Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think it was not possible for Carole Middleton to engineer her daughters marriage?

330 replies

Bahhumbug23 · 30/11/2023 10:05

https://www.marieclaire.com/celebrity/royals/carole-middleton-master-plan/

Kate was staunchly middle class. The royals are notoriously snobby. Aibu to think that Carole did not & wouldn't be capable of engineering this? How the hell would she be able to do this?!

It Was Apparently Always Carole Middleton’s Master Plan for Eldest Daughter Kate to Meet and Woo Prince William, New Book Claims

“Carole set things up, and Kate took it the rest of the way.”

https://www.marieclaire.com/celebrity/royals/carole-middleton-master-plan

OP posts:
User1775 · 30/11/2023 11:34

Catherine married down, a man of below average intelligence and average looks. She is a stunner, very clever, very hard working. Without the Head Girl of the UK the RF would be in deep deep shit right now. They owe Carole a deep gratitude.

Hamburgler666 · 30/11/2023 11:33

They definitely took steps to put her in the running, so to speak.

She was supposed to go to Edinburgh and she transferred to St A's once it was announced he was going there.

He did a gap year/placement thing, she tried to get on to exactly the same one but couldn't.

I do believe the stories from girls she went to school with, that she fancied him and had posters on her wall. As much as she might try to deny it, because it's embarrassing!

Of course the mother couldn't engineer the entire relationship, but I think Kate was strategically placed for it to be a possibility and it worked!

aquickquestion1 · 30/11/2023 11:32

She literally changed her university, deferred a year, took the same exams and purposefully got his attention dressed in lingerie. There was manipulation there from day1. Will never understand why people like Kate.

O2HaveALittleHouse · 30/11/2023 11:31

I find this idea hilarious. Anyone who knows the university entry system knows you need to apply, get offers, achieve the grades.. You can’t just see that Prince William is off to St Andrews and blindly follow.
Tabloid nonsense.

Mikimoto · 30/11/2023 11:31

if Katie Caballo is a 6, W. is more like a 2, so there's also that aspect, making it more feasible.

PippyLongTits · 30/11/2023 11:30

They engineered for their daughter to be well educated and go to a prestigious university. What monsters!

Anyone think maybe graduation was their end game, not marriage?

CornTheCob · 30/11/2023 11:29

You can take a horse to water....

I'm not calling Kate a horse btw.

Luddite26 · 30/11/2023 11:28

I had a niece at the time who was obsessed with PW and was so excited that he was going to St Andrews. If they had got together I wouldn't have thought it was stalking! Kate was in a play at school where she says she wants to marry PW. This has all been taken out of extreme context.the press just love bashing The Middleton's. And yes it is misogyny. I think they do well to keep their mouths shut.
Nobody mentions Johnnie Spencer's hopes for one of his daughter's to marry Charles.
Debutantes it was the way of the aristocracy. The Queen Mother fancied her chances with Edward V111 but he found her boring and dumpy and she landed his brother.

Supersimkin2 · 30/11/2023 11:25

Ridic.

The family are social climbers but no one’s that good. The culture of St A means all the poshos stick together in three streets so meeting was likely regardless of whether the unfortunate girl fancied him or not. St A is better for history of art, anyway.

Thepeopleversuswork · 30/11/2023 11:25

My middle class parents were keen for me to move upwards but what they encouraged was for me to get myself a great career

This. What’s slightly surprising and depressing about the Middleton parents is that they thought the best that a very bright, confident and attractive daughter could achieve was to be married into a gilded cage. It’s pretty medieval.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 30/11/2023 11:24

Naptrappedmummy · 30/11/2023 10:08

YANBU. You can of course move in the right circles but you can’t force somebody to marry your daughter it’s ridiculous. I find a lot of people to be very jealous of the Middletons.

I agree. You can definitely do your best to "engineer" a certain kind of match in this situation.

Ensuring that your beautiful, heterosexual daughter mingles with "certain kinds" of men? Encouraging her to present herself in a certain manner?
Absolutely.

But making sure that this many would be PW? No.

IDoughnutKnow · 30/11/2023 11:24

Jonad · 30/11/2023 11:20

I think it’s fair to say they were pushed into the ‘right’ circles, given that Pippa used to befriend men with titles/land etc, the future Duke of Northumberland etc. But that’s maybe a much more normal thing to do if you’re upper middle class?

Those are the people your children tend to socialise with if they go to particular schools. Not because it's "engineered" as such, but just because they become friends in the same way as all young people do at their schools.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 30/11/2023 11:24

Fulshaw · 30/11/2023 10:53

Misogynistic bullshit. The scheming, plotting mother.

I think the Middletons have always carried themselves with dignity.

And doing what parents have done for centuries - manoeuvring for a good advantageous marriage for their offspring. The Middletons, of course, are a self-made family who have done very well for themselves but they're trade, of course, my dear. Utterly beyond the pale.

IMO a lot of Kate's appeal for PW to start with was her family. Warm, loving, supportive and kind.

Sparthan · 30/11/2023 11:23

I think Carole intended for her daughter to marry someone with a title. The Middletons had become quite rich but a title is the one thing money can’t buy. So I have no trouble believing she purposely sent Kate to St Andrew’s and wangled her onto the same course as William, with the hope of befriending him and mixing with his circle. But she had no idea that Kate would snag William himself, I think she was aiming more for one of his titled friends and got lucky.

Sunnydays41 · 30/11/2023 11:23

Aprilx · 30/11/2023 11:19

He transferred to Geography in his second year, he did History of Art in in his first year and that is when he met Kate.

Of course Carole could not engineer a relationship and marriage, but deferring a year, switching university, switching course always seemed to me like attempts to engineer to put her in the same place. She also went to Chile on a Raleigh Expedition just weeks apart from William, I have always thought that was another attempt but they didn’t quite time it correctly.

This.

I didn't know about the Raleigh expedition... I guess they realised that even if they didn't meet on the expedition that was something that they would have in common and be able to talk about!

IDoughnutKnow · 30/11/2023 11:22

spriots · 30/11/2023 11:19

I think most middle class parents with sharp elbows do their utmost to make sure that their children will move even further upwards.

My middle class parents were keen for me to move upwards but what they encouraged was for me to get myself a great career

That, too. But wanting your children to have a great career doesn't mean you don't want them to marry a partner who also has a great career and, preferably, some money.

There are endless threads on here about cocklodgers and men who loaf around "gaming". Who wants their high-powered-career middle-class daughter to shack up with a cocklodger with an X-Box addiction?

WestwardHo1 · 30/11/2023 11:21

Because the media don't think that something like this could have happened without a scheming middle aged woman planning it all, probably muttering incantations and stirring a cauldron as she did so.

Thepeopleversuswork · 30/11/2023 11:21

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/11/2023 10:21

She couldn’t engineer it. The most she could do was raise the chances of them meeting but it would never be a certain thing.

There were lots of other girls who were probably “engineered” to be in his path to the same extent- this one came off but it doesn’t make it “engineered”. Just promoted maybe.

Quite. Kate Middleton won the “lottery” (and I use the word ironically as not one I would want for myself or my daughter but if you like that kind of thing she did “well”).

There must have been hundreds of other wannabe sloanes who also tried to push themselves into his circle, she was just the one who pulled it off.

On the other hand it’s very clear that her parents were ruthlessly ambitious and left no stone unturned to marry their daughter to a prince.

I can’t work out whether I am more impressed at their single mindedness or depressed about where they chose to focus their energies for a girl who clearly had a lot of potential to achieve things under her own steam.

Sunnydays41 · 30/11/2023 11:21

Sunnydays41 · 30/11/2023 11:20

Because Prince William took a gap year - I'm pretty certain it was known for a year beforehand that he was going to study art history at St Andrews..

Then I think he changed to geography? But would have likely already met Kate by then..

I definitely think she engineered the best circumstances of them meeting. And obviously it was then down to Kate, but she has good looks, a middle-class country upbringing and confidence on her side...

And Kate also took a gap year but applied afterwards.

TripleDaisySummer · 30/11/2023 11:21

I have no problem believing that she could have made choices to significant improve her daughter's chances of making a "good match", in specific social circles. Possibly some specific moves to improve her chances with William (especially once their paths crossed). But of course she couldn't manufacture the whole thing.

This.

We don't have those kinds of social connections and couldn't afford in like private school but education got DH and me more options in life so we've emphasized it's importance to our kids - (plus think career is better bet than marrying up these days).

Jonad · 30/11/2023 11:20

I think it’s fair to say they were pushed into the ‘right’ circles, given that Pippa used to befriend men with titles/land etc, the future Duke of Northumberland etc. But that’s maybe a much more normal thing to do if you’re upper middle class?

mantyzer · 30/11/2023 11:20

@BrieAndChilli I have never done that. But I agree they are married with children. No one made William marry Kate, he chose to.

Sunnydays41 · 30/11/2023 11:20

bellac11 · 30/11/2023 10:30

How would you pick the same subject. Where was it known what subject William was choosing at the time that Kate will have been making her university applications?

What was the subject anyway?

Because Prince William took a gap year - I'm pretty certain it was known for a year beforehand that he was going to study art history at St Andrews..

Then I think he changed to geography? But would have likely already met Kate by then..

I definitely think she engineered the best circumstances of them meeting. And obviously it was then down to Kate, but she has good looks, a middle-class country upbringing and confidence on her side...

spriots · 30/11/2023 11:19

I think most middle class parents with sharp elbows do their utmost to make sure that their children will move even further upwards.

My middle class parents were keen for me to move upwards but what they encouraged was for me to get myself a great career

Aprilx · 30/11/2023 11:19

TheClogLady · 30/11/2023 10:40

He did Geography

She did History of Art

so any supposed machinations to get Kate on the same course as William were a total failure!

He transferred to Geography in his second year, he did History of Art in in his first year and that is when he met Kate.

Of course Carole could not engineer a relationship and marriage, but deferring a year, switching university, switching course always seemed to me like attempts to engineer to put her in the same place. She also went to Chile on a Raleigh Expedition just weeks apart from William, I have always thought that was another attempt but they didn’t quite time it correctly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread