Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was we unreasonable to withdraw our child from a school church service?

830 replies

Dad0f1 · 30/11/2023 12:01

Hello everyone new member here just looking for some advice/reassurance that I/we've made the right decision regarding withdrawing our child from a church service at school.

So our DS who is our first child started Reception this September at our local CofE primary school and although neither myself or my OH are church goers we felt that this was the best school for him as the other practical nearby choices were a RC school or a two form entry state school which our DS would not have coped with.

And to be fair our DS has settled in nicely making lots of new friends and seems to be enjoying it however, the other week we was informed that the children would be attending a 'School Communion Service' in the nearby church that the school is attached to and not having a clue what this was I enquired with the Head of RE what the service entailed, how involved DS would be in the service and what was expected of him during the service.

As I suspected the service was in their words 'a simplified child friendly version of the Holy Communion Service' which would include bread and wine for those who were confirmed (as apparantly the children are offered the option to be confirmed if they wish in Y6) but the Reverend overseeing ther service likes to get the children involved so will offer all the children confirmed or not a wafer if they want one.
Also 'prompts' would flash up on a big screen at various points during the service to let the children know when to say 'Amen' etc.

Now to the reason why I/we chose to withdraw my DS from this service. Although the Head of RE made a point to explain that worship is voluntary at the school and that the children are free to take part in worship as much or as little as they wish. I very much doubt that children aged 4 or 5 can grasp the concept of this especially as they are at an age where they want to please the adults around them.
This is also made difficult for them not to be involved if they wish when they have 'prompts' flashing up on a big screen to help/nudge them into reciting a paticular phrase and when everyone around them is then repeating it parrot fashion.

Whilst we do want our DS to learn about Christianity we also want him to make up his own mind about whether to accept it or reject it in later life.
So AI/WBU to withdraw him from school church services that are being conducted like this or should I let him experience them bearing in mind his young age?

OP posts:
JaniceJanice · 30/11/2023 21:53

spriots · 30/11/2023 21:43

@JaniceJanice I agree that often faith schools are the only option but also that you may have other reasons like it being your closest school or the one best suited to your child for other reasons.

We have moved now but where we used to live, there was a C of E school 2 mins away, another C of E school 5 mins away and the nearest non denominational was 20 mins walk away. Sure we could have done that walk but I don't think it would have been unreasonable if we had gone for the school 2 mins ago. Our choice.

I agree- my son went to an RC school because it’s small, on our street and his friends and cousins were going to be in his class. The other school in walking distance was c of e (which I am and into which ds was baptised), but it’s much bigger and nowhere near as good. A non den school would have been a drive, which I didn’t want to do (although I could have).

Attending the RC but not going to mass was the compromise I and his other parents (who are atheists) agreed on.

Terfosaurus · 30/11/2023 21:50

@Muddybooties We don’t do confession as I’ve said and we can’t receive communion until after confirmed or accepted as a member of the congregation and it is symbolic. We only do communion a few times a year!!

Is this within a CofE church?

Muddybooties · 30/11/2023 21:43

mathanxiety · 30/11/2023 18:54

I fear you're mistaking the external for the essence here wrt Catholic rites and social/ secular customs, and also for CoE confirmation, which you're dismissing as not that important.

You may not have any suspicion that you're mining a seam of puritan responses to Catholicism here and a post-Imperial sense of downplaying the CoE's relevance, but I think I can detect the origin of some of your thoughts here to those elements of British religious history.

What you're wearing or what you're doing after the sacramental service is not the essential part of the sacrament. There is no more and no less virtue in wearing a white dress and veil or a pair of jeans to receive a sacrament or participate in a church service.

The CoE lost a good deal of wind from its sails as post-Imperial reality set in in Britain. It had been strongly associated with the Imperial imperative and the colonial project, and suffered when that particular nationalistic spirit faded. In particular, the social and often political pressure to appear to be loyal to the CoE disintegrated, but it had been a very strong force in British life from the time of the religious wars of the early centuries of the Reformation.

What I’m trying to push home @mathanxiety is that overall Catholicism is a lot more full on - both in terms of the requirements to attend and intensity with all the sacraments in early childhood, as well as with the overall nature of the religion; requiring the Priest to confess for instance, if you’re a Protestant you sit at home and pray not needing an intermediary.

While confirmation and dedication to the respective faiths may be analogous, the social dynamics and expectations/demands at school are totally different. In Protestant schools the religious aspect is much more toned down as well as the social/cultural aspects - very low key. That doesn’t mean it isn’t important; but it isn’t dominant as it is in a Catholic school. Because Protestants have Sunday school and bible class within the church environment as well as all preparation classes for confirmation taking place in church.

We don’t do confession as I’ve said and we can’t receive communion until after confirmed or accepted as a member of the congregation and it is symbolic. We only do communion a few times a year!! While it is integral to the catholic mass and you believe it is the actual blood and body of Christ transformed by the Priest.

So I really don’t see why OP is getting so upset about a Protestant school it isn’t dedicating the child to the religion. Nor is it an intense environment with indoctrination.

I periodically attend Catholic Churches, synagogues and mosques…. Doesn’t make me a Catholic, Jew or Muslim.

Grimupnorth442 · 30/11/2023 21:43

My husband has a different opinion, he believes in making people welcome he loves children and families attending church inwhatever capacity....because he is clearly a lot nicer then me. People ring our house as in his office number. The amount of people moaning because they NEED to getting their kids in a certain school, expecting him to pretend that they attend every week, wanting paperwork signed. When I tell them no they do need to come for twelve weeks they get an attitude on. I'm not going to be rude, I certainly don't mind helping those who need help but do not ever come to my door with double standards

spriots · 30/11/2023 21:43

@JaniceJanice I agree that often faith schools are the only option but also that you may have other reasons like it being your closest school or the one best suited to your child for other reasons.

We have moved now but where we used to live, there was a C of E school 2 mins away, another C of E school 5 mins away and the nearest non denominational was 20 mins walk away. Sure we could have done that walk but I don't think it would have been unreasonable if we had gone for the school 2 mins ago. Our choice.

JaniceJanice · 30/11/2023 21:40

Also, there can be an enormous difference in the attitude and culture of the faith school and the church it is affiliated with. You might be happy with the religious education your child gets at school but not with the culture of the church that school goes to. They can be at totally different places in terms of inclusivity etc.

JaniceJanice · 30/11/2023 21:34

Grimupnorth442 · 30/11/2023 21:13

This kind of rubbish drives me mad I am married to a Reverend. He puts so much effort into visiting her Cof E schools in our area. Sorting out child friendly services so the children can enjoy church and feel welcome. It's parents like you that make a mockery of a Cof E school. I never say it publicly but why on God's earth do you send a child to a Cof E school then act like an absolute arse and withdraw them from religious elements. So hypocritical. You ring up my house when when your child needs to get to the C of E high school pleading for them to be confirmed even though they've never attended church nor do you have any intention of ever attending. Mybhusband then says nothing enrols your child onto a confirmation course... you moan they have to attend that too. Then they are confirmed my husband buys each child a bible from his own money.....and never sees rhe child again. Take your child out of the school if you don't like it .

Have you missed all the posts about faith schools being the only option? If everyone in our town who doesn’t go to church stopped sending their children to church schools we would have to fit 8 schools worth of children into 2 schools… and the faith schools would close because there would be so few children left.

If your husband doesn’t want to provide those services then I suggest he takes it up with his bishop- plenty of c of e vicars require church attendance for confirmation.

If you don’t want people to ring up your house then don’t use that as a contact number for your husband (I’ve never known a vicar to do this because they have all run their offices from home). My MIL stopped parishioners ever calling their home or knocking on the door by being rude to everyone who tried and telling them to go away. You could do that.

WearyAuldWumman · 30/11/2023 21:31

Precipice · 30/11/2023 13:05

Totally, obviously unreasonable. Send him to a secular school if you don’t want him to attend church.

Is there even such a thing in the UK? Normal, non-religious schools, still have "acts of collective worship" and they still have Christmas/Easter assemblies to which they make all children go unless withdrawn by a parent, even in late secondary school, which include passages from the Bible being read out and religious songs sung.

In non-denominational schools, it's not unusual for parents to opt out of acts of worship and that's accepted because they're not faith schools. (I worked in non-denom schools in Scotland.)

Mischance · 30/11/2023 21:30

why on God's earth do you send a child to a Cof E school then act like an absolute arse and withdraw them from religious elements. ....... because there are no suitable state non-aligned schools in the area - that is why. Because some parents do not want their children involved in religious activities.

I understand that this is what you want for your children; but equally you must be open-minded enough to recognise that it is not what everyone wants for theirs. If they have no choice but to send the child to a CofE school because the state does not provide any other suitable one, I ask you what they should do? This will involve you putting yourself in the position of another who does not share your beliefs.

WearyAuldWumman · 30/11/2023 21:27

Notjustabrunette · 30/11/2023 12:56

missing the point, but 2 form entry is still a very small school. I think he would have coped just fine.

A good point. What's going to happen when the child is secondary school age?

Grimupnorth442 · 30/11/2023 21:13

This kind of rubbish drives me mad I am married to a Reverend. He puts so much effort into visiting her Cof E schools in our area. Sorting out child friendly services so the children can enjoy church and feel welcome. It's parents like you that make a mockery of a Cof E school. I never say it publicly but why on God's earth do you send a child to a Cof E school then act like an absolute arse and withdraw them from religious elements. So hypocritical. You ring up my house when when your child needs to get to the C of E high school pleading for them to be confirmed even though they've never attended church nor do you have any intention of ever attending. Mybhusband then says nothing enrols your child onto a confirmation course... you moan they have to attend that too. Then they are confirmed my husband buys each child a bible from his own money.....and never sees rhe child again. Take your child out of the school if you don't like it .

spriots · 30/11/2023 21:01

are not church goers also tax payers? Are not all children entitled to an education?

Yes, everyone is entitled to an education. Everyone can apply to whatever school they want. And everyone can withdraw their children from worship of they want too

StripeyDeckchair · 30/11/2023 20:59

Yabu to send your child to a church school & then complain that the pupils are participating in a church service

Ponderingwindow · 30/11/2023 20:56

StarlightLime · 30/11/2023 16:01

Why would a faith school celebrate diversity (of religion) amongst it's pupils?
It's an idiotic notion.

That faith school may be the only education option available. Every child has the right to an education, regardless of belief.

JaniceJanice · 30/11/2023 20:47

Chinhairsoftheworldunite · 30/11/2023 20:25

I think when people hate organised religions and what they think they stand for, they should really stay away from them. That includes schools. Someone upthread said why should she go out of her area when her council tax pays for the local church school. If this is the level of intelligence then there is nothing anyone can say- it’s the same kind of ignorance that says tax payers money go to church schools and should be stopped - are not church goers also tax payers? Are not all children entitled to an education?

Yep, all children are entitled to an education and shouldn’t have to drive to a different town to get one when there are 2 schools within 5 minutes walk. Its bad for the environment for one thing!

Marstonroadmrs · 30/11/2023 20:41

Tax not council tax

TheBluestEye2 · 30/11/2023 20:29

I don't think it would do him any harm to attend the service, he is young and won't be overly concerned about religion.

cleaninglady123 · 30/11/2023 20:28

My kids go to a CofE school with all different faiths. No one pulls their kids out of nativity or going to church.

Chinhairsoftheworldunite · 30/11/2023 20:25

I think when people hate organised religions and what they think they stand for, they should really stay away from them. That includes schools. Someone upthread said why should she go out of her area when her council tax pays for the local church school. If this is the level of intelligence then there is nothing anyone can say- it’s the same kind of ignorance that says tax payers money go to church schools and should be stopped - are not church goers also tax payers? Are not all children entitled to an education?

SouthLondonMum22 · 30/11/2023 19:22

BabaBarrio · 30/11/2023 17:25

The OP clearly states it is voluntary.
Although the Head of RE made a point to explain that worship is voluntary at the school and that the children are free to take part in worship as much or as little as they wish.

4yr olds are more than capable of saying no and digging in their heels. They learn this at age 2.

They tend to behave differently for others than when they are most comfortable with their parents.

Not all 4 year olds would be confident enough to say no, especially to a teacher

Not all 4 year olds would even be aware that they can say no, they'd just do it because everyone else is doing it.

Not to mention the fact that even if it is a 4 year olds choice, they are 4. They aren't capable of making those decisions yet which is why it is ultimately the parents choice at that age.

grass67 · 30/11/2023 19:18

@Benibidibici
I have three churches close to me.
One - dug up the deceased and sold off the land to fund a housing development and new church building, now used as a community, pre school and event hall.
Two- ripped out the pews and is now a cafe, event hall.
Three - sold off the building, dug up the deceased, built a housing estate.

Not sure the community are behind, grave removal and new builds...sure the church got lots of cash though.

JaniceJanice · 30/11/2023 19:13

Bogofftosomewherehot · 30/11/2023 19:09

@JaniceJanice OP asked AIBU, I relied yes. You don't have to agree with me, you clearly disagree , that's fine - I don't need to be baited by some random who's opinion is insignificant to me. Have a nice evening.

Sorry, I presumed people who posted publicly on a discussion forum were open to having a discussion.

Bogofftosomewherehot · 30/11/2023 19:09

JaniceJanice · 30/11/2023 18:19

I didn’t say you weren’t, I said I don’t see why it’s unreasonable or a big deal.

@JaniceJanice OP asked AIBU, I relied yes. You don't have to agree with me, you clearly disagree , that's fine - I don't need to be baited by some random who's opinion is insignificant to me. Have a nice evening.

mathanxiety · 30/11/2023 18:54

Muddybooties · 30/11/2023 17:18

@mathanxiety

Protestantism as a whole I’ve found is a whole lot less labour intensive.

I was amazed when I first went to my husbands church and there was all this participation all the way through both in physical movement and the need for reciting things.

In my church, you go in sit down, few prayers, few hymns, sit through the sermon. And that’s it.

It doesn’t make the religion any less valid just because it’s less complicated, less ritualistic and less demanding.

The point of a Protestant school as others have said, is to give a good moral grounding, and to develop a relationship with god and your neighbour, to understand Christianity. To support children in their faith but not to exclude others.

Whether you commit to that religion is entirely your choice as a mid teen to adult and there is not the same sort of social pressure.

For example catholic sacraments for children are almost put on a par with weddings - special outfits, celebratory party, money and gifts given. The children can feel pressure to join the big group of friends and they obviously are motivated by the money and party etc to take part.

What I experienced watching some friends get confirmed was they went to a few classes at church circa 14, then they turned up at church as normal in jeans and were confirmed as an adjunct to the church service, not a huge thing. But important for them personally to make that commitment.

I fear you're mistaking the external for the essence here wrt Catholic rites and social/ secular customs, and also for CoE confirmation, which you're dismissing as not that important.

You may not have any suspicion that you're mining a seam of puritan responses to Catholicism here and a post-Imperial sense of downplaying the CoE's relevance, but I think I can detect the origin of some of your thoughts here to those elements of British religious history.

What you're wearing or what you're doing after the sacramental service is not the essential part of the sacrament. There is no more and no less virtue in wearing a white dress and veil or a pair of jeans to receive a sacrament or participate in a church service.

The CoE lost a good deal of wind from its sails as post-Imperial reality set in in Britain. It had been strongly associated with the Imperial imperative and the colonial project, and suffered when that particular nationalistic spirit faded. In particular, the social and often political pressure to appear to be loyal to the CoE disintegrated, but it had been a very strong force in British life from the time of the religious wars of the early centuries of the Reformation.

Benibidibici · 30/11/2023 18:52

Christians on these threads never respond as to what the many many parents should do who live in more rural communities and have no choice of school except a cofe option.

The church are foolish. The growing resentment of excessive attempts to proselytise through schools are, against the backdrop of rapid dwindling of christianity in the uk, more likely to lead to movements to remove schools from church control than to successfully increase members of the faith.

There is more chance for the survival of the church as an establishment if they accept more of a community role focussed on charity, kindness, musical appreciation, supporting families etc but without the more direct religious elements such as worship, bible study, prayer etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread