Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was we unreasonable to withdraw our child from a school church service?

830 replies

Dad0f1 · 30/11/2023 12:01

Hello everyone new member here just looking for some advice/reassurance that I/we've made the right decision regarding withdrawing our child from a church service at school.

So our DS who is our first child started Reception this September at our local CofE primary school and although neither myself or my OH are church goers we felt that this was the best school for him as the other practical nearby choices were a RC school or a two form entry state school which our DS would not have coped with.

And to be fair our DS has settled in nicely making lots of new friends and seems to be enjoying it however, the other week we was informed that the children would be attending a 'School Communion Service' in the nearby church that the school is attached to and not having a clue what this was I enquired with the Head of RE what the service entailed, how involved DS would be in the service and what was expected of him during the service.

As I suspected the service was in their words 'a simplified child friendly version of the Holy Communion Service' which would include bread and wine for those who were confirmed (as apparantly the children are offered the option to be confirmed if they wish in Y6) but the Reverend overseeing ther service likes to get the children involved so will offer all the children confirmed or not a wafer if they want one.
Also 'prompts' would flash up on a big screen at various points during the service to let the children know when to say 'Amen' etc.

Now to the reason why I/we chose to withdraw my DS from this service. Although the Head of RE made a point to explain that worship is voluntary at the school and that the children are free to take part in worship as much or as little as they wish. I very much doubt that children aged 4 or 5 can grasp the concept of this especially as they are at an age where they want to please the adults around them.
This is also made difficult for them not to be involved if they wish when they have 'prompts' flashing up on a big screen to help/nudge them into reciting a paticular phrase and when everyone around them is then repeating it parrot fashion.

Whilst we do want our DS to learn about Christianity we also want him to make up his own mind about whether to accept it or reject it in later life.
So AI/WBU to withdraw him from school church services that are being conducted like this or should I let him experience them bearing in mind his young age?

OP posts:
sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:47

my children’s taught about religion as..

this school follows christianity but that does not make it fact and negate other religions

and i suspect those that say otherwise either so not have children at school or are remembering their education from decades ago

Current faith schools are very embracing

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:45

JaniceJanice · 01/12/2023 16:42

Right, so you do say ‘they believe x, those other people believe y’ etc. So it isn’t taught as if it’s all fact.

Faith schools have the attitude of ‘we believe this, because it’s true. They believe that- which is wrong- but they are allowed to be wrong. Be polite to them (but remember they are wrong)’

correct

they believe X
this school goes by Y faith
David and Odi go by Z

and so on

no right, no wrong, just different

NewFriendlyLadybird · 01/12/2023 16:43

CurlewKate · 01/12/2023 14:24

@NewFriendlyLadybird "It depends where in the country you are. Certainly where we live there are RC and CofE primary schools and a RC secondary school, but everyone is allocated places by the local authority based on catchment area, with other considerations (eg siblings at the school) added into the mix. Faith is not one of the criteria."
Really? So you can be allocated a faith school whether you want it or not? And if you want a faith school you could be just out of catchment for one and a non faith person gets a place? What's in that for anyone?

Yes. I dare say it would be possible to argue your way into the RC secondary school from out of catchment as there is usually a bit of juggling after the first round of place allocations. But the C of E primary schools in particular are just the same as any other state school. There are no faith criteria for admission. C of E schools aim to serve the whole community and to be inclusive.

A friend of my daughter is at the RC school. She’s Muslim. Perfectly happy there. She respects their faith and they respect hers.

I sometimes think that people who don’t know very much about the C of E have made it into a sort of bogeyman from somewhere in the 16th century. With the exception of some nut jobs on the evangelical wing it’s mostly so laid back as to be almost not religious at all.

Nice music though.

JaniceJanice · 01/12/2023 16:42

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:38

How do you teach in a way that says all religions are fact?

simple. It is fact to the believer

Right, so you do say ‘they believe x, those other people believe y’ etc. So it isn’t taught as if it’s all fact.

Faith schools have the attitude of ‘we believe this, because it’s true. They believe that- which is wrong- but they are allowed to be wrong. Be polite to them (but remember they are wrong)’

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:39

Muslims believe in a make believe god

i mean seriously, of course they don’t teach it like this

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:39

you honestly imagine a faith school would get away with saying…. judaism is made up tripe?

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:38

How do you teach in a way that says all religions are fact?

simple. It is fact to the believer

JaniceJanice · 01/12/2023 16:38

justasking111 · 01/12/2023 16:02

Well here all religions are respected as fact. Teachers at church of Wales don't teach Christianity as a fact and all the others as fairy tales.

We share large chunks of the bible for a start.

But I respect in England it may be quite different.

How do you teach in a way that says all religions are fact? Surely ‘they believe this and they believe that and they believe something different again, isn’t that interesting?’ is the only way to do it?

You can’t teach that death= heaven or hell, and that death = heaven or hell or purgatory, and that death = reincarnation or enlightenment, and that death = paradise and that death = top level heaven or middle level heaven or hell etc as if they are all simultaneously fact!

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:36

indeed it compares pretty unfavourably t! 😂

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:36

but recent homework asked for research on 5 religions teaching on war, and there no whiff that Christianity’s was correct

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:34

it’s a “faith” school insofar as christmas carol concert at local church

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:34

CurlewKate · 01/12/2023 16:33

Hang on- are people now defending faith schools on the grounds that they don't really teach Christianity as truth? 🤣

certainly not ours

CurlewKate · 01/12/2023 16:33

Hang on- are people now defending faith schools on the grounds that they don't really teach Christianity as truth? 🤣

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:32

SouthLondonMum22 · 01/12/2023 16:23

Sending a couple of children to a faith school doesn't make you an expert either.

I'm simply sharing my opinion, as is everyone on here.

indeed

hence i do not speak as definitively or dogmatically as you.

I said that your view wasn’t the case in “my children’s school”

Whereas you are talking as though this is fact and in all faith schools

which is plainly…. nonsense

JaniceJanice · 01/12/2023 16:31

SouthLondonMum22 · 01/12/2023 16:19

I also went to a faith school and have a nephew and niece at a faith school.

Only several pages ago, it was apparently a big part of the school ethos which will include religious ceremonies, praying and speaking about Christianity as fact according to many pp's arguing against OP withdrawing her son.

Which one is it?

At my faith school teachers spoke in tongues as part of assembly and told me I was going to hell because I’m gay 🤷‍♀️ this was a mainstream c of e high school in England in the 2000s.

My sons RC primary was religious obviously but less so and in a more appropriate way… definitely taught religion as fact though.

since getting a new head has become much more strident. My 5 year old nephew who is at that school was extremely upset when my wife told him she doesn’t believe in God, because he learned at school/ school mass that you will go to hell if you don’t.

SouthLondonMum22 · 01/12/2023 16:23

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:20

ah you’re nothing short of an expert then 😂

Sending a couple of children to a faith school doesn't make you an expert either.

I'm simply sharing my opinion, as is everyone on here.

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:21

as fact according to many pp's arguing against OP withdrawing her son.

One for hyperbole generally aren’t you

A couple of posters argued this and we’re vastly outweighed by opposing

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:20

SouthLondonMum22 · 01/12/2023 16:19

I also went to a faith school and have a nephew and niece at a faith school.

Only several pages ago, it was apparently a big part of the school ethos which will include religious ceremonies, praying and speaking about Christianity as fact according to many pp's arguing against OP withdrawing her son.

Which one is it?

ah you’re nothing short of an expert then 😂

SouthLondonMum22 · 01/12/2023 16:19

JaniceJanice · 01/12/2023 16:11

She has an opinion because she has principles, and knowledge because she lives in the world and knows stuff! We are not restricted to caring and learning about only that which directly affects us. I don’t have a dog, I still have an opinion on puppy farming. I’m not a man, but I have an opinion on male circumcision. I’m not straight but I have an opinion on whether straight couples should be allowed to get married. I also know how those things work and the laws around them etc… It’s quite normal to have opinions and know stuff!

Edited

I also went to a faith school and have a nephew and niece at a faith school.

Only several pages ago, it was apparently a big part of the school ethos which will include religious ceremonies, praying and speaking about Christianity as fact according to many pp's arguing against OP withdrawing her son.

Which one is it?

Ponderingwindow · 01/12/2023 16:19

People seem unable to
grasp the simple distinction between education about religion and religious endorsement.

A student can learn that it is typical for a member of the Muslim faith to pray 5 times a day. However, the school doesn’t have students roll out prayer mats and face Mecca.

Education about other religions should be no different. There is no reason that students should participate in the rituals of any one religion, especially when they only read about the rituals of others.

JaniceJanice · 01/12/2023 16:11

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:01

and you you don’t have any DC at school

So how come you are so convinced of this point?

She has an opinion because she has principles, and knowledge because she lives in the world and knows stuff! We are not restricted to caring and learning about only that which directly affects us. I don’t have a dog, I still have an opinion on puppy farming. I’m not a man, but I have an opinion on male circumcision. I’m not straight but I have an opinion on whether straight couples should be allowed to get married. I also know how those things work and the laws around them etc… It’s quite normal to have opinions and know stuff!

SouthLondonMum22 · 01/12/2023 16:08

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:01

and you you don’t have any DC at school

So how come you are so convinced of this point?

Because faith schools teach their religion as fact, it's part of their ethos.

I don't need to have DC at school to know that.

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:06

same at my children’s school in england @justasking111

and @SouthLondonMum22 doesnt have any school aged children so i’m baffled by her dogmatic approach to the issue

justasking111 · 01/12/2023 16:02

SouthLondonMum22 · 01/12/2023 15:23

Because for the 1000th time, there is a difference between educating children about religion and teaching religion as fact.

I have no issues at all with religious education such as teaching children what all of the main religions in our country believe and about the festivals they celebrate. Very different from teaching children that Christianity is fact and for them to take part in acts of worship.

I don't understand how people aren't grasping the difference.

Well here all religions are respected as fact. Teachers at church of Wales don't teach Christianity as a fact and all the others as fairy tales.

We share large chunks of the bible for a start.

But I respect in England it may be quite different.

sugarandsweetener · 01/12/2023 16:02

SouthLondonMum22 · 01/12/2023 15:54

Sorry, what may be the case?

that christianity is taught “as fact”