Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be filled with panic about WFH culture becoming a thing of the past?

565 replies

themusingsofaninsomniac · 01/12/2023 00:39

prefacing with please read the context before blanket responses 😊

I am stressing away as I tend to do lately on the same topic. I have WFH since the pandemic, with the odd day or so in the office I am lucky to have full flexibility with.

I have Autism. I also have ADHD. The combo together is quite the clusterfuck to navigate as a newly diagnosed female. Essentially the pandemic shone a light on so much and I'm so grateful that it enabled me to seek diagnosis, as much as it's an ongoing struggle.

From working remotely since the beginning I've never felt more stable and successful in my career. I was able to secure a promotion into a field I'd never have had the confidence to try in a non-remote setting in the first place, and I've been fortunate to earn a fair bit more as a result.

I feel completely at ease in my own environment and with the ability to tailor things to what works well for me. Having that commute time back has helped my wellbeing, as has having my lunch breaks in my own home. I am in a routine that I feel helps my mental health and the challenges neurodiversity brings me massively.

My current employer is great but they are the type of company that won't be around forever unfortunately. And from a lot of media and on here etc, it's becoming obvious that things are shifting to either back in the office or a hybrid with a good half your days expected in the office.

This absolutely fills me with dread. I feel like it would turn my world upside down. I'm sure people who don't relate to this will think I'm being dramatic but change and environments outside of your own control are so so hard especially once you've had several years of the opposite.

I guess I'm just wondering where this leaves me. I still have a few friends who WFH but not in my industry. I'm not sure if there would be more flexibility for me, but I also worry about how that will reflect towards my colleagues and I don't want to get anyone's back up. I guess I'm catastrophising that if I need to find another job I'll never be able to maintain what is working so well for me.

Not sure what I'm seeking here to be honest - reassurance maybe or just help to navigate this and whether it's best to be upfront with new employers from the start, or whether that might reduce my chances of being hired. I've been told I don't present as autistic, or typical ADHD but I guess the mix of both means it's a lot more blended. Either way I have generally got good feedback from interviews so it would likely not be known unless I was transparent.

I'd especially like to hear from someone in a similar boat too, if there is anyone? Probably not at twenty to one on a weekday though I imagine 😅

Thanks to anyone who has read this to the end as I know that got wordy!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
TrashedSofa · 01/12/2023 08:39

bellac11 · 01/12/2023 08:37

They dont need to recruit only within commuting distance, that varies from employee to employee, its up to the worker to decide if they're able to get to and from work in a way they are comfortable with

As with another poster pointing this out, there seems to be this view that employers now need to offer WFH or continue with it so that people dont have long commutes or can do the washing or the school pick up. Thats not their duty.

Of course they have to recruit within commuting distance, if you want people people. You can't get someone in Lancashire for an office job in London, whereas you can if it's remote. The pool shrinks. And it's not about employer duty, it's what they need to do to get staff in the labour market conditions they have to navigate. Employees have choices.

MsRosley · 01/12/2023 08:39

LaviniasBigBloomers · 01/12/2023 00:51

I think the pendulum will swing back to office based, then people will go 'wtf, we've just lost half our best talent and we need to spend a bazillion ££ on new offices to accommodate everyone' and then it will swing back to a sensible level. That's in general terms, of course.

In personal terms, two things are happening:

You are having intrusive thoughts about a return to the office full time which is causing you enormous amounts of stress. First step is to recognise that and find ways to manage those thoughts. Google will have a better explanation than me at this time of night after a couple of wines, but you do need to recognise that catastrophising isn't helping you.

Secondly: YOU are not 'life in general'. I've worked from home exclusively for 15 years because I'm a freelance. It's easier now than it's ever been, ngl lots of relationship building etc was much harder when i started, but in order to be home, I changed my career to one that let me BE at home. It doesn't matter to me what the rest of the world is doing, I WFH. So you need to find the way to make your career a WFH career. That might mean you have to change jobs, or firms, or retrain, or whatever. But it is absolutely possible to do it. There will be sacrifices, don't get me wrong, I miss a lot of things about the office for example - but no job is 100% perfect.

You are more in control than you think.

Great advice. This is what I did, and I've never looked back.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 01/12/2023 08:37

I think that for every person who is stressed at the thought of being back in the office, there's another person who is suffering from being at home, for all kinds of reasons, and who will benefit from being in an office with others

Well assuming their employer has an office, there's a very easy solution: go into the office (although they are usually pretty empty on Fridays).

If their employer is virtual only, there's a somewhat less easy solution of finding another job where there's an office.

bellac11 · 01/12/2023 08:37

TrashedSofa · 01/12/2023 08:37

Which leads us to the unpalatable question, how much more are you willing to pay to get such staff back in the office?

Has their pay gone down then?

youngones1 · 01/12/2023 08:37

In future jobs will be offered as hybrid, wfh or in office and you can decide at that point.

bellac11 · 01/12/2023 08:37

TrashedSofa · 01/12/2023 08:34

My reference to exceptions is that exceptions should be made to accommodate disabled employees' needs as opposed to creating/continuing carte blanche for those with no specific health needs to continue to WFH 100%.

I'm sure employers will be just delighted at the idea they've got to incur full office costs and can only recruit within commuting distance. That level of government interference, which is what it would have to be, always ends well.

They dont need to recruit only within commuting distance, that varies from employee to employee, its up to the worker to decide if they're able to get to and from work in a way they are comfortable with

As with another poster pointing this out, there seems to be this view that employers now need to offer WFH or continue with it so that people dont have long commutes or can do the washing or the school pick up. Thats not their duty.

TrashedSofa · 01/12/2023 08:37

bellac11 · 01/12/2023 08:34

Actually Im sick of the number of times the first thing I hear when I ring a company is the recorded message telling me that there might be a long wait time than usual due to the pandemic. I logged on to 3 the other day to see a banner saying the same thing, 'due to the covid 19' or whatever. Its incredible

Then when I finally get through to someone they need to answer the door for a parcel, thats my dog barking in the back ground sorry hahaha

No, not 'hahaha' Im having a business conversation with you, I also dont need to see cats and children wandering around in the background on teams.

Which leads us to the unpalatable question, how much more are you willing to pay to get such staff back in the office?

enchantedsquirrelwood · 01/12/2023 08:35

I always think the idea that people have to go to an office to have a social life is a bit odd. I realise I see office working through the prism of commuting to London and all the time, effort (and money!) that entails, but it's much easier for me to have hobbies working from home, because I save 90 minutes a day! And having hobbies allows me to meet people and socialise.

WFH and remote working (one of the things I always bang on about is that remote working does not mean balancing a laptop on the end of your bed, there are loads of options outside a pandemic situation) allow those with health conditions and caring responsibilities to access the workplace and be economically active. Along with the the fact that it's more environmentally friendly for people not to be travelling unnecessarily, and allows employers to recruit from anywhere and not be restricted geographically, it is not going anywhere.

TrashedSofa · 01/12/2023 08:34

My reference to exceptions is that exceptions should be made to accommodate disabled employees' needs as opposed to creating/continuing carte blanche for those with no specific health needs to continue to WFH 100%.

I'm sure employers will be just delighted at the idea they've got to incur full office costs and can only recruit within commuting distance. That level of government interference, which is what it would have to be, always ends well.

bellac11 · 01/12/2023 08:34

Actually Im sick of the number of times the first thing I hear when I ring a company is the recorded message telling me that there might be a long wait time than usual due to the pandemic. I logged on to 3 the other day to see a banner saying the same thing, 'due to the covid 19' or whatever. Its incredible

Then when I finally get through to someone they need to answer the door for a parcel, thats my dog barking in the back ground sorry hahaha

No, not 'hahaha' Im having a business conversation with you, I also dont need to see cats and children wandering around in the background on teams.

GettinChillyHereFFS · 01/12/2023 08:32

KnickerlessParsons · 01/12/2023 03:18

I think that for every person who is stressed at the thought of being back in the office, there's another person who is suffering from being at home, for all kinds of reasons, and who will benefit from being in an office with others.
There's a happy medium somewhere, and hybrid working might be it. It seems to be a good compromise.

A good compromise would be letting people have autonomy over whether they go in or not.

With teams and zoom there is no need to physically travel to an office just to sit there instead of your own house for 8 hours.

Shalopea · 01/12/2023 08:32

Be aware that due to below replacement fertility and an aging population throughout the entire developed world, there are global labour shortages in every industry.

If you are good at your job, employers will want to attract and retain you. Just stand firm on WFH. Fine to ask at interview . No need to disclose your ND if you don’t want to.

i know as women we sometimes have difficulty with these negotiations, but know your worth and stand firm.

GettinChillyHereFFS · 01/12/2023 08:30

2jacqi · 01/12/2023 03:10

you all might be surprised at the number of businesses which CANNOT do WFH! it just does not work all the times!! many businesses really should be all in the office now! even councils!

Edited

😂😂😂

If it's office based, 9 times out of 10 it can be done remotely.

And the government have said they want disabled etc to find wfh jobs so companies are going to have to become more flexible and start trusting people to do their jobs.

Presenteeism is just bullshit and damaging.

I work for a company that is completely remote. I'll never go back to working in an office again. There's just no need. And I don't want to.

Trez1510 · 01/12/2023 08:27

@Rosscameasdoody

I hear you. However, I was referring to those already in employment like the OP. My reference to exceptions is that exceptions should be made to accommodate disabled employees' needs as opposed to creating/continuing carte blanche for those with no specific health needs to continue to WFH 100%.

The government's purge on those currently not working due to disability is another matter altogether. I'm sure it is deeply concerning for those caught in their sights.

Regarding Hunt, perhaps we should all email him a link to this thread?

TrashedSofa · 01/12/2023 08:26

RecoveryDue · 01/12/2023 08:21

People need to think also though about the younger generation. They need to come in and learn about face to face interactions, negotiation and team-working. Need to socialise after work. Meet friends and partners etc.

Life cannot be lived entirely on a screen at the start of their careers. they need role models and mentors they can talk to face to face. And many don’t have the privilege of nice warm private homes with decent tech etc to work in.

Consideration needs to be give to those with disabilities. But we cannot become
a nation of people working in their homes all week.

The younger generation doesn't solely include people who are able to work in person, much less who'd benefit from doing so. Young people are neurodiverse, living remotely, have caring responsibilities and are disabled just like people of other generations. The socialisation after work that you clearly think is a good thing has functioned to exclude lots of people, and would do again if it we returned to a workplace model where it was the norm (we won't).

Also, the bit about a nation of screens is a bit silly. There are loads of jobs that can't be done any way other than in person, and as a pp pointed out, our worst recruitment crises tend to be in these sectors. A younger person starting out who wants to be able to work in person has many more solid options available to them than a younger person who can't.

Rosscameasdoody · 01/12/2023 08:26

RecoveryDue · 01/12/2023 08:21

People need to think also though about the younger generation. They need to come in and learn about face to face interactions, negotiation and team-working. Need to socialise after work. Meet friends and partners etc.

Life cannot be lived entirely on a screen at the start of their careers. they need role models and mentors they can talk to face to face. And many don’t have the privilege of nice warm private homes with decent tech etc to work in.

Consideration needs to be give to those with disabilities. But we cannot become
a nation of people working in their homes all week.

I agree with what you say, but if you have a look at the welfare reform plans, the government are holding disabled people to an entirely different standard, in that it’s OK for them to work entirely from home with none of the interactions or socialisation you mention. And this is going to impact people in similar circumstances to the OP.

NigelHarmansNewWife · 01/12/2023 08:24

AdamRyan · 01/12/2023 08:11

They can, mine is doing this. Might even be the same one.

This is insane: you cannot discipline someone for not putting in 3 days in the office when they are on holiday. You really have to wonder about the management of such an organisation if they are prepared to waste management time on this fruitless task and discipline employees for taking their statutory holidays.

MumblesParty · 01/12/2023 08:24

RecoveryDue · 01/12/2023 08:21

People need to think also though about the younger generation. They need to come in and learn about face to face interactions, negotiation and team-working. Need to socialise after work. Meet friends and partners etc.

Life cannot be lived entirely on a screen at the start of their careers. they need role models and mentors they can talk to face to face. And many don’t have the privilege of nice warm private homes with decent tech etc to work in.

Consideration needs to be give to those with disabilities. But we cannot become
a nation of people working in their homes all week.

Agree.

Hubblebubble · 01/12/2023 08:24

WFH allowed to get me a job that just isn't available in my sleepy Welsh town. And now I'm somewhat trapped, as all the better paying employers in my industry have gone hybrid and are based in London/Birmingham/Manchester.

MumblesParty · 01/12/2023 08:23

CesareBorgia · 01/12/2023 08:07

but unless you listen to all their calls, you can’t gauge how useful they’ve been.

Call centres in my experience randomly sample and assess calls for just that reason; they'll also check for any patterns such as calls being unusually long or short compared to peers, which might suggest someone is struggling and needs training.

My point is that managing people who aren’t in the same building as you, must surely be quite a challenge. Yes a manager can monitor productivity, listen to calls, record data etc, but chances are they’ve got their own work to do, and haven’t really got time to spend hours remotely monitoring suspected slackers. Office workers whose manager is in the next room, or even the same room, are clearly going to take fewer liberties, so are therefore easier to manage. They’re not going to hang the washing out, pop to the corner shop, catch up on last night’s Eastenders and so on.
It’s not as simple as saying it’s all down to effective management.

LakieLady · 01/12/2023 08:22

I agree with others that WFH could easily come under the "reasonable adjustment" provision of the DDA for you, OP. You have a diagnosis and both conditions are recognised as ones that can require adjustments. If you're in a union, they would support you with this.

My employer is now applying hybrid working, but they're very willing to relax the requirement for coming in to the office where there are adjustments required or where there's a business case for it. Office attendance is absolutely not required for my team, as most of our work was done out in the community anyway. Covid required us to stop meeting clients face to face, and doing stuff over the phone. That has meant that we've increased our caseloads by 50% or more, as we're not wasting time travelling to see clients.

If they did require us back in the office, I think we'd all make sure that we had community appointments on our office days, so we wouldn't be there anyway!

RecoveryDue · 01/12/2023 08:21

People need to think also though about the younger generation. They need to come in and learn about face to face interactions, negotiation and team-working. Need to socialise after work. Meet friends and partners etc.

Life cannot be lived entirely on a screen at the start of their careers. they need role models and mentors they can talk to face to face. And many don’t have the privilege of nice warm private homes with decent tech etc to work in.

Consideration needs to be give to those with disabilities. But we cannot become
a nation of people working in their homes all week.

Rosscameasdoody · 01/12/2023 08:18

Trez1510 · 01/12/2023 03:50

I do believe there are people who have diagnosed health/disability needs who should be afforded the opportunity to WFH 90/100% of the time.

This should be the exception rather than the rule though, imo.

Reading threads on here has left me with the impression some employees have lost the run of themselves when it comes to their contractual responsibilities.

They seem to believe their personal child care, financial, commuting, desire to maintain their homes in their 'lunch break' and/or do the school run during 'flexi breaks' are matters employers should be factoring into their business decisions when it comes to WFH policies.

This impression appears to be being borne out in the ever-increasing number of employees now identifying the need for workplace input from employees.

That said, the employers' findings appear to fly in the face of MNers who, to a person, report their personal production as having sky rocketed whilst WFH.😉

The government clearly don’t think disabled people working from home is the exception rather than the rule though. They’re basing their whole policy on welfare reform on exactly that principle.

In the Autumn Statement Jeremy Hunt announced plans to compel the very most disabled to look for work - these are people who have previously been exempted from job search because they are considered too ill/severely disabled to work.

Now that exemption will disappear along with the extra allowance paid in respect of the inability to work, the work capability assessment will be modified so that categories offering exemption will be taken out, and the WCA itself will eventually be scrapped - the PIP assessment will be used instead. The plan is for DWP assessors and work coaches to decide the level of disability and compliance/sanctioning.

All of this is predicated on the governments’ opinion that it will be easier for disabled people to work because they no longer have to venture outside to do it - they can WFH 100% of the time. No mention of where these jobs will come from, no plan as to how they will persuade employers to take on sick and disabled people, many of whom will not have worked for years, and many more who will be in long term and ongoing treatment.

In view of that, this is a really interesting and timely thread, and one which Mr Hunt would do well to heed.

greencheetah · 01/12/2023 08:17

No push to go back to the office in my sector (legal) In fact we are still selling off more offices.

There were WFH roles before Covid and there will be far more going forward. You now have the advantage of knowing this will work for you and can apply for wfh jobs only.

If your current job moves away from wfh, ask for an occupational health assessment and see if employers will provide a Reasonable Adjustment under Equality Act for you. Please try not to worry. 💐

TrashedSofa · 01/12/2023 08:13

Companies have to look at the big picture - not just “can Wendy, Fatima, Alejandro and Sean do their jobs better at home?” but also “can Fred learn his job without working alongside them?” and “will Imogen be able to do her job as efficiently if she isn’t spending her day saturated by the knowledge of the experts in her field?”

They also need to think about whether having Wendy, Fatima, Alejandro and Sean in the office is actually one of the options available to them. The wider labour market is very much part of the big picture.

The fact that an organisation wants staff there in person, even if backed up by solid evidence, doesn't mean those people are prepared to do it. Or that the organisation can pay what would be needed to buy their physical presence. So they may need to also think about, how are we going to ensure that Fred and Imogen are able to learn their roles remotely even if we'd rather they didn't have to.