Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you have adult children? Can I ask a quick question?

107 replies

Naptrappedmummy · 30/11/2023 19:42

Were childhood illnesses always this bad? It seems the norm now among parents I know for children to be unwell every other week (and I’m not exaggerating) until they reach school age at least. I don’t just mean snotty noses but also things that regularly require antibiotics, hospital admissions for oxygen and so on. A lot of newborns seem to be hospitalised with RSV at the moment.

My DD was unwell for about 2 years after starting nursery to the point I spent many nights sobbing, broken by the lack of sleep and inability to keep up with my job. I very nearly had to hand in my notice.

My mother in law is of the view there must be something wrong because while her children got sick, it was never as bad or frequent as this. The doctors just tell me it’s normal for children now.

YABU = yes my children were always this unwell this frequently, it’s normal
YANBU = they were unwell at times but not to this extent, it’s worse than it used to be

OP posts:
Allwelcone · 30/11/2023 20:38

My now 26 yo had ear infections galore and lots of bad colds as well as chicken pox. I was a single mum.
Did your MIL work? And did she have the whole additional work stress going on that so many mums now have to cope with? If not her memory might be rose tinted.
Obviously lockdown and increasing awareness mean illnesses and our attitudes might have changed.

IncompleteSenten · 30/11/2023 20:38

They're in their 20s now and yes, they were always down with something. First few weeks of every new term were worse than the rest with the start of the new school year the worst of the lot for some reason.

Cold after cold in the winter.
Kids played pass the snotty nosed parcel for months.

Both had chicken pox. All the kids did. I don't know if young children today all get it.

User136921 · 30/11/2023 20:37

DS is 31, he went to nursery from 6 months, had a lot of colds, a couple of lots of conjunctivitis and chicken pox but apart from that was well. Throughout school he only had one time when he was off sick for a few days with a fluey type illness, he did suffer badly from hay fever in the summer from about 8. I don't recall he had antibiotics apart from when he had conjunctivitis.

AuntyMabelandPippin · 30/11/2023 20:35

I remember one winter when I was at the GP every week with one of my three. They had multiple ear/throat/chest infections. I once walked in, the receptionist was nice to me and I burst into tears as I'd just had enough.

We moved into a house with a garden the next year, and the GP barely saw us from then, even though we tried really hard to get them out in the fresh air every day possible, it was much better once we moved.

sprigatito · 30/11/2023 20:34

My two are 19 and 21. Both had hospital admissions for RSV as babies/toddlers and one had ongoing respiratory issues, was tested for cystic fibrosis etc, on steroids and antibiotics. It resolved itself eventually.

I think parents are more proactive about getting treatment for sick kids than they used to be. Parents in their 70s might say their kids were never really ill, just normal bugs etc, but there are plenty of us in early middle age walking around with damaged hearing/weak lungs/scars/etc because we weren't treated for things that today's parents would get sorted out.

HalfBloodPrincess · 30/11/2023 20:33

I have 2 ‘adult’ children (19 and 20) and 2 primary age. My 20 year old was in and out of hospital every few months on nebulisers and having steroids for 6 years as whenever she got a cold it went to her chest. My 19yo has only ever had antibiotics once and that was tooth related.

my 6 year old hasn’t had antibiotics and only seems to get a few colds a year but my 4 year old spends winters with a constant cough and upper respiratory infections and has had antibiotics quite a few times already.

me - born 1981 and wasn’t vaccinated past the first one as had a reaction to it so mum never took me back. I had measles, German measles, mumps and whooping cough as a child. I can remember being in bed with a bell to ring and my sisters not being allowed near me for one of them. No hospital visits though and the doctor only ever came out when we had chicken pox, and brought his kids with him so they were exposed!!!

TooShortToReachThatShelf · 30/11/2023 20:33

My AC are 42 and 40. The MMR vaccinations weren't around then, so both my kids had Measles, one had Mumps, the other had Rubella, both had Chickepox.

(The MMR vaccine is the safest and most effective way to protect yourself against measles, mumps and rubella. Since the vaccine was introduced in 1988, these conditions have become rare in the UK - from Google, because someone accused me of making up the fact that the vaccine wasn't around then)

Bluegreen143 · 30/11/2023 20:33

Meant to add. My DS didn’t go to nursery til 3, and then only mornings, and DD didn’t start nursery til 2 (nearly 8 and nearly 5 now). And obviously were in lockdowns aged 4-5 and 1-2. So maybe we are getting this wave of illness now because they weren’t exposed to much when younger?

Hoping it’s something which will at some point end and this isn’t our lives for years and years! It’s bad enough them being ill but awful mustering up the energy for caring for them when you then catch it yourself.

SutWytTi · 30/11/2023 20:32

Naptrappedmummy · 30/11/2023 19:58

@RossPoldarksWife i do wonder. MIL’s theory is that it’s due to super spreaders like nursery and soft play, which far less children attended or attended as regularly when hers were little.

On the personal side, she may just be looking back with rose-tinted glasses, or she may have had healthy children.

At a national level, statistically more kids died or were permanently harmed by illnesses in the past - she is wrong that people are sicker in recent years (other than COVID of course).

Ragwort · 30/11/2023 20:32

My DS is early 20s and has rarely been ill .. he went to nursery/play school from 2 but never seemed to pick anything up ... everyone used to say 'He'll get so many bugs from nursery' ... but he just didn't. I think it's just luck & good genes .. my DH has just retired & never had a day's sick leave in all his working life. I am the same ... never had a days sick leave in the last seven years of my working life. The last sick day I had (about 20 years ago) I actually faked it to get a day off Blush.

Bluevelvetsofa · 30/11/2023 20:31

Chicken pox, German measles, mumps, croup, coughs, colds, vomiting bugs. Trips to A&E when DS pulled an empty cupboard onto himself and when DD fell off a bar stool and cracked her head.

Octavia64 · 30/11/2023 20:29

Oh, and just to add to the data -

Me, 1970s baby, constantly ill, many many ear infections and antibiotics and an operation when I was 6 to remove them. I got every cold and virus going and was frequently off school.

As an adult I am diagnosed with three auto-immune disorders (but no treatment, natch)

Storynanny1 · 30/11/2023 20:27

I also think it’s harder now because in most families the adults are both working - I was mainly at home when mine were in the peak catching everything phase so it wasn’t a problem if they were off school/nursery etc

areyouhavinglaugh · 30/11/2023 20:27

19 yr old had antibiotics once in his whole life, never went to A&E!

Youngest has had antibiotics twice he's 11, tonsillitis and Strep A, never been to A&E either.

I do have friends with much younger children who are constantly going to A&E for the most stupid pointless reasons, a GP or even common sense would've solved!

Iwasafool · 30/11/2023 20:27

Kids vary, one of mine suffered badly with chest infections and the first couple of years were hard, the others were generally fine just the usually snotty noses. My 3 GC who are primary school age don't seem to get ill very often.

Octavia64 · 30/11/2023 20:24

My kids went to nursery when they were 2 fur three days a week as I got a part time job.

I lost the job because I was off so much with their illnesses. They were twins. One would get d and v and then the other. The final straw was when one had chicken pox for two weeks and then the other got it just as the first one was ok to go back to nursery.

I gave up trying to work and studied an OU degree to retrain so I could change career for when they started school.

Bluegreen143 · 30/11/2023 20:24

I don’t have adult children - mine are 7 and 4. But we are struggling with illness so much! And they pass them on to us.

I’ve found it’s worse in the autumn and early winter.

This October and November have been a write off. We all sequentially had a very bad cold in October so it ended up three weeks of being unable to do much. The kids also had threadworm 🤢

November - we’ve all had a respiratory infection. I’ve had a bad cough for three weeks now and it’s so draining! And then last week DD caught norovirus. Which of course has passed through the whole family, one after the other.

We like to be outdoors and it’s really getting me down that we’ve been unable to take advantage of the dry, sunny weather to get out for some autumn walks. We’ve not taken the kids swimming in weeks and have had to cancel both a date night and a night out. I almost fully WFH, so haven’t missed too much work (my manager allows me to WFH around sick kids so I just juggle the work around them rather than taking the day off) but have still had two sick days the past fortnight and DH has now been off work for a week as is so drained after his bout of norovirus. DS has had about 4-5 days off sick at school this autumn and similar for DD from nursery.

To cap it all the kids have just gotten headlice and now need combed daily!!

Last autumn, at any given time at least one of us was ill the entire time from Sept to early Dec. A mix of respiratory infections, sickness bugs, hand foot & mouth, the year before was chicken pox and croup.

I’m sure it’s probably normal but a bit exacerbated by lockdowns messing with young kids’ exposure to illnesses, so they’re now getting them all at once?!

I’m really hoping it calms down from now as last year we then didn’t catch anything for ages from early Dec onwards. It was like we’d got a whole year’s worth of sickness in one go!

Storynanny1 · 30/11/2023 20:19

Mine are 1980’s babies. One was asthmatic but never admitted to hospital. Never heard of norovirus or rsv - they were just called “ a cold” or “ sick bug”. Chicken pox and mumps were fairly straightforward and it was easy to get children seen at the surgery or by a health visitor if you thought they might need medicine.
Quite a few trips to a and E with minor sports injuries.
My grandchildren get lots of colds and their parents take them far more seriously than I did - but I don’t know if they are stronger strains of not.

YouAreMyCentreWhenISpinAway · 30/11/2023 20:18

YABU

Mine got the odd cold, or a mild version of something nasty going around, but nothing more. Perhaps off once a year at school.

IMO a lot of it has to do with immunity.

Some DC have good immune systems, some don’t. I do think you can influence your DC’s immune system positively through nutrition and good rest.

Naptrappedmummy · 30/11/2023 20:14

Just clicked off the thread and instantly saw another one just posted by another mum at her wits end with the illnesses Sad

OP posts:
BeyondMyWits · 30/11/2023 20:14

Dd21 had to fill in a medical form in order to do bio lab work at uni. She rang me to ask if she was allergic to penicillin... I told her we wouldn't know, she'd never had it.

Dd23 had antibiotics for an infected ingrown tonail once.

We have been lucky. A few minor colds, chickenpox, no stomach trouble (unless being hungover as an "adult" counts.).

They both have had more illness since going to uni - "freshers flu" every year and this year a case of real bedridden actual flu.

cardibach · 30/11/2023 20:13

DD (27) had a lot of ear infections while teething. Went to full time nursery from 7 months. Rarely ill enough to be off. I worked with someone whose child was always off, to the point she resigned and became a SAHM to avoid it. I think it’s individuals, not a whole generation thing.
I also hadn’t heard of norovirus until into the 2000s

HeadNorth · 30/11/2023 20:13

My oldest was seldom ill and rarely off nursery or school. Her little sister seemed to be always ill and it always became serious, hospital admissions We called her the sickly Victorian child as she always seems to get retro illnesses really badly. This has continued into adulthood and she still gets everything worse than anyone else, poor lamb. Funnily enough - she is a nurse, must be all that experience of hospitals.

saraclara · 30/11/2023 20:11

I had mine in the late '80s, and they were rarely ill. One was slightly prone to ear infections, but otherwise, apart from colds, I don't remember them being ill much. They didn't mix with large numbers of children until they went to playgroup at just under three, though. It didn't ramp up illness frequency, as far as I remember.

One of my kids had full attendance at school for the first three years. And it wasn't because I sent her in ill. The other might have had an odd day off a year.

I hadn't given this much notice until I read the OP. I'm very aware though, that both my grandchildren (under four) seem to be ill a lot. But they both started nursery at 12/15 months old.

welcometothnuthouse · 30/11/2023 20:08

My dc were hardy ever poorly, colds but not sick very often. No allergies either or fussy eaters and all bottle fed, guess I was very lucky on that front.