Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dog ownership - responsibility not a right

80 replies

Baffledandalarmed · 30/11/2023 09:27

My friend is considering getting a Golden.

I have one, and he is everything a Golden should be. He’s high energy (2+hrs a day off the lead which is 8-10 miles at my walking speed) and still ready for more, high mental stimulation needs, expensive to insure and feed, boisterous and quite needy. He’ll grow out of the last two as he’s still young, but he’ll always be high energy and need lots of mental stimulation. I knew this when I decided to get him. I also have another high energy dog. The Golden is everything his breed should be in much the same way a Jack Russel is instinctively going to be a destructive (including digging holes) if it’s also not exercised given its instincts.

IMO she is in no way capable of giving a Golden the exercise or stimulation it needs.

I have always viewed dog ownership as ‘A responsibility not a right.’ I would never get a dog breed that I wasn’t capable of meeting the needs of (I.e I’d love a collie but outside of the v. select few families who do have the right lifestyle, they are not appropriate family pets for the majority).

So, wise people on mumsnet - tell me;

YABU - everyone has a right to a dog of any breed, regardless of whether having a dog fits with their lifestyle choices. You should beak out.

YANBU - It is a responsibility to own a dog and people should get breeds that fit their lifestyle. You should be a good friend and explain the risk she is running if she gets a high energy/high stimulation dog like a Golden and gentle steer her away to something less energetic like a Chinese crested or even a guinea pig.

OP posts:
mapleriver · 30/11/2023 15:40

No dog needs 2h of exercise a day, I have two lurchers and a spaniel who go rabbiting and I give them 90 minutes of hard exercise before the autumn to get them in working condition - a dog will take as much as you give it and you're creating a super fit dog as a pet owner for no reason if you do that.

It's fine to have a breed like a golden who has an hour pootle around a day aslong as he can get 15 mins of hard exercise like retrieving to get all of his energy around, pet dogs don't need to be made fit for no reason, it just becomes a chore for the owner when the dog always wants more. Aslong as it gets a decent walk a day and is a part of family life and gets to watch things going on and steal crumbs and sniff around in its garden on and off throughout the day it will be a happy dog.

I've been noticing alot of pet owners walking their dogs far too much and acting as though other owners are lacking when their less fit dogs don't need as much. Your fit dog will ofcourse need that much to be mentally healthy, a less conditioned dog will not. Especially when so many dogs are neutered, they have even less need for such intense exercise. I could understand if he was thinking of getting a malinois, but a dog like a golden is made fit and amped up through choice not design.

Shannith · 30/11/2023 15:27

I foster for a rescue. Lots of the dogs I see are dumped because people had not thought through the responsibilities of owning a dog.

I get dogs that have separation anxiety, reactive, resource guarding - all sorts. Lots of high energy dogs that are terribly cute as puppies and a massive commitment as they grow up.

You know what sorts them out? 2 hours off lead a day (once I've trained frock solid recall) and a non extendable long line/lunge rope until then.

It's should not be a right. I see the results of that every day.

Current foster is 5 year old working cocker bitch - dumped at the side of the road after she's bred multiple litters of your cute cockerpoos.

She is lovely. She has been kept in a dark shed for 5 years. She's one of the lucky ones. Most are pts by the dog warden if they can't find a rescue place. Loads more are just killed by the "breeder".

So your fiend is nuts it she thinks she can have a golden retriever and leave it all day.

OR she's going to have to budget c£40 a day for dog walkers/doggy day care. For ever.

The fact that so many people on here thing 2 hours off lead is too much is why most people shouldn't get a dog.

HappiestSleeping · 30/11/2023 15:13

It's not just the duration or distance of the walk, it's the mental stimulation. A dog could be walked for 3 hours per day, and without the correct mental stimulation, all you'd end up with is a fitter dog. It doesn't need this length of walk, there are other ways to stimulate it. I have a working line Lab, and play nose games, and other things to enable me not to have to walk miles per day. That said, he does often get an hour morning and evening, but more of an amble.

I would struggle with any dog being left alone for that length of time though. That isn't good.

LolaSmiles · 30/11/2023 15:03

And I don't want a dog to suffer because it's owner didn't really think it through before they got them...and just got it because they had always wanted that breed
That's not unreasonable, so what matters is how you communicate it.

Dog owners' lifestyles and situations can change and it's important to consider different scenarios, and accept that some owners will have seasons that aren't ideal but they do their best for their dogs during that time. Offering advice and guidance on a non-judgmental way is probably going to be more effective than being prescriptive and banging on about long walk, multiple hours of exercise etc.

Maybe show your friend different exercise patterns for a GR or similar dogs with the message that your dog may have exercise needs within this window and you'll only know your dog's personality and temperament once you get them. Have you considered how this will fit into your lifestyle because you can't rely on them being at the lower end?

Here's some typical costs for a dog so you can have a look at how it fits with your budget.

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 30/11/2023 15:00

YANBU and the same could be said about people having kids.

Baffledandalarmed · 30/11/2023 14:56

Teddleshon · 30/11/2023 14:09

Disagree that 2 hours a day is too much! I do an hour long dog walk minimum every day and then the dogs spend another couple of hours at least following me about tending to livestock etc.

Our neighbour was so inspired by our dogs she ended up getting 2 and they spend 8 hours a day locked in a cage while she’s at work. I find it very distressing. They never ever get a proper walk, just let out into her postage stamp sized garden.

This is what I am worried about.

I don't think she realises what a commitment it could be. She might well end up with a 'lazy' golden...but realistically she won't.

Mine is 'show' lines on both sides so, arguably, should be more docile. He's not. He's not even the most energetic from his litter. So even if she did as PP suggested and got a 'show' line as opposed to a working line, that still isn't a guarantee.

And I don't want a dog to suffer because it's owner didn't really think it through before they got them...and just got it because they had always wanted that breed.

OP posts:
Mothership4two · 30/11/2023 14:51

That's heartbreaking @Teddleshon so cruel of your neighbour.

Mothership4two · 30/11/2023 14:49

The general advice seems to be walk your dog twice a day, for mental stimulation and exercise, depending on breed. For some smaller breeds once a day is OK and others (like the OP's) need three times a day and at least two hours. I would look askance at an owner that doesn't walk their dog (unless there were underlying issues or it was elderly) - their dog might seem really 'chilled' but is probably bored out of its brains! Most dogs do seem to lie around or sleep during the day (other than very hyper and/or anxious ones) as they have evolved to conserve energy in between hunting or scavenging. I also wouldn't beat myself up if we skipped a day for some reason - although that hasn't ever happened yet. In the Summer we tend to do shorter walks (30-40 minutes) early and late in the day as our dog comes from a colder environment and hates the heat but when it is cooler out we go for two hourish long walks a day (I don't think I am covering 8-10 miles though!) and sometimes she might get a short walk at lunchtime too. She is used to it, loves it, and herds us out at 'walkies' time.

whatfreshheck · 30/11/2023 14:09

I have a golden that's completely different to yours. He hates going for a walk and has 20 mins down the field chasing a ball before he is ready to come back! Not all dogs are the same and I know ow very few Goldens who have a 2 hour walk everyday. Give her the info, let her make a decision and stay out of it otherwise.

Teddleshon · 30/11/2023 14:09

Disagree that 2 hours a day is too much! I do an hour long dog walk minimum every day and then the dogs spend another couple of hours at least following me about tending to livestock etc.

Our neighbour was so inspired by our dogs she ended up getting 2 and they spend 8 hours a day locked in a cage while she’s at work. I find it very distressing. They never ever get a proper walk, just let out into her postage stamp sized garden.

LolaSmiles · 30/11/2023 14:07

You're not wrong about being concerned that GR are often sold as family friendly dogs. In my experience people say Labradors are similarly family friendly without consideration of what the breed is like.

I agree with PP though that to a point you train the dog you want. We set the template for exercise, training, behaviour, socialising and rest time. It's no excuse for not being a decent owner obviously, but I don't think dog ownership is as black and white as some people suggest and you only get to know your dog's temperament when you've got them.

It's freezing cold here today, I'm WFH and mine were very reluctant to have a walk at lunchtime and as soon as we got in they have spent most of their afternoon napping. On another day they'd be happily out for an hour or more. I'm not going to beat myself up that they've not had multiple hours of walks today.

Supernova23 · 30/11/2023 14:03

I own a working line German Shepherd. She does not get 2+ hours of exercise and stimulation a day. She’s the most chilled out dog in the house. You can’t generalise I’m afraid, and as far as dogs go, Goldens are one of the easiest breeds out there so YABU.

You are CHOOSING to give your dog that much exercise and mental stimulation. They do not need it. Most dogs need to learn how to chill and do nothing rather than half of what the internet tells you to do. And I say that as someone who’s owned working line dogs of various breeds.

kitsuneghost · 30/11/2023 13:17

I do worry when people say they need a dog because they can't get out or because they have mental health issues
I definitely think people in this situation are not suitable for dog ownership

You need space, time, fitness and energy to look after a dog well

GelatinousDynamo · 30/11/2023 13:07

Baffledandalarmed · 30/11/2023 09:51

I don't think she can afford to pay for doggy day care every day or a dog walker every day - and the only 'support' she has nearby is me and I already have two dogs of my own, I can't take on responsibility for hers if she needs support. She often mentions how she can't afford things etc and I know she's not exaggerating.

I'm trying to decide what to do! And if I raise it, how to raise it...

A third option might actually be to have her spend a day with my Golden and actually see what it's really like (as opposed to the crap on YouTube that makes dog ownership seem like a breeze)?

This is actually what I would suggest (spending a day with you and your golden). If possible, choose a cold, rainy day, so that she gets the full picture and realizes that dog ownership does not only consist of cuddling puppies.

It does sound like she shouldn't be getting a dog, no matter what breed. We have a puppy at the moment. It's my third and still I find myself surprised that it's such hard work. It's worth it in the end, but still, my DH and I have been working from home alternately these last 4 months. I would never leave our pup alone for the entire day, we're up to two hours now and it's plenty!

And two hours walk a day is definitely not too much, my Vizsla needed even more than that. Even then, walks are not everything and they need other outlets.

greencheetah · 30/11/2023 13:05

Baffledandalarmed · 30/11/2023 09:36

She isn't home at all during the day during the week. She's out from 8 - 6. That is not someone who should own a dog (let alone a Golden!).

She can be my friend and I can still think she's being naive about what a dog is like.

Well that’s a MASSIVE drip feed 😂😂😂

Catleveltired · 30/11/2023 12:03

She might be your friend. But I'm not sure you're hers.

steppemum · 30/11/2023 11:12

we had my cousins dog and then my friends dog to stay at ours when they were on holiday.

We all loved the idea of a dog, but after 2 weeks of walking the dogs, we were always glad to hand them back.

We finally got our own dog, when we had a holiday stay and at the end I realised that I liked going for a walk every morning, and wanted to continue.

I walk 1-1.5 hours every morning. Dh walks an hour every evening. I wouldn't walk a dog for less unless it was a small lapdog type breed.

I would have a coffee with her and offer for her to stay at yours for 2 days and do everything with you for the dog. So if she needs to leave for work at 8, then both get up at 5:30, walk the dog for 1.5 hours and then get ready for work. Or after work do that long walk.
Talk about what she will need in place ot leave him all day (dog walker etc) and then how you can't do that until he is xxx old, and what is she going to do while a puppy and so on.
Do it as a supportive friend, not as a criticism.

meeplesmarples · 30/11/2023 10:52

YANBU, your friend sounds like she has no idea of the realities of dog ownership. So many people fail to realise that dogs are sentient beings and not lifestyle accessories, and that they have needs their owners have to try and meet. If you'd be happy to lend her your dog for a day or so, it might help her understand what dog ownership actually looks like - it's not all crisp autumnal walks with Insta-worthy pics, and a floofy friend to snuggle with on the couch after a day at work.

stayathomer · 30/11/2023 10:51

Maybe people are reacting to the fact that OP actually needs 'wise' mumsnetters to confirm something that is so obvious when you look at how she has worded the 'yabu'..
👏👏👏exactly this, op, did you really need to put a vote?!

Nobody knows whether they’ll step up to the responsibility of dog ownership until it happens unfortunately and nobody listens when people tell them it’s bloody hard. (We didn’t and people haven’t when we’ve told them and now they say they find it difficult). I did recently come to the conclusion that every household works so differently and a lot of things find their balance plus every dog is different so I wouldn’t assume someone is going to fail before they try. Within a week or two she might change over her routine to fit the dog

Haydenn · 30/11/2023 10:45

It is a responsibility. But to a point you train the dog you want. If you keep walking a dog you create an athlete. But many GR are more chilled than yours sounds to be.
8-6 is a long time to leave a sociable breed though

AdultLounge · 30/11/2023 10:42

After reading the clueless posts on here, I suggest OP you're on a hiding to nothing talking to your friend.

Reading this thread it seems UK dog owners haven't a clue. A previous poster even mentioned it was equivalent to running a marathon!!!

Madness! Complete anthropomorphism!!

Most dogs would prefer a really good walk than a "mind game". I think it suits the lazy owners well to believe it's just a good as a walk!!

Lazy fuckers.

And I know not all dogs love walks, I had a corgi cross who didn't not like going out if it was wet! Tough! We went out! She lived until she was over 20!!

I now have a cocker cross, he couldn't get enough exercise! Never managed to tire that dog out!!

However he's now 16 and just about manages half a mile before I have to carry him home.

Such selfish, lazy dog owners.

Just go to the cafe then and pose!

Look at us and our 2 kids, and lab and hunter wellies. Go to the forest for a walk? Oh no, we'll give him some mind games instead.

Fucking Insta generation!

Sorry for rant. Just hate the way dogs are treated at the moment.

I'll walk way from the thread now 🐶

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 30/11/2023 10:38

Baffledandalarmed · 30/11/2023 10:27

I didn't meant to be smug!

I think the point is that owning a working breed or a breed that was bred to be energetic or do a job (Jack Russel/Retriever/German Shepard etc) is v. different to owning a breed bred to be a lapdog such as a Pekingese. Working dogs don't just need lots of walking they need lots of stimulation.

If she wanted to get a Japanese Chin or any of the little breeds that don't need to much physical and/or mental stimulation, I wouldn't be half as concerned. Of course they still need exercise/mental stimulation, but not anywhere near as much.

It's the fact that Goldens are portrayed by the media as being some sort of lovable family pet and a breeze to own...when reality is just not like that (as it is for many dogs tbh) that has worried me. I don't think she's fully considered what it is really like (I'd be just as concerned if she said she wanted to get a spaniel tbh).

But thank you and all PPs for the pointers!

I'll do what PPs have suggested and invite her to my morning walk on Saturday and then suggest we grab a coffee after.

But not all golden retrievers are from working lines. Show line golden retrievers havr completely different nerds/tempermant than working.

In your friends situation she shpuldn't get any dog from working lines

Foxblue · 30/11/2023 10:33

She shouldn't get a dog because it sounds like she can't afford it.
However on the 2 hours thing - depends on the dog. I have a young, high energy dog (spaniel) who is happy with an hour a day in our local woods (big sniffy environment) but she's also not climbing the walls if you can only do half an hour.
Every dog is different, my friend has a spaniel who she's walked two hours a day since it was old enough to do that much and now it's climbing the walls if it gets any less.

Baffledandalarmed · 30/11/2023 10:27

BrimfulOfMash · 30/11/2023 10:18

I am not just a dog owner, I am a Golden dog owner…

OP, you are not wrong but be careful how you sound. Talk to her in a matter of fact way. It’s privileged to be able to spend so much money on a dog, and to have 2 hours a day to spend in fields and beaches.. and sounds a bit smug to say that other dog walks are ‘plodding’ while you exalt your walking pace and distance.

I didn't meant to be smug!

I think the point is that owning a working breed or a breed that was bred to be energetic or do a job (Jack Russel/Retriever/German Shepard etc) is v. different to owning a breed bred to be a lapdog such as a Pekingese. Working dogs don't just need lots of walking they need lots of stimulation.

If she wanted to get a Japanese Chin or any of the little breeds that don't need to much physical and/or mental stimulation, I wouldn't be half as concerned. Of course they still need exercise/mental stimulation, but not anywhere near as much.

It's the fact that Goldens are portrayed by the media as being some sort of lovable family pet and a breeze to own...when reality is just not like that (as it is for many dogs tbh) that has worried me. I don't think she's fully considered what it is really like (I'd be just as concerned if she said she wanted to get a spaniel tbh).

But thank you and all PPs for the pointers!

I'll do what PPs have suggested and invite her to my morning walk on Saturday and then suggest we grab a coffee after.

OP posts:
BrimfulOfMash · 30/11/2023 10:18

I am not just a dog owner, I am a Golden dog owner…

OP, you are not wrong but be careful how you sound. Talk to her in a matter of fact way. It’s privileged to be able to spend so much money on a dog, and to have 2 hours a day to spend in fields and beaches.. and sounds a bit smug to say that other dog walks are ‘plodding’ while you exalt your walking pace and distance.