Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Getting a dressing down at work in front of others. Ok or not?

108 replies

rolsete · 30/11/2023 13:19

I'd love to hear thoughts from others on this. I recently moved into an alternative NHS department to increase my skill set. For context, on the job description for my own job and this department also, 'the ability to cope with an often hostile and challenging workplace' is listed on the job description.

There is a lot of sickness in the department which, on the face of it, looks like it results from mental health issues. Perhaps these particular employees aren't able to cope ALL the time with the 'hostile' environment, but manage to the majority of the time.

The person in charge raises their voices and 'dresses down' employees who make mistakes in front of a room full of staff (minimum 6+ at any one time). Often these seem to be fairly minor mistakes, and to be honest to be expected since we are all human and some staff have minimal experience and are on the lower pay bands.

Some people seem to be targeted over every mistake. Others who are really experienced and so obviously don't make many mistakes, can make a really significant whopper but aren't pulled up on it by said manager. Also, the really experienced person who made significant whopper is the first to shout at others (who are human, inexperienced and lack training) even though they have shown themselves that they aren't perfect either.

AIBU to think that when providing feedback and pulling people up on errors it can still be done in a respectful, polite way? Is it ok to speak as loudly as you can so that everyone within 20 feet can hear? Is it ok to shout at people at work, instead of conveying the same information at a regular volume? Are they just doing it so that others don't make the same errors? It feels really humiliating and shameful for the person on the receiving end.

Genuinely just trying to get my head round the department I'm in.

OP posts:
rolsete · 30/11/2023 17:00

Nounderwireplease · 30/11/2023 16:45

Not the point of the post but I’m interested in how these mistakes affect patients, ‘significant whoppers’ does not sound good. Neither does the frequency of mistakes you allude to in your post.

What an absolute state the NHS is in.

None of the mistakes directly affect patient care. They affect patient waiting times though, but not significantly. The 'whopper' I refer to was forgetting to do something which meant colleagues had to do it instead. So no patient harmed, but colleagues had to cover. A bit like me just forgetting to turn up for my shift on a weekend. Lower staff members would get bollocked for anything like that but this person didn't.

This is not theatres/nursing.

OP posts:
fetchacloth · 30/11/2023 16:50

MargotBamborough · 30/11/2023 13:26

It sounds really toxic.

It's pretty astonishing that they actually advertised the workplace as being "hostile". That's not something to be proud of. They should be engaging in self reflection and trying to figure out how to make the environment a positive and supportive one, not recruiting people primarily for their ability to cope with a hostile one.

It seems like taking pride in having a "hostile environment" has spread from the Home Office to the NHS.

Unfortunately it's an attitude that's runs rife across the public sector. I was once a victim of it myself. The amount of bullying going on is frankly disgusting.😡

Nounderwireplease · 30/11/2023 16:45

Not the point of the post but I’m interested in how these mistakes affect patients, ‘significant whoppers’ does not sound good. Neither does the frequency of mistakes you allude to in your post.

What an absolute state the NHS is in.

fetchacloth · 30/11/2023 16:45

It's neither acceptable nor professional to be giving staff a dressing down in front of others.
I used to be a department manager and any reprimands were given in private behind closed doors. The employee also had right of reply so I could better understand how the situation arose.
Also I didn't shout as this gives the appearance of the manager losing control and one thing you need to be as a manager is approachable, otherwise you don't gain the trust of your employees.
OP, I think your manager needs some management training. If I was you I would be looking for a transfer.

Saltyswee · 30/11/2023 16:44

Tell me you work in a surgical specialty without telling me you work in a surgical speciality.

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 30/11/2023 16:36

My friend took a job like this knowing the 'boss' was a nightmare but it was an opportunity to work in a really specific area that was a growing industry and his plan was to just tolerate if for 1 year then leave. Female boss, male friend FWIW. She would shout, scream and occasionally throw things at him. Abusive emails 24 hours a day even on days off. Despite going in with eyes open with an exit plan, it still massively took a toll on him mentally and physically. It was actually disturbing to witness. There is absolutely no excuse for this type of bullying in a workplace.

user1471556818 · 30/11/2023 16:31

I knew this was the NHS. Sadly this type of working environment isn't uncommon. From my experience its really hard to be the person who says this is unacceptable and the personal impact can be devastating. So many policies and unions and Hr but this behaviour still continues. Sorry your in this position

N27 · 30/11/2023 16:23

Someone needs to raise a grievance to HR. I used to work with a colleague who did this and it was “just the way he is”. He would shout, have temper tantrums, and regularly have his employees in tears, but no one wanted to raise a grievance against him. In the end even though I was never on the receiving end directly as I wasn’t in his team I put in an official complaint as it was horrible to see the effect he was having on people and to have people in tear to me about him. This gave them all they needed to start an investigation and gather the witness statements they needed for formal action

ManateeFair · 30/11/2023 15:48

It's never OK. It's a sign of a horrible, dysfunctional and toxic organisational culture.

Deathraystare · 30/11/2023 15:41

Cannot really expect the staff to change if the job is described like that!!! Ok we know the NHS is not a fluffy and warm place to work, what is? But still...

PigletJohn · 30/11/2023 15:40

"the ability to cope with an often hostile and challenging workplace' is listed on the job description."

Only people who like workplace bullying should apply.

Sooner or later, ubiquitous mobile phones will record this behaviour, and after it becomes public, the organisation will say "we didn't know."

Deathraystare · 30/11/2023 15:39

@MargotBamborough ·

My thought exactly re being proud of being a hostile environment! Usually people are proud of the friendly team environment. That sounds like a war zone!!!

Katbum · 30/11/2023 15:37

It’s bullying. Start keeping a record and send to HR.

Hijinks75 · 30/11/2023 15:35

Rolsete, I managed a mental health crisis team, hard to get more frontline and still not acceptable to shout at staff, simply leads to a demoralised unmotivated workforce, I’m quite proud of the fact that in 9 years managing that team we had almost no staff turnover and negligible sickness, I like to think due at least to some degree on a contented, well motivated not shouted at workforce

LlynTegid · 30/11/2023 15:11

Not acceptable at all.

The only reasonable one I can think of in front of others which does not need shouting is to object to foul or discriminatory language.

MikeRafone · 30/11/2023 15:08

rolsete · 30/11/2023 15:04

Not yet. I wasn't sure if I was being overly sensitive to what I was witnessing.

Having just read up on the civility movement in healthcare, as prompted by a reply here, I can see how what I'm feeling is completely normal given the circumstances.

I’d be putting in a grievance, the manager needs training. If nothing is tackled the manager will continue to do the job in part badly

TellerTuesday · 30/11/2023 15:07

SaladSeeker · 30/11/2023 13:24

I read this as someone giving you a dressing gown

Me too 🤣

rolsete · 30/11/2023 15:07

^^ God, all of this. This is the thing, these people are trying their best. They aren't making mistakes to piss her off. It's horrible to witness. And it does make you feel like a child again (not that children should be shouted and screamed at either). It's completely uncivilised.

OP posts:
Lavender14 · 30/11/2023 15:04

I've had one manager shout at me on one occasion due to an error I'd made. I was straight in for a 1-1 meeting with her the next day to make it very clear that I'm a good worker, I take accountability for my mistakes and do everything possible to learn from and resolve them independently. I will not accept being yelled at and i will not accept being yelled at in front of other people as its completely unnecessary. She apologised and never did it again but if she had I would have complained to senior management. I don't go to work to be spoken to like a child. I have never needed to yell at any staff I manage even the ones who were struggling. That's poor management and lack of management skill and training and its not my problem.

rolsete · 30/11/2023 15:04

MikeRafone · 30/11/2023 15:02

Have you contacted your union and asked for their advice’s n this matter?

Not yet. I wasn't sure if I was being overly sensitive to what I was witnessing.

Having just read up on the civility movement in healthcare, as prompted by a reply here, I can see how what I'm feeling is completely normal given the circumstances.

OP posts:
MikeRafone · 30/11/2023 15:02

Have you contacted your union and asked for their advice’s n this matter?

rolsete · 30/11/2023 14:59

@Anisette Really helpful post. It does feel completely counter productive to have this situation. I need to look into it more and see what can be done.

OP posts:
Anisette · 30/11/2023 14:59

rolsete · 30/11/2023 14:02

Would anything actually be done about it? Would the people involved be told to stop? They need these people as they are highly experienced and we have massive staffing issues. I can't imagine they'd tell them off!

I suspect you'd have fewer staffing issues if it was a less toxic environment. The staff turnover must be pretty high. Who hangs around to be shouted at when they can get alternative jobs where they are treated with at least some respect?

LatteLady · 30/11/2023 14:59

Talk to your Freedom to Speak up (FtSu) Guardian, and they will investigate. No one should have to put up with public dressing downs... this is not good people management by any stretch of the imagination.

Nanny0gg · 30/11/2023 14:58

rolsete · 30/11/2023 13:30

Yes, I think they must be referring to patients, but patient contact is actually fairly minimal (although they CAN be hostile too!) and I have found that, actually, the hostility is the culture between the staff.

Can it ever be excused because it's a stressful environment?

No.

It's contributing to the stressful environment

And 'dressing down' is absolutely correct in these instances (although 'bollocking' also probably works)