Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be filled with panic about WFH culture becoming a thing of the past?

565 replies

themusingsofaninsomniac · 01/12/2023 00:39

prefacing with please read the context before blanket responses 😊

I am stressing away as I tend to do lately on the same topic. I have WFH since the pandemic, with the odd day or so in the office I am lucky to have full flexibility with.

I have Autism. I also have ADHD. The combo together is quite the clusterfuck to navigate as a newly diagnosed female. Essentially the pandemic shone a light on so much and I'm so grateful that it enabled me to seek diagnosis, as much as it's an ongoing struggle.

From working remotely since the beginning I've never felt more stable and successful in my career. I was able to secure a promotion into a field I'd never have had the confidence to try in a non-remote setting in the first place, and I've been fortunate to earn a fair bit more as a result.

I feel completely at ease in my own environment and with the ability to tailor things to what works well for me. Having that commute time back has helped my wellbeing, as has having my lunch breaks in my own home. I am in a routine that I feel helps my mental health and the challenges neurodiversity brings me massively.

My current employer is great but they are the type of company that won't be around forever unfortunately. And from a lot of media and on here etc, it's becoming obvious that things are shifting to either back in the office or a hybrid with a good half your days expected in the office.

This absolutely fills me with dread. I feel like it would turn my world upside down. I'm sure people who don't relate to this will think I'm being dramatic but change and environments outside of your own control are so so hard especially once you've had several years of the opposite.

I guess I'm just wondering where this leaves me. I still have a few friends who WFH but not in my industry. I'm not sure if there would be more flexibility for me, but I also worry about how that will reflect towards my colleagues and I don't want to get anyone's back up. I guess I'm catastrophising that if I need to find another job I'll never be able to maintain what is working so well for me.

Not sure what I'm seeking here to be honest - reassurance maybe or just help to navigate this and whether it's best to be upfront with new employers from the start, or whether that might reduce my chances of being hired. I've been told I don't present as autistic, or typical ADHD but I guess the mix of both means it's a lot more blended. Either way I have generally got good feedback from interviews so it would likely not be known unless I was transparent.

I'd especially like to hear from someone in a similar boat too, if there is anyone? Probably not at twenty to one on a weekday though I imagine 😅

Thanks to anyone who has read this to the end as I know that got wordy!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
AdamRyan · 01/12/2023 08:11

HoppingPavlova · 01/12/2023 03:21

no allowance for holiday or sick leave - no 3 days that week goes down as non-compliance, 2+ non/compliant weeks of the last 8 equals disciplinary

So, if you are on approved leave for 2 weeks, you will get a disciplinary? If you are signed off work sick for 2 weeks, you will get a disciplinary? Surely, you can see this is not correct. That means no one would ever be allowed to take more than 2 days leave (be it approved annual leave or signed sick leave) at a time, which is obviously not legal. No employer can do this.

They can, mine is doing this. Might even be the same one.

Wheelz46 · 01/12/2023 08:10

Reading some of these posts about people who WFH sound like they have pretty poor management.

The industry I work in, there is no way you can just abscond to sort out your washing or go settle a debate between the kids. More flexible yes, so they may allow school pick up and drop off but the time is made up the same day. If your productivity is low, it's very simple you go on a PIP.

In terms of promotions, penalising the ones who choose to WFH surely that is discriminatory. Our job description is described as hybrid but they let the staff choose where to work, although training is to be in the office. A few choose to work full time in the office, others choose to fully WFH whereas others prefer more of a hybrid role. Those who WFH are not penalised in anyway shape or form when it comes to promotions. If a company chooses the right applications to communicate with each other there is no reason why a homeworker is hidden away and seem less involved.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 01/12/2023 08:10

I’ve only read the first and fourth pages, apologies - will go back. I’m most of the way through a combined autism and ADHD diagnosis. It’s a complete headfuck and I agree OP that creating or arranging a work environment to suit someone with this kind of profile is incredibly difficult - I can’t speak for you or anyone else but I thrive on chaos one day and need monastic silence the next.

I burnt out of corporate life. I now run a small organisation (a charity), doing very well. No small irony, a lot of our volunteers seem to have ND traits - so I’ve apparently set up something that works for a particular kind of person.

I posted the other day, unsuccessfully, about how sad I feel about being locked out of so many workplaces - being smart and high achieving but becoming a diminished version of myself if the environment isn’t right. So I don’t have any advice for now, but I empathise.

Halfemptyhalfling · 01/12/2023 08:10

With the housing market meaning that people are priced out of cities and tourist areas plus childcare costs mean families need to live near grandparents l don't think it would be easy for firms to go back to full time in the office.

Teateaandmoretea · 01/12/2023 08:08

Sparehair · 01/12/2023 06:10

One problem is that 100% remote roles will probably get offshored over the next 5 years or so because if someone can do it remotely in the Uk then they can probably do it remotely from Gurgaon. So while it will probably look as though there are fewer remote roles, it won’t be because those roles are going back to uk based office roles.

Off shoring, that old chestnut. The UK isn’t even a particularly high wage economy.

The idea you can outsource everything to the third world is utterly laughable, you’ve clearly never worked anywhere where off shoring has been attempted. It’s an absolute nightmare even for simple roles.

TrashedSofa · 01/12/2023 08:08

bellac11 · 01/12/2023 08:04

The biggest labour shortage we have is for jobs that are very much not work from home, teaching, nursing, care workers, hospitality etc etc

This is true, but it doesn't tell us anything about recruitment in roles that can be done remotely.

Our labour shortage is very much not confined to just face to face jobs, and we've already had examples in this short thread of organisations not being able to enforce office working in roles that can be done remotely. They come up in every thread on the issue, too. I was in one the other week where someone who was in call centre management explained that they haven't been able to pay as much as they'd need to get sufficient staff to do the job in person. Their recruitment issues probably aren't as bad as, say, the care sector, but that doesn't mean they don't exist.

CesareBorgia · 01/12/2023 08:07

but unless you listen to all their calls, you can’t gauge how useful they’ve been.

Call centres in my experience randomly sample and assess calls for just that reason; they'll also check for any patterns such as calls being unusually long or short compared to peers, which might suggest someone is struggling and needs training.

NectarinesAreNotTheOnlyFruit · 01/12/2023 08:06

I have done a mixture of office and working from home for nearly 15 years now. I don’t think you should panic - there will be wfh jobs for a long time yet, but maybe you need to consider making sure you move towards an industry where wfh is more common. I don’t know what your skills are.

I can understand why some companies are keen to get their workforce back in. There is value in having teams together. From my own experience, I learned so much from being around people in other departments - seeing what they do, listening to them, meeting people in other departments and knowing who to ask for more help, and building up the social relationships that are necessary to deliver my work. I could not have learned my job in isolation. Companies have to look at the big picture - not just “can Wendy, Fatima, Alejandro and Sean do their jobs better at home?” but also “can Fred learn his job without working alongside them?” and “will Imogen be able to do her job as efficiently if she isn’t spending her day saturated by the knowledge of the experts in her field?”

jhy · 01/12/2023 08:06

I came to the end of a contract. My previous employer had reduced office space during pandemic so most WFH/hybrid. I only ever went to the office 3 times in 2 years.
However now I'm looking at new jobs, every job I've come across appear to be office based and specify WFH is not an option.

TrashedSofa · 01/12/2023 08:05

From what I can see, most companies don’t care if their offices in India are chaotic and don’t know what they’re doing. DP works for a huge successful retail company who have outsourced a lot of work to India. It saves the company a fortune, and the managers don’t see any of the down sides. It’s the frontline staff who bear the brunt of ineffective working from the India offices, having to pick up the slack and take over when things go wrong. The employees in India aren’t stupid, but their training consists of a couple of weeks in the UK when they start, and that’s it. And often there’s a significant language barrier.

Well, onshoring is also a thing. But sure, there are companies who are already doing it and who got in a while ago. Sometimes it works much better than you describe here, sometimes it works exactly as you describe here! My point was more about the idea that there are companies who could do it now but for whatever reason aren't, yet are going to in the near future. By definition those are going to be companies who have a reason not to, and risks like those you describe may well be part of it.

bellac11 · 01/12/2023 08:04

TrashedSofa · 01/12/2023 06:53

This comes up a lot on here. I don't get why people think roles that haven't already been offshored are all going to go in a few years time. It's been almost 4 years since the mass move to remote work, and will have been longer in some jobs. And we have a labour shortage in the UK already, making recruitment harder and sometimes impossible. What is it about the situation now that's making offshorable roles remain here now that's going to change in like 2027?

The biggest labour shortage we have is for jobs that are very much not work from home, teaching, nursing, care workers, hospitality etc etc

MumblesParty · 01/12/2023 08:04

NigelHarmansNewWife · 01/12/2023 07:58

But this can only happen with poor management and it's only a problem if the work isn't getting done. Potentially the job isn't full time if someone is "missing for hours" but the work gets done. If the work isn't getting done and the person isn't putting in their contractual hours then who is managing this person?

Well firstly, not all work can be quantified I don’t suppose. Helplines for example - yes you can monitor how many calls someone might have taken, but unless you listen to all their calls, you can’t gauge how useful they’ve been. One of the common features of customer services since covid is helpdesk staff not actually helping. They often say they can’t help, won’t help, can’t do anything else, can’t “ask their manager” etc - so having waited on hold for 30 minutes the caller gets nowhere.

And also, how can you manage people when they’re miles away. You might suspect that they’re watching a film or having a nap, but you can’t prove it if they’re logged on.

Deliaskis · 01/12/2023 08:02

Sparehair · 01/12/2023 06:10

One problem is that 100% remote roles will probably get offshored over the next 5 years or so because if someone can do it remotely in the Uk then they can probably do it remotely from Gurgaon. So while it will probably look as though there are fewer remote roles, it won’t be because those roles are going back to uk based office roles.

Well some will, many won't. Roles that require any kind of specific experience or specialist expertise will continue to be done by the best people a company can find to do them. The company I work for has been forced to adopt some off-shoring of work because we can't find enough people to do the work... But much of the work we do really needs people with the specialist expertise to do it, which we can't find anywhere else in the world. We also have client relationships and they want a team in their timezone who can get to a meeting in Europe or the US relatively quickly. I really don't agree that off-shoring is a threat to all 100% remote roles, probably only to the process driven type roles, e.g. data input, call centres, claims processing etc.

We're also not forcing people back to offices.... Work is a thing you do not a place you go, and where we have good people doing great work, we don't care where our even when they do it a lot of the time.

I suppose the broader point is it's very industry specific and sometimes company specific. But we would probably go out of business if we forced office returns because half our workforce would go and work for the competitors.

LittleMy77 · 01/12/2023 08:01

TrashedSofa · 01/12/2023 07:11

Yeah, people have this idea that there's an inexhaustible supply of highly qualified, dirt cheap, perfectly English speaking talent in India. It's nearly always India they default to. But the reality is quite different, especially for jobs with niche skills. And people who are very employable, even in India, increasingly want to be paid properly.

Yep; we have a huge workforce in India. For the latest roles I hired for there, the pay differential isn’t significantly behind the UK atm, prob only approx 30-35% lower, once you factor in local allowances etc. The job market in the 5 cities we have offices in is booming, enabling people to negotiate much higher salaries than 3-5 years ago.

Ginmonkeyagain · 01/12/2023 07:59

Do something productive with that panic energy.

Speak to your employer about a WFH contract as a reasonable adjustment for disability.

My workplace is default minimum of 3 days in the office. If you want anything different from that you need to agree a separate WFH contract, just as would have been the case before covid.

That is better for you as well as it means your working arrangements would be contractural rather than just based on the goodwill of your employer.

NigelHarmansNewWife · 01/12/2023 07:58

Hibambinos · 01/12/2023 03:42

Wfh is great, but sadly people take the piss with it and go missing for hours. That is what is killing off wfh sadly, and bosses are asking people to return to the office.

But this can only happen with poor management and it's only a problem if the work isn't getting done. Potentially the job isn't full time if someone is "missing for hours" but the work gets done. If the work isn't getting done and the person isn't putting in their contractual hours then who is managing this person?

MumblesParty · 01/12/2023 07:58

TrashedSofa · 01/12/2023 07:11

Yeah, people have this idea that there's an inexhaustible supply of highly qualified, dirt cheap, perfectly English speaking talent in India. It's nearly always India they default to. But the reality is quite different, especially for jobs with niche skills. And people who are very employable, even in India, increasingly want to be paid properly.

From what I can see, most companies don’t care if their offices in India are chaotic and don’t know what they’re doing. DP works for a huge successful retail company who have outsourced a lot of work to India. It saves the company a fortune, and the managers don’t see any of the down sides. It’s the frontline staff who bear the brunt of ineffective working from the India offices, having to pick up the slack and take over when things go wrong. The employees in India aren’t stupid, but their training consists of a couple of weeks in the UK when they start, and that’s it. And often there’s a significant language barrier.

My view on WFH is as others have said - it’s fine for experienced people who don’t take the piss, but for new starters or professional slackers, it’s a disaster.

LakieLady · 01/12/2023 07:56

Hibambinos · 01/12/2023 03:42

Wfh is great, but sadly people take the piss with it and go missing for hours. That is what is killing off wfh sadly, and bosses are asking people to return to the office.

Loads of people managed to go missing for hours pre-WFH imo. I've worked in plenty of places where some people managed to use work as an extension to their social life, wandering round the building chatting to all and sundry for hours on end.

This was especially true when I worked somewhere that had 2 buildings, approx a 10 minute walk apart. One colleague would return from a long trip to the other building having had a haircut and changed his library books.

Scottishskifun · 01/12/2023 07:53

Its worth getting reasonable adjustments agreed and in place with your employer but also any future employer, autism is classed as a disability and therefore workplaces need to have reasonable adjustments. Obviously this doesn't work for certain industries/jobs and wfh such as a vet or nurse.
Maybe even having it agreed with your work now will put you more at ease and it's then a document you can take with you?

I have one in place due to long covid and fatigue. Being in the office actually makes me far worse I do like going in so try for a few hours a week. From experience I would say how easy or hard it is depends on the line manager. My old one I had to go over their heads to HR and senior bosses as they saw it as not being fair and I should be doing or working towards the 3 days a week like others.....which ironically was then leading to me doing less work as I was ill after attendance.

Join a union as well mine were amazing support when needed.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 01/12/2023 07:48

Hibambinos · 01/12/2023 03:42

Wfh is great, but sadly people take the piss with it and go missing for hours. That is what is killing off wfh sadly, and bosses are asking people to return to the office.

I agree with this. The amount of people I know who’ve told me when they WFH they take the piss a bit, don’t make up hours and expect bosses not to notice. The good ones don’t do this. You see it with school pick-up and drop off but it’s not limited to parents. Don’t get me wrong I’ve been guilty sometimes of taking extra time off and then not making it up but generally I do, either shorter lunch freaks, log on later etc.

OP, you coped before with a work office based model so you may have to compromise with hybrid if you can’t get a fully WFH job. I’m similar to you re preferring WFH/hybrid models though I’m NT.

If you don’t already follow Flexa on LinkedIn, they are a company who promote and champion WFH/htbrid.

S23 · 01/12/2023 07:48

To give a slightly different perspective to your situation.

My DH, who we both strongly suspect is ASD, was hybrid for a year before lockdown (3 days WFH, one in the office) then has been fully WFH since March 2023 in our very rural property.

Prior to us meeting he had been travelling working as a diving instructor, and living in a house share in London and working office based.

My understanding of ASD is that a lot of effort is required to learn social skills that are instinctive in NT people. As with any learnt skill though, practice makes perfect, and skills need to be used to be maintained.

I feel my DH is loosing these social skills now he has been WFH for so long, and it is impacting on our marriage and other aspects of DH life as he is becoming increasingly socially isolated.

OP, you say people say you don't present as autistic, which suggests that you have refined your learnt social skills. If you WFH for ever more then you may undo this hard work, and then what happens in work and life?

I think their needs to be balance, and hybrid seems to be a reasonable compromise for employers and employees in this situation.
However, I do appreciate that hybrid working may not be the solution for a NT employee who is physically disabled in a way that makes travel or being away from the home challenging).

Jamandmarmaladeandjelly · 01/12/2023 07:47

Husband works in tech and can't recruit if he doesn't offer work from home! People expect it as part of their package.

MarieG10 · 01/12/2023 07:46

3luckystars · 01/12/2023 07:37

This is a ‘reasonable accommodation’ and you could get a medical note to cover you, it wouldn’t have to go into detail.

Don’t worry about anyone else, I’m sure you would not care if you heard ‘your colleague Anna was working from home on medical grounds’ you would not even question it.

Dong meet trouble have way. Be prepared but stop worrying. It’s like sitting on a rocking chair, it’s keeping you busy but getting you nowhere.

I wish you all the best and well done btw!!!

Oh for heavens sake. Do not believe this rubbish. It is not a reasonable accommodation. It could be but that very much depends on the employers model, what others are needing to do and some account of the employees needs. As ever the rubbish trumped here is that reasonable adjustments always trump....the word reasonable often being forgotten. The reality is no ET is likely to sanction full or mostly WFH if it clashes with the business requirement.

My team have done hybrid for a while but we all fully accept the benefits of being together in the office and particularly learning from each other which isn't great on MS Teams. The challenge is that the employer wants now no more than one day a week at home but the accommodation ratio for my team is just over 1 desk for 2 employees so just doesn't work!! Currently I'm in the public sector (more recent) so I look on with amusement at reports of rows of desks in the civil service left empty...perhaps they could share elsewhere.

The reality is many sectors will never remove it, especially tec as this is the model younger workers want and they move to get it. My friends son has just moved last year onto a contract which gives him 4 weeks a years working from anywhere in the world so he spends time with relatives in Spain working during the day and enjoying evenings

NeedToChangeName · 01/12/2023 07:42

The genie's out of the bottle. I can't see WFH disappearing entirely, especially for senior staff who don't require supervision

Teateaandmoretea · 01/12/2023 07:38

It's not going to become a thing of the past. Companies like that they have more choice of candidates, that people will accept lower salaries and that they don't have to pay for as much office space.

All of the negative stuff is largely from people who are not allowed to wfh and those with city centre property portfolios. In terms of absenteeism and people 'taking the piss' they surely have to actually deliver the work and if not then they will end up under competency? People have always taken the piss (Monday sick days etc) and someone sat in an office doesn't mean they are working.

The only true negative for me is in terms of team training and that I don't think it's great for young people.