Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be filled with panic about WFH culture becoming a thing of the past?

565 replies

themusingsofaninsomniac · 01/12/2023 00:39

prefacing with please read the context before blanket responses 😊

I am stressing away as I tend to do lately on the same topic. I have WFH since the pandemic, with the odd day or so in the office I am lucky to have full flexibility with.

I have Autism. I also have ADHD. The combo together is quite the clusterfuck to navigate as a newly diagnosed female. Essentially the pandemic shone a light on so much and I'm so grateful that it enabled me to seek diagnosis, as much as it's an ongoing struggle.

From working remotely since the beginning I've never felt more stable and successful in my career. I was able to secure a promotion into a field I'd never have had the confidence to try in a non-remote setting in the first place, and I've been fortunate to earn a fair bit more as a result.

I feel completely at ease in my own environment and with the ability to tailor things to what works well for me. Having that commute time back has helped my wellbeing, as has having my lunch breaks in my own home. I am in a routine that I feel helps my mental health and the challenges neurodiversity brings me massively.

My current employer is great but they are the type of company that won't be around forever unfortunately. And from a lot of media and on here etc, it's becoming obvious that things are shifting to either back in the office or a hybrid with a good half your days expected in the office.

This absolutely fills me with dread. I feel like it would turn my world upside down. I'm sure people who don't relate to this will think I'm being dramatic but change and environments outside of your own control are so so hard especially once you've had several years of the opposite.

I guess I'm just wondering where this leaves me. I still have a few friends who WFH but not in my industry. I'm not sure if there would be more flexibility for me, but I also worry about how that will reflect towards my colleagues and I don't want to get anyone's back up. I guess I'm catastrophising that if I need to find another job I'll never be able to maintain what is working so well for me.

Not sure what I'm seeking here to be honest - reassurance maybe or just help to navigate this and whether it's best to be upfront with new employers from the start, or whether that might reduce my chances of being hired. I've been told I don't present as autistic, or typical ADHD but I guess the mix of both means it's a lot more blended. Either way I have generally got good feedback from interviews so it would likely not be known unless I was transparent.

I'd especially like to hear from someone in a similar boat too, if there is anyone? Probably not at twenty to one on a weekday though I imagine 😅

Thanks to anyone who has read this to the end as I know that got wordy!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
TrashedSofa · 06/12/2023 07:32

It seems phenomenally common on MN though!

User43219 · 06/12/2023 07:25

Mukey · 05/12/2023 07:48

As I said before it depends on the type of conversation and whether an interruption would be OK if it was in a different environment. One bark or ignored doorbell ring is unlikely to annoy anyone. It's when its a prolonged issue or the person has to go and deal with the distraction that makes it an issue.
If someone is ringing their bank because they are behind on mortgage payments and they're crying on the phone that they are about to lose their house, if there is one bark in the background in pretty sure no one will notice. If the doorbell rings and nothing is said the conversation can carry on. But if you're in the middle of explaining your hunsbands terminal illness and the person on the other end says oh sorry that's just someone at the door give me a minute and they bugger off it's very unprofessional and rude to the person who might be very distressed. If it wouldn't be OK for a doctor in a surgery half way through a consultation where you're describing your severe depression to say oh excuse me a moment my phone is ringing, then it's not OK for it to happen at home.
If I'm just ringing EE to change my address and there's screaming kids, while it's annoying it's not the end of the world. (I would however wonder if they had heard me and put the correct address down though).
My point is there are some jobs that work fine from home and others that don't. The issue is there are some that don't work well with distractions etc and yet those people are at home.
Bog standard office jobs are fine at home if you're barely on the phone and the only meetings you have are with work. It doesn't affect me so I don't care where you're working. Jobs that work with customers should be much more careful about distractions. And even then as I've said before, if there are no distractions and noise I wouldn't even know the person is at home so it's irrelevant. I don't care. If for whatever reason it is obvious they are at home due to loads of noise and distractions then I don't think they job should be done at home.

I have never come across what you have described, not once have I called up the bank or electricity company and had "sorry got to get the door". Most people who work from home are set up for it and professional. You'd be surprised how many call centre people are now fully working from home. My company now has home workers in their call centre who are fully remote.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 05/12/2023 19:53

enchantedsquirrelwood · 05/12/2023 18:26

I just came across this article. It might be helpful reading for some on this thread who think people with neurodiverse conditions can and should just cope.

Lewis Silkin - Neurodiversity, employment policies and employment claims: what’s the latest?

Thanks for the article, it’s an interesting read. When I used to work as a legal secretary, one of the solicitors we often dealt with (mostly conveyancing) was Lewis Silkin who are not a huge law firm but they are (or were) one of the law firms with a good and respected reputation amongst other solicitors, so it’s good to see their employment law department has taken this up and acted on it by placing the information on neurodiversity on their website. I hope other smaller and larger law firms follow their example.

hydriotaphia · 05/12/2023 12:37

I guess you just need to keep finding roles that allow you to work remotely? I wouldn't worry about hypotheticals until it happens.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 05/12/2023 11:45

Trez1510 · 05/12/2023 01:00

Yes, it matters to me. It mattered to my brother. I'm confident we are not alone in this.

A lot of people have to prepare themselves to have telephone conversations, particularly difficult ones.

Screaming kids in the background, being put on hold (at my expense) and the employee losing the train of the conversation is an entirely unacceptable/unprofessional response from a service provider.

I also have to prepare myself for telephone conversations.

I'd rather hear someone's dog bark at the postman than hear a call centre in the background. The dog can't listen in on my conversation, whereas the call centre supervisor could be stood behind the operator earwigging and there's a small but possible chance that the supervisor is my abusive ex.

And, having worked in that kind of open plan office myself, I'd rather the operator was comfortable in an environment that they can control.

TrashedSofa · 05/12/2023 10:12

Mukey · 05/12/2023 09:49

I don't really mind if customer service people are at home. I mind when they are distracted and doing other things. If you're in the office you'd need to ignore the front door. So ignore it when at home. If you're in the office you can't look after kids. So don't look after them at home.
People on here always say one reason they like working at home is the money they save on commuting. So people want to save that money AND have a pay rise? The problem is if you start increasing the pay for lower paid workers too much then higher paid workers need to rise as well. Do you think may people in stressful professions would do it if they could earn as much doing something else? So their money would rise as well. And everyone would pay more for everything. Meaning their original wage increase is now worth nothing.
For example I pay a lot of money to my indemnity insurance. If I have a problem I call them for help. Maybe they work at home. Maybe they don't. I don't know. But regardless say they demand a pay rise in order for them to actually help me without distractions. They get it. In order to pay that the company increases my indemnity. In order to pay for that the dentistry prices need to go up. So people are now paying more for my service so I can pay more for their service. And so on.
I'm not denying some jobs deserve more money and everyone should have a decent living wage. But you can't expect all professions to paid extremely well. Life can't work like that.

The post of mine you initially quoted was in reply to someone who thinks those jobs shouldn't be done at home.

With regards to the rest, I don't expect customer service staff to be paid the same as a dentist, for example, but the fact remains that what they're being paid at the moment clearly isn't enough for the sector to have sufficient staff to provide the service people want. The proof is in the pudding.

Again, it's supply and demand. We're in a society that doesn't have enough workers, which not only has direct impact in recruitment for lower paid and less attractive roles, but also means some of the provisions people need in order to work aren't necessarily there either. The childcare sector has shrunk, for example, and we have a national shortage of bus drivers. These things are not affected by anyone's subjective belief about the customer service standards they're entitled to.

What this means in practice is that people who are in or would potentially take a customer service role don't have to pay any attention to arguments about why they shouldn't be paid more to work in person. There isn't any way round that whilst labour market conditions remain as they are.

Startingagainandagain · 05/12/2023 10:11

@NonPlayerCharacter
'I have to say I really hate background noise and obvious distractions like that on customer calls and it completely puts me off a business or service. I don't care if they're doing it from home but they need to do it professionally.'

Last week we had a Zoom brainstorming meeting. One person was in the open plan office and everyone else was WFH.

The person who was in the office has to repeatedly mute themselves because we could hear conversations/phone calls in the office so he could not really participate in the meeting as he wanted. This is a small office and there was no free meeting rooms where he could have gone to have a quiet space. The office internet connection is also abysmal.

My point is that noise and distractions can also be an issue in offices, especially when people don't have access to decent premises. The last time I was in the office my work was disturbed all afternoon by two people gossiping loudly....

user1497207191 · 05/12/2023 10:02

@Badgerandfox227

I won’t go back to working for an employer who has rigid office days, these employers will lose access to the best talent.

Isn't it ironic that nearly all the big employers moved to London in the first place "to access the best talent" apparently, but now people no longer want to work there! It looks like we're going through a full 360 to where people could actually work in the home towns etc rather than be sucked into the SE to get the good jobs!

Mukey · 05/12/2023 09:49

TrashedSofa · 05/12/2023 09:25

That's nice. What does it have to do with the terms and conditions employers need to offer customer service staff in order to get them all to work in person?

I don't really mind if customer service people are at home. I mind when they are distracted and doing other things. If you're in the office you'd need to ignore the front door. So ignore it when at home. If you're in the office you can't look after kids. So don't look after them at home.
People on here always say one reason they like working at home is the money they save on commuting. So people want to save that money AND have a pay rise? The problem is if you start increasing the pay for lower paid workers too much then higher paid workers need to rise as well. Do you think may people in stressful professions would do it if they could earn as much doing something else? So their money would rise as well. And everyone would pay more for everything. Meaning their original wage increase is now worth nothing.
For example I pay a lot of money to my indemnity insurance. If I have a problem I call them for help. Maybe they work at home. Maybe they don't. I don't know. But regardless say they demand a pay rise in order for them to actually help me without distractions. They get it. In order to pay that the company increases my indemnity. In order to pay for that the dentistry prices need to go up. So people are now paying more for my service so I can pay more for their service. And so on.
I'm not denying some jobs deserve more money and everyone should have a decent living wage. But you can't expect all professions to paid extremely well. Life can't work like that.

TrashedSofa · 05/12/2023 09:25

Mukey · 05/12/2023 08:29

I work in dentistry. My prices are £60 for a scale and polish. I'm not going to say well if you want me to turn my phone off while treating you it's £80.

That's nice. What does it have to do with the terms and conditions employers need to offer customer service staff in order to get them all to work in person?

TrashedSofa · 05/12/2023 09:19

Mukey · 05/12/2023 08:27

Why though? Should a doctor get paid more to actually do his job?
Say a bank manager got paid £100 a day to do their job.
Doctor got £200 a day as more skilled.
Why now do we need to pay the bank manager £150 a day for them to actually focus on you which is their job?
Should we then pay the doctor £250 a day so they are not distracted as well?
You can't say you need to pay people more purely so they actually listen to you. They both took the job knowing what it involved.

Because of supply and demand. We don't have enough workers as a society, and the low salaries usually paid for customer service roles don't buy sufficient staff who are willing and able to work in person any more.

Doctors aren't good comparators for customer service, because they're a regulated profession and as such have to answer to a regulatory body in a way that someone who works in a call centre doesn't. So they do have an extra layer of obligation, even potential criminal sanctions if they fuck it up badly enough, whereas that's not true of someone on 21k in a remote call centre type role.

The fact is that we have a tight labour market and workers as a whole have more choices than they used to. That evidently means you can't have the service you want at the rate you want to pay, and the proof of that is in the pudding. What you've written here is basically you just saying you don't like that. Your 'should' in shit situation doesn't actually matter, it isn't going to get the whole customer service sector back into the office for the crap wages they're mostly on.

Mukey · 05/12/2023 08:29

TrashedSofa · 05/12/2023 07:58

Jobs that work with customers should be much more careful about distractions. And even then as I've said before, if there are no distractions and noise I wouldn't even know the person is at home so it's irrelevant. I don't care. If for whatever reason it is obvious they are at home due to loads of noise and distractions then I don't think they job should be done at home.

Which raises the question of whether you're willing to pay more in order to get what you want.

I work in dentistry. My prices are £60 for a scale and polish. I'm not going to say well if you want me to turn my phone off while treating you it's £80.

Mukey · 05/12/2023 08:27

TrashedSofa · 05/12/2023 07:58

Jobs that work with customers should be much more careful about distractions. And even then as I've said before, if there are no distractions and noise I wouldn't even know the person is at home so it's irrelevant. I don't care. If for whatever reason it is obvious they are at home due to loads of noise and distractions then I don't think they job should be done at home.

Which raises the question of whether you're willing to pay more in order to get what you want.

Why though? Should a doctor get paid more to actually do his job?
Say a bank manager got paid £100 a day to do their job.
Doctor got £200 a day as more skilled.
Why now do we need to pay the bank manager £150 a day for them to actually focus on you which is their job?
Should we then pay the doctor £250 a day so they are not distracted as well?
You can't say you need to pay people more purely so they actually listen to you. They both took the job knowing what it involved.

Badgerandfox227 · 05/12/2023 07:58

My employer is a ‘remote first’ employer, we’ve massively reduced office space, so there’s only desks for 10% of the workforce. For me, it’s meant I can have a ‘London job’ whilst living 200 miles away. Which as a mum with 2 young kids I could never have hoped for before.

I can do the school run, make time for nativities and ad hoc school events. On the flip side, I can work earlier/later/skip lunch and my employer is fully on board with that approach. I get my work done and my performance is great.

I won’t go back to working for an employer who has rigid office days, these employers will lose access to the best talent.

TrashedSofa · 05/12/2023 07:58

Jobs that work with customers should be much more careful about distractions. And even then as I've said before, if there are no distractions and noise I wouldn't even know the person is at home so it's irrelevant. I don't care. If for whatever reason it is obvious they are at home due to loads of noise and distractions then I don't think they job should be done at home.

Which raises the question of whether you're willing to pay more in order to get what you want.

Mukey · 05/12/2023 07:51

MythosK · 05/12/2023 06:06

My office is next door to a fire station. The sirens are frequent and deafening. It distracts me but don't think my clients care too much considering that without our service, they'd be in real difficulties.

Unavoidable noise vs avoidable noise are totally different and most people obviously understand that.

Mukey · 05/12/2023 07:48

SurelySmartie · 05/12/2023 00:35

Oh get a bit of humanity will you. Does it really matter if there is the odd bark or very occasional doorbell when someone is on the phone or meeting? Most of us are human enough to understand occasionally these things happen and the benefits of wfh or hybrid for people’s quality of life and mental health are worth it. We tolerate it because overall it leads to a better society.

As I said before it depends on the type of conversation and whether an interruption would be OK if it was in a different environment. One bark or ignored doorbell ring is unlikely to annoy anyone. It's when its a prolonged issue or the person has to go and deal with the distraction that makes it an issue.
If someone is ringing their bank because they are behind on mortgage payments and they're crying on the phone that they are about to lose their house, if there is one bark in the background in pretty sure no one will notice. If the doorbell rings and nothing is said the conversation can carry on. But if you're in the middle of explaining your hunsbands terminal illness and the person on the other end says oh sorry that's just someone at the door give me a minute and they bugger off it's very unprofessional and rude to the person who might be very distressed. If it wouldn't be OK for a doctor in a surgery half way through a consultation where you're describing your severe depression to say oh excuse me a moment my phone is ringing, then it's not OK for it to happen at home.
If I'm just ringing EE to change my address and there's screaming kids, while it's annoying it's not the end of the world. (I would however wonder if they had heard me and put the correct address down though).
My point is there are some jobs that work fine from home and others that don't. The issue is there are some that don't work well with distractions etc and yet those people are at home.
Bog standard office jobs are fine at home if you're barely on the phone and the only meetings you have are with work. It doesn't affect me so I don't care where you're working. Jobs that work with customers should be much more careful about distractions. And even then as I've said before, if there are no distractions and noise I wouldn't even know the person is at home so it's irrelevant. I don't care. If for whatever reason it is obvious they are at home due to loads of noise and distractions then I don't think they job should be done at home.

MythosK · 05/12/2023 06:06

NonPlayerCharacter · 05/12/2023 05:42

I have to say I really hate background noise and obvious distractions like that on customer calls and it completely puts me off a business or service. I don't care if they're doing it from home but they need to do it professionally.

My office is next door to a fire station. The sirens are frequent and deafening. It distracts me but don't think my clients care too much considering that without our service, they'd be in real difficulties.

NonPlayerCharacter · 05/12/2023 05:42

I have to say I really hate background noise and obvious distractions like that on customer calls and it completely puts me off a business or service. I don't care if they're doing it from home but they need to do it professionally.

Trez1510 · 05/12/2023 01:00

SurelySmartie · 05/12/2023 00:35

Oh get a bit of humanity will you. Does it really matter if there is the odd bark or very occasional doorbell when someone is on the phone or meeting? Most of us are human enough to understand occasionally these things happen and the benefits of wfh or hybrid for people’s quality of life and mental health are worth it. We tolerate it because overall it leads to a better society.

Yes, it matters to me. It mattered to my brother. I'm confident we are not alone in this.

A lot of people have to prepare themselves to have telephone conversations, particularly difficult ones.

Screaming kids in the background, being put on hold (at my expense) and the employee losing the train of the conversation is an entirely unacceptable/unprofessional response from a service provider.

SurelySmartie · 05/12/2023 00:35

Trez1510 · 01/12/2023 09:31

No, I meant employees should not have carte blanche to insist upon 100%WFH roles unless they were required for health-related reasons.

Like other posters, I've had some pretty poor experiences of attempting to undertake business with people working from home - barking dogs, doorbells and, on more than one occasion, screaming/tantruming/squabbling children.

So, no, as a customer I'm not impressed with having to deal with others' domestic crises when I'm attempting to request/resolve issues of importance to me the customer.

I suspect, I'll vote with my feet/purse. This will happen when competitors revert to office-based operations. I haven't yet done so but I'm absolutely willing/keen to do so.

Whilst, 'employees have choices', equally or more importantly, so do customers.

Oh get a bit of humanity will you. Does it really matter if there is the odd bark or very occasional doorbell when someone is on the phone or meeting? Most of us are human enough to understand occasionally these things happen and the benefits of wfh or hybrid for people’s quality of life and mental health are worth it. We tolerate it because overall it leads to a better society.

UnfriendMe · 04/12/2023 23:23

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 04/12/2023 00:52

Only under capitalism would the workplace be considered a social space. There is something deeply wrong when people advocate going to work for its alleged social benefits. Why aren't people socialising in hobby groups? Rotary Club? The local pub? Pubs are closing left right and centre, support your local or lose it.

When you use the workplace as your social space, you let your employer choose your friends. I prefer to socialise with people of my choosing, outside of the workplace. Interacting with people uses huge amounts of my energy because I am autistic. Why would I waste that energy on people I only tolerate because I am paid to work in the same office as them, if I could instead be paid to work alone?

Edited

Completely agree with you. I don't have any issues perse that prevent me from going to the office but the hell if I want to go back. I totally agree that the office shouldn't be your social space, it's where you have to go to pay your bills, they are your colleagues not your friends, and in most circumstances you wouldn't voluntarily spend time with them given the option. At the same time I also completely disagree with the idea that we all need social interaction and are social creatures. Some of us don't want to be around other people and are far more content without that face to face interaction. On top of that, when I was commuting I was waking up at 5, getting home at 8, eating shit food and feeling like crap 5 days a week. Now that I'm fully remote I get 9+ hours of sleep, I wake up at 8, I shut my laptop at 5, I workout during my lunch break and I eat healthy, home cooked meals every day. Now please tell me why it was so much better for me when I was going to the office? I will never step foot in another office again and I couldn't be happier about that.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 04/12/2023 20:26

Duchydutch · 04/12/2023 16:13

Completely agree. Humans are social animals without which, mental health deteriorates, which is precisely what is happening now.
I can’t understand how people don’t connect the dots.

I would say that over Covid 19 when my friends and relatives all worked fully from home, though we socialised together (partly due to covid restrictions when we could, when it was safe to do so), we did actually recognise and say to each other that fully WFH was making us into hermits and comfortable with our own lives and less wanting to socialise externally. A couple of us were actually pleased to get back to the normality of hybrid working and we found that after the initial apprehension around returning to the office on a hybrid model, we actually enjoyed the social interaction of being in an office and even dare I say it, commuting, but also being allowed to WFH. I do think some people if they choose not to socialise then it can possibly have some sort of impact on their mental health.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 04/12/2023 20:19

Startingagainandagain · 04/12/2023 18:09

@Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain

''Actually you’re right about people coping before and now who don’t have ADHD/autism or do have it. What did they do before the hybrid/wfh model came out? ''

The answer to that is we did not 'cope'. I am autistic and also have another health condition that causes chronic pain and for which I had about 5 different surgeries in the past 10 years.

Before WFH I had to work part-time only because I could not do a full week in an office.

I had 3 breakdowns in my life because of my mental health issues/autism and the last one led me to try to take my life.

Before WFH I hardly had any social life because a day at work in the office meant I would need to spend the following day recovering at home. I barely went out or did any kind of activity because my body and mind were so exhausted.

I also ended up losing one job because I was struggling with my health and the employer choose to bully me for it and question my competence rather than support me.

I have seen colleagues with disabilities/mental health issues being pushed out of jobs because the organisation could not be bothered to put some reasonable adjustments.

That's what having autism and other conditions/disability can mean for people who try to stay in the workplace: losing jobs, not being able to get jobs in the first place or seeing your health take a turn for the worse when there is no flexibility offered.

WHF allows me to better manage my conditions and to hold on to a job. It is not just a nice to have for people like me. It is a lifeline.

You seem to think autism and other conditions/disabilities are some kind of lifestyle choice or that they don't add limitations to what an individual can do. It is not the case.

I do not think that autism and other conditions/disabilities are some kind of lifestyle choice or that they don’t add limitations to what an individual can do.

You have no idea of my background and that I’ve also suffered with mental health issues, but I’ve had to go to work rather than claim benefits. My DM was medically retired due to a health condition and having to have a knee replacement due to this condition. All I am saying is people who are ND before more awareness came about in companies of ND, they did “cope” as you’ve stated in your examples above or you didn’t cope. My own DB has chronic asthma and I also have asthma and an underactive thyroid that before it was medicated affected me badly, the asthma at least counts as a disability.

I am pleased that people with autism, disabilities are helped to stay in the workforce, gain jobs, make reasonable adjustments etc but as I’ve said before companies have said generally recently about wanting workers back in the office more or on a hybrid model and not fully wfh. In fact, even though this post has raised lots of comments and opinions I think it’s actually made NT more aware of the difficulties ND face and vice versa. Surely a healthy debate means that companies that don’t currently accommodate reasonable adjustments or don’t think about ND employees and even clients, if they see discussion like this or if someone here chooses to raise this with their own HR department then they will think about implementing these measures and look into neurodiversity and reasonable adjustments.

What doesn’t help everyone involved in this discussion is when you and other posters personally attack and take personally any criticism if a NT person expresses interest/concern eg here of a ND person. Of course I wouldn’t voice my concerns where I work or even generally but as this is a discussion forum and this post has been started by a ND person then others have the right to comment. I do sincerely apologise if I’ve offended some posters here with my language and posts, this was not my intention and I certainly didn’t intend to do this.