Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Group work issues at uni - AIBU to not be happy with the lecturer's response?

121 replies

groupworkblues · 30/11/2023 10:25

We have to give a group presentation next week as a group of 6. Two of the members have not been turning up to meetings and ignoring WhatsApp messages and emails sent to their university email address. They will turn up to the occasional meeting, but miss most of them. Most of the time they won't message or give any reason for missing the meeting, or they will let us know during the meeting that they can't attend due to work, a society meeting (where they were doing craft activities, so nothing compulsory) or an appointment they would have know about in advance. They make no attempt to reschedule the meeting or flag to us in advance to ask us to change the date/time.

Their contributions to the presentation has been pretty rubbish. Both aren't really relevant to what was asked of them and they both have misunderstood what was needed (and we've not been able to clarify as they're not in the meetings).

We spoke to the lecturer as our attempts of speaking to them on WhatsApp, email and in person haven't helped. They responded that they were frustrated for us, but if we want a good grade we'll have to just get on with it and do their sections ourselves.

OP posts:
Catza · 30/11/2023 15:03

Dubbledup · 30/11/2023 13:43

And as I said I do (30-40 is a fail) I just don't like going really low as you're basically failing them for the piece of work they haven't even started at that point too.

I personally design group work so it is a small % and used as feedforward so operates as 1/ a way to kick students into thinking about their later individual assignment and 2/ to provide detailed feedback which they can use for their individual assignment later on. If we make it informal/formative they won't do it. Obviously it changes things if the group work is 100% of a module.

This doesn't make any sense. You mark them at deadline, if they haven't started the work before the submission deadline then the work should be marked 0. What exactly are you marking as 30%? Lack of any work?
So if they don't submit their essay, do you also mark it as 30% because the circumstances are identical - the work is due and they haven't started it.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/11/2023 14:46

Actions (or lack of) should have consequences.

Now there's a novel concept!!

user1497207191 · 30/11/2023 14:37

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/11/2023 13:13

Surely that should be on them if they have contributed fuck all to the group?

The problem at many institutions is that people know they won't be failed on group projects. They're essentially guaranteed a free ride so there is little incentive for them to contribute.

I think it's pretty lazy practice on behalf of the academics tbh. If you're going to assign group projects, you should design them to be fair and you should have the balls to mark people down if they don't contribute.

I agree it's lazy and unfair. Just "giving" 40% to people who've made no effort is ridiculous. If them getting less (or 0%) means them failing the module, then tough! Actions (or lack of) should have consequences.

Zamzamzamdeedah · 30/11/2023 14:34

That's a good point. So it's "academia life"

MMMarmite · 30/11/2023 14:29

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/11/2023 14:27

This is simply just teaching people to tolerate useless colleagues and the useless that they will be tolerated.

To be fair, for some academics who haven't ever worked outside academia, that might just be what the world of work looks like. When I worked in HE, the management of academics was often extremely "light touch" and crap people were allowed to float around for years without anyone doing anything about it. So maybe some just think that's the norm?

Edited

That's true actually, I'm often amazed by stories from friends who work at universities.
I'm like "why don't you fire them?"
"Oh, we can't do that."

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/11/2023 14:27

This is simply just teaching people to tolerate useless colleagues and the useless that they will be tolerated.

To be fair, for some academics who haven't ever worked outside academia, that might just be what the world of work looks like. When I worked in HE, the management of academics was often extremely "light touch" and crap people were allowed to float around for years without anyone doing anything about it. So maybe some just think that's the norm?

Zamzamzamdeedah · 30/11/2023 14:20

I had this. Lecturer said the same as others. I counteracted that at work I would go to LM and something would be done, people moved around etc, so no. It's not "life". This is simply just teaching people to tolerate useless colleagues and the uselles that they will be tolerated.
He said to deal with it. So we did. We fired the person doing absolutely nothing from the project, notified the lecturer that it has been dealt with and how and that the matter is now closed. Even followed written warnings procedure. Did that part of presentation ourselves so no reason for some slacker to get credit.
I was easily annoyed mature student. Never had group work issues for the remaining time at uni.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/11/2023 14:07

WhatPostDoc · 30/11/2023 13:59

I've worked at unis before where there are 'fail criteria'. If they turn up, do the bare minimum and don't do anything to meet the criteria to actually fail them, they get 40.

Having previously worked in HE, I can well believe it. It's a shame that the academics involved don't have the courage and the integrity to push back on this a bit harder. I do appreciate that they have their career to think about and bills to pay etc, but dumbing down our universities to that extent is shameful, and it won't help anyone in the long term as degrees will become increasingly worthless as employers start to realise what's happening.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/11/2023 14:03

Hobbi · 30/11/2023 13:51

Absolutely. The mantra of external examiners is, 'have you considered other forms of assessment?' Often seems just for the sake of it. As an external, I suggested other forms of assessment but not group assessments. It can be done if students are able to log their contributions or if the assessment part of the assignment is about presentation skills or analysis of the process. There's also interesting work being done around assessment AS learning, wherein the process of group work is assessed in real time. Alverno College in the USA has some excellent examples of this, often using partners from local businesses to help with the process.

I can absolutely see the value of assessing the process of group work in real time, and of involving local businesses in this. That could offer genuine opportunities for learning and developing collaborative skills.

A written group assignment where everyone gets the same grade and the marker has no idea which student has written which bit... not so much.

WhatPostDoc · 30/11/2023 13:59

user1497207191 · 30/11/2023 13:00

Why would you give a non contributor such a high mark of 40%??

I've worked at unis before where there are 'fail criteria'. If they turn up, do the bare minimum and don't do anything to meet the criteria to actually fail them, they get 40.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/11/2023 13:57

Dubbledup · 30/11/2023 13:53

I've had few instances where they've not done anything at all or where contribution is disputed. Typically, when we get complaints it's by more conscientious students who plan ahead get annoyed it's not complete a week before deadline, then the procrastinators suddenly do a lot the night before. So generally it's different styles of working. If they truly haven't done anything and admit to that then I'll mark them accordingly. I think this has happened about twice in 16 years. Regular checking in with groups in seminars helps to alleviate some of the issues. Its hard work managing the groups as a result though, which is why more and more modules are going to 100% exam.

There will be plenty of occasions when people have done fuck all and you just don't know about it. People give up raising it in the end, because nothing is done. They just suck it up because there is no choice.

And I disagree that it's simply down to different styles of working. I have adhd and am a major procrastinator/last minute merchant, but I absolutely did more than my fair share on every single group assignment that I ever did.

And having interviewed literally hundreds of students over the years with questions about teamwork, I think my experience is the norm. Most groups will have at least one student who contributes nothing.

Dubbledup · 30/11/2023 13:53

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/11/2023 13:47

But if they have done nothing on the group task, why do you think they deserve 30%?

Yes, a lower mark might mean that they fail the whole module, but if they're smart enough to do university level work, presumably they're smart enough to work out that they need to do some work to get some marks?

You say that they won't do it if you make it informal/formative, but you seem to be missing the point that some aren't doing it anyway. Why is it that you think it's fair for those individuals to get the credit for other people's work?

Edited

I've had few instances where they've not done anything at all or where contribution is disputed. Typically, when we get complaints it's by more conscientious students who plan ahead get annoyed it's not complete a week before deadline, then the procrastinators suddenly do a lot the night before. So generally it's different styles of working. If they truly haven't done anything and admit to that then I'll mark them accordingly. I think this has happened about twice in 16 years. Regular checking in with groups in seminars helps to alleviate some of the issues. Its hard work managing the groups as a result though, which is why more and more modules are going to 100% exam.

Hobbi · 30/11/2023 13:51

WaitingRoomBoredom · 30/11/2023 13:25

I never set group assessments for this reason. But we are encouraged to have them because it diversifies the assessment tasks which is apparently popular with students and it's good preparation for the workplace. If you don't like them or want them assessing differently, tell your lecturer and your student rep.

Absolutely. The mantra of external examiners is, 'have you considered other forms of assessment?' Often seems just for the sake of it. As an external, I suggested other forms of assessment but not group assessments. It can be done if students are able to log their contributions or if the assessment part of the assignment is about presentation skills or analysis of the process. There's also interesting work being done around assessment AS learning, wherein the process of group work is assessed in real time. Alverno College in the USA has some excellent examples of this, often using partners from local businesses to help with the process.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/11/2023 13:50

All of the people on my MBA course were experienced managers to a greater or lesser degree. All of us were experienced at working in teams etc. The group projects did not help anyone develop any transferable skills as far as I could see. However, they probably did cut down quite significantly on the amount of marking that the lecturers needed to do. Call me cynical, but I do think that there are reasons for doing these group assignments that have nothing to do with any real or perceived educational benefit.

And if it really is about the educational value in getting people to work in a group, then academics need to design the assessments so that the marking is based on the process of collaboration rather than the end product. Otherwise, it is a completely pointless exercise from which the students will learn nothing.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/11/2023 13:47

Dubbledup · 30/11/2023 13:43

And as I said I do (30-40 is a fail) I just don't like going really low as you're basically failing them for the piece of work they haven't even started at that point too.

I personally design group work so it is a small % and used as feedforward so operates as 1/ a way to kick students into thinking about their later individual assignment and 2/ to provide detailed feedback which they can use for their individual assignment later on. If we make it informal/formative they won't do it. Obviously it changes things if the group work is 100% of a module.

But if they have done nothing on the group task, why do you think they deserve 30%?

Yes, a lower mark might mean that they fail the whole module, but if they're smart enough to do university level work, presumably they're smart enough to work out that they need to do some work to get some marks?

You say that they won't do it if you make it informal/formative, but you seem to be missing the point that some aren't doing it anyway. Why is it that you think it's fair for those individuals to get the credit for other people's work?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/11/2023 13:44

Bobtheamazinggingerdog · 30/11/2023 13:14

Seeing how you manage shitty group members is part of the assessment. I assume you'll have to write some kind of reflection on the process? Remember forming, storming and norming? This is your storming process. Focus on the task at hand and get it done. Tear them to pieces in your reflection 😁

None of the group assignments that I was required to do on my MBA (at a well respected business school!) included any reflective elements.

There was one module that did include a reflective piece on a group task, but it was only the individual reflection that was graded, and not the group task itself. That was much better imo.

Dubbledup · 30/11/2023 13:43

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/11/2023 13:13

Surely that should be on them if they have contributed fuck all to the group?

The problem at many institutions is that people know they won't be failed on group projects. They're essentially guaranteed a free ride so there is little incentive for them to contribute.

I think it's pretty lazy practice on behalf of the academics tbh. If you're going to assign group projects, you should design them to be fair and you should have the balls to mark people down if they don't contribute.

And as I said I do (30-40 is a fail) I just don't like going really low as you're basically failing them for the piece of work they haven't even started at that point too.

I personally design group work so it is a small % and used as feedforward so operates as 1/ a way to kick students into thinking about their later individual assignment and 2/ to provide detailed feedback which they can use for their individual assignment later on. If we make it informal/formative they won't do it. Obviously it changes things if the group work is 100% of a module.

WaitingRoomBoredom · 30/11/2023 13:25

I never set group assessments for this reason. But we are encouraged to have them because it diversifies the assessment tasks which is apparently popular with students and it's good preparation for the workplace. If you don't like them or want them assessing differently, tell your lecturer and your student rep.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/11/2023 13:22

Beenaboutabit · 30/11/2023 13:17

Working in and managed group work is part of your education. It’s not good when group members don’t contribute but how the rest of the group rise to the challenge of dealing with this is important and develops transferable skills.
good luck!

I think that's the theory. I don't think it's true in practice.

DeeCeeCherry · 30/11/2023 13:21

DD had this exact issue. We discussed it and then she aporoached Lecturer to say she no longer wished to be linked with this student, and why. Request was granted.

Im surprised at the 'do their work if they won't' attitude of some pp's. it's really not a good mindset to foist on a young person, that they should carry lazy people. & Uni isnt free so getting the best out of it is important, not being blighted by some lazy bod & lecturer, then not speaking up.

I guess some have been to Uni's that have shit lecturers...

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/11/2023 13:19

Sayitaintso33 · 30/11/2023 13:08

I'm with the lecturer.

I don't think I have ever seen a CV without a claim that they work well in a team. Well I've discovered today that many people lack this most basic of workplace skills.

It isn't comparable though. In a group assignment, everyone is equal. They have no leverage with which to manage their peers. There are no consequences to doing fuck all if marks are awarded for the group and not the individual. The only way in which other group members can "manage" the situation, if all reasonable attempts to secure cooperation gap fail, is to suck it up and do the extra work themselves.

In an employment situation, there is a manager and the potential to be fired if you don't do the job that is required of you. Yes, there are crap managers who don't do their jobs properly, but in theory at least, there is a mechanism to get rid.

It's lazy on the part of the lecturers to suggest that academic group work is comparable to teamwork in the real world. It isn't.

Beenaboutabit · 30/11/2023 13:17

Working in and managed group work is part of your education. It’s not good when group members don’t contribute but how the rest of the group rise to the challenge of dealing with this is important and develops transferable skills.
good luck!

lanthanum · 30/11/2023 13:16

I did a groupwork assignment where the lecturer said that he would mark out of 60, and that would be divided amongst us equally unless we let him know that we'd like it divided differently. I was ill for the first two weeks, and considered ducking out altogether and letting the others have the marks.

tortoiseshellcats · 30/11/2023 13:14

I've been through this too and so has pretty much everyone I met at uni! Unfortunately the only thing we could do was to split up the presentation and then all do our own slides/speaking so that it was obvious who hadn't done anything but the rest of us would still pass. I know that's not always possible though, was lucky to have lecturers who marked us separately

Catza · 30/11/2023 13:14

Dubbledup · 30/11/2023 13:07

You might need to 'pass' at 40 just, as repeating the assignment isn't an option. It also depends on the weighting of the coursework. I'm disinclined to give makes of under 30 to people for assessments that are worth 20-30% of a module because it can mean they have no hope of regaining a pass for the full module even if they do really well in a second different assessment.

But surely failing are the consequences of not doing the work? And if they don't learn it at uni, where will they? Is it fair that we then have to manage the very same issues in the workplace where a graduate shows up expecting to "get a pass" for not actually doing very much at all?