Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dads new GF and new baby

93 replies

BrummyJoan · 30/11/2023 18:18

A bit of a backstory to this one:
My widowed DF met his new GF about 8 months ago. It’s his first relationship since DM passing. I gave birth to my first DD 4 months ago. I met new GF once before birth. I had an extremely traumatic birth and was quite poorly afterwards, took a while to get home and was readmitted with sepsis. DF came to the hospital once and spent the whole time on his phone. After this he refused to visit me and DD until a would let GF meet her, lots of crying arguments about this and DH had to step in and tell him to stop contacting me until I was ready.

here’s my AIBU -
I have to have some work done on my bathroom to fix a leak. I don’t want DD here when it’s done due to dust etc. this is being done by freeholder of our building. DH is away with work during this time. DF offered to take DD to a local cafe for a few hours while this is done, it now transpires he wants GF, her adult daughter and the daughter’s husband to join him for this. AIBU to say no? I’ve never met the daughter or her husband and my child isn’t a play thing.
I don’t want to damage my relationship further with DF but to be honest I am really struggling with this whole thing. I’m happy he isn’t lonely but it’s moving very fast.

OP posts:
momonpurpose · 30/11/2023 20:11

Outofmydepthnow · 30/11/2023 20:09

My lovely aunt went out with a man who had a similar daughter.. she used to bring her late mother's ashes with her when she visited him (and my aunt) .. completely bonkers . Made him choose having a girlfriend over seeing his grandchildren.. awful. Truly awful and mind staggeringly selfish of the daughter.

Holy Hell! Your aunt must have been gobsmacked when she popped up with the ashes!

Moonwatcher1234 · 30/11/2023 20:11

OP stick to your guns. Even from a safeguarding perspective, you don’t know these people - why would you entrust them with your precious child.

mrssunshinexxx · 30/11/2023 20:10

@Ponderingwindow I could of written your post, it's heartbreaking. Particularly poignant the part you said where he treats her better than he treat your mum.

Outofmydepthnow · 30/11/2023 20:09

My lovely aunt went out with a man who had a similar daughter.. she used to bring her late mother's ashes with her when she visited him (and my aunt) .. completely bonkers . Made him choose having a girlfriend over seeing his grandchildren.. awful. Truly awful and mind staggeringly selfish of the daughter.

CoffeeMama1 · 30/11/2023 20:01

Not unreasonable at all. He doesn't get to just be a part of her life as and when he decides and shows her off to people.

Bluebutred · 30/11/2023 19:59

YANBU - your DF doesnt ‘know’ your baby. How baby feeds, winds, needs attention or not. I wouldn’t be allowing my young baby to anyone who wasn’t familiar with them x

TammyJones · 30/11/2023 19:56

BrummyJoan · 30/11/2023 18:53

I understand what you are all saying, I guess I’m hurt that it felt like an olive branch from him ( I didn’t ask, I’d actually already lined up a mate but he said he wanted to spend time with her) now just feels a way for him to have DD be an activity for GF and her family. Anyway, for many reasons I will decline his offer and sort myself out.
He has been a crap dad and I need to live wit that now and focus on my family

Actually, I think that is a good plan.
Dd is not a toy.

Silvers11 · 30/11/2023 19:56

10HailMarys · 30/11/2023 19:01

I think that, essentially, you’re not happy that your father has a new partner and you are simply looking for reasons to exclude her. You may not even be conscious of this, but every single thing you say is basically “I don’t want this woman anywhere near me or my baby” as if you consider her to be some kind of threat. She’s your dad’s partner and they’re obviously very serious about each other. It’s pretty normal that she wants to meet you and his grandchild. Why is it a problem for her to see your baby? How is your baby going to be affected by your dad's partner seeing her?

I don’t think the fact that you had a difficult birth is a rational reason to refuse to let her set foot in your home with your father. She’s his partner. Why is her presence in your house for an hour or so such a problem?

I think you probably have all sorts of complicated feelings going on due to having just had a baby and feeling that your dad is trying to replace your mum, and that you probably don’t even quite understand or acknowledge those feelings yourself. You need to deal with them, though, because at the moment you’ve basically just got a very strong hostility to someone for the sole reason that she’s in love with your widowed dad.

I totally agree with this.

AmazingSnakeHead · 30/11/2023 19:52

I can't relate to these replies at all. Nothing on this land would move me to allow my 4 month old baby to be looked after by 3 strangers and 1 person who I suspected was offering for nontransparent reasons. I would never allow this.

Commecicommeca26 · 30/11/2023 19:46

Not even remotely unreasonable. You’ve recently had a baby, had a tough birth and adjustment to motherhood (all without your own mum) and your dad was more interested in his GF and her feelings than you during recovery - that would be difficult for anyone! You don’t owe anyone access to your baby, let alone in the first week! I would say, having been in a similar position recently, that it is probably better to appear on board and let people make their own mistakes so if you could go with them or meet them after the contractors have left then you might feel more comfortable about the situation rather than feeling ambushed and like your DD is being used on some peace keeping mission. This might help the relationship with your dad and mean he is happy to see you alone rather than forcing the initial first meet. Or failing that you could say she’s not well/teething/clingy and you won’t be leaving her with them, plans change with babies all the time! Sending you a lot of love because it isn’t at all easy xx

tenbob · 30/11/2023 19:43

BrummyJoan · 30/11/2023 19:33

I’ve been sending updates and photos for weeks, I’ve offered to meet them and have GF over for tea and a cuddle. This is the first contact I’ve had back.
can someone please explain how this is controlling?

You’re not being controlling

Some of the replies you’ve had are ridiculous and I would bet my house that none of the posters accusing you of being ‘weird’ or ‘controlling’ would back the GF if she posted on here from her/your dad’s perspective

It sounds like you’ve made your mind up to cancel with him, so do it and put it out of your mind, and concentrate on your lovely baby

wjpa · 30/11/2023 19:38

Your dad is being ridiculous.

He wasn't there when you were really ill and prioritised the feelings of new GF.

And now, he would prefer not to see his grandchild if he can't use her as a toy with GF.

There is no way I'd send a 4 month old baby out with a man who doesn't know her (grandparent or not) and three total randomers who you haven't met.

Whattodo112222 · 30/11/2023 19:37

I think you have a subconscious fierce loyalty to your late mother. Thats perfectly understandable.

But presumably the gf has done nothing wrong. Don't make your father be in a position where he has to choose.

You're also cutting your nose off to spite your face by giving him terms and conditions on the childcare.

The gf will likely be part of your family so I would just accept it.

WillowCraft · 30/11/2023 19:37

Erm no way would I let someone take my 4 month old away from me in that scenario . You say your dad hasn't even visited you. So he doesn't know your daughter. And you don't have a good relationship, he is wanting to use your child to appease his girlfriend who you don't even know.
This is not a loving grandfather wanting to look after grandchild to help you out. It's someone acting completely selfishly. I would be saying a big no.
Why can't you take the baby out yourself? Do you need to be in when the work is done? I'd see about leaving a key with a neighbour and going to stay elsewhere for a day or 2.

Onlinetherapist · 30/11/2023 19:36

@BrummyJoan you aren’t going to get very much kindness, understanding, empathy or compassion on Mumsnet unfortunately. And especially not on AIBU.
So be kind to yourself. You’ve been through a lot, the loss of your mum, and then having to see your dad in a new relationship, the traumatic birth, new motherhood without your own mum (which probably adds to your feelings of grief). I think what you are feeling runs deeper than the cafe trip with your dad’s partner’s family. I’m guessing a big part of you is feeling that it should be your mum enjoying the new baby, rather than this stranger that’s come into all of your lives. It’s a very delicate and complex situation. I’m so glad your husband had your back at your most vulnerable time x

Mummymummy89 · 30/11/2023 19:35

Your baby is a baby. A tiny one at that. She won't care about who is present or what the dynamic is. If she's awake, all she will care about is being warm/fed/cuddled/changed when necessary.

While I agree with this, I don't think op's father is going to be any good at feeding and cuddling if he just sat there in hospital playing candy crush while his own daughter was bleeding and recovering from sepsis in the bed nearby.

Op, ignore the guilt tripping pps who are saying you need to put up with a terrible parent because you've lost your other one (I'm sorry for your loss).

You do not need to put up with an unsupportive dad when you're still recovering from a traumatic birth and looking after a small baby. Your needs and your baby's needs trump his, hugely.

BrummyJoan · 30/11/2023 19:33

I’ve been sending updates and photos for weeks, I’ve offered to meet them and have GF over for tea and a cuddle. This is the first contact I’ve had back.
can someone please explain how this is controlling?

OP posts:
ActDottie · 30/11/2023 19:32

Mrsphilmiller · 30/11/2023 18:27

You’re being very weird about this, OP.

This I don’t really get the big deal

ttcat37 · 30/11/2023 19:30

YANBU. I would not want my newborn being passed around by people I’ve not met or met once and don’t like. It’s clear that your dad is using your baby to make his girlfriend happy which is the wrong reason entirely. The girlfriend insisting on this and having a tantrum about seeing an effective stranger’s baby is weird and would be enough of a red flag for me to refuse.

momonpurpose · 30/11/2023 19:29

Muchof · 30/11/2023 18:30

YABVVU. I cannot even understand why it matters.

You have already lost your mother. Please don't ruin your relationship with your father. You are being completely unreasonable. Don't let this be the hill you choose to die on.

Goldbar · 30/11/2023 19:27

Your baby is a baby. A tiny one at that. She won't care about who is present or what the dynamic is. If she's awake, all she will care about is being warm/fed/cuddled/changed when necessary.

If you could do with some time with someone else looking after her, then for me the main question would be - do you trust your dad to look after her safely and meet her needs? If you don't, or you feel it is too early for her to be away from her primary caregiver, then YANBU to refuse.

Fwiw, I wouldn't have cared where my mum took my DC as a baby - to visit friends, a pet convention, a book group - because I trusted her.

Lolapusht · 30/11/2023 19:24

Lol.

Love how 8 months in this situation is a very serious, involved complex relationship that OP MUST respect but when someone wants to introduce their children after 8 months they’re in a transient, doomed relationship they can’t possibly know will last but crack on and forge a relationship with a baby you’re not related to 🙄

DisforDarkChocolate · 30/11/2023 19:23

He's been seeing her for 8 months and your baby will have no memory of it.

Aquamarine1029 · 30/11/2023 19:23

I think your father is a fucking jerk. Keep your baby at home, in a room with the door closed. She'll be fine.

LickleLamb · 30/11/2023 19:19

Tell workmen to keep bathroom door shut -surely they know you won’t want dust through the house. Tell LL you are concerned about dust ,tell workmen this too, keep DD in the kitchen or wherever is least dust.
I wouldn’t want show off Dad and anxious DGf (as she is seeing her DD for the first time in forever) to have baby. It’s a busy cafe . Keep her home.
Go and see Dad and GF at a time that suits you in a week or three.