Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To miss the class play because my son doesn't have a line (again)?

210 replies

TheYearOfSmallThings · 30/11/2023 22:43

I have always made an effort to take time off work and go to class assemblies, plays etc. The same few children get the main parts, because they are reliable and do a good job. My son (8, Y4) gets the odd line but, like most of the class, is essentially stage furniture. He is used to this situation, and not that bothered.

This time he literally doesn't have one word in the entire play. I am happy to send him in dressed as a pirate so he can stand behind the boy who has all the pirate lines, but I am about to wipe out a lot of A/L over Christmas and I really don't want to book yet more time off to go and watch other people's children perform.

My friend says I will regret it and DS will be mentally scarred for life. Will I? Will he? Or does there come a time when you can say "If he doesn't have an actual part it's fine to skip it"?

OP posts:
Draoicht · 04/12/2023 09:34

HelenTherese2 · 04/12/2023 09:28

My daughter never got a part or any lines at infant school or nursery. I was always a bit miffed. Then one year we went and afterwards the staff told us that they’d offered her the part of Mary and she’d said no.

For all those parents who think that everyone should get equal lines, you never know what happens behind the scenes because your kids won’t tell you and also children are incredibly unreliable witnesses.

Yes, DS huffily turned down the parts of Joseph, the narrator AND the innkeeper in Reception or Year 1, because he wanted to be ‘the third sheep’.

He had a funny line as ‘Third Sheep’ and got a regular laugh (I happened to see the dress rehearsal as well as the two performances as the teachers very kindly allowed my parents to come as they were visiting from overseas but were going to miss the actual play), and he hated the laugh, because he didn’t see why people found it funny.

HelenTherese2 · 04/12/2023 09:28

My daughter never got a part or any lines at infant school or nursery. I was always a bit miffed. Then one year we went and afterwards the staff told us that they’d offered her the part of Mary and she’d said no.

For all those parents who think that everyone should get equal lines, you never know what happens behind the scenes because your kids won’t tell you and also children are incredibly unreliable witnesses.

Iateallllllthepies · 04/12/2023 08:56

I would still go.

I do get it though. For the last two years of primary, ds was just stood at the back of the christmas play with nothing to do. Not even sing as that was just the choir.

What I didn’t do was take him to stand at the back for the two 6pm performances. Neither did the parents of the other few boys who were just standing there. The school went nuts and tied to enforce it - they got nowhere with that!

Newsenmum · 04/12/2023 08:12

Mswest · 04/12/2023 06:45

Mentally scarred 😂 Such resilience we are developing in our kids! I'm a teacher and can't take AL for this type of thing anyway, I'm sure my kids will survive. I don't think him having a part is a huge issue, or missing the play. Not everyone can get a speaking part 🤷 it's really not a huge deal either way. I was shy at primary so didn't get parts in stuff, which was fine. He doesn't seem bothered you shouldn't be either.

I agree but that’s different - your children know you cant take al. The op is choosing not to go because his part doesn’t have words.

Newsenmum · 04/12/2023 08:10

I’d definitely go - otherwise you’re saying you’re only going if his part is ‘good enough’. Whereas you’re supposed to go because you want to see him!

Robbee · 04/12/2023 07:40

You are seriously out of touch with what goes on in the class to prepare for a performance. Every child normally has to learn the songs and perform them - that takes a lot of time and effort and without the music side the nativity would not be worth watching unless the children were extremely talented and capable of acting large parts - very unlikely.
Every child in that nativity play is a performer - the speaking parts are usually allocated to the children most likely to be able to deliver the lines clearly, who can be heard throughout the hall and are not going to stop to look for their mum mid line and who actually want to do the job. A small proportion of the class usually, but the performance is very much done by the whole class who will have put a huge effort in and that should be recognised - they are never just wallpaper - that is an appalling thing to say - equivalent if saying only those people in managerial positions are worthwhile, the rest are just cogs enabling the managerial staff to have a better lifestyle.
If someone, child or adult puts in their best effort at what they are doing or working at they are never of less value than anyone else, their task is never of less value. Nobody or their contribution to life is of more value than anyone else's - and that includes standing in the choir at a nativity play.
What would it say to a child if he found out his parent would only come to watch him if he had a particular role in a joint venture - if he was just part of the majority that everyone relies on they wouldn't bother because it wasn't worth their while?
A lot of parents genuinely can't get to daytime events - we all understand that, although in this case OP obviously has a choice

TizerorFizz · 04/12/2023 07:33

@Mswest Do you not think schools should encourage dc to speak on stage if they can? It’s certainly something that boosts confidence. Lack of confidence and ability to speak in public (or clearly at an interview) are well known issues that hold dc back. It’s best to try and start early and not think it doesn’t matter. Schools should try very hard to ensure as many dc as possible get a line or two.

CasperGutman · 04/12/2023 06:57

My kids' school nativity plays have always involved every child having a line (and very few, if any, having more than one line).

OK, so it makes the whole thing feel a bit contrived, with a group of four angels standing up and each angel speaking one line, then the four shepherds each speaking one line in response, etc.... But we're not there for the gritty realism. We're there to see our children looking cute with teatowels on their heads, having lines in their class nativity play.

I wouldn't change it for the world!

Mswest · 04/12/2023 06:45

Mentally scarred 😂 Such resilience we are developing in our kids! I'm a teacher and can't take AL for this type of thing anyway, I'm sure my kids will survive. I don't think him having a part is a huge issue, or missing the play. Not everyone can get a speaking part 🤷 it's really not a huge deal either way. I was shy at primary so didn't get parts in stuff, which was fine. He doesn't seem bothered you shouldn't be either.

Honeychickpea · 04/12/2023 01:50

stand up, hoot and hollar for him. Doesn’t matter he didn’t have lines
Please please don't humiliate your child like this.

TheSilkLady · 04/12/2023 01:29

As you get older you learn things I’m 47 if I had my child’s childhood over again I’d do so much differently. I’d go to the play. My sons 27 and he often talks about remembering this and that about his plays and he never had huge parts but to him they were Oscar worthy.

NoThanksymm · 04/12/2023 01:23

Lol. You need to go.

he needs to see you there and know he’s important. Even if he isn’t the top billed performer.

stand up, hoot and hollar for him. Doesn’t matter he didn’t have lines.

Whyohwhywyoming · 04/12/2023 00:20

I don’t remember my mum coming to pretty much anything, including me reading a poem I’d written at a town hall event!

it never bothered me as a child, and I am a very independent and resilient adult.

RhiannonTheRed · 03/12/2023 21:12

My parents worked full time. They didn't come to my sports days, they may have come to the occasional play but I honestly can't remember how many they came to (I remember they did for two for sure but other than that, no clue). They weren't on the PTA, they didn't chaperone school trips, I often couldn't go to after school clubs as they couldn't pick me up, and large amounts of the summer holidays I was at summer club or a child minder. I'm 25 now, and I have an excellent relationship with my parents and hold no resentment, they did what they had to to keep us fed and housed and they always did their best. It's primary school - as long as you love your kids and they're safe, they're not going to care when they get older and yes they might be a little sad at the time but I promise you they'll understand when they're older, as long as you explain.

LongAndWindingRoads · 03/12/2023 20:16

My son when only given one line would quite happily ad- lib, throwing the production into chaos. Parents thought it was funny, teachers not so much. Then he would get really angry when pulled up on it because according to him it was the teachers fault for only giving him one line.

It was quite a relief for me that l couldn't often attend due to work commitments. I used to be a nervous wreck.

TizerorFizz · 03/12/2023 20:07

I do think parents have to accept some dc are better on stage than others. Some are better at sport than others. Some are more academic than others. Not everyone will get a starring role. It’s inevitable the best and most confident dc tend to be used for parts and represent the school. As others do at sport, maths and other competitions. It’s mostly about doing something at primary school level and older dc should be encouraged to do something.

If a dc thinks a parent isn’t keen on coming, they tend to go along with it to please the parent. Most prefer to see a parent there. It’s human nature to want your parent there when everyone else’s is.

I remember at senior school my DD got a song to sing in the musical production. Then it was cut out as the musical was too long. Ar the dress rehearsal stage!

rmcc1983 · 03/12/2023 19:30

I’m 40 years old now. I have been trying very hard, and I honestly can’t recall whether my parents attended primary school nativity plays or not. They both worked. I expect they came to some. I cannot recall any of the things we performed either. So I can’t imagine your child would be scarred for life. It’s only a nativity play or whatever…not like it’s a massive once-in-a-lifetime event like a graduation, passing-out parade, wedding, or something. Kids aren’t daft, they understand the concept of working to earn money. Explain it to him and he will be fine - after all you said it was something he wasn’t that bothered about himself. I imagine he would much prefer more one-on-one time with you over the holidays, doing something fun - if you explain that is the ‘payoff’ for missing the play, I’d say he’ll be fine.

Fluffyhoglets · 03/12/2023 18:18

I'd go - he's year 4 - you only have until end if year 6 and after that neither of my children did anything at high school that required my attendance in any way! They do like to know you're there as well even if they don't admit it!

eeek88 · 03/12/2023 16:52

My parents only came to things if I had a relatively important role. I was not scarred emotionally. It’s possible that your son won’t be either.

Hopingforholidayhelp · 03/12/2023 10:21

Hmmmm fear that his achievements in life may not quite match your expectations as time goes on.
The message a child may receive in this scenario is ‘ Your not really anything much in the play ( you didn’t achieve ) so I won’t bother’ versus ‘ I always love seeing you in your play, I’m so proud of you to get up and have all those eyes staring back, and I love that you give your all, ‘
most of us have to consider AL for events like this, it’s just how it is.

Kezzy16 · 03/12/2023 09:49

Doesn’t matter what part they have, the kids light up when they see you. I’ve been when other parents haven’t and the kids look so disappointed it’s awful. You will regret it if you dnt go because then they get older and you miss these things.

do think it’s slightly unfair though that the parts go to the same kids time and time again and that doesn’t change in senior school either. Clear favouritism at its finest

IamMummyhearmeROAR · 03/12/2023 09:46

All our classes have a defined role so P1 are sheep and shepherds so they are the only ones on stage for that song and dance. P2 are angels and stars. P3 are travellers and innkeepers. All classes get their clear time to shine and then ensemble songs too. We always do an Out of the Ark play so traditional story but with a twist.

ZebraDanios · 03/12/2023 09:40

JudgeJ · 02/12/2023 13:45

All those saying 'you must go' would be pleased if their child's teachers also took time off work to attend their children's school plays? Not everyone is able to conjure up Annual Leave for odd days off.

I’m a teacher and a parent. I would far rather my kids’ teachers missed half a day’s teaching than missed their own children’s plays, just as I’d far rather cover a colleague’s lessons than know they’d missed their kids’ play.

It’s one of the great paradoxes of teaching that we expect parents to show up to support their kids but often aren’t allowed to do the same for our own children. No wonder there’s a recruitment/retention crisis…

InTheRainOnATrain · 03/12/2023 09:38

IamMummyhearmeROAR · 03/12/2023 09:24

Our nativity doesn't have enough lines for the 120 children taking part . But we need all of those 120 voices to sing and the faces to smile.

My school was a 3 form entry so maybe 90 kids and they used to do the fulll unabridged story, religious school so went big on the details, but they split the parts so each character was played by a different kid in every scene. I got Mary 3 one year 🤣
Possibly torturous for the parents as I imagined it really dragged but I think nearly everyone got a speaking parts as a result. With hindsight maybe it’s a trade off that isn’t worth it…

IamMummyhearmeROAR · 03/12/2023 09:24

Our nativity doesn't have enough lines for the 120 children taking part . But we need all of those 120 voices to sing and the faces to smile.

Swipe left for the next trending thread