Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To this this wage is far too low?

142 replies

thirtytalking · 30/11/2023 10:14

I work as a dental nurse. Have to pay £55 a day childcare, have to pay £120 a year subscription to the GCC, and £40 a year for a CPD programme. It's hard, stressful work.

I get £11.20 an hour. I thought that was bad. Talking to others who have been there longer, they don't even earn that. Some have done extra courses and have other duties and have been refused a pay rise.

I worked in pubs and came home with more. I claim UC and the pay is so low (I only do a few days) it's triggered a back to work meeting. In my last job there was no stress, I didn't have to be qualified or pay anything.. I just served a few drinks and came home with more money. It's a joke.

OP posts:
CocoChanellee · 01/12/2023 09:35

BarbaraofSeville · 01/12/2023 08:53

That's not a salary band on gov.uk, just an indication of average pay. Dental nursing in hospitals, or other large public sector employers like the military will pay banded salaries, but the vast majority of dentists are small businesses who are free to set pay and conditions how they like, as long as they comply with statutory requirements.

The salary came from this NHS site, which I assume shows the pay scales.

https://www.healthcareers.nhs.uk/working-health/working-nhs/nhs-pay-and-benefits/agenda-change-pay-rates

The title of 'nurse' is slightly misleading as it's not the same as a nurse in the NHS where you are a graduate.

For someone with very little beyond the basic training, it's not a terrible salary.

The issue with the OP is she only wants to work 15 hours.

Tatumm · 01/12/2023 09:28

So I would see if you can do your job at another practice with a higher salary. You might be able to ask for a pay rise where you are. I think you have options but it’s terrible your pay is so low.

BarbaraofSeville · 01/12/2023 09:25

I think it's really wrong in this country that even a full time job on minimum wage isn't enough to live on for a single parent with bills/mortgage or whatever

But how would that work? To earn enough as a single parent in a high cost area to pay for housing, childcare, bills, food might mean you'd need about £5k+ pm coming in, which is a salary of well over £100k pa for someone with a student loan and pension contributions of 5% of their salary.

If we started paying everyone £100k pa, then everything would get a lot more expensive and suddenly even £100k wouldn't be enough.

Or if you have a partner or don't have childcare bills you could afford to work for less so who would employ a single parent who needs to earn over £100k pa when others would be happy to be paid half that because their essential expenses are lower and they have a partner?

Topping up wages with UC according to differences in essential costs targets help towards those who need it, but that's a separate issue from the OPs problem, which is mainly that her hourly rate has likely stagnated compared with the increased NMW so now isn't seeing pay matching the experience and qualifications required, as well as feeling the squeeze in living costs.

honeylulu · 01/12/2023 09:15

It's really shockingly low paid for a professional job/qualification. I was aware of this as my son was considering an apprenticeship instead of uni and when he was looking to see what the options were there were LOADS of dental nursing apprenticeships. But when we looked into what a full time salary would be after qualifying it would have been £17k.

When I was at uni we were told to aim for £15k as a first starting salary and that was nearly 30 years ago!

There seems to be hardly any NHS dentists now and the appointments aren't cheap so I'm surprised dental nurse salaries haven't gone up more.

Paddleboarder · 01/12/2023 09:11

I work as a supply teaching assistant. It's a bit more money than if I had a contract although obviously it's a term time job. I like it though because I don't get sucked into any politics and I am free to accept or decline the work, of which there is plenty!

I think it's really wrong in this country that even a full time job on minimum wage isn't enough to live on for a single parent with bills/mortgage or whatever.

(Edited to say I don't think you said you were a single parent, but I am!)

LakieLady · 01/12/2023 09:01

I had no idea that dental nursing was so badly paid (I've looked at the pay rates for dental nurses in my area and they seem to top out at around £12ph, which is appalling for an expensive area in the SE), and I think it's an absolute disgrace. I know people with no qualifications working as carers and support workers who are earning more than that, and that sort of work is notoriously badly paid.

Is there a hospital near you with a dentistry department, OP? The pay might be better, and the pension and other conditions definitely would.

With regard to your UC, it's more to do with the money than the hours you work. When your youngest is 3 or 4, they will expect you to earn the equivalent of 16 hours x NMW, at ages 5-12, this rises to 25 hours. If your pay is below these thresholds, they will expect you to look for more hours or a job with better pay. Getting a better paid job would get them off your case without you working more hours.

Beezknees · 01/12/2023 09:00

WeekWeekWeek · 01/12/2023 08:17

the pay is so low (I only do a few days) it's triggered a back to work meeting

Can you explain what you mean by this, OP?

I don’t get how a low salary could trigger a back to work meeting.

Edited

She claims UC, you are required to work a certain amount of hours or earn a certain amount to claim otherwise they make you look for more work.

BubbleBubbleBubbleBubblePop · 01/12/2023 09:00

I was a dental nurse for a couple of years after leaving school. It was low paid because it wasn't really a qualified role as such. Yes, you could do further courses but they weren't essential and the courses that you did do were very basic ie how to sterilise equipment etc. It was a mix of admin stuff and preparing the equipment that the dentist would need, infection control etc. The majority of work is NMW in private dental surgeries. Its not really on the same level of a nurse or other AHP, I think the name of dental 'nurse' is a little misleading. I mean no disrespect with that, as I say, I did the role myself.

OP if you're keen to progress career wise, there are degree level qualifications such as in oral health etc. An NHS dental nurse is quite different from a dental 'nurse' in private practice; you do get some who have gone through further education but they would work in roles in dental hospitals etc carrying out more complex duties. Perhaps have a look at qualifications that you could do (if its something that you wanted to progress in), it would give you a much wider scope of practice and obviously a better wage.

Lucyh999 · 01/12/2023 08:58

I think all of this sounds unsustainable. I’m sorry the pay is so low, that is really tough. It’s amazing how little some organisations pay and how they expect people to live on that. If you’re not getting anything out of it, I’d recommend you leave as financially it doesn’t work and you’re not enjoying it.

good luck in whatever you decide, it’s really tough.

Lucyh999 · 01/12/2023 08:55

piperpheobepruepaige · 30/11/2023 10:28

I work as a dental nurse. Have to pay £55 a day childcare, have to pay £120 a year subscription to the GCC, and £40 a year for a CPD programme. It's hard, stressful work.

I get £11.20 an hour

You cant include your childcare as part of your pay - obviously you cannot work without paying for the care, but it was a choice to have a child, not a necessity of the job.

Its crap - you're right - how many hours do you work?
Does it put you below min wage having to pay £160 a year for subscriptions?
What happens if someone is part time, does that cost come down?

I don’t think she is including childcare, she is just setting the scene.

BarbaraofSeville · 01/12/2023 08:53

That's not a salary band on gov.uk, just an indication of average pay. Dental nursing in hospitals, or other large public sector employers like the military will pay banded salaries, but the vast majority of dentists are small businesses who are free to set pay and conditions how they like, as long as they comply with statutory requirements.

CocoChanellee · 01/12/2023 08:51

This is the info from the NHS website on pay @thirtytalking You sound underpaid and need to talk to your employer, while you look for another job. If you have 8 years' experience you should earn the higher salary here.

Band 4
< 3 years' experience £25,147
3+ years £27,596
Examples of roles at band 4 - assistant practitioner, audio visual technician, pharmacy technician, dental nurse and theatre support worker.

CocoChanellee · 01/12/2023 08:45

Or on the other hand, maybe most are now owned by venture capital companies that scoop up the fat profits and pay staff miserable wages.

LOL there isn't enough money in dentistry for venture capital.

Most of the dentists where I live are private. They are owned solely by the dentist and mine is run by a family who opened it years ago.

I don't understand why the OP is on the bottom of the salary band.
There IS a band as it's listed as such on Gov.uk
Either her experience isn't being taken into account or she's not updated her training, or she's accepted a low band.

Any ideas @thirtytalking ?

Tatumm · 01/12/2023 08:39

Do you have a union or anyone in the industry that can advise you? What is the broader picture for your industry? It seems a pity to give up something skilled without exploring the options within that industry.

Given that private dentistry is so expensive for individuals, maybe some practices pay better. Or on the other hand, maybe most are now owned by venture capital companies that scoop up the fat profits and pay staff miserable wages. ….Worthy of journalistic investigation actually!

Chocoswirl · 01/12/2023 08:35

Most (all?) dental practices are private now, so if you look elsewhere you may find one that offers a better rate of pay? Don’t let them screw you over, I bet the patients are charged phenomenal amounts of money. More of it should be coming to you!

Bananazebra · 01/12/2023 08:32

I'm pretty sure you posted about this a few weeks ago and the fact that the other dental nurses are horrible. So you don't even like your colleagues. I don't think there's much reason to stay at this point.

CocoChanellee · 01/12/2023 08:26

According to Gov.Uk, the range of salary is £23K - £35K pa depending on experience.

Where on the scale are you?

Is your experience not being taken into account @thirtytalking

Nottodaty · 01/12/2023 08:26

I was a qualified dental nurse (many years ago) hours long, expectations - pay was just a tiny bit more than minimal wage, no sick pay. Expected to manage a room - ordering etc, the front desk, phone calls , diaries, patients and a lot more! I worked 7:30 to prep the room to 6.30 & Saturday mornings. As a qualified Dental Nurse I received 15p more an hour than a non qualified staff member.

I left as I wanted to progress but couldn’t do the course as they wouldn’t slightly change my hours. And I was completely restricted when I could take leave. I lived no where near my family and at the time couldn’t afford a car - one Christmas planned to travel down Christmas Eve and asked for the day of after Boxing Day to travel back - was told no I had to come in - I handed my notice in.

GetYourBaublesOut · 01/12/2023 08:24

YANBU - it's a very low wage for a qualified, experienced professional.

Wouldn't blame you for leaving.

Runnerduck34 · 01/12/2023 08:21

It is low, I have a friend who was a dental nurse who studied to be a nurse after being fed up of such low pay with no prospect of better wages staying in the same job.
Would you consider retraining? You will have transferable skills.
Can you ask your employer to pay your registration/ professional body membership fees? I think morally they should pay these but of course aren't obliged to.
Unfortunately I think dental nurses are under paid
Another example of very low pay for qualified job is a vetinary nurse.
Both jobs female dominated.

Irishmama100 · 01/12/2023 08:21

That is scandalous. My 16 year old has a part time retail job that pays £11 an hour. To have to actually pay money to work for that rate is soo bad.

CocoChanellee · 01/12/2023 08:19

OP isn't paid enough to pay tax

She must pay NI as the income bar is set very low for that.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 01/12/2023 08:18

mamma65432 · 01/12/2023 08:17

Could you not ask for a pay rise in the first instance? and the child care should be tax free shouldn't it?

OP isn't paid enough to pay tax

CocoChanellee · 01/12/2023 08:17

Are there different grades of dental nurses?

As a patient (I go to a private dentist) the assistant in the room simply does paperwork (record keeping) or hands the dentist the tools they need. They don't do anything clinical. At the very most they might use the aspirator, but that's it.

What does your role involve?

WeekWeekWeek · 01/12/2023 08:17

the pay is so low (I only do a few days) it's triggered a back to work meeting

Can you explain what you mean by this, OP?

I don’t get how a low salary could trigger a back to work meeting.