Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect DD to sleep through the night or at least allow my DH to resettle her?

105 replies

lucieth · 30/11/2023 08:23

DD is nearly 2. In a SAHM, my husband works full time. He's a very loving dad and does his very best to share in parenting and house chores whilst working, but naturally being a SAHM I spend a lot more time with DD than him. They do have a great relationship though - when he gets in from work she runs to the door shouting PAPPIIII (daddy in his language) with hugs and she belly laughs with him like she doesn't with anyone else.

DD absolutely refuses to be put to bed or resettled at night by my DH. It has to be me, otherwise she will cry MUMMMYYYYYY and refuse to go to bed. I can count on my hand the number of times I've been out for bedtime but each time she will cry and bedtime will take 3-4 hours. Once she still won't go to sleep till I come home at 11pm (bedtime normally 7:30pm) and other times he could only put her to bed by doing it in our bed (as opposed to her cot where she normally sleeps) and stay will her in the dark from 7:30 in the bed.

It makes me exhausted as it clearly means he can't help if she wakes at night (feels like every child sleeps through around 1 year old but here we are at 22 months still having 3-4 wakes per night) and if she wakes whilst I'm showering by the time I'm out she's been crying for a while and woken herself up more.

Hes not always home before bedtime from work so can't commit to always doing it more often. Plus it's truly torture for everyone if he can't put her to sleep for 3-4 hours and it feels right for me to step in.

OP posts:
googledidnthelp · 30/11/2023 09:59

Normal for some toddlers. My own included. DS is 2y 3m and is hard to get to sleep even for me sometimes never mind his dad. Always wakes at least once a night normally 2/3 and that's even with consleeing all night because I simply don't have the energy at the minute to go in and out his room when I'm just falling asleep in his bed anyway.

Tomorrow we are doing our for a Christmas meal so will be interesting to see what happens for grandma.

SecondUsername4me · 30/11/2023 09:53

If she falls asleep "on the bottle" (which just isn't suitable at this age/for teeth/sleep crutch etc), then no wonder she can't naturally get herself back to sleep when she wakes in the night.

Tackle the milk first (for teeth), then once she's sleeping without milk, work on both of you taking turns to put her to bed.

Tbf she's only reacting to the specific crutches she's been allowed to develop in order to get to sleep.

Bearbookagainandagain · 30/11/2023 09:52

if she has eaten well & especially if she's had a bottle at bedtime, then I'd just give her water after that. Quite often that fixes the 'I enjoy waking up for milk & cuddles' mindset.

that's so true 😂We thought we had learned but then struggled to get our son off his milk bottle in the evening. We thought he would self-wean like he had for the others, but at 22 months we decided enough is enough, and from now on he could only have it a cup and not a bottle. He decided he didn't want milk at all in these conditions, went cold turkey from 240ml to 0... And was completely fine about it!
He now enjoys cuddling on the sofa with his comforter instead, and appreciate just as much as with a bottle.

WonderLife · 30/11/2023 09:49

You make it sound like your DD is purposefully doing this, but actually it's just that her parents haven't taught her any other way.

She's not 'refusing' she's just doing the only thing she knows.

If you want to change her sleeping habits then it is up to you and your partner - decide how you are going to do it and be consistent, don't confuse her by 'giving in' and giving mixed messages.

You've spent two years teaching her to sleep a certain way, and if you want her to make this huge change it's going to take you time and a lot of effort. Sleep will be worse at first.

Pinkpinkpink15 · 30/11/2023 09:44

@lucieth I get the exhaustion & frustration!! But you're expecting a bit much from a not even yet 2 year old. It's a bit much to make it sound like 'she should know better & do better' she's not doing it on purpose!!

Having a preference for one parent doing xyz is perfectly normal for a toddler. You just have to train them to accept either parent (lots of suggestions already made) and it's perfectly normal for them still to wake in the night. It's not outside the parameters of 'normal'

if she has eaten well & especially if she's had a bottle at bedtime, then I'd just give her water after that. Quite often that fixes the 'I enjoy waking up for milk & cuddles' mindset.

so does having a cooler response in the night, ok DD, you're not too hot, you're not too cold, your nappy is fine, here's a drink of water... right it's night time, time to go back to sleep' Not in a harsh voice, but very factual... rinse & repeat.

if it's not rewarding to wake up, she'll stop doing it & you're doing no harm as you're going to her when she calls got you.

However, as exhausting as it is, they soon grow out of it & you miss the nighttime cuddles!

theleafandnotthetree · 30/11/2023 09:35

Bearbookagainandagain · 30/11/2023 09:23

It's not going to be popular but just throwing it out there: you can also say "no" and let her cry/call...

The more you give in and go, the more she will call for you (and why not since she knows it'll work?). If she feels you really mean it, she will stop.

It doesn't mean you don't love her, and I'm sure she knows that as you show it to her in many different ways every day.

I agree with this....people (including little children) do what works and you teach your child how to be. Why wouldn't a child continue to default to warm cuddles and warm milk when this is on tap? You can be loving but firm and there is no harm at all in them occasionally getting upset or coming up against a boundary that they really don't like. These are normal human experiences which arguably, actually need to be experienced in terms of human development. The best parents I know - with the most happy, grounded and pleasant children generally - are warm and loving but run a tight ship where they are in charge and where the children aren't setting the agenda.

crumblingschools · 30/11/2023 09:32

On a completely separate note it’s not a good idea to give a bottle after teeth brushing.

I would start giving her water if she wants a drink in the night.

MissyB1 · 30/11/2023 09:31

Well your Dh is just going to have to do more bedtimes. You say he’s not home in time from work, could that change even just for one or two nights a week? Or he has to do every Saturday and Sunday bedtimes. Your child has to get used to dad putting her to bed. And both of you need to learn to ignore any nonsense - and yes I know that’s hard!
I’ve got 3 kids and all of them slept through by 18 months (my eldest slept through from 10 months), but I did sleep training, I know that’s not for everyone though.

GoingOffOnATangent · 30/11/2023 09:24

Sounds completely normal to me. I've had two kids, one was like this, the other wasn't. They vary so much.
She obviously associates you with nighttime comfort. It will pass as she gets older. Meanwhile I sympathise with how hard it is. Mine still woke occasionally until 5yo (she had growing pains at night) but gradually the necessity it was me that went to her faded so though it still happened occasionally it didn't have to be me. I can't remember when the change occurred, though I remember finding it tough.

Bearbookagainandagain · 30/11/2023 09:23

It's not going to be popular but just throwing it out there: you can also say "no" and let her cry/call...

The more you give in and go, the more she will call for you (and why not since she knows it'll work?). If she feels you really mean it, she will stop.

It doesn't mean you don't love her, and I'm sure she knows that as you show it to her in many different ways every day.

DaveWatts · 30/11/2023 09:21

We had the same - I think if you go out every night for a week and let him do bedtimes then it might help, rather than just doing the odd night. Yes the first time it will take 4 hours but the next night will be shorter and the next after that probably shorter again. That way your DH can build his own bedtime routine with her and then you can start alternating nights. That's how we did things for my daughter when she was about the same age and it worked fine. She didn't stop waking in the night and asking for me for about another 6 months, until I had Covid and DH had to do all the night wakings - again, after a week they had their own routine worked out and after that we could alternate.

lucieth · 30/11/2023 09:19

SecondUsername4me · 30/11/2023 09:08

What does you putting her to bed look like? What's your routine with her?

Her routine is books in her bedroom in dim-ish light (but still enough light to read and see pictures) for about 15min. Then brushing her teeth, then putting to sleep by having milk. If she wakes up in the night I try to comfort her without the bottle, just cuddles but if she keeps saying "Bot Bot" I'll give her the bottle.

OP posts:
lucieth · 30/11/2023 09:17

BeckhamSeven · 30/11/2023 09:02

So this was us but the other way round. My DH always did bedtime from her being about 11 months old, so she (strongly!) associated sleep with him. It was a nightmare on the rare occasion he went out and I too was stuck at 11.30pm with a screaming and fidgety child 🤣

It was a gradual thing, so I started doing a couple
of bedtimes a week on a weekend and it was "daddy will do bedtime tomorrow but tonight it's my turn" etc.

Also you've identified her sleep association (you) so now you need to gradually introduce other sleep associations (a good bedtime routine, with us it was white noise, a story etc)

In terms of waking up, we told our daughter that she just wasn't allowed to wake us up in the night unless she was poorly. If she woke us up, well the next day we couldn't go swimming/to the park/to her play date because "mummy was tired" etc.

It's not foolproof, and she does still settle much better if my DH puts her to sleep, but we can muddle through now

She does have other sleep associations like we do a bedtime story before and switch the white noise machine as she's going to sleep.

How old was your daughter when she could understand the link between waking mummy up and mummy being too tired to do things next day?

OP posts:
theleafandnotthetree · 30/11/2023 09:16

I absolutely do not think it is normal for an almost 2 year old to be waking 3-4 times a night. How could most people have other children or hold down a job if that were the norm? I have no solutions OP but I certainly would be exploring every avenue before accepting this or hoping she'd grow out of it. Avenues include diet, anxiety, over or under tiredness, medical issues, a poor routine, lack of fresh air.... Other people have offered some good ideas about the issue of your child's father not being able to put her to bed but I personally wouldn't be having that either. Sometimes you have to put up with a bad few nights in a row to break a pattern. A pattern which is detrimental to everyone, including the child.

lucieth · 30/11/2023 09:15

Goldx2 · 30/11/2023 08:42

Oh no there is absolutely nothing wrong with her. Please don’t worry about that. I found that when my children were that age, they were better off in a bed rather than a cot. Does she have a routine? Baby lavender bath & story? I don’t know what to advise about letting daddy put her to bed. All I do know that is why this feels it is lasting forever, it won’t.

Her routine is books in her bedroom in dim-ish light (but still enough light to read and see pictures) for about 15min. Then brushing her teeth, then putting to sleep by having milk. If she wakes up in the night I try to comfort her without the bottle, just cuddles but if she keeps saying "Bot Bot" I'll give her the bottle.

When he's home dad (DH) will do the bedtime stories and teeth.

She seems to hate baths and it makes her more agitated so we don't do them before bed.

OP posts:
lucieth · 30/11/2023 09:12

Torganer · 30/11/2023 08:41

What happens if you go out with friends for the evening, will she settle then or does it take ages.

I've only done it a few times but each time it took my husband 3-4 hours to get her to sleep, and other time she didn't go to sleep till I came home at all (at 11pm)

OP posts:
SecondUsername4me · 30/11/2023 09:08

What does you putting her to bed look like? What's your routine with her?

Nortam · 30/11/2023 09:07

Totally normal for a bit yet 2 year old to not sleep through the night and prefer mum to resettle them.

Yogaandcrochet · 30/11/2023 09:07

I think this is pretty normal. Hard, but normal!

HikingforScenery · 30/11/2023 09:06

You told your two year old you wouldn’t be able to go the park if she woke you up and it worked?
Mine wouldn’t remember that association the next day tbh

Seeline · 30/11/2023 09:06

In terms of waking up, we told our daughter that she just wasn't allowed to wake us up in the night unless she was poorly. If she woke us up, well the next day we couldn't go swimming/to the park/to her play date because "mummy was tired"

You can't tell an under-2 that!
They wake for all sorts of reasons, and generally just need comfort. They certainly won't associate waking after a nightmare with not being able to go to the park the next day!

TurquoisTiger · 30/11/2023 09:06

I’ve learnt after having two children that this is in fact the norm (not sleeping through anyway) and it’s just that people only seem to talk about it if their kids sleep through! Re settling for someone else, he just has to persevere and you have to all decide if you are motivated enough for it to get worse before it gets better when he does it

BeckhamSeven · 30/11/2023 09:02

So this was us but the other way round. My DH always did bedtime from her being about 11 months old, so she (strongly!) associated sleep with him. It was a nightmare on the rare occasion he went out and I too was stuck at 11.30pm with a screaming and fidgety child 🤣

It was a gradual thing, so I started doing a couple
of bedtimes a week on a weekend and it was "daddy will do bedtime tomorrow but tonight it's my turn" etc.

Also you've identified her sleep association (you) so now you need to gradually introduce other sleep associations (a good bedtime routine, with us it was white noise, a story etc)

In terms of waking up, we told our daughter that she just wasn't allowed to wake us up in the night unless she was poorly. If she woke us up, well the next day we couldn't go swimming/to the park/to her play date because "mummy was tired" etc.

It's not foolproof, and she does still settle much better if my DH puts her to sleep, but we can muddle through now

Seeline · 30/11/2023 08:53

I would do bedtimes together for a while and then you can begin popping in and out of the process with a breezy Daddy's going to read your story now, I'll pop back for my kiss in a minute etc.
Don't have him do bedtime rarely and only on the occasions that you've actually gone out in the first place

If you can sort bedtime, she might be happier being settled by dad if she wakes.

It's quite normal for a not-quite 2yo to wake during the night.

Goldx2 · 30/11/2023 08:42

Oh no there is absolutely nothing wrong with her. Please don’t worry about that. I found that when my children were that age, they were better off in a bed rather than a cot. Does she have a routine? Baby lavender bath & story? I don’t know what to advise about letting daddy put her to bed. All I do know that is why this feels it is lasting forever, it won’t.

Swipe left for the next trending thread