Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to deal with narcissist in parents group

93 replies

motheroffour1980 · 30/11/2023 12:00

I find it hard to interact with dominating narcissistic woman in our school’s mum group.

I am a more quiet and laid back person and I generally get on with people and don’t judge. So do most of the mums I meet typically.

However there is one category of person that I cannot bare to be around and that’s loud, abrasive, domineering, narcissistic know-it-all, shallow types.

My kids school parents get together occasionally and we all get on well enough. They are all lovely and even if we don’t all have exactly the same interests or agree on everything, we generally get on which is lovely.

However, there is one mum who is loud, nosey, overbearing and overly opinionated to a point where hers is the only one that matters.

She talks about other peoples private lives, their businesses and gossips about people who are not present getting divorced, etc. She will do this openly in front of the whole group, when many of us don’t even know her that well. It is really uncomfortable. She also bitches about some of the teachers in the school, in front of some of the mums who are actually also teachers in the school.

The main problem though is that no one challenges her, including myself in fairness, but that’s because everyone seems to gush at her and laugh along and enable her.

Other than that I know these other mums are normally lovely and wouldn’t engage in negative trash talk conversations, it’s only when she is there she brings out the worst in conversation.

It’s so frustrating. Why do these people have to come along and ruin the dynamic of groups. I foresee the group heading down a cliquey gossipy path now, when previously it had been a nice bunch.

Does anyone else find this infuriating? Not only the abrasive characters but also the weak, brown nosing, lick ass types of people who suck up to narcissists and allow them to thrive in the first place?

Please advise. What do you do in these situations when you really dislike someone and want to call them out for being nasty, but no one else does?

OP posts:
motheroffour1980 · 30/11/2023 13:36

PianPianPiano · 30/11/2023 13:28

Based on how people are reacting to me rather than the mum in question who is slandering other mums and teachers with her gossip and meanness tells me everything.

Because nobody knows the mum in question or can hear any of what she is saying, we only have your word for it that she is doing, so of course people are reacting to you rather than someone they only have your (ott and judgey) description of.

Literally every story on mumsnet is written from one point of view and it is down to readers to decide who or what they think is right or best in any situation.

OP posts:
AboutYouTalk · 30/11/2023 13:36

She sounds like a Queen bee type, the ones who are loudmouths usually don’t have as perfect a life as they make out hence trying to control Mum/parent groups. It’s their way of trying to make themselves feel better about themselves. I would not call her out on it as inevitably you will look like the bad guy whilst the others take her side. Don’t let her wind you up and concentrate on the Mums you do like and avoid her where possible.

MissBuffyAnneSummers · 30/11/2023 13:29

no one challenges her, including myself

If you are not willing to challenge her yourself then don't be a hypocrite and criticise others.

the weak, brown nosing, lick ass types of people who suck up to narcissists and allow them to thrive in the first place

That is you too OP. You are just as enabling as everyone else.

It is hugely disgusting yet no one says anything

see my points above - don't be a hypocrite

perhaps they all can’t stand her either

Possibly

I don’t want to rock the boat as I will see these people for years to come

Maybe everyone else feels the same.

You can either:

  1. Suck it up - status quo
  2. Challenge directly - risky but might get quick results
  3. Challenge more subtly - the mature sensible but slower approach
PianPianPiano · 30/11/2023 13:28

Based on how people are reacting to me rather than the mum in question who is slandering other mums and teachers with her gossip and meanness tells me everything.

Because nobody knows the mum in question or can hear any of what she is saying, we only have your word for it that she is doing, so of course people are reacting to you rather than someone they only have your (ott and judgey) description of.

motheroffour1980 · 30/11/2023 13:28

PianPianPiano · 30/11/2023 13:25

Of course people find entertainment in other peoples problems - that is literally what tabloids do, what most 'celeb gossip' is based around, how is that a surprise to you?!? Its also, let's face it, what a lot of AIBU on mumsnet is based around too.

Would you like a group of your friends or colleagues to discuss details of your own flaws, financial woes, your husband’s torrid affair, or worse your kids failings?

OP posts:
DidiAskYouThough · 30/11/2023 13:27

No one is ‘triggered’ 😄
A ‘mums group’ sounds shite, why not just be around people you like?

PianPianPiano · 30/11/2023 13:25

motheroffour1980 · 30/11/2023 13:13

I guess I would wonder why people might find discussing anothers marital affairs or financial problems entertaining?
Judging by the responses here maybe more people think it’s acceptable than I originally thought.
Maybe it’s just horrible human nature to find entertainment in other peoples problems and possibly more common than I thought.
Responses have been enlightening.

Of course people find entertainment in other peoples problems - that is literally what tabloids do, what most 'celeb gossip' is based around, how is that a surprise to you?!? Its also, let's face it, what a lot of AIBU on mumsnet is based around too.

NonPlayerCharacter · 30/11/2023 13:24

motheroffour1980 · 30/11/2023 13:13

I guess I would wonder why people might find discussing anothers marital affairs or financial problems entertaining?
Judging by the responses here maybe more people think it’s acceptable than I originally thought.
Maybe it’s just horrible human nature to find entertainment in other peoples problems and possibly more common than I thought.
Responses have been enlightening.

You aren't reading what anyone is saying. You're simply deciding they're bad people because they're questioning you and making up the worst motives.

I'm now not convinced this woman is as dreadful as you say she is. What you're saying about other posters isn't accurate but if someone who couldn't check the posts heard you say it...

motheroffour1980 · 30/11/2023 13:23

PullTheStringsAndAddSomeRings · 30/11/2023 13:16

People who post an opinion different to yours are not ‘triggered’ - they are merely disagreeing or posing an alternative POV.

To claim people are ‘triggered’ is demeaning and seems to used in order to disregard their opinion.

Well some responses here have shown a bit of hostility and anger, that’s why I used the word triggered.
Of course you’re entitled to your opinion, I just don’t understand the need for the angry tone.
Based on how people are reacting to me rather than the mum in question who is slandering other mums and teachers with her gossip and meanness tells me everything.
Perhaps more people find her behaviour socially acceptable and are more like her than I thought. So thank you for the responses.

OP posts:
BadSkiingMum · 30/11/2023 13:20

I do get what you mean - she dominates the space and is also doing so in a style that you don't like.

Like Vroomfondles says, I once had a parent-group conflict with a very exuberant and talkative parent but, as time has passed, I have recognised how this particular parent is amazing at getting things done. She also has a very generous spirit, which makes her quite easy to like, as long as you accept her for how she is: loud, extrovert and flying by the seat of her pants!

Gossip can also be fun, but there is a limit. Your description suggests that Ms HotGossip's talk tends towards the seedy end of things.

Why not challenge it? The next time there is a lull in her description of how X found Y with Z on their kitchen table just start up a new topic of conversation. Or challenge directly:

'Well this is all intriguing but we just don't know if it's true! Y and Z aren't here to set us straight, so we probably shouldn't repeat it. Any plans for the summer, Jane?'

But, if you do so, you must be prepared for people to also form views about you.

mightymam · 30/11/2023 13:20

She also can’t bare anyone with a different opinion to hers.

Just like you then @motheroffour1980! 😂

Verv · 30/11/2023 13:19

Being crass / opinionated doesn't make you a narcissist, a word which has become woefully overused these days.

Anyway, you've got two options -

Do nothing say nothing or tell her to knock it off when she starts.

Vuurhoutjies · 30/11/2023 13:19

Yes, I think that's a bit of a weak basis to call her a narcissist.

Moving on to the meat of the issue - what to do. It's pretty simple. Don't join in. When she is saying or doing inappropriate things, either politely say, "ooh, I don't think we should be talking about that" or casually get up and wander off. By sitting there silently, you are as much to blame as everyone else.

Then, instead of feeling obliged to have this one amorphous group, start developing personal friendships with a smaller group. If there are three or four women you get on particularly well with, suggest a meet up separately.

Incidentally, I was tangentially in a similar position a few years ago. Was invited along to something with some other mums, not all of whom I knew that well. One was going on and on about one child's parent being in jail etc. It was all hot gossip and very unpleasant. So I said, "Oh, how do you even know this? I'm not sure it's something we should all be speculating about" and she said, "Oh, the child told me herself, she's in my brownies group". I was quite shocked so said something like, "oh, are you sure you should be talking about something she told you like that". She was dismissive. So I quietly sat back, then went to the bathroom and managed to manoeuvre myself into a different seat on my return. I also didn't accept that same invite the following year.

PullTheStringsAndAddSomeRings · 30/11/2023 13:16

People who post an opinion different to yours are not ‘triggered’ - they are merely disagreeing or posing an alternative POV.

To claim people are ‘triggered’ is demeaning and seems to used in order to disregard their opinion.

TillyTrifle · 30/11/2023 13:15

Is it just me who finds the current trend for accusing anyone who doesn’t agree with you of being ‘triggered’ immensely tedious? It’s so condescending and obviously just you trying to make the fact that someone thinks differently to you a problem with them instead of just a plain old different viewpoint.

They’re not triggered. They just don’t agree with you. Try listening to their views and considering them instead of immediately accusing them of being ‘triggered’ as if that’s some kind of failing on their part. You don’t have to agree with them but please stop being so defensive and leaping to use that awful phrase. It doesn’t have nearly the gotcha effect that people seem to think it does.

motheroffour1980 · 30/11/2023 13:13

LittleStringOfFairyLights · 30/11/2023 13:01

Surely you just carry on with your day? You are in a group situation so she isn't the only one there to talk to.
You find her rude, loud and gossipy, others may find her enthusiastic and entertaining. Tread carefully or you could be the one that doesn't come out of this very well.

I guess I would wonder why people might find discussing anothers marital affairs or financial problems entertaining?
Judging by the responses here maybe more people think it’s acceptable than I originally thought.
Maybe it’s just horrible human nature to find entertainment in other peoples problems and possibly more common than I thought.
Responses have been enlightening.

OP posts:
mrlistersgelfbride · 30/11/2023 13:13

I'm the quiet laidback type too. I'm never going to be one of the loud confident mums or in the cliques. (Mumsnet doesn't like this term to describe school parents, but they do exist!).

My advice would be step back from the mums group a bit, you can't change people's personalities but you don't need to hang round with folk that you don't like.
You can still be civil, friendly, but you don't have to meet up with them (as much). You don't want to get into bitching about any of them, it causes problems.

How old are your children?
You can make different parent friends at school as your kids grow up, through different hobbies, etc.

uninterestingusernamealert · 30/11/2023 13:12

Well you can either avoid her or challenge her really. Don't just whine anonymously about her, that's no better than what she's doing. Worse really, because at least she's not anonymous.

You don't need to be aggressive or rude about it.

Next time she starts slagging someone off I would (and have before) said "I really don't like to talk about other people when they're not here to say their piece or defend themselves, so can we just not?" Then change the subject.

If it's about teachers at school (I'm amazed the mums who're also teachers haven't said this frankly) then similar to above but along the lines of 'this is really not appropriate, and it's pretty unfair on Mary and Gill as they work there so now they're in a bit of an awkward position. Why don't you discuss with the school?'

If it's gossiping about people marriages etc - similar. "No one knows what goes on behind closed doors and I'd rather not gossip about people behind their backs. Why don't you ask Susan yourself, if you're curious about Jim and the barmaid?"

You need to politely and assertively call it out, avoid her, or you'll have to put up and shut up!

squeekychicken · 30/11/2023 13:07

If it made me feel uncomfortable due to unnecessary over sharing I'd prob jokingly say 'I really don't want to know all this' and try and change the convo.

motheroffour1980 · 30/11/2023 13:07

genesis92 · 30/11/2023 12:30

Everyone is different. If everyone in the world was meek and quiet, it would be pretty boring. Is there a bit of jealousy perhaps? Not trying to be nasty, just maybe there's elements of her you wished you had.

If she really is that awful though, people just won't want to be friends with her.

I'm fairly loud and confident, and I find it hard meeting people who are inherently quiet and placid. I like someone who has strong opinions and can stand up for themselves.

But I never said I had a problem with her being loud! Why did that trigger you?
It’s her being loud along with all the other horrible things which makes her extra challenging. Most of my amazing friends are extroverts!

I think in order to have a “not boring” world we do not need more trash talking people. There are multiple ways to create an exciting world, while also being kind.

OP posts:
NonPlayerCharacter · 30/11/2023 13:06

I don’t know why I’m triggering so many people here. I’m talking specifically about this one isolated situation here with a person I find difficult. Does no one ever encounter difficult people or people they dislike?

The fact that you've taken a less than universally positive response as you "triggering" people for no valid reason might be part of it...

Of course we all encounter people we don't like. But we don't always pathologise it. And some of us find that person who quietly seethes but wants someone else to do something about it, or who sets up the tired old "I'm an introvert, extroverts are so xyz" stuff, to be one of those characters we just don't gel with.

If she really is as sincerely awful and universally disliked as you say but nobody else is saying anything, they probably have the same reasons as you. You can't control who's in a group like this so just suck it up (unless she really is outrageously offensive) and focus on the people who are your type.

motheroffour1980 · 30/11/2023 13:03

NonPlayerCharacter · 30/11/2023 12:54

I wasn't going to say it but I'm glad others have. She doesn't have a diagnosable personality disorder (there's actually no consensus on whether NPD is real anyway; all of us are "narcissistic" at some level) just because you don't like her personality. I'm a bit weary of people pathologising personality clashes.

If she's that genuinely awful, nobody will truly like or be there for her so it's pretty self-regulating in that regard. If she's just not your type of person, focus on nurturing friendships with the people who are.

It’s not that I don’t specially dislike her personality. It’s the horrible things she says that are so inappropriate that I detest.
And I believe she is a narcissist because she continuously brags about how her family are perfect while others are all flawed. She also can’t bare anyone with a different opinion to hers.

OP posts:
LittleStringOfFairyLights · 30/11/2023 13:01

Surely you just carry on with your day? You are in a group situation so she isn't the only one there to talk to.
You find her rude, loud and gossipy, others may find her enthusiastic and entertaining. Tread carefully or you could be the one that doesn't come out of this very well.

fairybaby · 30/11/2023 13:00

As someone who in the past would have openly clashed with the annoying person, I would a) avoid her like a plague; b) take the opportunity to reflect on what is going on because inevitably this is about me as much as it is about her and c) maybe consider if this mum group is right for you. If the other mums are okay with this type of negativity, you won't be able to change the group dynamics on your own.

motheroffour1980 · 30/11/2023 12:57

I don’t know why I’m triggering so many people here. I’m talking specifically about this one isolated situation here with a person I find difficult. Does no one ever encounter difficult people or people they dislike?
The only one judging is this horrible woman who goes into great detail about other kind peoples private business including intimate details of marital affairs and others financial difficulties, all at a large table of people who don’t know each other that well.
It is hugely disgusting yet no one says anything so I feel I unsure of what to do. (perhaps they all can’t stand her either)
As someone else mentioend, it is a difficult situation being my kids school group and I don’t want to rock the boat as I will see these people for years to come.
Surely you’ve all encounter this catch 22 situation in your workplaces, etc. I just want advice, not to trigger or offend anyone!

OP posts: