both got partners - one is married, they have both got successful professional careers, and they both bought a house with their partner within the past 2 years. They have many friends, and very busy lives.

They can easily go three days without any contact. I do send WhatsApp messages - and sometimes they will answer within five minutes sometimes it's 3 or four hours, occasionally it's several days. I do see them on Twitter and Instagram. quite a lot, and they don't respond to me for a couple of days, which I do find a little bit irksome ... I think 'well you have the time to post on here, but not to send me a quick whatsapp message back?' Confused But I know they don't do it deliberately. Something else probably comes up as they are about to message me.

They've both got about 20 friends each. (I'm not kidding you!) From college and school and uni. and very, very full lives. They travel a bit with work, and they go away a lot - abroad on weekend trips, and to London, Edinburgh, Brighton, Bournemouth, Devon, and other places where they have old uni friends, and other people they know. It's can be a bit hard to pin them down for a visit, and we have to plan it several weeks in advance! I gave up phoning them to have a chat, because they never EVER answered.

They visit us about once a month and we visit them once a month in between. So we see them every two weeks if you see what I mean. We go a day trip together. (Me, DH, and the 2 DDs,) to the beach - in the summer, and we will go to see a show another time, and we will go for 2 or 3 meals together during the year. (Their husbands don't come on the day trip, and will come to one of the meals.) Neither of them are planning on having any children anytime soon. Although probably they will one day. The older one says she would like one in about five years.

We go to the oldest DD for Christmas day, for a couple of hours, (because she lives in the middle of me and DH, and our youngest.) Me and DH leave on Christmas day at about 1pm and have the rest of the day/our Christmas meal on our own... They all come to ours for Easter, and spend 2 or 3 ours on Easter Sunday with us.

Upshot is, they really, really, really don't need me (or DH,) and it does sting to be quite honest with you. I know it's natural, and I feel me and DH must have done a good job for them to be so independent and successful. But it makes my heart a little bit sad that they don't need me, for anything...

Not far from me, there's 4 or 5 families who have got between 15 and 20 family members within 15 minutes walk - and they're always popping in for coffees, going for a walk together, going on a day trip together, (two or three times a week for the six weeks during the summer holidays!) Going to the bingo together, having big family BBQs in summer, and all the little cousins play together.

3 of 4 generations of family are all there for each other all the time, and they gather at the gran's - or great gran's for special occasions and have big family parties. I do get so envious of this and long for my daughters to live closer to me and DH, and have a couple of kids each, and have the kids running to my house, to come and see nan and grandad for an hour or so. I would take them to the zoo or the woods or the park and play with them, and bake cakes with them, and have a great time. Grin

I grew up with this situation - living close to about 20 family members and they'd all pile into my nan's house on Christmas Day, and go to the oldest uncle's house on Boxing Day for a great big family get together, about 30 people. Me and my cousins would play together at uncle's house on Boxing day, and me and my friends would play outside on Christmas day with our new bikes/scooters/skateboard etc.

Quite honestly, it was a magical time and it's not like that anymore. But I know our DDs do love me and DH so much - and there's nothing they wouldn't do if we asked them. (And the same for us with them.) They speak to me a few times a week on Whatsapp. and I communicate with them on Twitter and they message me back - and as I said they do visit, and we visit them.... and see them twice a month, and I know they'd be here in a heartbeat if we needed them urgently. And they're only 30 to 40 minutes drive away after all.

But yes, I really, really do wish that they were a lot closer and I do feel a little bit woeful and envious when I see the families in my street that have all their family members within 15 to 20 minutes walk. I long for that ..... Maybe one day.... Maybe when my DDs hit their 30s, and they have kids, they will need me and DH more, but right now they don't need us at all. I remember the wonderful days, when they were tiny, big-eyed infants, and I was the centre of their world. Now I'm just on the edge of it, looking in.

And oh, how I miss the wonderful, magical CHRISTMASSES with them, when they were little. 😄 Going to Santa's grotto, and lots of different Christmas events and places, and driving around looking at all the Christmas lights, and taking them to the big indoor shopping centre in the evening for the late night shopping, a few days before Christmas. Such wonderful days.

Edited

This really resonates with me. I think I've seen DS maybe twice this year. He works long days then goes to the gym - and most weekends are spent with friends. It's hard to arrange a date for lunch far in advance (to book him up, so to speak), because I can get last minute bookings worth ££££, so I never really know what my week looks like until right before), but I think I might just try booking more things like lunch and hoping for the best!

I am reading every single post, and am so grateful that people have taken the time to reply. SO many good points here, thank you.

OP posts:
BenjaminDisraeli · 01/12/2023 14:09

I'm very close to my daughter but can still go quite a while without hearing from her. I think mothers just have to accept that, as our children, they're constantly on our minds; and as their parents, we're not on theirs (except in a vaguely benign fuzzy way).

Also that, shockingly, we may only come to the fore when financial, practical or emotional support is required. Motherly wisdom or compelling matriarchal presence is on the list of things usually not required of us!

All signs to me that you've brought your kids up lovingly and well. Would you really want it any other way?

Whisperingangel1 · 01/12/2023 14:05

I'm in my 30s but WhatsApp my mum every day, probably ring every 3-5 days, at least once a week. But I'm a SAHM so I have lots of free time. Probably less when I worked full time. No excuse for not replying to WhatsApp, that's rude. But phone calls I find it's always an hour long call and my mum doesn't want to get off the phone and even if I try to end it she keeps talking so that does put me off ringing, I know she means well and I love catching up, but not hearing about her next door neighbours daughters cat etc.
I think you will find once your kids have kids you will hear from them alot more, they're just young. And you've obviously done a greta job at making them independent. Don't over think it.

mindsetchange · 01/12/2023 13:58

Shrammed · 01/12/2023 12:55

I do find as well, that they don't really value my opinion. They think I'm a worrier, or a bit OTT, but I think they are quite naive in many ways (I don't say this, of course). But if I give advice, I can sense the eye roll. It makes me feel insignificant, rather than an older and wiser family member.

I'm at the start of getting this eldest just started uni - and it does make it hard though I'm not offering advice more asking if she is okay and does she need anything you can heard the eye rolls. On first visit asked if she need us to bring anything in effort to be helpful and response was to bring up me inadvertently leaving some plasters and other minor inconsequential items behind - which doesn't answer my question and make me feel like I;m in the wrong.

Everyone says it's normal - though some of the family saying that got weekly phone calls - we've tried to find times when she's not busy but still made to feel like we are imposing.

Assume it will pass or not but I do have fear as there is lurking family who like to cause issues and are there for fun stuff but are fuck all help in bad times and have very much form for sweeping in taking over fun stuff and leaving me especially but also DH with the crap stuff to deal with. They've already swept in before us and done fun first visit - which upset younger siblings who couldn't drop off due to school more than Dh and me but still felt off.

I wondered if your Ex is like this - a malevolent floating spector that gets to do fun stuff leaving drudge to you and who it's hard to say no to for the kids but it's easy to say no to you as your expected to understand.

Yes, some truth in this. I moved both of them in to Uni Halls. I did every subsequent move with them, which included hiring vans and lugging a lot of heavy stuff up and down flights of stairs. Their Dad did sweet FA, and on one of the moves, I happened to find out he was in a pub just ten minutes down the road with his mates. This was not his home town. He'd travelled in to see friends and watch Rugby in the pub. Meanwhile, me and DS are unloading a van in the pissing rain and setting up his new flat. I was annoyed at getting no help at the time, but then to find out he was actually in town and drinking in a pub just down the road made my blood boil.

For some reason though, they think he is the bees knees. He's actually a very high earner, but doesn't give them much. He cheated on me (which they know). He has also been arrested for drink driving and had a long driving ban. But he told them that he got breathalised at home, an hour after he'd been driving and that he'd only had alcohol after he got home. They believed this story. 🙄

OP posts:
Lemonyyy · 01/12/2023 13:57

I had this from the other direction when I was early 20s. My mum moaning about how I wasn't phoning her enough, didn't make an effort, blah blah....

Don't moan at them, don't make them feel like shit. it doesn't help and they won't start messaging more out of love or wanting to spend time with you, but out of guilt, which is never a good thing.

I will say it used to piss me off that I was always the one who had to ring. My mum never bloody rang me! maybe try phoning them? You might be pleasantly surprised.

WimbyAce · 01/12/2023 13:57

My brother phones my mum constantly which I find bizarre tbh, like sometimes it's even several times a day! I find that a bit needy as he is a grown man (allegedly). I am not a phoner, I never phone anyone. I do WhatsApp my mum pretty much every day though, just general chat.