Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was we unreasonable to withdraw our child from a school church service?

830 replies

Dad0f1 · 30/11/2023 12:01

Hello everyone new member here just looking for some advice/reassurance that I/we've made the right decision regarding withdrawing our child from a church service at school.

So our DS who is our first child started Reception this September at our local CofE primary school and although neither myself or my OH are church goers we felt that this was the best school for him as the other practical nearby choices were a RC school or a two form entry state school which our DS would not have coped with.

And to be fair our DS has settled in nicely making lots of new friends and seems to be enjoying it however, the other week we was informed that the children would be attending a 'School Communion Service' in the nearby church that the school is attached to and not having a clue what this was I enquired with the Head of RE what the service entailed, how involved DS would be in the service and what was expected of him during the service.

As I suspected the service was in their words 'a simplified child friendly version of the Holy Communion Service' which would include bread and wine for those who were confirmed (as apparantly the children are offered the option to be confirmed if they wish in Y6) but the Reverend overseeing ther service likes to get the children involved so will offer all the children confirmed or not a wafer if they want one.
Also 'prompts' would flash up on a big screen at various points during the service to let the children know when to say 'Amen' etc.

Now to the reason why I/we chose to withdraw my DS from this service. Although the Head of RE made a point to explain that worship is voluntary at the school and that the children are free to take part in worship as much or as little as they wish. I very much doubt that children aged 4 or 5 can grasp the concept of this especially as they are at an age where they want to please the adults around them.
This is also made difficult for them not to be involved if they wish when they have 'prompts' flashing up on a big screen to help/nudge them into reciting a paticular phrase and when everyone around them is then repeating it parrot fashion.

Whilst we do want our DS to learn about Christianity we also want him to make up his own mind about whether to accept it or reject it in later life.
So AI/WBU to withdraw him from school church services that are being conducted like this or should I let him experience them bearing in mind his young age?

OP posts:
Hayliebells · 30/11/2023 12:43

I understand you're not religious, but pulling him out is way ott. It's good to experience religious services, it's just life experience and part of understanding different religions. It doesn't mean he's going to become Christian. If they were going on a class visit to a Hindu temple, or mosque, or synagogue (as schools often do), would you have pulled him out of one of their services too? Tbh I think you were a little nieve if you thought religious services and celebrations weren't going to be a regular part of a church school. Don't make him that child whose always pulled out of them due to your slightly unreasonable (given you chose this school) sensibilities.

reesewithoutaspoon · 30/11/2023 12:43

I'm an atheist. I would let them go. nothing puts you off religion faster than a boring church service in a cold church will do.

Andthereyougo · 30/11/2023 12:43

It’s a learning experience for your child. A different place, walking round as a class etc.. are all part of the early school experience.
I live between the village school and church and there’s always lots of excited chatter when the kids are walking between the two.
Your dc will be introduced to different aspects of different religions and he’ll be missing out if you pull him from them all.

empee47 · 30/11/2023 12:43

It’s a bit like going to a steakhouse then moaning that there’s no vegetarian food - YABVU OP!

avenue1 · 30/11/2023 12:42

Couldn't you have allowed him to go but requested he didn't take communion? Seems an easy compromise...

AnnPerkins · 30/11/2023 12:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Was that necessary?

Charlotte120221 · 30/11/2023 12:42

YABU.

You chose the church school. There were other options.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 30/11/2023 12:42

I dare say that withdrawing him - especially a reception age child! - from such things, will only make him very eager to know what he’s missing.

My dd and SiL are not remotely religious but Gdcs attend a very good C of E primary, and they’re never made to feel different by being withdrawn from anything.

Most of us who are older will have had daily school prayers and hymns etc. as a matter of course, and we still managed to make up our own minds as to what we did or didn’t believe, certainly by the early teen years.

And BTW, I sincerely hope that the ‘was’ in your title was a typo.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 30/11/2023 12:42

But the best way to learn is by seeing so you are removing the learning opportunity.

your son is 5, so just let him join in with the class. He can choose to opt out when he is old enough to make the choice himself. Right now you are saying the choice should be his so then why are you trying to make it for him.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 30/11/2023 12:42

YABU. You had a choice about sending him to a Church school, and now you're moaning that it's religious.

My DC attended a CofE primary as we lived rurally and it was the only school. So no choice. You'll be relieved to hear they are now both atheists.

People are all telling you that you're bring Unreasonable but you're not listening.

easylikeasundaymorn · 30/11/2023 12:42

He's four i doubt he's capable of reading amen let alone having any comprehension what it means. He's not going to remember this particular service in a week or two let alone the rest of his life. Even eating a wafer isn't going to magically influence his later beliefs. If you're that worried about what overhearing other kids repeating amen to him will do aren't you worried that every time he hears someone talking about Christmas they are referring to Christ's mass? Slightly hypocritical....

On the other hand being the only kid to have to sit out will make him feel ostracised if the others come back altogether having sung songs etc not to mention probably highlighting you to the staff as "those parents" for the next 7 years.

If you deliberately send your kids to a religious school you shouldn't be allowed to pick and choose which elements you follow.

WearyAuldWumman · 30/11/2023 12:41

CornishGem1975 · 30/11/2023 12:03

Yeah, YABU. If you're going to withdraw them from these services, you should have chosen a different school. It's church school, it's in the name.

Agreed. OP wants the child to have the benefit of attending a faith school, but without full participation in the life of the school. If it's a problem for the OP, it's better to organise a transfer to a non-denominational school sooner rather than later.

amylou8 · 30/11/2023 12:41

It's a church school, what exactly were you expecting? You'll do him far more harm pulling him out an making him feel different.

NoSquirrels · 30/11/2023 12:41

Totally up to you and your ‘line in the sand’, so to speak. If you don’t want him offered a communion wafer and think he’s too young to understand, it’s within your rights to withdraw him. Other people will have different opinions but there’s no right or wrong on this, it’s all just subjective depending on your own principles and views of religion.

Personally I think the kids singled out to not go when it’s a whole-school event miss out and feel ‘othered’, and that’s a shame as it’s always their parent’s principles but they’re not the ones living them, their kids are paying a price not them. But that’s just my opinion.

Nanny0gg · 30/11/2023 12:41

Dad0f1 · 30/11/2023 12:24

Yikes! Do some of you actually read an OP fully before replying?

First of all we sent him to the CofE school as it was the best of three and ONLY options in our area.

Secondly we are NOT withdrawing him from EVERYTHING religous just certain services that offer him a form of communion that he has no concept or understanding of what is being offered to him yet.

Once he knows and understands what is being offered to him then he is free to make up his own mind if he wishes to attend these type of services or not whatever age of understanding may be.

Some of the replies appear be confusing learning about Christianity and practicing Christianity the former of which we are happy with.

I can read fine, thanks

He won't learn if he doesn't participate

It's the school's ethos. You sign up to it or you don't go

Why won't he cope in the two-form entry?

PortalooSunset · 30/11/2023 12:40

Yep, I think YABU. Are other kids left out? What does dc do when the others are in the service?

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 30/11/2023 12:39

I wouldn't have done the same, but I don't think you're unreasonable. You're allowed to withdraw them for this very reason.

OllieCollieWoo · 30/11/2023 12:39

YABU

If you are willing to send your child to a school of faith, don't start cherry picking out the bits they can and cannot do. You'll confuse them. They'll be wondering what happens "behind the doors" and make it worse.
If you are not happy at any of tha faith elements, remove them from the school and let a family who are happy with the school to go there.

icallshade · 30/11/2023 12:39

Atheist here and I would let my daughter go. Best way to learn is to experience, which I gather you agree with. You say you don't want him to be part of something that 'means something' ie the communion service but I would argue that as he doesn't understand what it is (which you say yourself) then it doesn't mean anything. To him he'll be eating a cracker and saying Amen. Which means absolutely sod all unless you believe.

ThatMrsM · 30/11/2023 12:38

I think you're being unreasonable and probably overthinking it. I went to Catholic primary and secondary schools. In primary school I remember not really caring either way about religion....a church visit was a fun trip out of school with friends singing hymns etc. In secondary school I got quite bored of it all and questioning the religion, but I think by year 8 or 9 we were allowed to chose whether we went to mass.

I also remember there were a couple of non-catholic children at my school, they attended the services but just didn't get communion. Is this something you could discuss with the church so he doesn't miss out on the experience?

Zarah123 · 30/11/2023 12:37

I’m Muslim, I went on all the offered religious school trips in primary school. I ate the communion wafer in church, I ate the langar in the Sikh temple etc.

I’m still very much Muslim, but have friends from all religions.

MrsMiddleMother · 30/11/2023 12:37

Yabu, let him join in and experience it. As you said, given his young age he won't understand and it'll just be a bit of singing, saying amen and a bit of bread. He'll decide what, if any, religion to follow when he's older.

Fruitflylady · 30/11/2023 12:37

Pressed post too early…
… if you don’t believe in any of it then you can’t possibly believe him experiencing a church service will affect him one way or the other, except to help him understand what goes on in a church service.
I’d see it as a learning experience. Talk to him afterwards and see what he thought. Discuss other forms of religion. The school are doing you a favour; helping him see what it’s all about without you having to lift a finger.

WhatWouldHopperDo · 30/11/2023 12:35

My 2 DCs went to a CofE school. 1 believes in God but doesn't have any particular involvement in religion as such. 1 is an atheist.

I am an atheist but I sometimes go to church as it's an uplifting experience.

Learning about religion is an important part of education, it doesn't mean you have to practice that religion. It would be a good opportunity to start having basic discussions about how people believe different things.

Whiskerson · 30/11/2023 12:34

Dad0f1 · 30/11/2023 12:24

Yikes! Do some of you actually read an OP fully before replying?

First of all we sent him to the CofE school as it was the best of three and ONLY options in our area.

Secondly we are NOT withdrawing him from EVERYTHING religous just certain services that offer him a form of communion that he has no concept or understanding of what is being offered to him yet.

Once he knows and understands what is being offered to him then he is free to make up his own mind if he wishes to attend these type of services or not whatever age of understanding may be.

Some of the replies appear be confusing learning about Christianity and practicing Christianity the former of which we are happy with.

At a faith school the children will not just learn about, but practice that faith.

This school was not your only option; it might not be your ideal school but you prioritised school size above whether it was a faith school. Own your choice.

As for him "understanding" the service, it sounds from what you've said that the younger children will be offered "a wafer", not an actual communion host, in order to join in. What do you think is going to happen if he eats a wafer? Why make this a tense thing? For your child it will basically be like a big assembly; all the baggage is coming from you. As with most things, children notice and remember the completely random stuff that we adults hadn't even considered - his big takeaway might be "the chairs were blue" or "Freddie bumped into me when we were going in and then Molly laughed and Mrs Smith shushed her" or "the vicar's voice sounded like Daddy Pig".