Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be filled with panic about WFH culture becoming a thing of the past?

565 replies

themusingsofaninsomniac · 01/12/2023 00:39

prefacing with please read the context before blanket responses 😊

I am stressing away as I tend to do lately on the same topic. I have WFH since the pandemic, with the odd day or so in the office I am lucky to have full flexibility with.

I have Autism. I also have ADHD. The combo together is quite the clusterfuck to navigate as a newly diagnosed female. Essentially the pandemic shone a light on so much and I'm so grateful that it enabled me to seek diagnosis, as much as it's an ongoing struggle.

From working remotely since the beginning I've never felt more stable and successful in my career. I was able to secure a promotion into a field I'd never have had the confidence to try in a non-remote setting in the first place, and I've been fortunate to earn a fair bit more as a result.

I feel completely at ease in my own environment and with the ability to tailor things to what works well for me. Having that commute time back has helped my wellbeing, as has having my lunch breaks in my own home. I am in a routine that I feel helps my mental health and the challenges neurodiversity brings me massively.

My current employer is great but they are the type of company that won't be around forever unfortunately. And from a lot of media and on here etc, it's becoming obvious that things are shifting to either back in the office or a hybrid with a good half your days expected in the office.

This absolutely fills me with dread. I feel like it would turn my world upside down. I'm sure people who don't relate to this will think I'm being dramatic but change and environments outside of your own control are so so hard especially once you've had several years of the opposite.

I guess I'm just wondering where this leaves me. I still have a few friends who WFH but not in my industry. I'm not sure if there would be more flexibility for me, but I also worry about how that will reflect towards my colleagues and I don't want to get anyone's back up. I guess I'm catastrophising that if I need to find another job I'll never be able to maintain what is working so well for me.

Not sure what I'm seeking here to be honest - reassurance maybe or just help to navigate this and whether it's best to be upfront with new employers from the start, or whether that might reduce my chances of being hired. I've been told I don't present as autistic, or typical ADHD but I guess the mix of both means it's a lot more blended. Either way I have generally got good feedback from interviews so it would likely not be known unless I was transparent.

I'd especially like to hear from someone in a similar boat too, if there is anyone? Probably not at twenty to one on a weekday though I imagine 😅

Thanks to anyone who has read this to the end as I know that got wordy!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
themusingsofaninsomniac · 01/12/2023 10:36

Ger1atricMillennial · 01/12/2023 02:14

Our organisation currently has 4 floors, and over 2 weeks they found the max capacity was 25% at any one time, even though our policy is 3 days at work.

I live on my own and I need social interaction, it is great to be flexible about it. However, there are a lot of people who cannot deal with hot-desking at work- so the organisation has to balance what the needs are.

There are a lot of different ways to approach it, but they are looking to cut the budget- loss of office space will be the best way to do it.

I completely understand your view - I know that the approach has to be flexible because as you say some need to be present in the office for their mental health and others feel the opposite. I wish that flexibility was just given to employees to decide what is the right route for them.

I will admit if I don't go in for a while I do start to feel a bit disconnected from people so I do ensure I attend key team meetings face to face which aren't all the time.

OP posts:
enchantedsquirrelwood · 01/12/2023 10:34

bellac11 · 01/12/2023 10:20

Yes Im registered blind but have successfully managed to become a bus driver.

There are 'reasonable' adjustments for the business needs of your service, not carte blanche to just say you have a disability and therefore anything goes.

With an office job, working from home is a very easy adjustment to make. Your example is silly.

As an example, it is not at all unreasonable for a woman with heavy periods to be permitted to work from home on the days she needs to be close to a loo all day.

especially if she spends the whole day on Teams anyway

themusingsofaninsomniac · 01/12/2023 10:33

Anotherparkingthread · 01/12/2023 01:18

I'm also sad to see that there's a push to go back in office. It's clearly been an agenda for those with office premises and other business or investments that rely on corporate money and footfall.

Sadly I think it's incredibly short sighted. The amount of traffic returning to the office puts back on the roads has enormous environmental impacts.

Not to mention that turning suitable office buildings into housing could have been a way to combat the housing shortage in the UK.

You could tell your employer that it effects your disability and ask that work from home be considered a reasonable adjustment. You have proved that you can do the job from home so I highly doubt they could argue it was unreasonable.

You could search for an entirely remote job, there's still lots of more progressive companies who don't have any days in office.

Thank you, this is fair. I guess my stress is around navigating this at a new company and that when you first start a job you can't really be as picky. Like a PP said sometimes there is judgement declaring this sort of stuff at the application stage so I'm in two minds about that and this would be the first time I'd be going into a new role with a diagnosis. I'd also feel quite dishonest to withhold it too so it's a conundrum!

My current employer is great like this and basically allows individuals to choose a working pattern that works for them but I know others are more like how you said and would be nervous to approach this as a new hire in case it could impact my employability - as I wouldn't have proven myself to them just yet.

OP posts:
Tryingmybestadhd · 01/12/2023 10:33

You developed your career and you got a promotion, autism or not you a very competent person in your field and if you need to move jobs you will find a company that supports that . I’ve been wfh since before covid as as my sibling . Some companies never had a issue with it

user1497207191 · 01/12/2023 10:33

HoppingPavlova · 01/12/2023 04:02

Wfh is great, but sadly people take the piss with it and go missing for hours. That is what is killing off wfh sadly, and bosses are asking people to return to the office

That’s the problem. I’m honestly more productive as wfh but I don’t have young kids, mine are adult. You see a lot of people who have young kids and no childcare in place, or disappear around school drop off/pick up and then are not available once kids get home due to kid wrangling, or kid wrangle during school hols rather than holiday clubs etc. They honestly believe that the necessary dispensations in place during Covid lockdown/home schooling should continue ad infinitum. As a manager it’s a real problem as they don’t understand it was a necessity at that time and should not continue as it’s not ideal.

I also see how the younger crew without decades experience under their belts fare so much better when able to connect in person in the office. They get all of this ‘ad hoc value add’ from us oldies they miss out on if it’s just scheduled catch ups via teams/zoom etc.

Yep, new/young staff are really impacted by too many staff WFH. They need to be around experienced staff to pick up on "soft" skills, such as communication, office behaviour, etc. You can teach them the hard skills via courses (in person and on line), but if they're not around experienced staff in person, they'll take longer to pick up on all the other workplace skills.

Re WFH workers taking the piss, then that's down to management, not just their immediate line manager (who may also be taking the piss), but right up through the chain of management. People can get away with things for a while, but sooner or later, piss taking and poor performance gets picked up.

At my son's firm, where he's just started 3 months ago, they've nailed it! There's a "whole department" online teams meeting at 9.15 and 3.15 every day, where everyone who's working that day have to attend, whether they're in the office, at home, or in an internet cafe somewhere - no excuses! It's only a short meeting, 5-10 minutes, but it's basically a catch up for all staff, and it highlights who's not there! Timing is perfect really - make sure everyone is out of bed (and back from the school run) ready to start at 9-15, and a mid afternoon meeting means staff can't go out to pick up their kids, have afternoon tea, go shopping, etc. I think that kind of thing will become more common if WFH is here to stay. Of course, if you've booked time off for holiday, sick, study day, or whatever, you don't need to attend the teams meeting, but otherwise it's obligatory! With son being a new trainee, he loves them as it's his only chance to get an idea of the bigger picture as he listens to the experienced/managerial staff talk about their work, allocate tasks, etc., even those working in other buildings who he'd never "meet" otherwise. Though he does find it funny that all the staff in the office are talking to each other via Teams, even if they're on adjacent desks - but he understands that's to ensure the WFH staff are properly engaged and remain part of the team!

enchantedsquirrelwood · 01/12/2023 10:32

Naptrappedmummy · 01/12/2023 08:50

I understand why it’s better for you and hope you can find a solution, but it’s my belief wfh has created a nation of people with social anxiety and a form of agoraphobia. Look at the number of kids who were ok before lockdown but refused to go back to school after. Despite what tiktok tells us human beings are broadly social creatures who benefit from human interaction even if it’s with people they don’t really really like. Isolated elderly people are more likely to suffer from dementia. It might be easier in the moment to stay at home in pyjamas and not go to work but I think years of it will have a very negative mental effect on our population. DP and I are sociable people and we’ve been flat and depressed since wfh became the norm

So find hobbies and get out of the house. Work is work, it's not your (only)social life.

themusingsofaninsomniac · 01/12/2023 10:30

Glitterbaby17 · 01/12/2023 01:07

ASD here and waiting to also be assessed for ADHD. I love the odd day in the office but do find it massively draining, I think I’d be ok with hybrid and 1-2 days in the office but not more than that. And my commute is 1.15 hrs so ideally a shorter office day as a compromise e.g. 9-4.30

I'm the same, currently a long commute too which I know I do have a say in going forwards. But I find office days a complete drain on me now as well as so distracting with all the goings on - it's like I have become more sensitive to it or just realise how much less stressful it is now I've seen the alternative.

I do like to go in for social reasons on occasion as I think it's important to connect with the team etc in real life here and there - but I also feel like I'm massively awkward and don't have the confidence/directness that they do so often come away doubting myself as I do things differently to them too!

One day a week/fortnight would be my sweet spot I think.

OP posts:
gotomomo · 01/12/2023 10:28

Before covid there were wfh jobs, some employers are embracing long term hybrid too. But I would also say that you, we will adjust back to other ways of working too, neurodivergence doesn't mean you can't adjust to new things, but it takes time

bellac11 · 01/12/2023 10:20

JFDIYOLO · 01/12/2023 10:11

Read up on your rights as a person with a disability in the workplace. The Equality Act.

Yes Im registered blind but have successfully managed to become a bus driver.

There are 'reasonable' adjustments for the business needs of your service, not carte blanche to just say you have a disability and therefore anything goes.

Superscientist · 01/12/2023 10:19

Make sure you get any arrangements formalised and ensure they are put in terms of "reasonable adjustments"

My company is pretty good and for all bar one department flexible working was a thing before covid. I am in the department that couldn't but now can and it is brilliant for my mental and physical health. I have bipolar and am a migraine sufferer and it makes things much easier and I can have an hour out of work in my own space and catch up at the end of the day whereas before I would have had to go home and had a partial sick day.
I have flexible working agreement which is one designated day and a second day when it is required for my role. I typically work 5-7 days a month in the office. Not long after this agreement was put in place they brought in a 2 day minimum and there are rumours about this being increased or more strictly enforced as people are dropping down to 1.5 days averaged. Having the agreement in place especially having it phrased for reasonable adjustments for my disability gives me some protection. They could come back with by not being in the office I can't fulfill all the aspects of my role but this would be a harder sell since I have been doing my job mostly from home for nearly 4 years.

Trez1510 · 01/12/2023 10:11

TrashedSofa · 01/12/2023 09:44

Right, thanks for clarifying. That is broadly what I thought you meant.

It's good that you're at least prepared to vote with your purse, which is more than at least one previous poster seems willing to do. You stand more chance of getting what you want if you'll pay more for it, as we live in a capitalist society.

However, there are a great many office based roles where you're simply not going to have any input at all, either because you don't use their services or you do in some way but it's too remote a link for you to have any influence. In those situations, it's simply not for you to say what the employer/employee relationship should look like. They are, naturally, not going to be persuaded that they should incur office costs and reduce the pool of people able to work for them.

I disagree that seeking a more suitable service necessarily means a greater cost to me. It certainly didn't when I voted with my purse in moving from various companies (banks, insurance etc.) who off-shored their services.

Equally, it's simply not for the employee to say what their contract is as that is a decision made by employers based on how many customers they are able to retain. Also, they will need to factor in their ability to recruit, retain and keep up the morale of staff who are required to be office-based whilst their colleagues (in the 'remoter' linked roles) continue to watch Classic Eastenders, spend their 'working' day on MN, hanging out their washing and picking up their children from school etc. etc. etc.

It seems to me you are advocating a two-tier contract. Those who are customer facing must be office-based whilst the hangers-on work from home.

You appear to believe the employees hold the power in this dynamic. They won't. The combined power of customers, unwillingness of people to be employed as office-based whilst similarly (skilled/unskilled) colleagues 100% WFH and the business wishing to survive outweigh anyone's dislike of commuting, paying for childcare, having to improve their laundry routine etc. etc. etc.

JFDIYOLO · 01/12/2023 10:11

Read up on your rights as a person with a disability in the workplace. The Equality Act.

Percie · 01/12/2023 10:08

I'm in a similar position (autism) and I'd begun the shift to WFH pre-pandemic because I wasn't coping well. Post-pandemic my employer is doing an excellent job of sitting on the fence about their long-term plans, which is causing a lot of anxiety, so my line manager is pursuing the reasonable adjustment route so WFH becomes my standard regardless of what changes they make in future - could this be an option for you?

I found the boiled frog explanation helps people understand, e.g., pre-pandemic you're the slowly boiling frog, you don't understand why you're struggling so you don't jump out and you keep struggling (you know what the mental cost is here). Post-pandemic going back to the office you're the frog thrown into already boiling water so you jump straight back out because you know what the problem is now.

JoanThursday · 01/12/2023 10:06

RecoveryDue · 01/12/2023 08:21

People need to think also though about the younger generation. They need to come in and learn about face to face interactions, negotiation and team-working. Need to socialise after work. Meet friends and partners etc.

Life cannot be lived entirely on a screen at the start of their careers. they need role models and mentors they can talk to face to face. And many don’t have the privilege of nice warm private homes with decent tech etc to work in.

Consideration needs to be give to those with disabilities. But we cannot become
a nation of people working in their homes all week.

Absolutely this!

The nature of my work means that I am in the office for most of the week and I'm happy with that. However, I see people at the start of their careers that don't have an office to go to. The churn in some of these teams seems to be quite high. I wonder if there is a link between that and unavoidable wfh.

bellac11 · 01/12/2023 10:05

TrashedSofa · 01/12/2023 09:44

Right, thanks for clarifying. That is broadly what I thought you meant.

It's good that you're at least prepared to vote with your purse, which is more than at least one previous poster seems willing to do. You stand more chance of getting what you want if you'll pay more for it, as we live in a capitalist society.

However, there are a great many office based roles where you're simply not going to have any input at all, either because you don't use their services or you do in some way but it's too remote a link for you to have any influence. In those situations, it's simply not for you to say what the employer/employee relationship should look like. They are, naturally, not going to be persuaded that they should incur office costs and reduce the pool of people able to work for them.

If you're referring to me I didnt indicate or imply whether I would vote or not with my purse so dont make things up

However the reality is that my costs as a consumer and customer have gone up. People who are working from home still are being paid the same wage, often including london weighting or other enhanced payments for other areas in the country which was to take account of housing and commuting costs for workers in expensive areas.

You say their pay may have gone down in real terms, well so has everyones, including mine due to inflation, yet I pay more for a poorer service.

I think in 5 years time the landscape will be very different, more and more people are getting pissed off with how this is being managed and despite claims of a worker shortage, there isnt a shortage in the sort of roles that you're talking about. The shortages are for work where essentially we have never had high levels of employment, teaching, social work, nursing, care work, front line workers.

3luckystars · 01/12/2023 10:03

MarieG10 · 01/12/2023 07:46

Oh for heavens sake. Do not believe this rubbish. It is not a reasonable accommodation. It could be but that very much depends on the employers model, what others are needing to do and some account of the employees needs. As ever the rubbish trumped here is that reasonable adjustments always trump....the word reasonable often being forgotten. The reality is no ET is likely to sanction full or mostly WFH if it clashes with the business requirement.

My team have done hybrid for a while but we all fully accept the benefits of being together in the office and particularly learning from each other which isn't great on MS Teams. The challenge is that the employer wants now no more than one day a week at home but the accommodation ratio for my team is just over 1 desk for 2 employees so just doesn't work!! Currently I'm in the public sector (more recent) so I look on with amusement at reports of rows of desks in the civil service left empty...perhaps they could share elsewhere.

The reality is many sectors will never remove it, especially tec as this is the model younger workers want and they move to get it. My friends son has just moved last year onto a contract which gives him 4 weeks a years working from anywhere in the world so he spends time with relatives in Spain working during the day and enjoying evenings

Well I think if she has been working from home already, and has a diagnosed disability, it is worth asking her employer if this is a reasonable accommodation.

My relative has autism and works from home permanently.
In truth I am in a different country with different employment laws and am definitely not an expert on this, but I don’t think what I said was rubbish.

All the very best and I hope you can continue to work from home.

LGBirmingham · 01/12/2023 10:02

I'm neurodiverse. Diagnosed dyslexic and borderline dyspraxic. I also tick a lit of traits for adhd but haven't sort diagnosis.

Working from home is not for me. Firstly it is too much of a reminder of the depression I sank into during lockdown. Secondly I kearn much better by being shown how to do something in person. Thirdly I'm a career changer so relatively new in this career and I gain so much from overheard conversations and the extra attention I get from mire experienced team members because I am there.

I do value the flexibility to wfh if I'm ill or there is a nursery event I need to attend. But otherwise I'm in.

We're all different and being part of a society I think we compromise to help everyone. I'd much rather my colleagues were always there but accept they benefit from being home some if the time. Presumably they'd rather stay at home but accept others benefit from their presence some of the time.

Citrusandginger · 01/12/2023 10:02

I’ve worked from home on and off since 2001. There were WFH jobs before the pandemic and there will be for a long time afterwards. So I agree with PP who are suggesting you try not to catastrophise OP. Can you access tools/support via autism support organisations to help you to manage this better?

WFH is totally normal in some industries and is normal many freelancers and consultants. My advice would be to continue to do your job well and build your skills and qualifications so that employers will bite your hand off.

re the government - I know it’s not a surprise that they are rubbish, but DH is looking to get back into work after a period of Ill health and being a carer. So he looked at the so called working from home jobs, and found a whole bunch of roles in care homes. They really are all over the place.

Rosscameasdoody · 01/12/2023 09:57

Startingagainandagain · 01/12/2023 09:31

Same here. Also on the autism spectrum. WFH helps me manage my condition.

My employer recruited me (post covid) claiming that I would need to travel once a month at the most (2 hour commute each way), then as soon as I passed my 6 month probation they started moving the goal post and said I would need to be in the office once a week. I had a massive breakdown 2 months ago and was under the care of the crisis team for 2 weeks. Once I was stable enough to get back to work the GP wrote a fit note saying that I was fit to work provided I could work from home/avoid travel for at least a month. Employer pressured me to ignore this advice on my first day...

Basically I am looking for something else because this workplace is contributing to my depression. The 'office' is one small noisy room with poor wifi, no PCs so you always have to bring your own laptop and I can't get any work done there. It also has one toilet and one meeting room and completely unfit for purpose...

WFH is a lifeline for people with disabilities like me.

I think some companies thankfully realise they will lose good employee if they insist people are in offices for no good reasons. People have seen that the alternative to being glued to your office desk is possible now for many jobs. My current employer has a massive issue with recruitment and especially with retaining staff...

Please have a look at the Equality Act 2010. Your employer needs to make WFH a reasonable adjustment for you if working in the office puts you at a disadvantage because of your disability.

Neiiighbour234 · 01/12/2023 09:55

RtHonNicolaMurray · 01/12/2023 02:46

Crying reading this post as a ND woman who also thrived during the pandemic, now navigating a totally inflexible and mandatory 3-days-per-week office policy. No exceptions (requires VP approval and no requests are being granted). It’s being enforced by badge scan data and tracked at an individual level, no allowance for holiday or sick leave - no 3 days that week goes down as non-compliance, 2+ non/compliant weeks of the last 8 equals disciplinary.

I commute an hour each way to do video calls with colleagues across the world and at other organisations, am line-managing a terrible new hire, and also travel internationally with my job through the year. I am constantly over-stimulated in the office and burnt out outside of it from trying to live normally; my quality of life has nosedived since this policy into effect. Currently can’t sleep because I’ll be up in 5 hours for another day of this. I am not coping.

Oh, that is so hard. I am really sorry you are having to go through all that.

I don't know what type of neurodiversity you have, but ADHD and Autism are considered a protected characteristic under the Equality Act (2010). This legislation requires employers to make adjustments that are considered reasonable (copied from my assessment report). You may have already looked this up, but the extract below is Gov.UK.

Reasonable adjustments in the workplace
"An employer has to make ‘reasonable adjustments’ to avoid you being put at a disadvantage compared to non-disabled people in the workplace."
It sounds like your employers requirement is putting you at a disadvantage compared to other people. Is this something you could research and take to them showing that they have a legal obligation to make reasonable adjustments for you?

Wishing you luck with it.

Disability rights

Find out about protection for disabled people from discrimination at work, in education or dealing with the police

https://www.gov.uk/rights-disabled-person/employment

TrashedSofa · 01/12/2023 09:44

Trez1510 · 01/12/2023 09:31

No, I meant employees should not have carte blanche to insist upon 100%WFH roles unless they were required for health-related reasons.

Like other posters, I've had some pretty poor experiences of attempting to undertake business with people working from home - barking dogs, doorbells and, on more than one occasion, screaming/tantruming/squabbling children.

So, no, as a customer I'm not impressed with having to deal with others' domestic crises when I'm attempting to request/resolve issues of importance to me the customer.

I suspect, I'll vote with my feet/purse. This will happen when competitors revert to office-based operations. I haven't yet done so but I'm absolutely willing/keen to do so.

Whilst, 'employees have choices', equally or more importantly, so do customers.

Right, thanks for clarifying. That is broadly what I thought you meant.

It's good that you're at least prepared to vote with your purse, which is more than at least one previous poster seems willing to do. You stand more chance of getting what you want if you'll pay more for it, as we live in a capitalist society.

However, there are a great many office based roles where you're simply not going to have any input at all, either because you don't use their services or you do in some way but it's too remote a link for you to have any influence. In those situations, it's simply not for you to say what the employer/employee relationship should look like. They are, naturally, not going to be persuaded that they should incur office costs and reduce the pool of people able to work for them.

bellac11 · 01/12/2023 09:43

You can be as competent as you like but if occ health and HR give mealy mouthed support, suggesting adjustments that in no way reasonable for the business needs of the service, these people limp on and you just have to manage it as best you can. Round after round after round of action plans, informal, formal, occ health referrals that the worker 'forgets' to attend or didnt get the letter blah blah blah

Naptrappedmummy · 01/12/2023 09:40

LakieLady · 01/12/2023 09:38

I had a colleague who was always a bit of a slacker but got really bad once lockdown started. Our manager spotted what was going on quickly and put him on a performance improvement plan which led to him leaving (and he's since left the job he went to under a bit of a cloud).

Any competent manager will be able to identify people taking the piss and address it imo.

Not all managers are competent though! In fact only the minority are in my experience

LakieLady · 01/12/2023 09:38

EvelynKatie · 01/12/2023 09:30

Exactly this. I'm always surprised on these WFH threads when people mention people not doing their job purely because of WFH, or that because someone WFH they're forgotten about and don't get given projects or miss out on promotions, as to me that's just bad management. There's no way I'd let anyone in my team get away with not doing their job.

I had a colleague who was always a bit of a slacker but got really bad once lockdown started. Our manager spotted what was going on quickly and put him on a performance improvement plan which led to him leaving (and he's since left the job he went to under a bit of a cloud).

Any competent manager will be able to identify people taking the piss and address it imo.

EarringsandLipstick · 01/12/2023 09:33

LaviniasBigBloomers · 01/12/2023 00:51

I think the pendulum will swing back to office based, then people will go 'wtf, we've just lost half our best talent and we need to spend a bazillion ££ on new offices to accommodate everyone' and then it will swing back to a sensible level. That's in general terms, of course.

In personal terms, two things are happening:

You are having intrusive thoughts about a return to the office full time which is causing you enormous amounts of stress. First step is to recognise that and find ways to manage those thoughts. Google will have a better explanation than me at this time of night after a couple of wines, but you do need to recognise that catastrophising isn't helping you.

Secondly: YOU are not 'life in general'. I've worked from home exclusively for 15 years because I'm a freelance. It's easier now than it's ever been, ngl lots of relationship building etc was much harder when i started, but in order to be home, I changed my career to one that let me BE at home. It doesn't matter to me what the rest of the world is doing, I WFH. So you need to find the way to make your career a WFH career. That might mean you have to change jobs, or firms, or retrain, or whatever. But it is absolutely possible to do it. There will be sacrifices, don't get me wrong, I miss a lot of things about the office for example - but no job is 100% perfect.

You are more in control than you think.

That's a great reply.

Swipe left for the next trending thread